• We have updated our Community Code of Conduct. Please read through the new rules for the forum that are an integral part of Paradox Interactive’s User Agreement.
Showing developer posts only. Show all posts in this thread.

ManoDeZombi

Content Designer - HOI4
Paradox Staff
Oct 23, 2019
237
3.515
Здравствуйте товарищи! - Greetings comrades! And welcome to a new Hearts of Iron 4 Dev Diary! I hope that you are all having a great summer, and that you are prepared for a little reading, because today we’ll be talking about the last country left to show for the upcoming expansion, a country that, in the direst of times, did take No Step Back.

As you all know, the Soviet Union is huge, and we’ve had to form our own Content Design Soviet to properly implement all the cool stuff we wanted to represent. So today I’ll be talking about my main responsibility, which has been the historical and the common branches for what is one of the most interesting countries in HOI.

I’d just like to mention a couple of things before we start:
First of all, yes, everything we’ll be talking about today will be coming for free with the Barbarossa update, although some content might vary if you don’t own some of the previous DLCs.
Secondly, our beloved Motherland is still WIP so you might see content, values or even art that’s not final and is subject to change before release. You will also see a fair amount of debug decisions that we use in order to test the new systems.
And with that said, I suggest you make yourselves comfortable and ready for a long read, and let’s get started!

01 Bookmark.png


This country entered World War I as the Russian Empire, but got out of it as Soviet Russia, having lost substantial territory in Eastern Europe as a result of the Treaty of Brest-Litovsk in 1918, where the Bolsheviks in Petrograd ceded control of Poland, Lithuania, Estonia, Latvia, Finland and other areas to the Central Powers.
Since the Allies did not recognize the Bolshevik government, no Soviet Russian representation attended the Peace Conference of 1919 at Versailles, where the former Russian territories previously ceded to Germany became independent states.

In December 1922, the Union of Soviet Socialist Republics was formed. The term soviet means “council”, and they emerged in the 1905 Revolution as groups or assemblies of Russian workers, soldiers and peasants, in opposition to the Tsar. These soviets disappeared after the (failed) revolution of 1905, but re-emerged under socialist leadership during the revolutions of 1917, which overthrew the Tsar.
Through the Soviets, the Bolsheviks, led by Vladimir Lenin, constituted the political structure of the new regime.

Following Lenin’s death in 1924, Iosif Stalin came to power and soon began to suppress all political opposition inside the Party, starting with Trotsky and his followers, but turning against many of those who supported him in his political struggle shortly after (such as Zinovyev or Bukharin), developing a climate of political paranoia and carrying out the Great Purge, with its massive arrests and extremely harsh repression to citizens, military and even party members.

But that’s enough history for now, let’s take a look at how the Soviet Union looks when you start the game in 1936.
02 Start.png


As you can see, a few things have changed:
Initial War Support has been significantly reduced, aiming at making it a bit harder to get to War Economy super early on, something that the Soviet Union was not really ready to do in 1936.
Stalin has finally got a trait (and as you’ll see, this is not the only trait he’ll be getting).
There are far more starting National Spirits than before, we will take a look at them later, but the first two of them you might recognize: Home of the Revolution and Trotskyite Plot?
03A Home of Revolution NS.png
03B Trotskyite Plot.png


We also have a starting advisor, Genrikh Yagoda. He is one of three possible Heads of the NKVD, each one with different characteristics, that you will not be able to manually remove/replace until you get rid of the purges (during which, Yagoda might get purged and be replaced by Yezhov, who can in turn get purged and be replaced by Beriya, as happened historically).
04A Yagoda.png
04B Yezhov.png
04C Beriya.png


The advisor roster has been greatly expanded, these are the advisors available to Stalin in the early stages (unless he goes too wild with the purges).
05 Stalin Advisors.png


There is an even longer list of advisors available for the alt-history communists, most of them will be targeted during the purges, but those are for the next dev diary!

There have also been some changes to the Generals roster: You will now start the game with the five first Marshals of the Soviet Union. Kulik has been demoted to General (since he was made marshal only in 1940, after having lost 3 of the previous marshals in the purges), and there is a new cavalry-specialized general, Vitaly Primakov, available at game start, although a potential target in the purges (generic portraits mean WIP portraits!).
06A Marshals.png
06B Primakov and Kulik.png


Last but not least, we have sent several Soviet generals on leave to a rejuvenation center, as some had portraits from long after the war. But as you can see, they have not yet returned from their trip (traveling up to 30 years back in time might take some... time, after all).

Okay, we are now finally ready to take a proper look at the new Soviet focus tree (well, except for the Alt-history branches, those are for the next week).
07 FULL HISTORICAL.png

Kinda wide and populated, yes? Well, our main goal with this rework was to offer a more flavorful and historically-accurate experience, while presenting the player with an ample variety of options (both historical and not-so-historical-but-still-plausible) to go for in every different area, just as the largest country in the world deserves!
In terms of gameplay, there are lots of short focuses in this tree, however you will never be able to complete all the focuses in all branches (unless you play until very, very late in-game). You will have to choose your strategy and pick the focuses and branches that will be key for your success in the campaign.

Let’s start talking about the industrial branch.
08 Industrial Branch.png


During the first years of Soviet rule, the economic and industrial development basically consisted of recovering the formerly rural-agricultural Russian economy from the devastation of the Civil War. From 1921 to 1928, the USSR pursued the New Economic Policy (replacing the policy of War Communism, which had led to the decline of the national economy). During the time of the NEP parts of the means of production (light industry, food industry, etc.) was largely in private hands, while the state controlled the heavy industry, transport, banks and international trade.
However, during the Stalinist era, the primary goal was the establishment of an industrial base in the country, and during the late 1920s measures were taken again against the kulaks, initiating the collapse of the NEP. In 1928 the implementation of the First Five Year Plan began, followed by a forced industrialization and collectivization.

As you might guess, the main feature of the Soviet industrial branch is the Five Year Plans:
You start with a National Spirit representing the Second Five Year Plan (1933-1937), this plan was characterized by a harsh collectivization and a major advance in industrialization and infrastructure. However, the hectic pace of this industrialization and the lack of qualified personnel often resulted in high accident rates (meaning frequent losses in lives and expensive material) and, overall, low efficiency.
09 FYP NS.png


As you complete focuses on the Five Year Plan branch, your National Spirit will evolve, representing the Third Five Year Plan (1938-”1942”, the plan was of course ruined in 1941 after Barbarossa). This plan initially emphasized the need of increasing quality in production and resource extraction. However, with tensions in Europe growing at an alarming rate, the plan soon started to gradually focus on defense and military production.

This is represented in game by the possibility of specializing your Third Five Year Plan, you can focus on increasing the efficiency of your factories in the long term, or you can shift the focus to start boosting armament production as soon as possible. As you might have noticed, the focuses in the centre are all resource-related.
10A FYP Generic.png
10B FYP Civilian.png
10C FYP Military.png


As I’ve mentioned, the Third Five Year Plan was ruined after Barbarossa, so how is that represented in HOI?
Well, all the focuses related to the Third Five Year Plan (the ones inside the red boxes below) will get locked forever once the Soviet Union gets dragged into a war against a major country, meaning that once the Great Patriotic War starts, the Third Five Year Plan goes to hell, forever. You will keep your current national spirit with all its bonuses, but you won’t be able to progress any further in this part of the branch.
11A Third FYP Focuses.png
11B Third FYP Tooltip.png


But fear not, that’s not the end of the Five Year Plans. If you manage to survive and defeat your enemies, and right after the peace conference against the enemy that ruined your five year plan, Restoration and Development will be automatically completed for you, not only granting temporary bonuses for repairing and rebuilding your (potentially) devastated industry and infrastructure, with a cost in consumer goods, but also unlocking access to the Fourth Five Year Plan and the final focuses in the industrial branch. The Fourth Five Year Plan (1946-1950) was focused around the reconstruction and economic development of the country.
12A Restoration and Development.png
12B Fourth FYP.png


The focuses below the Fourth Five Year Plan are late-game focuses aiming to provide interesting things to do and goals to achieve if you decide to continue playing after the main war (or if you manage to have an independent war against another major while world war 2 is raging elsewhere).

The COMECON was an economic organization, founded in 1949 by countries from the Eastern Bloc, and led by the Soviet Union. Once you complete the focus Found the COMECON (presumably earlier than 1949), a small decision system will be unlocked, aimed at aiding your allies (usually at your expense) in order to boost their military and industry so that they keep the pace in the potential wars to come.
13A COMECON Focus.png
13B COMECON Decisions.png


To the right of the Five Year Plan focuses, we have a choice to make: train National Specialists or rely on Foreign Experts. The first will significantly improve the national designers, which are now slightly weaker at game start. The latter will unlock the Gosproyektstroy.
14A National vs Foreign.png
14B Gosproyektstroy.png


The Gosproyektstroy was a State Design and Construction Bureau set up in 1930 following an agreement with the "Architect of Detroit" (Albert Kahn), by which American architects became consultors for all industrial construction in the Soviet Union in the early 30s. This is one of many cases in which the USSR concluded agreements with foreign companies, mainly American (Ford, General Electric...) and German (Krupp, Borsig...) to carry out industrialization during the years of the first five-year plan.

In HOI, you can bring back the project, represented by a construction designer that will provide no research bonus (you’re relying on foreigners, after all) but that can, however, be improved by bringing foreign experts, boosting your production in the long term. Each country will grant different bonuses, Germany will give a bonus to efficiency growth, the USA will grant an efficiency cap bonus and Japan will boost your starting efficiency, for example. All of them will also grant a License Production Cost bonus (atm it’s shown as that amazing “None: +0.75” in the pic below :D).
15 Gosproyektstroy Decisions.png


The Russian Academy of Sciences, founded in the 1700s, became the highest scientific institution in the Soviet Union after the revolution. National academies appeared throughout the 20th century in the Union republics, and regional branches were created as part of the USSR Academy of Sciences.
16 Academy of Sciences Soviet.png


The first focus (The USSR Academy of Sciences) will grant you a research slot and a small bonus (1%) to research speed.The second focus will allow you to build more academies of sciences in the Soviet republics, both in integrated (not-released) republics and in puppeted republics, for an extra 1% research speed each and, if built on a puppeted republic, then it will also boost your puppet’s research, now that’s a win-win if I’ve ever seen one.
17A Academy of Sciences Puppet.png17B Academy of Sciences Integrated.png

Moving on to the Airforce branch.
18 Airforce Branch.png


During the 1930s, the Soviet government funded missions to break numerous world aviation records. Aviation achievements and records became demonstrations of the USSR's technological progress and Soviet media continuously exalted record-breaking pilots.

However, Soviet aviation was far from being in as good a shape as the Soviet media seemed to indicate. It was, in fact, plagued by mismanagement, inefficiency and technologically-deficient equipment, leading to a staggeringly high accident rate (in early 1941, prior to the war, apparently 2-3 planes on average were lost daily due to accidents, which led to the famous “flying coffin” incident, which sealed Pavel Rychagov’s fate during the Great Purge).
The Great Purge definitely took its toll on the Soviet Air Force too, newly promoted officers lacked flying and command experience, while older commanders, having witnessed the fate of so many officers during the purges, lacked initiative and efficiency out of fear of being labeled as enemies of the people.

In HOI, this terrible situation is represented via the National Spirit Soviet Airforce, which has fairly harsh and frightening penalties to anything related to getting your feet off the ground.
19 Airforce NS.png


Throughout the Airforce branch, you will be able to fix most of these penalties and get some bonuses too. You will not be able to remove all of those penalties though, since you will eventually have to choose between production or pilot training: the left part of the branch aims at improving aircraft production (more planes, better planes), while the right is focused on getting skilled aviators from among flying clubs, and training men and women alike to become competent army pilots, culminating with the three all-female aviation regiments formed by Marina Raskova (they come with aces and everything!).
20 Female Aces.png


And it’s time to talk about the Soviet Navy!
21 Navy Branch.png


The Soviet Navy was divided between four operational zones: The Baltic Fleet, the Black Sea Fleet, the Arctic Fleet and the Far East Fleet, with vast distances separating them.
By 1941 the Red Fleet possessed few large modern warships, its expansion had focused instead on submarines and light ships, aiming at protecting the country’s coasts and borders from enemy attacks, the naval defense strategy. After the purges (in which many of the advocates of the defense strategy perished), Stalin pushed to turn the maritime strategy into a resolutely offensive one, but the construction of large military vessels was hindered by the war.
Anyways, when Operation Barbarossa commenced, German bombers focused on airfields instead of targeting naval bases. The Third Reich didn’t need to destroy the Soviet navy, as long as their navy managed to blockade Soviet ships in their ports with mines.

In the left part of the tree, you will be able to reinforce the naval bases of any of the four fleets.
22 Naval Bases.png


You can then Expand Shipbuilding Plants to get a significant amount of dockyards, based on the naval bases you previously reinforced.
23 Shipbuilding.png


To the right, the PC of the USSR Navy will grant you The Red Fleet national spirit.
24 Red Fleet NS.png


This national spirit will be further improved in the focuses below, based on your choice between surface or submarine warfare. Most of them will provide some navy experience, tech research bonus and production cost reduction for the appropriate type of ship.
25 Surface Warfare.png


Long Range Raiders will also unlock Cruiser Submarines tech and add a couple of K-Class submarines to your production line.
26 Cruiser Submarines.png


Similarly, Expand the Morskaya Aviatsiya will grant you bonuses for carriers and navy aircraft, while also adding a carrier to your production line.
27 Carriers.png


And we’ve made it to the last actual common branch, the Military branch!
28 Army Branch.png


There are three branches here really, one for Military Industry, one for Defense, and one for the Army. Let’s start with the Military Industry, to the left.
29 Military Industry.png


Here you will find multiple research and production bonuses, some military factories and some tank templates.
30 SU 122.png31 SU 100.png32 T 34.png

Development of Tankograd will make it cheaper for you to edit tank templates, while also building military factories in heavily industrialized states in the Urals and to the East.
33 Tankograd.png


Last but not least, let’s talk about Merge Tank and Materiel Plants. Did you notice that there were similar focuses in the Air and Navy branches?
34 Merge Tank.png
35 Merge Naval.png
36 Merge Aircraft.png


Well, during my research for Soviet designers, I was amazed by the sheer complexity of just keeping track of a single designer candidate during HOI’s timeline, since many plants were repeatedly renamed (or re-designated), merged or split into different bureaus (which were also frequently renamed, merged and split themselves). Sometimes plants or entire bureaus were merged into even bigger agencies, and other times a plant would just be merged into a nearby, bigger plant to focus on the R&D aspects of it, for example.
Last but not least, we have the evacuation of entire plants from West to East carried out by the Soviets shortly before Barbarossa and of course during the war, which often resulted in more merging, renaming, and repurposing of plants.
So, in the face of all this industry reassignment frenzy and plant renaming festival I thought: why not just embrace this chaos and make something out of it for HOI?

These focuses will unlock decisions to merge different plants into your active designers, providing them with many different small bonuses. All these plants are real, although not all of them were actually merged into a bureau or into another plant.

37 Merge Plant Decisions.png

38B Materiel Plant.png
38C Aircraft Plant.png
38D Naval Plant.png


Worth noting that there are also a few new Naval and Tank designers available for the Soviet Union.
38D Tank Designers.png
38E Naval Designers.png


In the Defense Branch you can choose between building a defensive line in the border with Poland (Stalin Line) or in the border with Germany, assuming you have somehow gained control over Eastern Poland (Molotov Line). You can also fortify Moscow and the White Sea-Baltic Canal and the border with Japan and their minions. Impregnable Forts is meant to represent the fearsome coastal batteries around Leningrad and in the Crimea, that caused so much trouble to the Germans during the invasion.
39 Batteries.png


Further down the tree, we have Leningrad Polytechnical Institute, which will grant you your 5th research slot, The Road of life and the Soviet Atomic Bomb Project.
40 Final Defense Focuses.png


The Road of Life were the transport routes across Lake Ladoga (water routes during the period in which the lake is navigable and ice routes in winter) to Leningrad during the Second World War. They were the only Soviet surface routes into the city while it was besieged by the Germans (if you want to know more about the Road of Life, I can recommend watching a fantastic episode centered about the siege of Leningrad, as part of the documentary “Soviet Storm - WW2 in the East”. I find the whole documentary very interesting and enjoyable, by the way).
In-game, this focus represents the desperate yet brave and daring supply methods used by the Soviets in the direst of times. It will become available as soon as one of the key Soviet cities is threatened by enemy troops, and it will provide some bonuses to winter attrition and supply.

The Soviet Atomic Bomb Project was the military project, part of the Soviet atomic program for nuclear research and development, aimed at developing nuclear weapons during the war. It was greatly stimulated by the activities and achievements of scientific institutions and military industry of foreign powers such as the German Reich and the United States of America.
Initial efforts were hampered by the German invasion and remained largely reliant on the intelligence knowledge gained from the Soviet spy rings working in the USA's Manhattan Project.
The focus requires having built at least 7 Academies of Sciences, and it will provide an array of bonuses and tools to infiltrate enemy atomic programs and develop your very own nuclear bombs, including an extra operative slot and a new historical operative.
41A Atomic Bomb Focus.png
41B Atomic Bomb Success.png
41C Atomic Operative.png


Now let’s talk about the army branch.
42 Army Branch.png


The Army Branch is one of the most important ones in the tree, and it has a lot of content related to it, so let’s focus on the key aspects of it, starting with the initial National Spirits.

The Military was highly politicized, making it dangerously inefficient, even though political discussions (and indoctrination) among the troops also had its benefits for the Party. Politicized Military can be improved further down the branch.
43 Politicized Army.png


As you can see below, The Red Army has a lot of red modifiers, how fitting, right?
Well, no worries, most of the focuses in this branch will deal with those red modifiers, gradually putting your unreliable army in very good shape.
44 The Red Army.png


Once you Strengthen the Mobilization Plan for some manpower and mobilization speed, you will be faced with a decision to make: Restore Cossack Units or opt for Cohesion First.

After the Russian Civil War, Cossack troops were disbanded, since many of them sided with the white movement. However, in 1936, the restrictions on conscription of Cossacks for the Red Army were lifted and some cavalry divisions received the status of Cossack Divisions. The wearing of the previously prohibited Cossack uniform was also restored (although it would only last for a few years), and in this uniform walked the Cossack units in their first military parade as part of the Red Army in 1937, and later on at the Victory Parade on June 24, 1945.

In-game, Restore Cossack Units will grant you small bonuses to cavalry, a new general and a few divisions, including a new Cossack cavalry template. To be fair, this template is inspired by the composition of cavalry divisions (not necessarily Cossacks) later on, around 1941, but I really wanted to offer the player an interesting cavalry template from which to work on.
45B Cossack General.png
45A Cossack Template.png


Cohesion First will instead boost your division organization, in exchange for some extra training time.
46 Cohesion First.png


The old Rehabilitated Military and Military Reorganization have suffered some changes. Rehabilitated military will be available once you get rid of Stalin’s Paranoia and the purges (more of this later), and will help you recover some valuable organization.
Military Reorganization has now become an actual reorganization, during which you will have to deal with some nasty penalties that will be applied when you start the focus. However, once the focus is completed, not only will you get rid of said penalties, but your national spirit The Red Army will also get useful bonuses to modifying division templates.
47A Rehabilitated Military.png
47B Military Reorganization.png


Similarly, Desperate Measures and Lessons of War have also suffered significant changes.
Desperate Measures can only be taken while at war against a major power, and will grant a temporary boost to fielding divisions, as well as a set of decisions to help you contain the enemy invasion.
48A Desperate Measures.png
48B Desperate Measures Decisions.png


Lessons of War can only be taken once the national spirit granted by Desperate Measures is gone, representing how, even though the Soviet Union suffered numerous and devastating defeats and military failures during the first years of the war, those fatalities were acknowledged and the military slowly learned their lessons from them.
This focus is probably the turning point in which the Red Army leaves behind the terrible state in which it was at the start of the game, to begin the path towards becoming a formidable military force. The focus will not only add key bonuses to The Red Army national spirit, but it will also unlock the famous Order 227 (“No Step Back”), which will, in turn, unlock decisions to prepare and carry out important Military Offensives.
49A Lessons of War.png
49B Lessons of War Decisions.png


In your struggle against the enemies of the people, you will also be able to raise Penal Battalions in the form of divisions entirely composed of convicts. Penal battalions might not be as well-equipped as regular infantry, but they are definitely easier to replenish and overall can perform very good as cheap meatshields, as long as you don’t care too much about your manpower (something that is probably not the biggest issue in the Soviet Union).
50 Penal Battalions.png

Partisan activity in occupied Soviet territory (especially Ukraine and Belarus) was impressively high and played a role perhaps not very decisive but definitely important to the overall war effort. Organization of the Partisans will give you a set of tools to increase partisan activity, disrupt enemy supply and hinder enemy offensives, including a related historical operative and an extra operative slot for him. It will also come with a couple of partisan Generals that can prove to be very useful.
51A Partisan Focus.png
51B Partisan People.png


Once you have carried out the military reorganization and learned your lessons of war, you may choose what to do with your Political Commissars:
Keep Commissars Organization means that political commissars will continue playing the role of “second commander” within the military units.
You can instead Swap to Political Advisors, and try to increase efficiency by subordinating political officers to commanding officers, allowing for more freedom in the military command chain while the new role of political advisor focuses more on morale-related functions.
52A Keep Commissars.png
52B Political Advisors.png


The Glory of the Red Army will make it easier for you to unlock those last doctrines remaining and field more special forces divisions. It will also unlock a Soviet-specific improved version of the Blitz Tactic, as well as a new General: I read a lot about General Rybalko in various different sources during my research, and I feel that he deserves a place in the Soviet Generals roster.
53B Rybalko.png


Now, let’s skip the political branch for a moment and jump to the Internal Affairs branch, a common branch for the communist paths.
54 Internal Affairs Branch.png


In this branch you will be introduced to the new Propaganda Campaigns system, unlocked by the focus Expand the Agitprop. As you probably know, propaganda was a very important tool that the Soviet Union used extensively through media, books, films, theatre, etc. The use of propaganda was far from being Soviet-specific but, truth be told, Soviet propaganda was very characteristic.
55 Propaganda Intro.png


Propaganda Campaigns are a decision-driven system, full of new and, imho, very cool art coming from real Soviet propaganda posters. The system has three slots that will allow you to activate up to three different propaganda campaigns at a time, from among a total of 24 campaigns.
Each campaign will grant certain bonuses for a duration of 6 months upon activation, after which the campaign will finish and the slot will become available again. Every time you activate a specific campaign, its cost will increase. There is also a cooldown for the propaganda campaign to be available again, so that you cannot activate the same campaign twice in a row.

However you will not start with all these slots and campaigns available at once, Expand the Agitprop will unlock the system with a limited number of campaigns (both military and non-military) and only one poster slot. You will get extra slots in the focuses right below Expand the Agitprop, and different campaigns will be gradually unlocked by certain focuses scattered throughout different branches (Industrial, Military, Political…). In the image below you can see, from left to right, an active propaganda campaign, an available poster slot that is still empty, and a locked poster slot still to be unlocked.
56 Propaganda Slots.png


There are many different campaigns, there are military campaigns that will grant bonuses to MP, breakthrough or core defense, there are industry-related campaigns that will boost production or repair speed, there are campaigns related to prosperity (stability, research speed), campaigns to glorify and support the partisans, etc. Also, a small (yet very cool) detail is that all these posters will actually age when they near the end of the campaign duration.
57A Propagandas.png
57B Propagandas.png
57C Propagandas.png


Back to the Internal Affairs branch, both Positive Heroism and Collectivist Propaganda will still lead towards mutually exclusive sub-branches, however there have been some changes in them. First of all, both focuses will grant an extra poster slot for your campaigns, and each will unlock a different propaganda campaign.
Further down the Positive Heroism branch, you will get some production and military bonuses, and some of your generals will get promoted to Marshalls (prioritizing Konev, Rokossovsky and Zhukov, if possible).
In the Collectivist Propaganda branch, you will find bonuses to research speed, consumer goods and production efficiency growth.
58A Positive Heroism.png
58B Collectivist Propaganda.png


In 1941, after having learned about the beginning of the Great Patriotic War, Metropolitan Sergy wrote an epistle to the pastors and believers of the Russian Orthodox Church, blessing those who decided to go to the front. Relations between the Church and the Soviet government gradually improved and, in 1943, Metropolitan Sergy was elected Patriarch of Moscow and All Russia.
The focus will unlock Patriarch Sergy as an advisor. He will boost your stability and division recovery rate, while also reducing the Compliance growth in your lost states.
59 Patriarch Sergy.png


The Foreign Politics branch is also common for all Communist paths. The goal with this branch was to provide the Soviet player with ways to interact with different parts of the world, from the western theatres in Poland, the Baltic and the Balkans, to the Middle East and, of course, the Far East. One very important note here is that we really wanted to move away from the mechanic of sending Ultimatums to countries by justifying a wargoal on them, since those came from a time when decisions didn’t exist and were really unintuitive. So, Ultimatums have now been moved to decisions, along with a set of other decisions to pressure or seek cooperation from certain countries.
60 Foreign Politics Branch.png


The Eastern Development sub-branch is focused mainly on preparing your minor allies in Asia for war. You will be able to build some factories and help them field some more troops, as well as increasing their efficiency defending their own borders. You will also be able, of course, to annex everyone’s favorite, Tannu Tuva.
61 Eastern Development.png


Next, we have a choice to make, we can follow the Policy of Collective Security, as advocated by the PC for Foreign Affairs, Litvinov, which will lead towards an anti-fascist stance, or we can follow Molotov’s (also PC for Foreign Affairs after Litvinov was removed from his post) Policy of Individual Security, which will lead towards seeking closer ties with Germany and emphasizes the need for anti-capitalist policies. Each focus will unlock the appropriate Commissar for Foreign Affairs as well as an exclusive propaganda campaign. The final focuses in each sub-branch will provide wargoals against major fascist or democratic nations in Europe, as well as some bonuses to fight them.
62 Foreign Policies.png


Additionally, in the Policy of Collective Security branch, we can try to form a defensive alliance with France.

63A Collective Security.png
63B Collective Security Event.png63C Collective Secuirty Successful.png

The branches in the middle are basically a slightly expanded version of the choices the Soviet Union had before the rework.
64 Foreign Basics.png


Baltic Security and Middle East Diplomacy will influence countries in their region, and then we have focuses to seek (I guess you could sometimes call it “force”) cooperation with certain countries, and to just send an ultimatum right away, either way, the goal is the same: ensure Soviet control over the neighboring regions.
65A Influence.png
65B Cooperation Decisions.png
65C Ultimatums.png

65D Foreign Event.png


In the Eastern theatre, your first choice will be whether you want to befriend or antagonize Japan.
66 Far East Branch.png


If you decide to work against Japan, you can then pick your favorite Chinese tag and make it your protégé. Note that the Soviet Union will no longer be able to send volunteers to every single Chinese tag, but only to their chosen Chinese best friend. If you choose to aid the People’s Republic of China or the Kuomintang, you will grant them some bonuses to licenses and you will also unlock a (currently) beautifully unlocalized decision to send them equipment.
67 Mainstream Chinas.png


If, on the other hand, you opt for aiding your fellow comrades in Sinkiang (my personal favorite option), you will attempt to develop a “symbiotic” relationship. During my research on Sino-Soviet relations, I found the interaction and treaties with Sinkiang to be extremely interesting to me (for some unknown reason). Sinkiang was rich in many key resources, such as oil, gold and other valuable minerals, and the Soviet Union repeatedly sought to incorporate the region to their sphere of influence. They pushed for being allowed to carry out mineral prospecting in various regions, where they found oil deposits as well as tin, tungsten and other minerals, not to mention the interest on purchasing other goods such as cotton and manufactured products.

In-game, supporting Sinkiang will be the starting point to develop the infrastructure, the resource-exploiting industry and more in the country, sometimes in exchange for local manufactured goods (consumer goods reductions), other times aiming at getting resource extraction rights in the appropriate state, allways benefitting (in principle) both nations.
68A Sinkiang Focus.png
68B Sinkiang Decisions.png


This part is still a bit WIP, but the idea is that, little by little, Sinkiang can become permanently part of the Comintern or, in case the Soviet Union is invaded and its future seems uncertain, Sinkiang can decide to revoke its concessions to the Soviets (taking full advantage of the Soviet investments in the country, the Soviets will probably be busy and won’t be able to retaliate against them) and strengthen ties with their Chinese comrades.

Further down the branch, you will be able to intervene in China against the other Chinese tags, and prepare for the war against Japan. Since the Soviet Union had very specific territorial desires in Japan (Kuril Islands, Sakhalin and even Hokkaido), you will be able to demand Japanese submission if you control the appropriate states, offering to immediately cease hostilities in exchange for your desired territories.

If you, on the other hand, want to try and reconcile with the Japanese, you can offer them territorial concessions (North Sakhalin) in order to develop closer ties with them. You can then send an Ultimatum to Sinkiang, and form an offensive pact with Japan against the USA.

And we’ve finally made it to the Political branch, hurrah!
69 Political Branch.png


As you may know, the 30s and 40s were quite turbulent times in terms of social stability in the Soviet Union. After having secured power, Stalin was (at least, officially) quite worried about potential saboteurs, wreckers, counter-revolutionaries, spies, and so on. After several incidents (probably the most important one being the assassination of Kirov in late 1934), and with the desire of protecting and perpetuating his authoritarian regime, in order to lead the country in the direction he envisioned, Stalin gave green light to a period of extremely harsh political repression among civilians, the military and even among the Communist party: The Great Purge had commenced.
Hundreds of thousands of individuals and entire groups were oppressed during this period (mainly 1936-1938), in which everyone could be suspected of being an enemy of the people, and be treated as such, with potentially lethal consequences.

So, before going through the focuses, let’s talk about how this instability, political oppression and the process of the Great Purge is represented in-game through the new Stalin’s Paranoia system.
70 Paranoia UI.png


This system will be introduced to you at some point in early 1936 and, as you can see, you will be able to keep track of it in the decisions window.
Once the system is “activated”, certain focuses, decisions and traits will increase/decrease Paranoia. There are flat increases that you will get mostly via focuses, events and decisions, and there are weekly modifiers that will slowly impact your Paranoia over time, these ones come from leader and advisor traits that will be applied to Stalin and the NKVD advisors the moment this system is activated.
71A Paranoia Focus.png
71B Paranoia Stalin.png
71C Paranoia NKVD.png


And how does this Paranoia affect you? Well, once the system is activated, random purge events might happen if your Paranoia gets over 25. The higher the Paranoia and the more days it’s been that high, the more likely it is for a purge to happen. If Paranoia goes over 75 (note that it is capped at 100), then really nasty things can happen, and you might get what I call “great purge” events, instead of “regular purge” ones.

There are a lot of different purge events, and they can be sorted based on the “area” they’re targeting: the administration (civilian), the army, the navy and the airforce. Additionally, as I mentioned above, each “area” has its own “regular” and “great” purge events.

Regular purge events will usually purge a single character (be it a political advisor, a navy chief, a field marshal, etc.), or give some penalties in the form of national spirits.
Great Purges are significantly worse, their effects varying from granting nastier national spirits than their regular counterparts, to purging a number of characters at once while cowing some of the survivors, to even dissolving your aircraft designer!
72 GP Aircraft.png


As you can see, the loc, and also the system's UI are still WIP, but I thought I’d tease you with an event and maybe a few of the National Spirits you can get. Some of these National Spirits will be temporary, others will need to be removed via decisions.
73A Purge NS Airforce.png
73B Purge NS Civilian.png
73C Purge NS Naval.png


Purging will always reduce Paranoia, and you can also avoid purging someone/something when a purge event happens, but it will cost you greatly both in PP and in Paranoia increase, and you won’t be able to avoid the next purge if you run out of PP, so be cautious with your choices when dealing with purge events.

With the new Paranoia system and the purges, I wanted to make the player feel the impact of the purges not only in terms of pure gameplay, but also in terms of “people” (after all, everytime a purge happens, it means someone has been subjected to oppression, to say the least). So you will start with a huge roster of characters in the form of political and military advisors (not necessarily available) and military leaders. This list will slowly be reduced more, and more and more as people get purged. At the same time, your Paranoia interface will start growing more and more populated with generic portraits as purges rage on, with some key people joining in once they get purged, can you find the 5 of them? (Again, WIP UI)
74 People Purged.png


Now, how do we get rid of Stalin’s Paranoia and the purges (when going Stalinist)? That’s when the focus tree comes into play. The Stalinist tree can be split into two parts: The upper half before the Purges end, and the bottom half, after you have removed the Paranoia system. Let’s start talking about the first half.
75 Purge Branch.png


The focus The Centre will grant you some stability, PP and will add a fairly weak national spirit, The Politburo, which will be improved by the focuses in this branch (just like in almost every other branch in this tree).
The focuses featuring a bloodied sickle will trigger the historical purges in the form of unavoidable Great Purge events such as the Moscow Trials and the Trial of the Generals. These purges will always attempt to target people that were historically purged and, if some of them have already been removed from the game, then some random candidates will be picked to fill in the slots.
As a side note, keep in mind that, even though we are trying to keep it as historical as possible with these focus-triggered events, we need to take some licenses and group people to be purged let’s say in the First Moscow trial even if some of them were actually purged a few months later, for example.

These purge-related focuses have a cooldown requirement which will prevent the player from rushing that part of the tree. But once you complete The Bloc of Rights and Trotskyites the Third Moscow Trial event will be triggered and the Paranoia system will be removed forever: the Purges have finally ended.

Worth noting that some focuses in different branches (such as part of the foreign politics branch and some military and industrial focuses) will be locked until you get rid of the Paranoia system.

In case you were wondering, Behead the Snake will unlock two different operations to attempt to kill Trotsky while he is in Mexico. One is a raid on its villa, as happened in May 1940, the other one is a more subtle operation representing the one that actually killed Trotsky three months after the raid. Succeeding at killing Trotsky will not remove entirely your Trotskyite Plot national spirit (you never know how many Trotskyites may have escaped the purges and be still plotting against you), but it will drastically reduce its penalties.
76 Trotsky Operations.png


And we can finally talk about the last remaining part of the focus tree: Stalin’s Cult of Personality.
77 Cult of Personality Branch.png


This part of the Stalinist branch is mainly focused on developing a strong cult of personality around Stalin, starting with a new unlocked propaganda campaign, but you will also find focuses granting some bonuses to the Politburo, building some railways and unlocking a tank design template, can you guess which one?
78 IS2.png

Back to the cult of personality, all these focuses are titles that were at some point applied to Stalin in real life, and as such, they will grant Stalin new traits or improve existing ones. In order to emphasize the character of propaganda and manipulation of the masses of these focuses, they all require a certain number of propaganda campaigns to have been activated, the further down the branch, the more they require.
79A Inheritor.png
79B Great Cmmander.png


Finally, the focus Father of Nations will replace Stalin’s starting trait, culminating the branch with a “fully-traited” Stalin (WIP values), ready to carry out a world conquest!
80 Father of Nations.png


Aaaaand that was all from me! It was a long diary but I hope that you guys enjoyed all the new stuff we’ve been working on! (I definitely enjoyed working on it!)
Make sure to stay tuned for the next dev diary, where we will talk about the opposition against Stalin!
Be seeing you, comrades!

P.S. By the time this diary goes live I will be on vacation. I will do my best to try and answer any questions or concerns you guys might have, but I might not be able to answer right away, so please be patient :)
 
Last edited:
  • 290Like
  • 152Love
  • 27
  • 17
  • 10
  • 3Haha
Reactions:
  • 18
  • 5Like
  • 1Haha
Reactions:
I am slighty confused with the Stalin’s Cult of Personality branch requiring Propaganda campaigns. Do those propaganda campaigns the same as the Collectivism/Positive Heroism campaigns, or do they use the same system but are just a third option to pick from, or are they fully seperate from those propaganda campaigns?

Stalin's Cult of Personality branch requires that you have activated certain number of propaganda campaigns, whichever the propaganda campaign. Every single propaganda campaign you activate will always count for this. It can be military-related, industrial-related, the Stalinist campaign, etc. Every one of them counts.
 
  • 34
  • 10Like
  • 1Love
Reactions:
But I wonder why you would spread communism in Iran if you will just invade it. Iran and the Soviet union had a treaty of friendship. The reason Soviets and British invaded Iran was as they believed that Iran had German influence (real reason was to get acces to the railroads and in a lesser grade oil). Will this be represented like improving the connection with Britain and the Soviet union.

After the war the Soviets had to leave Iran, will there be an event for that?
There is no plan to add a post-war event for this, at the moment.
This is WIP content still, but iirc what I have planned is that you can send an Ultimatum to Iran, so commie support there might be useful to encourage them to accept. If they refuse, then you will be able to invade yourself or seek a joint Anglo-Soviet invasion.

Well done, just wondering since some of the focuses are late game oriented if there is an event for stalins death?
No event for Stalin's death, Comrade "Heart of Steel" will live forever.

Thanks for the work you've done! From the point of view of history, everything is clear, except for one thing: Penal military division
(because I don't know about divisions, only about battalions). What is the point of them from a military point of view in this game? And are there any restrictions on their number?
PS The idea that Stalin is not a person, but a figure that we ourselves fill with meaning through focuses is a genius, I take off my hat.
Afaik, historically there were no such thing as entire Penal Divisions. But for gameplay reasons we decided to create locked division templates composed of Penal Battalions, which you can spawn via decision yearly.
Players cannot use Penal Battalions in regular templates, unfortunately.

what is with the strange spellings of names, like "Beriya" and "Khrushchyov" when there are standard English spellings of these names?

I understand that transcription of Cyrillic into the Latin alphabet has changed since these names became famous, but it's a bit confusing and weird to use these "more accurate" ones when everyone knows them as Beria and Khrushchev. also it's arguable whether they even are more accurate considering they imply misleading pronunciations
It is something I considered carefully for some time before actually deciding on doing it.
There are several reasons that led me to rewrite all Cyrillic names so that they all follow the same transliteration system, some of them being the case in which the same Soviet person was written in 4 different ways between localization and script_keys as ideas, country leader and general.

I understand that it sounds weird at first, especially for people like Beriya, Khrushchyov or even Iosif Stalin, but I took as reference leaders in other countries: If Spanish Francisco Franco and José Miaja, and Polish Józef Haller are all called like that, and not Frank Franco, Joseph Miaja and Joseph Haller, I honestly see no real reason for treating Soviet people differently.

Last but not least, from the little Russian knowledge I have, I believe the system I use is actually more accurate prounciation-wise (imo Beriya is closer than Beria pronunciation-wise, same for Khrushchyov vs the old Khrushchev)
 
  • 39Like
  • 36
  • 9Love
  • 3
  • 2
  • 1Haha
Reactions:
He was definetly not paranoid, and the cult of personality did exist but not in the you have it your mind. The CPSU worked around democratic centralism. Making it seem that the USSR followed the Fuhrerprinzip is nonsensical propaganda. The purges did not happen because Stalin had bad dreams at night, but because there was actual factionalism within the party and the army. Were they way too harsh and broad? Maybe, but Stalin knew war with Germany was unavoidable while France and the UK rejected his alliance attempts. It was all much more complex than your average History Channel documentary would have you believe. As for the cult of personality there are several transcriptions of CPSU meetings and foreign interviews where Stalin insists on chilling the f*** down with it. Yes, Stalin was a leader, but he was not THE leader.

Instead we have the usual, "the purges happened because a blood thirsty mad man would not let anything stand in the way of his ascension to divinity". You can be critical of communism, Stalin, and whatever without falling for silly propaganda cliches.

I agree with most of what you say here, to be honest, and I can assure you that I want to move away from "the purges happened because a blood thirsty mad man would not let anything stand in the way of his ascension to divinity" as much as possible.
When I joined this DLC development there was already an idea for a Paranoia system, and with that as core I tried to be as faithful as possible to everything I read, and offer more mature flavor and context from the multiple sources I've read about this topic. I think the way the loc is written, the content is structured, and the details and flavor around it will have a different feeling than what you expect. But we will have to wait for release.
 
  • 51Like
  • 32
  • 12
  • 2
Reactions:
An absolutely amazing dev diary, I'm usually much more interested in the mechanics changes with each major patch but by god, this focus tree is excellent so far (especially from a modding perspective). I do have a couple of questions regarding some of the stuff in the diary however, preferably just more context :) Firstly, does this part of the tree (the coastal battery guns) show up as a modifier when in combat? and if so, is it to that state or province? Just wondering as that could be something really fun to mod with, such as the Norwegian costal guns which fired on German ships during WW2, and just in general, as being able to make your own costal battery installations could be quite a unique (if costly) way of preventing invasions more-so than normal costal forts.
Those modifiers are still WIP (haven't decided yet on how to represent them via modifiers), but they will act as state modifiers, affecting the whole state in which they are located.

While not to the same extent, German forces also used Penal Battalions during the war - is there anything in place to reflect this, or it is Soviet exclusive? And if so, does it just count as a new "tech" like bikes and camels, so something quite easily able to be modded in?
Soviet-exclusive for now. And yes, they are unlocked via hidden tech, just like bikes and camels.

Any chance we could see this applied to other nations on a generic scale in the future? Pretty neat concept, but hardly exclusive to the Soviet propaganda machine as you mentioned. Take it it's decently moddable as with most decisions? I'm not too worried if it's not planned, I'd just like the ability to do it myself in that case :)
No plans for now. I personally like the idea, but can't make any promises. Regarding moddability... It's not super-friendly but it should be fairly easy to take the system as reference, copy-paste it and tweak some stuff to adjust to your needs. There are a lot of scripted effects and triggers for this system that should make it quite modular and flexible, hopefully.

Has the Battle of Khalkhin Gol been implemented for this? I remember the difficulty being border conflicts couldn't work over neutral territory, but I hope that has been changed, it'd be a shame to miss such an important battle between Japan and the USSR
Not really, unfortunately. The focus is meant to provide different objectives in your war with Japan. I considered some ideas in the past, but I am honestly not sure if it's worth the effort of implementing a border conflict for this, while having tons of other things to take care of at the same time...

Really really like that this is now an agency mission, but does it have a chance of failing? Just wondering what the parameters are really, as it can be a pain in the ass sometimes when trying to do historical actions and RNG smacks you in the face :p
Can't recall the values right now, and they might change still. There are chances of failing, but you can ensure good chances if you put in charge the appropriate operative, as certain traits might help.
Other than those questions, I'm super impressed! You should all be really really proud, it's by far one of if not the best looking focus tree I've ever seen. I really hope it plays as well as it looks! :)

Thanks a lot! I hope so too!
 
  • 23Like
  • 16
  • 2Love
  • 1
Reactions:
With the industrial path highly linked with communists paths, how will it work if you go a non-communist alternate history path?
For Soviet-themed focuses in the common branches (The Red Fleet, Found the COMECON, The Glory of the Red Army), names and sometimes focus icons will change if you dare to embrace a non-communist ideology (you heretic!). Effects will usually remain the same, for the COMECON I believe the effect vary a little bit to fit in the context and flavor.

I'm really concered about the consumer goods debuffs you start off with, the soviet union starts off with civilian economy and adding this five year plan spirit will make the situation even worse for the soviets, a total of 40%. The soviets are in need of a good civilian economy to contest the german one, have you thought about how this will impact multiplayer lobbies? As trading 10% consumer goods for 5% civilian construction speed isn't that good of a trade. And by looking at the focus tree i can see that there are a few civ focusses, but i sadly do not know how much they will give in total. As the germans get 12 civs from 2 focusses.

Is there still a chance to test out all the debuffs from the start and check-out how this will impact multiplayer games? Because early war for the soviet union looks like hell from this perspective.

Overal i think you did a good job for the soviets, but atleast thinking about multiplayer games would be a nice way of showing you care about us.

As stated at the begining, these are all WIP values. The content is still under testing by our wonderful QAs and Betas, who provide super-valuable input in both single player and multiplayer scenarios. I haven't really spent that much time in balancing just yet (but I have some plans for that already), so no worries, we keep these concerns in mind!

Oh I've been looking forward to this one!

After reading all of the diary, when it comes to the military and industrial segments, this is very much on point!

Bonus points for checking out my Twitter comment regarding the Road of Life, would have appreciated the mention ;)

Only thing I have to disagree upon(regarding military) is Soviet manpower reserves, which have actually been a problem since 1943 at the earliest, unlike the "Asiatic hordes" myth which has become common thanks to Nazi officer memoirs and their insistence on how they did their best and what not. Using excerpts from the excellent "Soviet Myths Debunked" video by Military History Visualised to showcase

[...]

Thank you for reading!

Additional reading material:
Origins of the Great Purges: The Soviet Communist Party Reconsidered, 1933-1938 - J. Arch. Getty:
Stalinist Terror: New Perspectives - J. Arch. Getty, Roberta Manning
Soviet Democracy - Pat Sloan
Life and Terror in Stalin's Russia - Robert Thurston

Thanks for the post and the proposals (and the interesting sources provided!).
There will probably not be any major changes to the purge system at this point, but I appreciate the input and your proposal is definitely interesting! Maybe I can find some places that can be improved along those lines (can't make any promises though).
 
  • 19Like
  • 16
  • 1Love
Reactions:
Would be great to know what reasons for the purge you believe were. I would like to remind that at least hundreds of thousands of people were blamelessly murdered in the events, so a statement from a developer they “mostly agrees” with a post implying there were some good reasons for those is surprising to say the least. I guess a similar statement with regards to German history would result in a shitstorm.
I apologize for the confusion, I should have been more specific, my bad!
This is mostly what I agree upon, after doing my research and investigation (with many different sources, books, authors...):

- The purges did not happen because Stalin had bad dreams at night, but because there was actual factionalism within the party and the army. -> I agree, not as a justification for the purges, but because yes, there was factionalism (as usually happens with the left), and no, imo the purges didn't happen because Stalin was just a bloody madman, there is so much more to it.

- Stalin knew war with Germany was unavoidable while France and the UK rejected his alliance attempts. -> I agree (again, as a fact not as something justifying the purges, which are 100% unjustifiable imo).

- It was all much more complex than your average History Channel documentary would have you believe -> Agree

- As for the cult of personality there are several transcriptions of CPSU meetings and foreign interviews where Stalin insists on chilling the f*** down with it. -> True, and there is a "path" in the tree to go that way: "Humble Servant of Lenin" is how Stalin described himself during an interview, after having been labaled as "Inheritor of the Mantle of Lenin". In-game, that focus leads to "Ban Excessive Worship", also inspired in history, when some completely over-the-top stories about Stalin were circulating in certain books, which were then banned.

- You can be critical of communism, Stalin, and whatever without falling for silly propaganda cliches -> 100% agree
 
  • 59Like
  • 19
  • 15
  • 1Love
  • 1
Reactions:
Any NATO symbol for Penal Battalions?
Yes there is one, my PC apparently melted a moment ago so I can't access the game right now, but iirc the NATO symbol is the infantry one with a "PB" at the bottom.

How will it interact with already researched models? Without that interaction it arouses pretty limited interest as before war we will have much more important stuff to spend focus time and PP on besides tweaking designers. And during war we will probably just produce our horde of T-34s. So, some way to reapply design company bonuses to researched technology (maybe, for some research/XP cost) would be appreciated.
That's a good point, I will take a look at the system, keeping that in mind, and see if I need to tweak some stuff!

Given that some attention has been put on resistance, even including resistance figures being used as generals, will we see any additional resistance missions?

Will there be new covert operations similar to capture cipher/radar tech?

An area with resistance target of at least X could open up missions to target infrastructure, factories, the new supply depots, or damage radar/AA batteries/forts.
There are no additional resistance misions. The only new missions at this moment are the ones to infiltrate foreign atomic programs and the ones to kill Trotsky, both Soviet-specific.

Dear Developers,

first of all I want to say, that I am very impressed about your work on the focus tree and the update in general and that I very much look forward to the release. But there is one question I have to a game mechanic which was briefly mentioned. It was said: "The focus will not only add key bonuses to The Red Army national spirit, but it will also unlock the famous Order 227 (“No Step Back”), which will, in turn, unlock decisions to prepare and carry out important Military Offensives.", which means that there will be finally the option to carry out military offensives via decisions. My question is, is it planned to add this feature (maybe not in this update) to the Axis or the Allies, since they also had several iconic offensives.
Not plans atm, I personally still need to evaluate how well they work.

How will you be able to kill Trotsky if you don't have La Resistance? (Since it seems to use the new intelligence system.)

Overall this looks fantastic though.
Decisions (same for the atomic program). You rely more on RNG but, iirc, there are some factors that will increase your chances of success, like the target country (Mexico to use your question as example) having high communist (or appropriate ideology) support, or having very good opinion towards the Soviet Union.
 
  • 22
  • 6Like
  • 1Love
Reactions:
Time for Questions:

Will there be a way for Yagoda, Yezhov, or Beriya to take over and counter-purge Stalin?
Not as a Stalinist. No coups will happen if you are Stalinist. This is an intentional design choice we all agreed to follow in order to leave behind the "Stalin was right, after all" feeling of the old purge.

There will be more info about these guys and what they can do in the future :)

Will the Factory Worker Militias be weak infantry divisions similar to the SCW divisions?
Right now they are represented as a state modifier. I believe there weren't really any divisions made up of Militias, the factory workers would instead just fill the losses in the divisions fighting in the area.

Why is the national spirit "Central Headquarters of the Partisan Movement" only 720 days? I understand that some values may get reworked, but I think would make more sense to have it for the rest of the war, otherwise a Germany player could just wait it out.
There are a handful of National Spirits that I am still evaluating wether to make them temporary or permanent. This one could perfectly be permanent, but I need to make sure that the effects have the desired impact first.

I assume Patriarch Sergy will show up elsewhere on the non-Communist path as well. Correct?
:rolleyes:

How far south into the Balkans will the Soviets go for the "Demand Balkan Submission" and "Seek Balkan Cooperation"?
Not 100% sure but I believe it includes Turkey, Bulgaria, Yugoslavia, Greece and Romania.

Will supporting Communist China on a-historical increase the likelyhood of them doing "Marxist Orthodoxy" and putting Wang Ming into power? Also will supporting the Kuomintang increase communist support in the ROC?
Not AI weights for no.w I know something like that would be cool, but that requires time and is not easily done properly. If I have time I would definitely like to do something like that, but right now I have other things to prioritize. I believe that commie support is applied in the previous focus, before you choose your Chinese best friend.

Will the purges also target foregin communist leaders? Currently Hungary can lose Bela Kun via the Purge. Is this still possible?
Not for now, we'll see how it can be expanded in the future.

Will Stalin's paranoia remain if Trotsky both assassination attempts? What if Trotsky has become leader of Mexico? Will there be a special operation in that case, along with a war for Trotskyite Mexico if it fails?
Paranoia goes away once you complete the focus that triggers the Third Moscow Trial. Killing Trotsky only affects your National Spirit Trotskyite Plot?. Its penalties will be greatly reduced if you kill Trotsky. Regarding Trotsky being leader of Mexico, that's still WIP, we'll see how much time we have for that.


How does the AI handle then new paranoia system along with the new propaganda system? How has historical USSR done in your guys tests?
Still a bit early to say, supply changes have big impact on the AI and it's hard to evaluate other stuff. There are different AI weights for each campaign, so sometimes the AI looks smart, but other times it looks dumb :) I still need to work on it! :D

Also a question to the devs, i asked this in the Poland dev diary but got no response:

Will we be able to send Rokossowski to Poland and make him a FM there if Poland turns communist?
No plans for now, if we have time we might look into adding something like that, but no promises.

Will the new 'Seek Balkan Cooperation' Soviet focus allow the AI to form the Balkan Federation under Dimitrov if you own the Battle for the Bosphorus DLC with its revamped Bulgarian focus tree?
Do you mean "encourage" the Bulgarian AI towards seeking the Balkan Federation? Not at this moment. It would be great but it can be very painful to imlpement properly (we are doing something similar with another country at this moment), but I'll see if I have time and it can be done with reasonable effort.

Not sure how much time there is for this, but I think there could be slightly expanded options/choices for this. Maybe for each of them mutually exclusive focus choices between further development or annexation, (maybe with a third option of giving them to a Chinese ally, since China still claimed the area).

Mongolia actually petitioned to join the USSR several times for instance. So ideally the player could choose to keep Tuva around or to also annex Mongolia.

Regardless, both should really start as Soviet puppets like in HOI III, perhaps even integrated puppets. Neither was really independent at the time in any meaningful sense.
Annexation of Mongolia is something I've considered in the past as well, I thought about adding implementing an event or adding a focus for that, maybe even unified with Tanu Tuva but I am not a big fan of that tbh... I'll think about it!


Oh and I want to add that some of the Stalin traits feel a little bit redundant or pointless.

"Faithful Servant of Lenin" gives +15% stability and then also a bonus 15% stability from party popularity but since the Soviets are probably going to be sitting at 100% Communist popularity that second bonus isn't going to really change very much and could probably safely be folded into the first one. Or you could fold them both into the "Defensive War Stability Modifier" and make that +60% and save a couple of lines and feel very chunky.

"Father of Nations" gives -50% justify war goal time when at war with a major but justify war goal time when at war with a major is already like 10 days because of world tension so I'm not sure how much players are going to feel like that's impacting their game play.

The content looks really good but I am missing the Iranian occupation which was really important for bringing supplies to the USSR, a big part of why Stalingrad was so important, and a major potential operational target for Axis operations in the Kuban region and the Middle East if they happen to be more successful than they were historically. The allies shipped large amounts of rolling stock to Iran to maintain vital railroad corridors into the USSR, and this seems like something that would be really cool to have in the game, though full development could probably wait for an Iranian focus tree.

I am really excited to play this I have to say.
Yeah Stalin's traits were implemented fairly early in development and will need to be re-balanced in the near future also based on playtesting feedback. Thanks for the input, will take it into consideration!
And yes, there are plans for some representation of the invasion of Iran, nothing super in-depth though since time is limited.
 
  • 26Like
  • 16
  • 1Love
Reactions:
all I can say is that this looks amazing to say the least, my only concern is that, even though mentioned, there will be too many 70 days national focuses, still, I hope I am wrong, other than that, everything about it looks amazing, also I am so glad you worked on this since you've made probably my favourite focus tree in the past (bulgaria), you did an amazing job.

edit: for example I do believe that tanu tuva shouldn't require 70 days, 35 is more than enough for annexing such a small piece of land with so little resources.
There is a fair amount of 35-days focuses already, and more will most likely appear during balance pass. The case of Tanu Tuva tho, is that I wanted to prevent the player for rushing that and annexing Tuva super early, which, tbh, might not be very benefiital either way, so it can be changed.

I really only have one very small critique to make, given how great this looks overall: Since the Patriarch of All Russia is not a Stalin or Stalinist exclusive focus, I think it makes sense to offer an alternative to it. It actually doesn't really make sense that a more politically radical Soviet Union would rehabilitate the church, especially a Trotsky-led Soviet Union for instance. I also think a more radical line on religion is not even unthinkable for Stalin and the Stalinists. The ultra-Stalinist dictator of communist Albania after the war, Enver Hoxha, basically outlawed religion..

I propose that a mutually exclusive alternative be added that allows the player to double down on the Soviet Union's previous policy of state atheism. This could involve some kind of small political bonus, or perhaps even a small industrial/economic one, as historically atheist propaganda mostly targeted, and was most effective on, the urban, industrial workforce.
That's an interesting proposal, I like it. Can't make any promises but I will consider something along those lines! Thanks for the input!

One question, though. It seems implied, but not stated that Mongolia and Tannu Tuva are now finally properly represented as Soviet puppets. Is this finally the case?

Neither country had an independent economy or government. Representing them as puppets is not only historically accurate, but also has the added benefit of giving the player direct control over their army. For Tannu Tuva, it becomes a moot point because of the annexation, but Mongolia usually does produce a number of divisions which, although not powerful or numerous, can make a difference if the Soviet Union is hard pressed by Japan. The question of optimization of supply is also a pressing one that makes direct control over Mongolia's forces an important one as well.
They are not puppets, however there might be ways to puppet them on the run.

@ManoDeZombi was there another label for the "Stalin's Paranoia" mechanic that you considered? Most of the controversy over it seems to stem from disagreement over whether Stalin was actually paranoid or just somewhat very overzealous in his various attempts to consolidate power through murder. Otherwise, the basic simulation of internal Soviet politics as a process in which Stalin killed a bunch of people in various bids to quash dissent and centralize the country makes sense as a historical narrative and as a mechanical necessity for balancing the Soviet Union.
Yes there is, in fact I am not married at all with the name "Stalin's Paranoia", and we need to look for an alternative name not including "Stalin" anyways, due to reasons (you'll see why next week).
Something along the lines of "Political Paranoia" might be less controversial while keeping the essence of the political climate at the time.

That's a lot of content, thanks for the update. While i understand that you're going to work on balancing things out - just some questions:

1.) It seems like a lot of nerfs and debuffs - as you are not changing things for germany, how do you make sure that ussr doesn't get curbstomped by germany as the idea already before the nerfs was that germany should win 1-1.
So far, the input coming from QA and our Betas is that the Soviet Union is slightly more powerful with the new content. The new supply system kinda plays on Soviet favor now, so even without touching Germany, they are having harder times invading the Motherland.
As stated before, we still need to do quite some balance work, but overall it doesn't look that the Soviets are now going to be stomped by the Germans, if anything the other way around!

2.) That seems to be a lot of focuses of 70 days which limits the stuff you can do and on the other hand,
As I said, there are a lot of 35 focuses, potentially some more will come during balance pass.

3.) You are building mechanics of escalating negative random consequences. Are you sure that this + major debuffs is not too much restriction and imaginary choice? If war support is low, you can't really do anything and every game might turn out pretty much the same where you sit around removing debuffs and don't have much real agency.
Debuffs are not that limiting. So far the feedback we've got indicates that it feels like the player has significant agency and there are things to do all the time. There are fairly powerful effects, modifers and decisions all around the Focus Tree, and the sheer size and industrial potential of the country is also a key factor.

Will this actually be fun to play?
I hope so!

Generally it looks massive and detailed. My only concern is the 5 years plans trait. 10% of consumer goods is a severe debuff and other slight buffs could not compensate it. Even you go with Sinkiang it's still terrible.
As I said above, playtesting indicates that Soviets can easily beat German industry fairly early if focusing on that. Still need to do quite some balance, and I have some plans to tweak the Five Year Plans, but overall we are happy. Also note that there are other focuses in the political branches that will reduce Consumer Goods. We wanted to represent the downsides of a harsh industrialization and collectivization, and Consumer Goods looked like an appropriate focus for that.
 
  • 28
  • 9Like
  • 7
  • 1Love
  • 1
Reactions: