• We have updated our Community Code of Conduct. Please read through the new rules for the forum that are an integral part of Paradox Interactive’s User Agreement.

Jopa79

Lt. General
48 Badges
Aug 14, 2016
1.466
6.096
  • Europa Universalis IV: Pre-order
  • Victoria 2: Heart of Darkness
  • Victoria 2: A House Divided
  • Europa Universalis IV: Art of War
  • Europa Universalis IV: Wealth of Nations
  • Hearts of Iron IV: Colonel
  • Crusader Kings II: Horse Lords
  • Europa Universalis IV: Cossacks
  • Crusader Kings II: Conclave
  • Europa Universalis IV: Dharma
  • Hearts of Iron IV: Cadet
  • Hearts of Iron IV: Expansion Pass
  • Crusader Kings II: Reapers Due
  • Europa Universalis IV: Rights of Man
  • Hearts of Iron IV: Together for Victory
  • Crusader Kings II: Monks and Mystics
  • Europa Universalis IV: Mandate of Heaven
  • Europa Universalis IV: Rule Britannia
  • Hearts of Iron IV: Death or Dishonor
  • Europa Universalis IV: Cradle of Civilization
  • Europa Universalis IV: Common Sense
  • Crusader Kings II: Way of Life
  • Europa Universalis IV: El Dorado
  • Victoria 2
  • Europa Universalis IV: Golden Century
  • Imperator: Rome Deluxe Edition
  • Imperator: Rome
  • Europa Universalis IV
  • Hearts of Iron IV: Expansion Pass
  • Hearts of Iron IV: La Resistance
  • Crusader Kings III
  • Crusader Kings III: Royal Edition
  • Battle for Bosporus
  • Hearts of Iron IV: No Step Back
  • Hearts of Iron 4: Arms Against Tyranny
  • Europa Universalis IV: Mare Nostrum
  • Europa Universalis IV: Third Rome
  • Crusader Kings II
  • Europa Universalis IV: Res Publica
  • Europa Universalis IV: Call to arms event
  • Europa Universalis IV: Conquest of Paradise
  • Crusader Kings II: Sword of Islam
  • Crusader Kings II: Sons of Abraham
  • Crusader Kings II: The Republic
  • Crusader Kings II: Rajas of India
  • Crusader Kings II: The Old Gods
  • Crusader Kings II: Legacy of Rome
  • Crusader Kings II: Charlemagne
This spring it will be 100 years from the end of the Finnish Civil War in 1918. It was a conflict for the leadership and control of Finland during nation's transition to an independent state. The collapse of the Russian Empire caused a power vacuum in the Grand Duchy of Finland and this led to internal tension in the Finnish social order. The downfall of the former government created serious crisis in the political power and militarily. Two different authorities in the field of politics were established in Finland, The Senate of Finland(Whites) and The People's Council(Reds). Disagreements between these two parties eventually resulted a full-scale war, the Finnish Civil War.

When measured in time, the war was a short, three and a half months. But it's known for its cruel drawbacks to which both parties committed. The mental wounds caused by this war rooted deep in to the Finnish society for decades and the war and matters related to it were kept in silent. Even in modern day talks it's hard to find a neutral interpretation and the topic is challenging. Some matters are transpired in the battle of Syrjäntaka in the ending days of the Finnish Civil War.

In February 1918 the Reds carried out a general offensive but it turned to be an unsuccesful in all fronts. The Whites counter-attacked and the Reds line of defense was crushed in many critical points. Meanwhile the German Baltic Sea Division had landed in the coast of the southern Finland capturing its capital, Helsinki and continued deeper in the heartland. Now with heavy pressure from south and from north the Reds had to retreat aiming Karelian Isthmus where their lines still could repel the attacker.

This pullback movement obtained signs of chaos and panic and it also hit the "red" civilian people living in the area. They didn't feel being safe if they would fall into the Whites or the Germans. Researchers are talking of tens of thousands of civilian refurgees who joined this withdrawal.

Towards the crossroads of Syrjäntaka withdrew 5 000 Red Guard soldiers and with them 18km long column of refurgees. Contingent of German troops, approximately 400 men had previously taken control of the crossroads. Without knowing the presence of each other they encountered and the battle started in a darkening evening.

The Germans had dug-in but the line was stretched thin due the low number in men. The Reds were not organized well due the painful retreat and the chaos of the column of the refurgees. The darkness hindered action, but secondly all nearby buildings were ignited fire due this battle. Uncertain about the future destiny and the despair of the crowd, the Reds tried to break through the German defensive line through all the night. Company of Red women soldiers participated this fiercely fight as well as other women and children from among the refurgees. At dawn the German resistance wavered when the casualties and losses increased, they were also low on ammunition. The battle resulted a Red breakthrough and the crossroads remained open for retreating Reds and refurgees for 10 more hours.

In military terms battle of Syrjäntaka was irrelevant, it didn't affect the outcome of the war, the Reds and the refurgees never made to the Karelian Front or Soviet-Russia, they all surrendered at the end of the war just a few days later. The outcome of the Syrjäntaka battle was the last victory achieved by the Red Guard in the Finnish Civil War. But there are other significant aspects in this matter. It is noticeable that this battle was fought between the Reds and German Empire, there were no White Guard forces present. This tells about the desire of establishing a German hegemony in Finland and creating a German possession in the country. This didn't happen in the end because of the outcome of the World War I. Another significant point is the masse of the civilian population who attended fighting and the local people suffering directly and unintentionally. This is completely unusual event in Finnish history. In Syrjäntaka it was apparent that the Finnish Civil War applied to all sections of population, soldiers, men, women, children, civilian. It is unfortunate to say that the uncertainity and the fear among the refurgees was justly, it all came true in the aftermath of this war.
 
Here's a few questions from me, both regarding Finland in early 20th century, about the civil war and battle itself.

What was the pre-war relation between Finland and the Finns and the Tsar in S:t Petersburg?

How much of the forces in the Finnish Civil War were ex-Russian Imperial soldiers? I understand that Mannerheim for example had a role to play and that he had a past in the Russian Imperial Army.

What were the total ammount of losses for both sides respectively in this battle?

Also you write that

This tells about the desire of establishing a German hegemony in Finland and creating a German possession in the country.

And its not clear to me what you mean. Did Germany want to annext Finland? Did they want, as I recall, to install a German noble as the new monarch of Finland or what's the thing here?

You mention that this battle tells that the Germans wanted to create a hegemony in Finland, but why would this battle be significant of this? In all honestly I just see a skirmish that didn't lead to anything particular. Now in the presence of German troops I can certainly see that Germany had interestes in Finland, but why would this skirmish be important at all regarding this? Were there no other fights between the Red Finns and the German troops?
 
I'm not sure how there being a German presence in the civil war, and more exactly a purely German unit fighting without any "whites" nearby is supposed to be proof for establishing Germany hegemony in Finland, much less "creating a possession in Finland". There are countless times foreign units who helped one side in a civil war ended up in a battle in which they didn't fight alongside troops from the side they were helping. That doesn't somehow make it anything but one battle in which they happened not to fight alongside their "allies".

Yes, Germany did have a general interest in helping establish states in eastern Europe and along the Baltic sea that could act as a buffer to the Soviets, be a possible source of resources and have a friendly attitude towards Germany. Not to mention that it would help keep the Soviets away from that territory. German help was partially a request by White Finland, as they were vastly outnumbered in terms of troops, partially an offer by Germany. Seeing how the Reds controlled the south of the country, with the whites mostly controlling the north, any German involvement would obviously operate independently from white units at the beginning. The whole thing was like a pincer movement, with the whites coming from the north and the Germans from the south. Doesn't change the fact that they were operating in concordance with each other. In fact, it was Detachement Brandenstein which linked up with the whites and cut off the link between the Reds and their path to the east. After the civil war was over, the German troops were asked to stay for the time being and helped create the Finnish army. With some parts returning to Germany by August, and the rest leaving by December.

A single relatively small battle isn't really any sort of indication of what German plans were, especially when you consider that German troops had linked up with the whites at that point, with the reds merely trying to break through at a point in the line that was held by Germans.

And from what I've gathered, most of the civilians involved where supposedly the families of the red troops. That those didn't want to stay behind (or the troops wanting to leave them behind) is obvious. As is that they might help with breaking through the lines if they thought it could help them get away. It's not like a civil war really has clearly defined soldiers and civilians. There was no fully operational standing army at that point, making many of the combatants civilians that took up arms. In other words: militia.
 
Hi Gurkhal!

What was the pre-war relation between Finland and the Finns and the Tsar in S:t Petersburg?

Finland and the Finns had a strong desire and aspiration for nation's independence during the late 19th and early 20th centuries. The relations with the Russian Empire cannot be described as very warm-hearted. During this period the Russian Empire aimed at limiting the special status of the Grand Duchy of Finland, terminating its political autonomy and cultural uniqueness (1899-1905 and again 1908-1917). This era is called the Russification of Finland. This activity awakened growing Finnish resistance e.g. The Jaeger Movement and also this historical event is strongly linked in the Finnish Civil War and the entire Finnish society during the interwar years in 1920s and 1930s. It can be said that at least the Finns were content for the collapse of the Tsarist Reign because of the Finnish independence efforts, but Finland didn't see or wasn't prepared for the formidable eruption of chaos. You can read more from here:

300px-Suomineito[1].jpg

The Finnish Maiden defends against the eagle of Russia (Painting symbolizing the era of Russification of Finland)


https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Russification_of_Finland
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jäger_Movement

How much of the forces in the Finnish Civil War were ex-Russian Imperial soldiers? I understand that Mannerheim for example had a role to play and that he had a past in the Russian Imperial Army.

Exact numbers are very hard even to estimate, but it's known that during the Finnish Civil War there were 80 000-90 000 Russian Imperial soldiers in Finland. The Finnish White Guard carried out the disarmament of the Russian forces and after it there remained 7 000-10 000 of Russian troops active in the Red Guard of Finland. These troops were not very active in combat and they had no responsible duties in the fronts compared to the German Baltic Sea Division in the ranks of the White Guard. But some Russian officers served in management positions and they were military advisors in the Red Guard.

Against as some might think - with the career and the service in Russian Army, Mannerheim didn't serve in Finnish Red Guard. He choose his side and he was appointed Chief of Staff of the Finnish White Guard.

200px-Mannerheim_rakuuna[1].jpg

Mannerheim in Russian Dragoon officer uniform

What were the total ammount of losses for both sides respectively in this battle?

Battle of Syrjäntaka was a minor battle in the Finnish Civil War and maybe in English the most proper term would be 'skirmishing'. However, in this battle there were some phenomena and events of ruthlessness, cruelty, outrage and desperation - and these words describe well the aftermath of the Finnish Civil War. The direct translation or the meaning of this 'skirmishing' -word is in Finnish too dilute, still in the combat in Syrjäntaka human lives were lost. German casualties were 48 dead and 88 wounded. The Reds lost 300 in dead and 315 in wounded. After this first phase of combat the German detachment retreated some distance to higher ground and from there observed the marching Red Guardians and the refurgees. When they noticed the end of the column they cut off the Syrjäntaka crossroads again taking 150 women Red Guard soldiers as prisoners and handed them over the Finnish White Guard. The Whites executed them almost immediately.

300px-Captured_Red_women_in_Syrjäntaka_1918[1].jpg

Syrjäntaka Red women prisoners and a German soldier

Did Germany want to annext Finland? Did they want, as I recall, to install a German noble as the new monarch of Finland or
what's the thing here?

Yes, I explained this matter slightly weakly at first. The German Empire joined the Finnish Civil War in absolute complete - unlike The Russian Empire. In Syrjäntaka there was no Whites in Chief of Command, the Germans acted at their own discretion, maybe instructed by the Whites. It's a multiplicity of things when talking about this matter and many real facts are still hidden and the studying and researching of all this is still unfinished. To clarify some issues, it might be that the Finns didn't expect the independence to happen like it did. In Finnish society this era was thrilled by the ideas of rejoining the nation of Sweden and a part of the population favored the annexation of the German Empire. Historians say, that in foreign policy in 1918 Finland was under German possession, protectorate and a military beachhead. The Finns just could beat the course in the whirlpools of the Great War and struggle between the Russians and the Germans. Their point of interest limited the Finnish operating possibilities and these Great Powers "set the spot" of Finland. Against all the expectations both of these Empires collapsed in the World War I. The idea of German Monarchy in Finland fell with the German defeat in the First World War. Eventually, the matter of independence was just Finnish and in their own hands.
 
Last edited: