CK II - Counties revolting with effectively less than 0% revolt risk

[ThisIsMyForumAccount]

One line summary of your issue
Counties revolting with effectively less than 0% revolt risk

Game Version
3.2.1 [AZCE]

What expansions do you have installed?
All of the above

Do you have mods enabled?
No

Please explain your issue is in as much detail as possible.
I've seen this for a while, but it's getting tiresome, especially since my realm is massive. Peasant revolts are an annoyance, sure, but it's worse when you're trying to stomp out heresies and such in counties that are at risk, and then you get a revolt in a county that has a less than 0% effective chance of revolt. Why does this even happen? The county is prospering, the peasants are happy, I've recently crushed another revolt...and then they decide to have a futile peasant revolt and I have to stand up armies AGAIN and squash it.

Peasant revolts should only happen in counties that have a greater than 0% effective chance of revolt. It's not something that should just spontaneously occur.

Steps to reproduce the issue.
Get a massive, world-spanning realm. Wait. It'll happen eventually.

Upload Attachment

 

[Karlington]

One line summary of your issue
Counties revolting with effectively less than 0% revolt risk

Game Version
3.2.1 [AZCE]

What expansions do you have installed?
All of the above

Do you have mods enabled?
No

Please explain your issue is in as much detail as possible.
I've seen this for a while, but it's getting tiresome, especially since my realm is massive. Peasant revolts are an annoyance, sure, but it's worse when you're trying to stomp out heresies and such in counties that are at risk, and then you get a revolt in a county that has a less than 0% effective chance of revolt. Why does this even happen? The county is prospering, the peasants are happy, I've recently crushed another revolt...and then they decide to have a futile peasant revolt and I have to stand up armies AGAIN and squash it.

Peasant revolts should only happen in counties that have a greater than 0% effective chance of revolt. It's not something that should just spontaneously occur.

Steps to reproduce the issue.
Get a massive, world-spanning realm. Wait. It'll happen eventually.

Upload Attachment

Which kind of revolt are you having? Do you have screenshots or save games?

 

[ThisIsMyForumAccount]

It's your general single-county peasant revolt. They have the nerve to demand independence, or if it's not crushed soon it'll spread like wildfire. I have a save posted here: https://forum.paradoxplaza.com/foru...ails-to-save-probably-a-memory-issue.1222744/

You may have to wait a while, but I do see it from time to time.

 

[Ambion Iskariot]

https://steamcommunity.com/sharedfiles/filedetails/?id=1857649010

Screenshot from the same problem I had today.

 

[Rockphed]

I haven't looked in to how it works, but the antagonize option lets you inspire revolts in your enemy's territory (which might be cleared when the revolt happens). Also, the spy master can be given a mission to sabotage a county, which might lead to revolts.

 

[Lewa263]

I haven't looked in to how it works, but the antagonize option lets you inspire revolts in your enemy's territory (which might be cleared when the revolt happens). Also, the spy master can be given a mission to sabotage a county, which might lead to revolts.

The Spymaster sabotage adds a province modifier. It would show that in the revolt risk. I don't know about the antagonize one, but I expect it does the same type of thing.