• We have updated our Community Code of Conduct. Please read through the new rules for the forum that are an integral part of Paradox Interactive’s User Agreement.
It was random you got the OEO council member; but yes I likes the irony.

Also I have no idea why the wolves never even thought about there being OEOs in the council. But more on that in the AAR---because I will do an AAR opposite other people.:p
OEO on the council wasn't a big risk I though. The only two hunts on the council I was in favour of was one on Skobelev, before we knew the whole council, and on Dr. Livingstone once I knew he was vengeful. And OEO vengeful would be a stupid trait combo. Delta shooting Alxeu was blatantly a bad idea that only went through because he sniped it in without asking anyone else.
 
How is one both cursed and blessed? You really like piling up traits Wagon.
As the rules state the blessing is used first.

How did Audren and Hazbot end up killing each other anyway? Pure "luck"?
Luck; as stated above the dice gave a 6 meaning Audren died.

Double digit winners, huh.
Yes; the village had loads of luck whereas the baddies had bad luck/shot itself in the foot.
Ah, so close to 2/2 as Van Helsing.
You won last time you were van Helsing?
Hax should have survived. Night order lists indicates that the werewolf hunt is after the assassin. So aedan was dead, and there was no wolves to hunt at night.
He wasn't hunted by aedan, but by johho the liar. So no he dies, since the game doesn't end until after the end of the night.
 
Did you think the baddies had it in the bag after we lynched the seer and doctor? Cause I was almost certain the village lost after that.
Not in the bag, but it seemed a good set-up to win. Plus we knew Johho was the liar for ages since I infiltrator scanned him. Getting the hunt around to him was more difficult since he was likely GA protected every other night.
 
You won last time you were van Helsing?

Yeah; got to out a bajillion people in the process. It was hectic, but neat. And, as before, I nearly mucked it up by shooting a JLer (in this case, Johho, who I terribly feared was cursed and making a play to end it for the baddies).
 
Because my hunt was set on Dr. Livingstone because I wanted the council dead, since I feared their powers, and I knew he was vengeful.
And he indeed would have taken out Ike had you hunted him.

What? How am I killed?
johho decided to eat you.
Delta shooting Alxeu was blatantly a bad idea that only went through because he sniped it in without asking anyone else.
Well I had a blast reading it. I will comment on it in the AAR; I literally laughed for minutes seeing that correspondence.
 
Game wasn't as unbalanced as the result ended out. Bad luck by the baddies, good luck by the goodies combined with some excellent JL play all upset the balance of the game. My only recommendation to Wagon when I saw the setup, was to add a few more curseds in as I thought it slightly tilted in the village's favour. Wagon was wary because in a previous game of his they hit all the curseds. In this game, the wolves hit no curseds. That happens sometimes and I don't think Wagon should get too much stick for the balance. Too many traits, maybe, but that's a more personal issue.


EURO and I will probably have the game thread for the next Big set up tomorrow, unless anyone else wants it.
 
Shouldn't johho be killed then?
Why? You weren't OEO and didn't have your vengeful set on him (or anybody for that matter).
Game wasn't as unbalanced as the result ended out. Bad luck by the baddies, good luck by the goodies combined with some excellent JL play all upset the balance of the game. My only recommendation to Wagon when I saw the setup, was to add a few more curseds in as I thought it slightly tilted in the village's favour. Wagon was wary because in a previous game of his they hit all the curseds. In this game, the wolves hit no curseds. That happens sometimes and I don't think Wagon should get too much stick for the balance. Too many traits, maybe, but that's a more personal issue.
Not to mention that the baddies shot themselves in the foot repeatedly; sometimes by accident and other times deliberately.
 
As the rules state the blessing is used first.

He wasn't hunted by aedan, but by johho the liar. So no he dies, since the game doesn't end until after the end of the night.
Ok, I think it should have ended as soon as the last wolf died and just end the night actions there. But I can see why you say the night actions all get resolved before the game ends.

Just so long as you were not having a dead wolf do the hunt on Hax. Everything should be fine.
 
Ok, I think it should have ended as soon as the last wolf died and just end the night actions there. But I can see why you say the night actions all get resolved before the game ends.

Just so long as you were not having a dead wolf do the hunt on Hax. Everything should be fine.
Also, since Johho had lied to be a wolf, technically not all wolves were dead until the night was over anyways.
 
Set vengeful? What kind of bs is this.
Vengeful is brutal for nightly actions. If a person with vengeful dies at night, they can kill any other player, not whomever killed them.
 
The post about hair obscuring his vision. I think Wagon was pretty laissez-faire with allowing lie posts, but johho made a nice RP show of it, so I suppose it's alright.

I thought it was necessary to say directly: "I'm a wolf".
 
Ok, I think it should have ended as soon as the last wolf died and just end the night actions there. But I can see why you say the night actions all get resolved before the game ends.
You could argue that people don't realise the wolves are gone until the next morning. When you already have left to assassinate/hunt somebody you won't get news about the developments until after having done your deeds and returned.

Just so long as you were not having a dead wolf do the hunt on Hax. Everything should be fine.
No it was johho who did the hunt; dead people of course can't hunt. Similarly if an assassin is targeted by another assassin and both want to shoot then the decide decides who shoots first and the targeted assassin could risk dying first and therefore not shoot at all.

Also, since Johho had lied to be a wolf, technically not all wolves were dead until the night was over anyways.
This. He could have started a third pack after all. And in all ways he were a wolf during the night; scans on him would return wolf and had Marshall padred Hax he would have been told johho was a wolf.

Set vengeful? What kind of bs is this.
Just like you have to set brutals. Though I guess you weren't aware of that?
And when Johho lied about being a wolf?
In that Tintin post where he used pictures of the Dupont detectives eating those pills which makes them all hairy and strange. I think it is from the Black Gold.