• We have updated our Community Code of Conduct. Please read through the new rules for the forum that are an integral part of Paradox Interactive’s User Agreement.

Kasperus

Field Marshmallow
8 Badges
Nov 5, 2001
4.379
0
  • Cities in Motion
  • Cities in Motion 2
  • Crusader Kings II
  • Europa Universalis III
  • Europa Universalis IV
  • For The Glory
  • 500k Club
  • Mount & Blade: Warband
Delaying the Execution - A Polish AAR

Another AAR, this time with a country which surely won`t take over the world... My goal is to survive at least 3 months....

Poland, 1939-scenario, Story-based with a fictional mayor-character (colonel Lewandowski) in a day-to-day describing of the war of survival of one of the proudest but unluckiest nations ever....

Settings: normal/normal

A bit statistics from the beginning of the scenario:

Image2.jpg

Europe on 1st September 1939

Image3.jpg

Polish Government at the beginning of the war

Ask freely for more additional statistics :)
 
Last edited:
Prologue

September 1st, 05:00 AM, Krakow Barracks

The ringing of a phone sounds in the corridors of the silent officer appartements-building in the barracks at the Kawaleryjska-street in the suburbs of Krakow. the sleeping man wakes up and checks his alarmclock: 5:00 in the morning. He takes up the phone.
"Yes?"
"colonel Lewandowski? You are requested to attend to an emergency-meeting within 58 minutes from now on at the headquarters" - the harsh voice from the telephone sounded in the ear of the still sleepy man.
"What is the problem captain?" - even sleepy could the colonel distinguish the coice of the young captain Maraszewski, in the past one of his own recruits.
"er.... I have... I have been not informed on the cause sir. but...er..."
"speak freely captain, one knows that you know usually more that officially mentionnend from the headquarters. That was obviously why you made such a speedy career..."
"right. Thank you sir... I think.... Er... from what i heard the general will order full activity of the divisions here. there has been just a dispatch from the headquarters in Warsaw and... they brought some very bad news from the norths...eh....I think that...eh"
The captain could obviously not find the right words but he didn`t have to. Colonel Lewandowski was right awake. Moreover he was pretty sure that he knew what that bad news was.
"I understand it captain. I`ll head to the military quarters right in a minute."
"Is it ...has it finally happened sir? That..."
The colonel took a deep breath. It could have been nothing else obviously. But well, didn`t he expected it? Sure he did - they all did. General Dab-Biernacki has enlightened him as his communications-adjutant in the most recent events. He suspected it for a few days already. Now he knew it for sure. And soon his whole fatherland would have to face it...
"Yes, i`m affraid so son....It finally is so far... Hitler finally decided to make war on Poland...."
 
Chapter 1: The beginning of the end

September 1st, 06:00 AM, Krakow Military Quarters

The general looked up from his paperwork on the writingdesk at the man who entered. A tiny knick of his head made clear that he recognized the visitor.
"Glad you made it colonel. Please sit down. We are almost complete"
Colonel Lewandowski glanced around the room. He recognized everybody of course. The whole top of the Krakow Army was here, including the man in charge, general Dab-Biernacki. He nodded to his old camerade from the camp of recruits in the days of the Bolshevik wars - already 20 years ago - and now Major Janikowski, the commendant of the mountainous divisions of the Krakow army. The others: a Major whatever his name was, he always forgot, the guy of the anti-aircraft brigade. And another Colonels of the in total 6 divisions of which the Krakow army consisted.
When Colonel Bareziak entered a few minutes later, the general asked for attention.
"Gentlemen, I`m sure I don`t have to explain to you why you were summoned so early in the morning. I know you all have your information sources and yopu are all of course keeping urselves up to date in accordance of the latest developments. Colonel Marysiak who has been recently inspecting the defense of the Cieszyn-line has been updated by me personally before you entered."
"Gentlemen, I have had received the orders from Warsaw 3 hours ago, from general Rydz-Smigly himself. At the moment we are finished with this meeting you will start carrying out the plan 14. All the troops need to be prepared to move within 36 hours. The appropriate orders will handed out by mayor Kobylanski". - All looked at the mayor who was responsible for all the communications with Warsaw and the adjutant of colonel Lewandowski. He handed out papers, the first and thick one to Lewandowski, a smaller to every other officer in the room.
Lewandowski quickly scrolled through the pages. Most of it he could recite out of his mind - all the routines of emergency operations - not uncommon in a country as Poland in the recent years. The fresh pages he could have guessed of what they contained. Indeed, germany had declared war on Poland and the Allies in the west. Then an inventory made by the spionage-network of the german forces: About 20 divisions in the border territory, quite a few tank-brigades. Yes, tank-brigades, why we don`t have any? Lewandowski often didn`t understood the general strategy of Warsaw. While all the world was modernizing their warfare, the Poles let it decline. Now the country with the modernst weaponry attacks us and we even have no tanks! And our aircraft hardly can come of the ground, not that it is so numerous anyway. A strategical failure obviously.
The general repeated a few standard routines, but Lewandowski didn`t have to listen as he knew it already. Then the placement of Polish forces:
"As you all know our role is to defend the southern flank. The germans will come at us from both Silesia as the Karpaten. General Jagmin-Sadowski of the Karpaty-Army will take care of the eastern part of the southern border, we take care of the west. We have to stay mobile as the Chief of Staff Rydz-Smigly wants us to counterattack in the south and perhaps occupy Silesia. We play a crucial role in this war, don`t forget that. The Germans will have to attack in the north and there our armies will stop them. We are the moving part."
Lewandowski somehow could not imagine how the general came to that conclusion. The divisions of the north would never be able to stop the Germans. The terrain was poorly defendable, the armies small and bad equiped. Finally Germany could have attacked from the west, nort and north-east. No one could defend such a long line. How much divisions did we have there? 28 in total - apart for krakow army and the 3 Karpaty divisions as well the 2 small armies in the east all of Polish manpower. Was it such a good step to put all of Polish army in those so hard to defend positions?
"You all know that the germans will use tanks" - the general continued - "our own tests have proved that tanks are absolutely not usefull in a war, and especially not on this terrain. Still, the minister of Armanent ordered to build up 2 tank divisions which will be ready in 6 months. I cannot imagine how they could make a difference as we still cannot dig them in. The germans have a lot of those useless machines thus so we will see finally if there is any use to build more of them in the future."
Future...but was there a future? Lewandowski certainly wasn`t so sure about the uselessness of tanks. If they were so poor a weapon, why did the germans invest so much in their development? And yes, well, Polish-made tank wasn`t exactly top, but well, it was developed without any financial aid lately and it was almost not tested. Still it proved certain potential in testing but the government decided not to produce them. Now they did though...
"Gentlemen, you know what to do. You have your orders, now go enlighten your under-officers." - the general ended and left the room. Colonel Lewandowski issued a few orders to Major Kobylanski and left to meet his luitenants who were ready to receive the orders. Then he headed to the communications-centre where - he suspected - he would make quite a lot of days from now on...
Image1.jpg

Polish army in the west at the beginning of the war
 
Last edited:
Hmm. Thi should be interesting.

Does the colonel know the Polish stats?
 
errr... good luck!
 
Oh, a Polish AAR? In 1939? Should I log this as an "I could have wone, but..."? ;)

Looking forward to reading more. :)
 
Splendid beginning, I only hope you last long enough to keep the AAR going for a while!

Those huge numbers of German aircraft look a bit overwhelming...
 
Looking good...
It's nice to see screenies now when the NDA are lifted.
You have one perfect I think.
Continue in that spirit!
 
great AAR but one part confused me for a bit.
Mayor in pollish/russia/slavic= Major in English

Mayor in english means some one who is the elected ruler of a city.
Like a burgermaister or waht not.
 
Chapter 2. Showtime

September 2nd, 11:00 PM, Krakow Headquarters

"What did you say?!!" - Major Janikowski was a very stable man but Lewandowski expected that reaction. He reacted himself that way when he heard the orders he just presented to his old comerade.
"So are the orders from Warsaw, Michal. I guess they know what they do. " - he answered as calm as he could.
His old friend looked at him for the moment and saw the doubt and depression on his face:
"You don`t believe what you said yourself don`t you?" - he asked without expecting any answer and sighed.
"Yes, I could have knew that some idiot who never heard about strategical warfare would be appointed minister of War." - he continued.
"He is not for nothing appointed Field-Marshal. We all know that we have alot to thank for Marshal Rydz-Smigly. This strategy has surely certain value which could help us defeat the German beast." - Lewandowski kept saying that but did he really believe himself that Poland made any chance to win this war?
"Why Slovakia? We are to defend the southern flank from attacks from Silesia. You don`t do that by sending one fifth of your forces into the mountains to fight some Slovaks! We have no reserves for back up. Hitler can just walk into Poland between our lines!"
What Janikowski said made a point and Lewandowski has been asking himself already exact the same questions since he received that order an hour earlier. Invading Slovakia - German ally without doubt but how could the Slovaks hurt Poland? And how would the Hungarians react? As far as Lewandowski knew they still had not officially joined the war against the Allies and Poland.
Major Janikowski bowed over the charts:
"It will take more than a week to even reach Bratislava. If Germans will cut us off the supplements-line through the Carpathes - which looks also very easy as no one will back us up here - we are doomed and will have armies from Hungary, Germany and Austria all around us. How could that work? Who will take the lead of this charge anyway?"
"General Dab-Biernacki himself. He takes 6 divisions, including yours with him. We keep here the 5 divisions of Rydz-Smigly, stationned there" - Lewandowski pointed down at Lodz - "And the 3 divisions of general Jagmin-Sadowski near Lwow."
"Not really close to the southern line. How is he planning to defend the northern line if he has to move between Lodz and krakow? I thought that most german troops are stationned alongside the Northern border. Who of hours are in command there?" - the mayor asked.
"General Kutrzeba is in Poznan, general Romml in Bydgoszcz and general Bortnowski in Torun. They should stop the attack from the north."
Janikowski thought for a moment looking at the map:
"And when the germans break through the defense?" - Indeed, Lewandowski thought. We don`t have anything else in reserve. That line of defense is our only hope here.
Janikowski looked at him for a moment and asked:
"Aren`t you thinking that we could actually lose that war?" - God! He wasn`t sure there was actually a chance that they could survive! he answered carefully:
"Don`t forget that we aren`t fighting this war alone. France and England will not leave us alone. We can smash the Germans between... well, we can at least hold them on till the french and british armies defeated the germans in the west." - he said it what all the officers were talking all the time "officially". he didn`t think that anyone believed in it, but most decided not to think about it.
Janikopwski saw his doubt and his worries. They knew eachother to well after years on the front to be able to conceive their actual thoughts and fears:
"Yes, I guess you are right..." - he continued cautiously - "We do what we have to do, we do it for Poland. I`m leaving then. Wish me luck and hopefully we`ll see eachother with christmas. My wife will be happy if you visit us.
"I will, I promise. Farewell my friend." - the two men shaked hands, both wondering if they would ever see the other one alive again.
 
@Faeelin
Added a bit "stats" in the title-post. feel free to place more specific requests :)

@ZeShiWO
Fixed

@Sytass
Everything is possible but the title tells it already ;)

@Others
Luck I will need :D
Screenies I`ll add when appropriate
 
Originally posted by Kasperus
@Faeelin
Added a bit "stats" in the title-post. feel free to place more specific requests :)

Screenies I`ll add when appropriate

Cheers, Kasperus! You know what us HOI junkies are like: the more screenies and stats we get, the happier we are (though I must say we're in danger of ODing this evening :D ).
 
There is never enough SS ! haha :D
Althouhg invading Slovakia ? hmmmmmmm
 
You know, if you look at that map Berlin is only 2 provinces away from Western Poland.
Why not concentrate all ur forces into capturing that !
 
Chapter 3: The first offensive

September 5th, 10:00 PM, Krakow Headquarters

Lewandowski finished his dinner and left back on the way to his office. He was thinking over the developments till date. This war went so fast! How was that possible? Wars should last months, without fighting! But this time just on the 5th day of the war the Polish front has been hit hard. He ordered the events from the last days once again in his mind:
On 2nd september, just after general Dab-Biernacki left for that strange and useless offensive to Slovakia, they received the message of the first German aircraft attack. The Pomorze-army of general Czarnkowski was attacked and auffered a lot of sacrifices - including the general personally. General Romml replaced him as well as other official appointments for general-position of the various armies were made. Rydz-Smigly, the current Chief of Staff and defacto Minister of War, himself led the 5 infantery-divisions of the Lodz-Army. Kutrzeba was assigned to the 4 infantery-divisions in the Poznan-Army, Romml to the 5 divisions in Pomorze, Bortnowski to the 6 divisions of Prusy and Przedzmirski commanded a 2-division army of Modlin.
Then on 4 september the Hungarians finally fell for the German pressure and joined the axis in the war. Now was Poland from 3 sides surrendered by enemy, not to mention the Bolsheviks in the east: what were their intentions?
Today the Poles reacted by sending the aircraft to bombard Elbing. Obviously the pilots lost the way as the attack had absolutely no effect. Lewandowski started to swear: why the hell didn`t they bought more aircraft? The Luftwaffe is shooting us out - a few more days and the whole defense-line will be gone and the germans can just come in. And we can`t do anything because our planes are worthless and we have only so few! And the tanks will be finished in 6 months! My god, do we have 6 months?
The Colonel entered the hall where his office was. Underway he encountered his clerk, sergeant Hajto:
"Sir, I have very important messages for you"
Lewandowski sighed. I can`t take more bad news today:
"I`m affraid you won`t like the messages." - the sergeant clearly noticed the mood of Lewandowski.
"Well, whatever I like or not doesn`t matter much now. What are those messages?
"Sir, we received messages that USSR declared war on the 3 baltic-republics 3 hours ago" - the man began.
So, thus Josef made his first move. What is it all about? Why just now? Pure coincidence or...?
"Just within an hour thereafter Japan declared war on the Netherlands."
"Hmm, interesting. Had London or Paris reacted already?" - Lewandowski asked.
"No sir. As far as we know this new conflict has nothing to do with the European one. We know for longer that Japan is out on domination of Asia and the Dutch are just a weak party there, but Indonesia is rich"
Yes, that could be the cause, Lewandowski considered, Oil and Rubber from Indonesia was surely the cause. Japanese surely would like to have it... But till now it has nothing to do with Poland...
"well, that was it sire...ah no, one more. German movements near the Polish borders. Doesn`t look to dangerous it seems... haven`t heard much else about that... it was 1 hour ago..."
"Let go to the communications-room and see if we got any other messages. It could be the first serious German move"
It took 40 minutes before they gained further information and when it finally arrives it was obviously not good, considering the looks in the eyes of the receiver...
"Well? " - Lewandowski asked - "what do they say? Speak up man! We need information."
The clerk turned to Lewandowski, his face pale.:
"Sir, I have reports of german attack near Bydgoszcz. But also in Poznan."
Lewandowski sat quiet for a moment. Then he murmured:
"Well, then we have finally the german invasion there I guess...."
The orders followed. One clerk was appointed to elighten the Major-general Boruta-Spiechowicz of the Headquarters in Krakow about the invasion, another clerk had to inform the lower divisins of the southern network, again another was send to contact general Dab-Biernacki about the recent developments. The rest had to wait for other messages and instructions.
20 minutes later another message arrived.
"We lost Czestochowa which was undefended. Till now further instructions, the Germans are regrouping" - the clerk-sergeant recited the message to Lewandowski.
"And the battles in Poznan and Bydgoszcz?" - The colonel asked.
"Still going on sir.".
Not for long though. With midnight they received the information that Romml had to retreat and withdraw in the direction of Stettin. Bydgoszcz was lost as well.
At 2:00 o`clock in the morning of the 6th September the aircraft reacted with offensive to aid Kutrzeba near Poznan but it was intercepted and defeated by the Luftwaffe 6 hours later and had to retreat to Warsaw. Kutrzeba without aid from the air surrendered and retreated from Poznan at 6 o`clock in the evening the same day. Two hours later Cieszyn and Danzig had surrendered to germans.
Lewandowski haven`t had slept for more than 40 hours now. the messages kept coming on and virtually no good ones were received. the Poles were paralyzed. the whole defensive line in the north-west fell as a cardhouse. The divisions sent to Slovakia occupied Ruzomberok in the Carpathen but what succes was that? We have to fact that we are losing badly - he thought.
Major Kobylanski sent him to get some sleep half an hour later and he took over. The Colonel was tired but he could not sleep. He thought about the longa chain of events which led to the inevitable. He didn`t want to think abou that but had to face it. Also they were surrendered. The germans occupied all the provinces on 3 sides of Krakow. And they had no reinforcements here. He thought about his family - his wife and children were in Canada on "vacations", at least far away from this war. If he was not in the army he could have join them...what a thought, it is Poland we are fighting for! What would be our live without it? - he thought. But the calmness of a far-away country... Finally he fell asleep.

Image4.jpg

The western-polish front after the first german offensive
 
@Karhu
won`t OD you anymore today as I`m going to sleep now ;)

@ZheShiWo
mm, have to win time if I want to keep that AAR longer than just a few days so Slovakia is a perspective... Berlin? Hmmm.... I won`t even get there...
 
A great evening's work, Kasperus.

BTW, where did the French planes north of Warsaw come from, or did I miss that?


EDIT: spelling
 
Originally posted by Karhu
A great evening's work, Kasperus.

BTW, where did the French planes north of Warsaw come from, or did I miss that?


EDIT: spelling

I didn't see it mentioned but I imagine the Frence sent them to help out. They did in RL anyhow.

Kasperus: Did you start with an airforce or did you build from scratch?
 
Last edited:
Hmmm, do you have any hopes of winning at all?
Or surviving that 3 month? You seem to be hit pretty badly during the first days of war...