• We have updated our Community Code of Conduct. Please read through the new rules for the forum that are an integral part of Paradox Interactive’s User Agreement.

Tinto Maps #24 Korea and Japan Feedback

Hello and welcome to another week of Tinto Maps Feedback. Today, we will take a look at Korea and Japan. This area has required less rework than other ones, but still some adjustments have been made.

ADDITIONS

Added the following:
  • Locations
    • Tamura
    • Seongwi
    • Jindo
    • Heungyang
    • Namhae
    • Geoje
  • TAGs
    • Shěnyáng
  • Characters
    • ssg_jo_hwi
    • ssg_jo_yanggi
    • ssg_jo_rim
    • ssg_jo_sosaeng
    • ssg_jo_don
    • ssg_jo_inbyeok
    • kor_ja
    • kor_ko
CORRECTIONS

Renamed the following:
  • Locations:
    • Renamed Aira to Kuwabara
    • Renamed Jeju to Tamna
Areas and Provinces
  • Total rework of areas and provinces of Korea
  • Renamed Tōhoku to Ōu
Cultures
  • Renamed Jeju culture to Tamna
Raw Goods
  • Changed several Raw Goods as suggested
Terrain and Vegetation
  • Total Review
Locations
  • Redrew several Locations
Minorities
  • Added someminorities

Countries:
Countries.png

Countries color.png

Not many changes here, only the addition of Shenyang.

Dynasties:
Dynasties.png

Not many changes here either, but you can see that Shenyang has the same dynasty as Goryeo.

Country ranks and Government Types:
Country Ranks.png
Government Types.png


Locations:
Locations.png

As I said, no major changes here, only minor adjustments.
Locations zoom 1.png

Locations zoom 2.png

Locations zoom 3.png

Locations zoom 4.png

Locations zoom 5.png

Locations zoom 6.png

Locations zoom 7.png

Locations zoom 8.png

Provinces:
Provinces.png


Areas:
Areas.png

Provinces and areas of Korea is what has received the most change here.

Terrain:
Topography.png
Climate.png
Vegetation.png


Development:
Development.png


Harbors:
Harbors.png


Cultures:
Cultures.png

Not much change in the major cultures, although a bit of adjustment of minorities.

Languages:
Language.png

Court Language.png

Location’s language first, Court Language second.

Religions:
Religion.png


Raw Materials:
Raw Materials.png

Raw Materials zoom 1.png

Raw Materials zoom 2.png

Raw Materials zoom 3.png

Raw Materials zoom 4.png

Raw Materials zoom 5.png

Markets:
Markets.png


And not much has changed with the clans distribution, but here you have it:
Clans.png


That is all for today, this week we will not move far from these areas, here’s the schedule:
  • Tuesday: Tinto Flavour for Korea and Manchuria
  • Wednesday: Tinto Talks for Shintō and the Shogunate
  • Thursday: ‘Behind the Music of Europa Universalis V - Composing the Grandest Score’ video!
  • Friday: Tinto Flavour for Japan and the situations of the Nanbokuchō and Sengoku Jidai

And always as a reminder: Wishlist Europa Universalis V now!
 
  • 127Like
  • 31Love
  • 9
  • 3
  • 1
Reactions:
I found another English source mentioning it, shouldn't the locality of Inaka also have a visible Ainu minority?

1749478866659.png


There is no real concrete evidence but I think if you go with this interpretation Inaka seems a good center of Ainu presence too.
 
  • 5
  • 1
Reactions:
According to the shugo appointment list I'm currently editing, the Hatakeyama clan came to possess Noto in 1391. The source I referenced is from Tokyo Shuppan Publishing: https://www.tokyodoshuppan.com/book/b79498.html. Please note that the list itself is in Japanese.

Additionally, while referring to "Ishikawa Prefecture Surnames and Historical Figures Encyclopedia (Kadokawa Japanese Surnames and Historical Figures Encyclopedia Vol. 17)", no records were found of the Hatakeyama clan being active in Noto during the Nanboku-chō period.
The Hatakeyama clan is already present in Noto. For the rest of issues, I'd say wait for the Tinto Talks and Tinto Flavor of the rest of the week.
 

Attachments

  • 守護.xlsx
    122,5 KB · Views: 0
Last edited:
  • 1
  • 1Like
Reactions:


The Manchurian region should be looking something like this:

(Dark Green is Yuan)
(Everyone is a vassal of Yuan, but some are colour-coded to represent their own spheres of influence)




Country information table:
(feel free to contribute)

NOTE: Indentations represent subject hierarchy

CountryTitle (Ruler Title)RulerHeirDynastyCultureReligion
YuanKhaganate (Khagan)Toghon Temür-BorjigidMongolBuddhism
Shenyang​
Kingdom (Wang)KoDeoksuWangKorean-
Ssangseong​
Commandery (Marshal)LimSo-saengJoKorean-
Goryeo​
Kingdom (Wang)ChungsukYongsanWangKorean-
Tamna​
Lordship (Seongju / Star Lord)SeokSun-ryangGoKorean-
Belgutei Ulus​
Ulus (Wang)An HunchaTemür BuqaBorjigidMongol-
Hachiun Ulus​
Ulus (Wang)Munanzi-BorjigidMongol-
Qasar Ulus​
Ulus (Wang)Shiliemen-BorjigidMongol-
Otchigin Ulus​
Ulus (Wang)YanaširiAǰaširiBorjigidMongol-
Bugū​
------
Hūlan​
--XiyanghaNara--
Sibe​
--NacibuluGūwalgiya--
Hūrga​
---Wanggiya--
Towūn​
-Bu'eryu-Hešeri--
Wanlin​
---Hitara--
Odoli​
--FanchaGioro--


 
Last edited:
  • 26Like
  • 6
  • 1Love
  • 1
Reactions:
I'm not sure what you expected...View attachment 1315845
This reminds me: have you considered adding a separate Tsunami natural disaster type? They have quite a different and unique way of spreading. They should likely start from certain sea (or coastal) locations, and spread through the sea tiles, affecting coastal locations to a certain distance (lowland locations might be more affected than higher locations)
 
  • 6Like
  • 1
Reactions:
The dark gold regions stay the same?



Which ones do you refer? I have dark green for Yuan, light green for Yuan vassals.

Other vassals have different colour-coding to represent their own spheres of influence, although they are all still vassals of Yuan.


 
  • 2Like
Reactions:
I found another English source mentioning it, shouldn't the locality of Inaka also have a visible Ainu minority?

View attachment 1315859

There is no real concrete evidence but I think if you go with this interpretation Inaka seems a good center of Ainu presence too.
There are Ainu there too, it's just not reaching the minimum to show the stripes (barely though)
 
  • 17
  • 12Like
Reactions:
Its quite a pleasant surprise to see my location suggestions for South Korea's southern archipelagos be realized considering all the recent flops for map feedbacks, makes me ever so slightly optimistic for the map feedbacks that Corominas oversees, but i wont get my hopes up too high les i get disappointed.

Although none of my Japanese island suggestions like for Iki Island(splitting from Higashimatsuura circled in white), Hirado Island(splitting from Nishimatsuura circled in pink), Fukue Island/Goto (splitting from Minamitsuura circled in purple) and Shōdo Island (splitting off from Jōtō circled in red) were implemented is it possible for the implementation of this or is it not technically possible? or is it a design choice im sure youve read my argument regarding why island locations should have a bit more leeway in granularity due to how geographically distinct they are, if you guys were to have a pirate based DLC later on it would be really good to implement this in my opinion.

1749479942662.png



Also Jeju island having 2 locations from 1 still feels really underwhelming is it possible if you could make it to 3 and have a location representing the mountainous center on it?



Considering further would it be possible to add just 2 more locations to Southern Korea? Ive made a revised map of my initial feedback and suggested getting rid of 8 and combining 7 and 2 into the Sinan archipelago and having 1 be another location



1749480061740.png



Clearer Image



1749480443221.png


Also it it possible for Ulleung Do to be depicted? Or is it too small, a conclusive answer to this would be appreciated

Thank you for your work Corominas.
 
  • 10Like
  • 6
  • 2
  • 1
Reactions:
According to the shugo appointment list I'm currently editing, the Hatakeyama clan came to possess Noto in 1391. The source I referenced is from Tokyo Shuppan Publishing: https://www.tokyodoshuppan.com/book/b79498.html. Please note that the list itself is in Japanese.

Additionally, while referring to "Ishikawa Prefecture Surnames and Historical Figures Encyclopedia (Kadokawa Japanese Surnames and Historical Figures Encyclopedia Vol. 17)", no records were found of the Hatakeyama clan being active in Noto during the Nanboku-chō period.
They are indeed not considered to have enough presence in Noto yet, they are only present in a single location
 
  • 20Like
  • 1
Reactions:
Its quite a pleasant surprise to see my location suggestions for South Korea's southern archipelagos be realized considering all the recent flops for map feedbacks, makes me ever so slightly optimistic for the map feedbacks that Corominas oversees, but i wont get my hopes up too high les i get disappointed.

Although none of my Japanese island suggestions like for Iki Island(splitting from Higashimatsuura circled in white), Hirado Island(splitting from Nishimatsuura circled in pink), Fukue Island/Goto (splitting from Minamitsuura circled in purple) and Shōdo Island (splitting off from Jōtō circled in red) were implemented is it possible for the implementation of this or is it not technically possible? or is it a design choice im sure youve read my argument regarding why island locations should have a bit more leeway in granularity due to how geographically distinct they are, if you guys were to have a pirate based DLC later on it would be really good to implement this in my opinion.

View attachment 1315876


Also Jeju island having 2 locations from 1 still feels really underwhelming is it possible if you could make it to 3 and have a location representing the mountainous center on it?



Considering further would it be possible to add just 2 more locations to Southern Korea? Ive made a revised map of my initial feedback and suggested getting rid of 8 and combining 7 and 2 into the Sinan archipelago and having 1 be another location



View attachment 1315878


Clearer Image



View attachment 1315883

Also it it possible for Ulleung Do to be depicted? Or is it too small, a conclusive answer to this would be appreciated

Thank you for your work Corominas.
Unfortunately, all these are too small to be able to be properly represented.
 
  • 27
  • 11Like
  • 6
  • 2
Reactions:
The deep ocean's graphic style looks beautiful... maybe you could add some reflections to the other seas as well?
View attachment 1315880
They all have reflections; this is just how reflection often looks like, it usually creates a circle like this where the Sun is directly reflected
 
  • 4Like
  • 2
Reactions:
They are indeed not considered to have enough presence in Noto yet, they are only present in a single location
Sounds good. My research only covered up to the prefectural histories, so I wasn't aware of that level of detail.

But if you're going to add this much detail, I think it would be good to include clans like the Chō, Tokuda, Togi, Tokue, and Amano as well.
 
  • 1Like
Reactions: