-
We have updated our Community Code of Conduct. Please read through the new rules for the forum that are an integral part of Paradox Interactive’s User Agreement.
The Feast for Crows bookmark lists Catelyn Stark as murdered by Walder Frey. Doing a character search for 'Stoneheart' doesn't turn up anything, either. So I'd say no, unless I'm missing something.
- 2
Every time I play a bookmark with Catelyn in it, she's incredibly murderous and is constantly plotting to kill anyone between her children and a title - in my last game, she had Edmure assassinated so Robb could be Lord Paramount.
The mod doesn't need Lady Stoneheart, she's already worse than her in the game before she dies.
The mod doesn't need Lady Stoneheart, she's already worse than her in the game before she dies.
- 7
I suppose she could be a rare event in the AFFC bookmark, which randomly kills unlanded Freys and Lannisters in the Riverlands.
- 8
- 1
I'd like to say it is all well and good everyone clicking the nice little disagree button on my post but unless you actually come up with an idea for it you are not helping in the slightest and are completely ineffectual
- 15
- 4
- 1
Perhaps add the Brotherhood without Banners as a mercenary company fighting a war against Walder Frey, complete with event chains about murdering Freys until she is killed
- 6
The problem with making someone like Catelyn Stark/Lady Stoneheart is that CKII, while very focused on certain aspects of a characters' life, is not as detailed as the ventures of characters in the books/show. I bet many people would love to play as Arya when she was travelling (just an example) towards the Wall, but the game isn't designed for somebody to play as a travelling character unless (as of 2.4.3) you are a mercenary, which isn't even close to what she was. We can pepper a character with events, but unless CKIII adds more depth to characters' lives and focuses on the finer points of living then one will be playing people like Lady Stoneheart and there will forever be this sort of little void when one plays as a given person, if they are really into the course of events that GRRM details in the series.
no h8 pls
- 4
But that's completely incorrect. I'd love the idea of a Lady Stoneheart event that would lead to certain dynasty members being killed. It could be similar to the Robin Hood event in vanilla, with Lady Stoneheart spawning as a character upon arrest.
There could also be a potential event like Arya's discovery at Harrenhall, if certain characters (Jon, Brienne, Jaime) lead an army into forested provinces of the Riverlands/Westerlands.
I have a pretty good understanding of modding and such, but how would this even be possible? It looks like it would be very hard to do, if it even can be done.
Just having her go around and kill people at random doesn't really do justice to her character also it would be likely unbalanced with no real way to defend against if you are the victim
- 3
But isn't that exactly what she does in the books, killing Freys at seemingly random?
No, she only killed those that were present and contributing to her and Robb's murder. There were many, yes, but if I recall correctly there were some who weren't aware of the conspiracy.
Perhaps I'm remembering wrong, but I thought she was going after any Frey, Bolton, or Lannister. She does, after all, go after Brienne and Pod, and wants Jaime dead, despite none of them having even the slightest to do with the Red Wedding.
Even if she did distinguish, if you were to implement it, you can't make the distinction in-game anyway, so you would just have to keep it random
Very true game-wise, of course, but I wasn't aware of that since I hadn't gotten to that part in the books!
But now that you think of it, it seems she was really spiteful about her ordeal. Brienne essentially failed her task of escorting Sansa back to her, Podrick Payne is/was the Imp's squire, who she thinks sent an assassin to kill her sweet Bran, who she thinks is dead anyway, but we all know that's false, so there is a method to her madness, if you were killed and reanimated and fully conscious, I'd think one would be pissed about all the bad things that have happened.
Very true game-wise, of course, but I wasn't aware of that since I hadn't gotten to that part in the books!
Whoops! My bad, didn't mean to spoil anything (trust me when I say that those elements of the plots haven't truly happened yet, so only George knows how things play out
That's ok, I forgive you. Compared to the rest of the series, that's nothing though. But I've just been trying to force myself not to see the wiki and stuff, since it's too tempting, but it isn't too terrible of a revelation.
Might want to add spoilers tag to topic or first post. Not that it matters for us who read the books as soon as they come out.