• We have updated our Community Code of Conduct. Please read through the new rules for the forum that are an integral part of Paradox Interactive’s User Agreement.

unmerged(17221)

Lee "Apollo" Adama
May 24, 2003
220
0
A History of the Little Entente​


A Czechoslovakian AAR

The situation that existed in Eastern Europe prior to the outbreak of the Second World War contrasted greatly with the situation before World War I. Where there was once a small group of empires, there now stood a multitude of nation-states of varying sizes. During the inter-war period, the large empires, Austria-Hungary, Germany, and Russia, had retreated from the region, leaving a number of smaller states in their wake. The Soviet Union had absorbed several of these successor states, Ukraine being the most prominent example, following the conclusion of its civil war. Nonetheless, a majority of these states still existed in 1936, when Germany made the first of its aggressive moves, the remilitarization of the Rhineland.

These small states were well aware of their weakness compared to the resurgant Nazi Germany and Soviet Russia. True, Poland had defeated a Soviet invasion just 15 years early, but the Ukraine had failed against a similar invasion. The Eastern European successor states were also well aware of the consequences of the Ukranian failure - oppression and famine. The nations of Eastern Europe had tried defend themselves against the danger: Poland signed a non-aggression pact with the Third Reich and Czechoslovakia aligned itself with the Soviet Union. Meanwhile, Austria considered itself secure after Mussolini mobilized the Italian army in response to the Nazi assassination of Austrian Chancellor Engelbert Dollfuss in July 1934. An alliance between the successor states themselves was largely unthinkable as a result of the complex series of territorial demands that afflicted the region.

Change came with the Italian invasion of Ethiopia. The French and British made noises in the League of Nations, but failed to follow up with actions. Austria began to doubt their former protectors. It was easy for Poland to sympathize; German loomed large on the Polish borders and German aggression towards Austria was quite obvious. Poland could only wonder whether the Polish Corridor would be the next demand. If Germany was willing to revoke the Versailles Treaty to absorb Austria, why would the Polish-German non-aggression pact be any different? Czechoslovakia seized on the opportunity to create an anti-German coalition between itself, Poland, and Austria. The two nations surprised Czechoslovakia by proposing not simply a coalition, but a formal alliance, a much stronger commitment than it had hoped for.

Czechoslovakia, bouyed by its diplomatic success, opened the new alliance to Hungary and Romania. Hungary, with an appetite for Czech territory refused, but Romania quickly agreed, nervous by Anglo-French actions, or, more accurately, the lack thereof, regarding Ethiopia. With memories of the First World War fresh in the minds of the statemen of the new alliance, Yugoslavia was not initially invited to join. Ethnic conflict, displayed by the actions of the Croatian Ustashe terrorists, made war in the region a strong possiblity. While the members of the new alliance, now called the Little Entente, hoped to provide collective security for one another, they had no desire to become involved in a war. As a result, many government ministers openly wondered whether the Little Entente would stand together in the face of either German or Soviet advances.

Excerpt from Eastern Europe in the Second World War: Collective Security in the Modern World

Appendix 1A: Eastern Europe in January 1936​
AlliancePic2.jpg
 
This is my first AAR, so suggestions are greatly appreciated. I'm playing vanilla 1.06, though I usually play CORE (I added a bunch of events and it seemed too complicated to add them to the plethora of events in CORE). As you can see, I created an alliance between Czechoslovakia, Poland, Austria, and Romania, trying to create a feeling of HOI2 in HOI1. Can anyone think of any problems that might arise from taking the Soviet Union out of an alliance? I don't want to play for six years (in-game) and get it with an unsolvable CTD.

It's also my first attempt with screenshots. Is the screenshot in the first post visible? If it is, how is the size (too big, too small, just right)?
 
Interesting.

This alliance may even have a chance against Germany...

BTW Austria in the Little Entente? Quite surprising, adding the altrenative history feel for this AAR. :cool:
 
Acesand8s1003 said:
It's also my first attempt with screenshots. Is the screenshot in the first post visible? If it is, how is the size (too big, too small, just right)?

IMHO the screenshot is just right.
 
Wolfhound: It's a little far-fetched putting Austria in the alliance, but it adds a little more uncertainty to the equation. Historically, it would be better to do Czechoslovakia, Romania, and Yugoslavia, but then I'd bear the brunt of German attack and be destroyed. With Poland and Austria there, I get a little help. Also, now I have three possibilities for the outbreak of war: Anschluss, Sudetenland, and Danzig, rather than just Sudetenland. It also gives me the chance of betraying Austria if I'm not ready for war in March '38, with some crippling effects on the Entente (Poland and Romania get the choice to leave the alliance and the chance of Hungary and Yugoslavia entering drops significantly).

Mettermrck: I'm hoping the Soviets don't go Axis. Actually, I hope they don't go Allied either. If they do, they've probably got a border with Germany, in which case, I probably won't have a country left. :D

Seidita: Thanks. Based on your comment and Wolfhound's, I'll use that as my standard screenshot size.

elbasto: Thanks for the tip. I'm using photobucket.com for now, but I'm still shopping around for the best. Photobucket resized a bunch of my screenshots and forced me to fiddle around for a half-hour.

Jopi: Thanks and I hope so too. It wouldn't be good if I lost my southern flank.

Dhatori: Thanks for stopping by.

Next update is coming in a few hours, as soon as I finish typing it.
 
Part I: Preparations

The First Preparations​

January 3rd 1936, Prague

The only sound echoing in the plush room was the incessant tick tock of a grandfather clock that sat in the corner. The room wasn't empty; on the contrary, it was filled with government ministers and military officers. Over a dozen men, all sitting quietly. The previous two weeks of celebration had been an inconvinence to the men sitting in the room. Anxiety about what they had done had grown with each passing day. It had happened all too quickly in the last days of December - war in Ethiopia, half-hearted British and French protests, another wave of Nazi and Heimwehr protests in Vienna, the catalysts for the most stunning diplomatic move of the decade.

The door to the office opened and Edvard Benes, President of the Czechoslovak Republic, entered. It was Benes, former Foreign Minister before recently taking over the presidency after Tomas Masaryk's retirement, who had radically altered the situation in Eastern Europe. The alliance between Poland, Austria, Romania, and Czechoslovakia had been Benes' brainchild. It had also been a major shift from his traditional policy of distancing the country from the rest of Eastern Europe and concentrating on the West, specifically France and Great Britain.

"Good morning gentlemen," the President said in a conversational tone, "I hope you found the last few weeks relaxing." The former silent men erupted in a hurricane of words.

"Mister President..."

"...protests from Berlin and Moscow, even some questioning from Rome and Paris..."

"...the military is in shock, all our defensive strategies have been invalidated..."

"...concerns from Czechs in Tesin and rioting by the Poles, we still have a border dispute with Warsaw after all..."

"...the German delegates in the National Assembly, even the Social Democrats, say they'll refuse to sit at the next session..."

Edvard Benes held up his hand. "Please gentlemen, let us act like civilized men."

The flurry of opinions ceased. The ministers looked at one another briefly. By silent acclaim, the Prime Minister, Milan Hodza, took centerstage to address the President.

"Edvard, you must understand. The world has turned upside down in only a few days. We find ourselves at the head of an alliance that is already fracturing after a mere few weeks. Our border dispute with the Poles continues. Antonin Svehla and the Agrarians aren't happy with Kurt von Schuschnigg's dictatorship in Austria and they certainly aren't happy with the fact that our soldiers will now be responsible for his safety. Ivan Derer and the Slovaks are...well, angry isn't strong enough a word...with our proposal to Hungary. They are well aware of Hungarian designs on their territory."

"Quite true, my friend, very true in fact. The alliance, our Little Entente, is certainly unstable. But the Third Reich as a neighbor is far more unstable. Our nation is populated by millions of ethnic Germans, as is Poland. We are viable targets for Berlin and we can longer depend on Italy or France or Britain as a protector...only ourselves."

None of the men in the room spoke in favor of the new alliance, but none were attacking it anymore. It will do for now, Edvard thought to himself, they will come around in time.

"On that note, let us address our new course of action. Field Marshal Machnik, you mentioned that our plans are now obsolete."

The officer nodded. "Yes sir, our major plans addressed Germany or Hungary as the enemy, but, even so, they didn't take into account Polish or Austrian assistance. It also fails to take into account our increased responsibilities."

"Responsibilities?" Hodza questioned. "I thought we had allies now."

"True, but war between us and Germany will now involve Austria and Poland. If the Germans make deep advances into Austrian or Polish territory, Slovakia would be wide open to invasion." Machnik replied.

Kamil Krofta, the Foreign Minister, spoke up. "Also, as the clear head of this alliance, we must also make some significant military contributions."

"Mr. President, the nation isn't ready for rearmament. The Depression has done too much damage to the economy. We all know that and the Social Democrats in the Assembly know it too."

Benes nodded at Josef Kalfus, his Economic Minister. "I have no intention of expanding the army just yet. Maybe in a few years, but not now. Rather, defense shall be our modus operandi. General Krejci, perhaps you'd like to brief us on your plans to expand the Sudeten Line?"

--------------------------------

February 1936, Outside the city of Krnov, on the German-Czechoslovak Border

The sound of the heavy machinery was overwhelming to Antonin Svehla as he navigated the rough terrain that would soon become an extension of the already impressive Sudeten Line. The young Army Lieutenant was carefully explaining the features of the new defense line while Svehla was ignoring him and carefully watching where he walked. Barbed wire, half-dug trenches, and the remains of boxes of all shapes littered the frost-covered ground. It was an undignified position for the head of the Republican Party of Farmers and Peasants, the largest party in the National Assembly, but Svehla paid the thought no mind.

"And the activity is continuing at the same pace throughout the region, Lieutenant?"

"Yes sir. In the autumn, we'll start work in Bratislava at the same speed. Cold, rain, or hail, the work will continue. General Krejci's efforts have helped shorten the expected completion date significantly." The Lieutenant then continued with his speech, walking past a group of workers using pick-axes to break through the frozen ground.

InitialForts.jpg

Regions of Fort Construction

Regions of Potential/Proposed Fort Construction

--------------------------------

June 1936, Prague

Field Marshal Machnik walked through the halls of the War Ministry after his working lunch with the President and the Foreign Minister. Plans for joint exercises between Czech and Polish forces were progressing rapidly. The first multi-national operation for the Little Entente should be underway by September. With his thoughts on the exercise, Machnik continued down the hall, rather than walking up the stairs towards his office. General Krejci was in the middle of a war game with Lieutenant General Koutnak. The two men were going to take part in the joint exercise and the Field Marshal decided that, with the operation now a certainty, it would be best to examine the two generals in action.

As he entered the room overlooking the massive map of Eastern Europe, the Field Marshal expected to see a flurry of activity as Koutnak's German force advanced against Krejci's Entente. Instead, the map room was empty. Machnik walked to the window to examine the situation below. A long line of red pins, representing the Wehrmacht, stretched deep into Polish and Austrian territory, approaching Warsaw and Vienna. Blue pins, the Czech army, either lay static on the Sudeten Line or were surrounded on the Polish frontier.

The door to the observing room opened and an excited Koutnak and a dejected Krejci entered.

"I see the exercise is over." Machnik commented.

"Yes sir." Krejci said. "I regret to inform you that most of our army has been defeated in the field of battle."

"Your secret, General Koutnak?"

"I massed my forces entirely on the Polish border, sir, and drove deep into enemy territory. The bulk of the Polish and Czech forces were surrounded, allowing spearheads to drive toward Warsaw. Without Czech support, the Austrian army simply collapsed and Vienna is now threatened."

"What my esteemed collegue fails to mention," Krejci replied, "is that western Germany and East Prussia were left almost defenseless. As you notice, Prussia fell to Polish forces and a French offensive could overrun the Ruhr without finding significant resistance."

"I was acting under the assumption that the French and British wouldn't respond." More than a bit of betrayal and anger escaped into Koutnak's words; the lack of Anglo-French actions against Italy and Germany had not been forgotten.

"Perhaps a valid assumption, perhaps not." Machnik stated.

--------------------------------

July 18th 1936, Prague

Kamil Krofta slipped on his jacket as he prepared to leave the office. It had been a long night, putting the finishing touches on diplomatic framework for the Czech-Polish-Romanian joint military exercise in late September.

"Mr. Krofta" came the shrill voice from a young aide as he burst into the room. "The military attache in Madrid is on the phone, he demands to speak with you."

Krofta, angered by his aide's rude interruption as he was about to leave, let a trace of menace enter his voice. "Tell him to call Machnik." The or else was left out, but was obvious to the young clerk.

"Sir, he says it's important and he doesn't know how long he can stay on the line."

Call the Foreign Minister and say you can't stay on the line!?!? The minister's anger was overflowing now.

"Put him on. He'll have fun serving the rest of his career on the top of the highest mountain I can find."

Krofta sat in his chair and picked up the phone. "Yes?" He was greeted by a burst of static, but it cleared in moment. The minister, a veteran of the Great War, thought he could make out the crash of artillery fire and the long brappp of machine gun fire.

"Sir! There's fighting in the streets all over Madrid. The ambassadorial district took a few hits and our ambassador's been wounded..." another burst of static came over the line.

"Thank you for the information Captain." Krofta replied, all his anger gone. "I'll inform the President of the coup immediately."

"This is no coup, it's civil war." The line went dead.

--------------------------------

Tomorrow (or Thursday depending on my schedule): the Spanish Civil War, don't worry, there will be more action and more screenshots.
 
Great update! I wonder how powerful your expanded Sudeten Line will be by war time? 2 or 3? That's still formidable enough to help protect Troppau and Bratislava and bring the Germans into a meatgrinder against you. So I take it your research is geared on anything that brings you ground defense?
 
Mettermrck said:
Great update! I wonder how powerful your expanded Sudeten Line will be by war time? 2 or 3? That's still formidable enough to help protect Troppau and Bratislava and bring the Germans into a meatgrinder against you. So I take it your research is geared on anything that brings you ground defense?

By the outbreak of the Spanish Civil War, I was starting lvl 2. It's nice having a Static Defense Doctrine General for the Chief of the Army. I should have lvl 3 forts by the Anschluss; if war holds out till Munich I'll have lvl 4. I'll probably stop at that point, as I'm losing a good 9 IC constructing those forts in high IC provinces. And, yes, I'm researching the GD doctrines and techs.
 
Excellent work! :) I'm eager to see how your alliance will perform. Regarding tinkering with alliances. I cannot think of any problems removing the SU from the comintern. In my own AAR I made France leader of the Axis alliance and had the same worries you have, especially if Slovakia would be created (which it was). Would it join my alliance and if not would the game crash? Fortunately, that didn't happen, so I think its safe to assume that you'll be OK.
 
well, if I were you, I would consider losing even more IC and build some AA guns in your fortified provinces...
 
Thursday Update - As Promised

La Guerra Civil:​
The Battle of Madrid​

SpanCivWar01.jpg

July 18th 1936, Madrid, Czech Embassy

Captain Jan Drakoff dropped the phone to the ground as the line went dead, feeling fortunate that it had lasted as long as it had. He crawled out of the ambassador's office, mindful of the rifle fire that still slashed through the embassy. Drakoff heard the shriek of yet another artillery round from General Emilio Mola Vidal's forces and laid down on the wooden floor. He heard the impact and explosion, about a block away I'd guess, and proceeded to begin crawling once more, reaching the hallway a few moments later.

"Did you get through?" came a voice from an old female secretary.

The military attache nodded. "The line went dead in the middle of the conversation, but Krofta got the gist of it." Outside the embassy, a machine gun began to rattle. "How long can our food last? We certainly don't want to go out there." That was how the ambassador had been wounded; he had been in the city when General Mola Vidal's divisions began their assault.

"A few days," the woman replied. "I wonder who's winning?"

July 20th 1936, Madrid, University City

Luis de Santiago y Vera labored under the weight of the heavy hardcover books. A copy of The Wealth of Nations fell to the ground but he didn't stop to pick it up. The young socialist merely smiled briefly as he stepped on Adam Smith's work and continued towards the makeshift barricade. Stacks of books, desks, and other hubris lay on the university lawn in front of hastily dug trenches. A few wounded soldiers, no use in the fight against Mola Vidal's units, directed the student's entrenching efforts. In University City, named for it's dense concentration of colleges, there was no shortage of either students or material.

Luis set the books down on the ground and turned to race back to the library. He was distrcted by a professor shouting at the top of lungs on a wooden chair. As he approached, he quickly recognized the speech, having heard it a dozen times in the last two days. The professor reached the last line of Dolores Ibarruri's July 18th radio address, yelling even louder now, "the Fascists shall not pass!"

Swept up in the moment, Luis replied along with everyone else in hearing distance, "NO PASARAN", 'they shall not pass'.

The feeling, however, passed quickly. Luis continued on his trek towards the library. As an artillery shell burst a few blocks away, Luis couldn't help glancing at the rifles resting on the ground nearby. Soon enough, they'd stop digging in and start fighting.

UniversityCity.jpg
Republican soldiers preparing to defend University City

July 21st 1936, Madrid, Czech Embassy

"Thank you Captain." the ambassador said in his raspy voice, as Drakoff handed him a cup of water. "It's been quiet out there this morning."

"Yes sir, it sounds like the fighting has moved on."

The ambassdor sat up from his bed, grimicing from the pain of the movement. "Has Mola Vidal advanced? Or was he driven back?"

Drakoff shook his head. "Unfortunately sir, he's pushing forward. From the reports we've started to receive from the rest of the country, this isn't an isolated incident. Towns, cities, even whole regions are refusing to acknowledge the authority of the central government."

"Were there any attacks on the embassy during the night?" that ambassador asked.

"Just a few looters; we drove them off without..." Drakoff stopped as a loud rumble sounded in the distance. The artillery fire had ceased during the night and Drakoff had begun to hope the rebel units were running out of ammunition.

"Where is that coming from Captain?"

"University City."

July 21st 1936, Madrid, University City

Luis had thought combat would be terrifying. He told himself that over and over, trying to prepare himself for the experience. Several of his friends had laughed with the inexperience and invincibility of youth. Luis had simply shook his head ruefully at their actions. Soon enough, they would be as scared as him, and there was nothing he could do to change their minds till then.

He had quickly learned, though, that he knew nothing of the depths of terror.

Explosions had torn through University City as the heavy artillery barrage slammed against the brick buildings. Mola Vidal's men had attacked the position soon after, their rifle and machine gun fire replacing the artillery bombardment. There had been no time for thoughts of the cause, no shouts of 'No Pasaran', just pulling the trigger and working the bolt of his Mauser rifle. It was over now. Thank God the young socialist thought, more sure of His existence now than he had been yesterday.

The fighting had lasted hours and the rebels had pushed deep into University City. Luis remembered the panic that spread through the reserve line manned by the students and wounded soldiers as the remnants of the regular units fell back in disarray. The rebels had assaulted the final defense line, my defense line, expecting victory. Most of the students had fled without firing a shot. Most of them had returned by now, all saying they remembered Luis standing there, alone, firing as the rebels approached. They all said he was a hero. He mentally snorted, I was just too scared to run. He hadn't stopped the attack, in fact, he couldn't even remember aiming. Just working the bolt and pulling the trigger. The rebels had been on the edge of securing the entire area, yet they had suddenly stopped and had withdrawn. Scouts were reporting that they'd left University City entirely.

What happened?

July 23rd 1936, Madrid, Czech Embassy

Captain Drakoff peered out of a hole in the rubble heap that was once part of the Czech Embassy as a column of infantry passed. Most of them were part of General Jose Miaja's division, with the rest being civilians. Students? Drakoff thought. He had heard of tenacious resistance in University City but he didn't think that many would have remained 'in uniform' (none of them were actually wearing uniforms, just their university clothing) now that the fighting in the city had ended.

Miaja's division, or the Saviours of Madrid as they were now being called, continued marching past. Arriving in the city early in the afternoon in the 21st, they had managed to seize the bulk of the rebel's artillery when the infantry was committed to the fight in University City. The students and soldiers had held up the rebels and forced Mola Vidal to send in his reserves, leaving the way completely open for Miaja. With its artillery gone and its supplies in danger, the rebels had retreated in disorder.

Drakoff turned to a young engineer, attached to the embassy's staff. "Let's see if we can get the phone lines set up again. We need to see what President Benes wants to do about this civil war."

"Yes sir. The rebels were defeated though."

"Here, yes, they were defeated. But they're still strong in the south-west and the north. This war won't end for a long time."

NoPasaran.jpg
No Pasaron - They Did Not Pass
 
Classes just started again and my time's been limited. I've only played a few days past the start of the Spanish Civil War, so it was either play or update. I'll try to play a few more months tomorrow and write an 'actual' update. Don't expect many (if any) more updates like tonight's, unless there's a popular demand for them.
 
A nice update. This is a real personal telling of the Spanish Civil War, not like the strategic ones I've read. I'm actually very interested in Luis as a character and I hope you develop him more. There's something about the 'reluctant hero' that's real cool to read. :)