• We have updated our Community Code of Conduct. Please read through the new rules for the forum that are an integral part of Paradox Interactive’s User Agreement.

Kurt_Steiner

Katalaanse Burger en Terroriste
5 Badges
Feb 12, 2005
21.168
1.188
  • Arsenal of Democracy
  • For The Glory
  • Victoria: Revolutions
  • Hearts of Iron IV Sign-up
  • Crusader Kings Complete
Die Tweede Vryheidsoorlog - The Boer War

A HoI2 DD Boer AAR

Settings:
Scenario: Joe's War
Mod: Mod 1914

Well, I'm planning something dealing with something which has a small role for the Afrikaaners. Then I stumbled upon this scenario in the 1914 mod and thought... Trashing the Empire?

Why not? :D


Perhaps this would be the shortest scenario with the longest introduction, ever.


You'll see...
 
Last edited:
Die Tweede Vryheidsoorlog - The Boer War

Prologue
Rhodes's dream becomes a nightmare

'Johannesburg is ready... this is the big idea which makes
England dominant in Africa, in fact gives England the African continent.'


Secret letter from Cecil Rhodes to Afred Beit in August 1895,
when they hatched the plot to create a revolution at Johannesburg.​


Johannesburg was not ready. That was the message of the last code telegrams to Dr. Leander Starr Jameson. They confirmed his fears. So did a verbal report from Major Heany, the special messenger sent by the Johannesburg revolutionaries of Rhodes and Beit. The rising was going to be a flog. The revolutionaries were in a funk. Jameson left Heany in the white bell-tent at Pitsani, his camp in Bechuanaland within a few miles of the borders of both Cape Colony and the Transvaal. For twenty minutes on that of Sunday afternoon, 29 December 1895, Jameson paced up and down in the sand outside the tent. Then he called to Heany. He was going, despite everything, damn them all. He'd kick the burghers all round the Transvaal. If the fellows at Johannesburg wouldn't start the rising as agreed, their hands would have to be forced. He wasn't spending another day at Pitsani.

800px-Cecil_rhodes_%26_alfred_beit00.jpg

Cecil Rhodes & Alfred Beit, instrumental in the Jameson Raid​

"Boot and saddle!" Dust swirled across the parade ground, as the grey-suited Rhodesian police paraded in a hollow square. "Dress by the left! Bugler!". Defiantly the bugle calls echoed off the thin walls of the single store at Pitsani, and floated across the three miles of empty while veld to the invisible Transvaal frontier.

Jameson had nearly 400 Rhodesian mount police at Pistani, belonging to the Chartered Company, the company created by Cecil Rhodes and Alfred Beit. Jameson had collected another 120 volunteers. If one counted the Cape Coloured "boys" who led the spare horses, that brought the total of the force about six hundred volunteeers. Jameson had planned to invade the Transvaal with fifteen hundred. With six hundred it did seem a bit of a tall order: one regiment against the whole Boer army. But Jameson and the Rhodesian had faced hopeless odds before: they had crushed Lobengula, King of the Matabele, in 1892. This new expedition, according to Cecil Rhodes, would be "easier than Matabeleland". Unfortunately, rumours about the rising had already reached the local papers. So it was now or never.

Of course this was a wild gamble, this dash to Johannesburg. But then so was much of the work of Rhode's, and in fact much of the history of the British Empire. "Clive would have done it", Jameson told a friend. If Jameson gambled and won, the illegality would be forgiven. If they gambled and lost, well, the usual penalty was death. It was one of the lessons of history that it needed a disaster to make the British interested in their Empire. British seemed to be more keen on their dead generals than on the living ones: they avenged them by ending their work. At least half the Empire had been conquered by dead men. Any day now Gordon would be avenged by taking over the whole of the Mahdi's country. Now the same was going to take place in the Transvaal: General Colley and the four hundred men cut up at Majuba by the Boers fourteen years ago would be now avenged.

In the gathering dusk the bugle sounded. There was no going back. With three ringing cheers for the Qeen, across the border and into the Transvaal rode the six hundred.

--​

Four days had passed, and 2 January found Jameson's small army halted close to a whitewashed farm south of a kopje called Doornkop, in Transvaal. Johannesburg had not risen. The Uitlanders had made peace with President Kruger and his Boers and a relentless army barred Jameson's path.

For two days Jameson carried a running fight against the commandos. At first the Boers had hung on their tail, picking off stragglers. Jameson fought as they had fought the Zulus: with the rattle of Maxims, the crash of shrapnel from the guns and the charge to death. But the only dead were British. How could the fight mere puffs of smoke? That last night they had gathered in a rough squeare formed by the ammunition carts, the ambulance wagon and the horses. The trooperes fired into the darkness, across the saddles.

No help was coming. Jameson and his officers well knew what England expected of them. That was the moment they had been trained for ever since childhood. The Gattling has jammed; the colonel, eyes uplifted, grasps his sword; the little band sings "God Save the Queen"; and, one by one, they fall.

Someone lifted a white flag, made from the white apron of an African servant girl. The firing ceased. From all around them, the Boers, Mausers in every hand, rose up out of the ground, like ants, with bandoliers crossed over ordinary working clothes. The Boers disarmed the British, assisted the wounded and seized the baggage. The humilliation was complete when the dead were counted before burial. The British had lost sixteen, the Boers one man - one less they had lost at Majuba.

Weeping, Jameson was led away in a cart to the gaol at Pretoria.

779px-Leander_Starr_Jameson00.jpg

A Portrait of Jameson being led to the gaol, in a French Magazine​
 
Last edited:
Chapter one
The Abyss of Blunders

'Take a community of Dutchmen of the type of those who
defended themselves for fifty years against all the power
of Spain at a time when Spain was the greatest power in
the world. Intermix with them a strain of those inflexible
French Huguenots who gave up home and fortune and left
their country for ever at the time of the revocation of the
Edict of Nantes. The product must obviously be one of the
most rugged, virile, unconquerable races ever seen upon
earth.
'

Sir Arthur Conan Doyle, The Great Boer War

Trained for generations in constant warfare against savage men and ferocious beasts, facing extreme hardships in a wild country and moved by a finer temper upon their military qualities by a dour fatalistic Old Testament religion and an ardent and consuming patriotism, those were the modern Boers, the most formidable antagonist who ever crossed the path of Imperial Britain since Napoleon's time.

The first Dutch settled had arrived to the area in 1652, and remained there, slowly increasing their lands and numbers until it was subsequently occupied by the British, first in in 1795 during the wars against the revolutionary France, and again in 1806, to prevent Napoleon using the Cape. Sir Benjamin D'Urban would be the first to try to seize the South African nettle in 1833. Cape Colony was to become the Gibraltar of the South, the chief link in the imperial defence between England and the Jewel of the Crown, India.

boer2.png

The problem, to D'Urban and his successors, was that the Afrikaner inhabitant's loyalty was not beyond dispute. The country was poor and did not attract many British settlers. So, a pro-British majority never materialized at the Cape. As a result, the Afrikaans-speaker remained a majority. And a stubborn one, it must be added. After the British takeover there had been risings in 1795, 1799 and 1815.

D'Urban ennacted the outlawing slavery edicts from the metropolis was the last straw to the Boers. Away they trekked, beyond the Orange River and the Vaal, into a new and empty territory where they could rule themselves. It was the Great Trek. The trekkers (Boers), numbering around 7,000, founded communities with a republican form of government beyond the Orange and Vaal rivers, and in Natal, where they had been preceded, however, by British emigrants. There two voortrekker republic would rise, the Orange Free State and the Transvaal.

After some time that no action was taken about them, when the Boer had stirred up a hornet's nest in Natan. The emigrant Boers faced the native tribes and fought for the lands. Alàs! they met again the British, Natal was annexed to the British Empire in 1843. Cape Colony doubled its size and the Boer lands looked to be the next. When Pretorious was defeated by the British, annexation semmed certain to follow.

But Westminster saved them. New British governments, led by Russell and Derby, were against colonial adventures, and two treaties (1852 and 1854) guaranteed the independence of the two Boer Republics by Britain. Why fighting for an Empire, it was said, when you can trade with the whole world?

boer1.png

Then came the follwoing blunder. In 1877 Britain annexed the ZAR as a convenient way of resolving the border dispute between the Boers and the Zulus. This also saved the Transvaal from financial ruin, as the government had completely run out of money. In a reckless fit of impatience, the British tried to force the hand of the Boers by annexing the Transvaal before the federation was agreed. The so-called First Boer War followed, and then the great blunder: Majuba.

In 1877 the British army marched unmolested to Pretoria and the Union Jack flew over the new colony of the Transvaal. Then, after destroying the Zulus as military nation in 1879, came the surprise: in 1880 the Boers, under Paul Kruger, rose in revolt against the new government and defeated the British in three small but shattering reverses, which culminated at Majuba and general Colley's humilliating defeat.

Gladstone was quick to seize a compromise. The self-government of the Boers would be restored, keeping London the control over their foreign affairs. The Conventions of Pretoria (1881) and London (1884) would settle the issue, but leaving the Boers willing to remove the shadow of British paramouncty over the Traansval and leaving the British feeling humilitated with this "peace under defeat".

boer3.png

Alfred Milner would correct that mistake.


TRP & XHR: Wao! That's what I call a wonderful beginning! With such a readers, what can go wrong!
 
Last edited:
Whoa, another AAR from you.

Am I responsible for this AAR? :p
 
Ah here comes the first hero: Alfred Milner :)

Being to RSA once, I felt the pride of the Afrikaans-speaking people firsthand - there still are a lot of them today and Afrikaans (language of the Boer) is still the most widely spoken language of the many national languages in South Africa.
Jeez I feel really drawn into your story.
 
Last edited:
Chapter two
The Man and his Vision

'As he spoke his eyelids seemed to tremble
and to fall a little over his keen grey eyes. In a flash
the phrase of Scudder's came back to me, when he
had described the man he most dread in the world.
He said he 'could hood his eyes like a hawk'. Then I
saw that I had walked straight into the enemy's
headquarters
'

John Buchan (Sir Alfred Milner's Private
Secretary in South Africa, 1901-03) The Thirty Nine Steps

Sir Alfred Milner, High Commissioner for South Africa and Lieutenant-Governor of Cape Colony, was a man with a vision. A man of mixed origins, born in Giessen, near Frankfurt on Main, the son of a half-German medical student and an English woman, had his heart divided between Germany and England. He had as heroes Bismarck and Frederick the Great as well as Cromwell and Pitt the Young. However, as it has been said, he had a vision: the consolidation of the British Empire.

300px-Lord_Milner.jpg

What did men like Milner mean when they talked in that mystical voice of "imperial unity" and "consolidating the Empire" Was it all rethoric to hide sheer ambition?

Milner saw that South Africa's history was a history of struggle for supremacy between Britain and the Boers. And of abysmal blunders. All the attempt to solve the Boer question had ended in disaster, for various reasons. To Milner "avenging Majuba" seemed crude and distatesfully. The battle itself was a disaster and the whole affaire that led to it had been hopelessly bungled, as all the previous British erratic policy in South Africa. The real problem to him was that the explosion in the wealth of the Transvaal in 1886 had an explosive political result. It could give the Boer the political leadership of the sub-continent. Who controlled the Transvaal, the richest state in Africa, would control the lanes to India.

Milner found Britain in shame after the Raid. Rhodes and Beit had vanished, nowhere to be found. Milner's job was to restore the world destroyed by Jameson. What was to be done? He had to be in good terms with the pro-British party, and on good term he was: but he did not trust them: "they would give me away or anyone else for the least of their own ends", he declared to Phillip Gell in an outburst. Even if the were "money makers" and "potential rebells", he could not help liking Rhodes.

Thus he based his future politics in three bases: agreement with loyalists at the Cape, with the Colonial Office at home and the complete support of the British public opinion. He would force a quarrely over some issue or issues with Kruger and let events unfold the crisis.

Either Kruger must make political reforms (1) or there must be a "row". To put it bluntly, the choice was "reforms or war". And, of the two, Milner prefered war.



(1) With reforms, Milner (and London) meant "full uitlander rights", that is, giving the non-Boer citizens of the Republics the same right as the Boers, which, of course, would have meant, eventually, giving the power to the pro-British block. It goes without saying that Kruger and Steyn weren't quite keen on that...


gaiasabre11: Unless you're a blonde lady with long legs, I wouldn't say so...:D

XHR: Milner... mmmh... I always wondered if the Boer War was Joe's War or Alfie's War...

Curbough: Another fan here, too :D
 
Last edited:
Ok - I was wrong. Definately NOT the hero here - more like the enemy. And a somewhat cunning man with a vision what usually is really dangerous. A diplomat would have been an easier foe.
 
gaiasabre11: Unless you're a blonde lady with long legs, I wouldn't say so...:D

Well, anyways, I'm going to end my stuff in Africa soon enough, and move on to somewhere you don't know yet. :p
 
Well, I'm in for an adventure on the dark continent :D Excellent!
 
Chapter three
For Queen and Country!

'A war in South Africa would be one of the most
serious wars that could possibly be waged. It would
be in the nature of a Civil War. It would be a long
war, a bitter war and a costly war... It would leave
behind the embers of a strife which I believe generations
would hardly be long enough to extinguish... to go to
war with President Kruger, to force upon him reforms
in the internal affairs of his state, with which [we] have
repudiated all right of interference - that would have
been a course of action as immoral as it would have been
unwise
'

Joseph Chamberlain, Colonial Secretary, speaking
in the House of Commons, May 1896.​

From his desk, the Colonial Secretary, Joseph Chamberlain, eyed the world through his eye-glass, and the world trembled. Queen Victoria was the symbol of the mother country, the Empire made flesh; Chamberlain epitomied its other side, the dreadnought spirit. A self-made man he had risen from the his middle class originals to a successful industrial career, which led him to the commanding heights of politics. He expected, once Gladstone retired, to be the next Liberal Prime Minister.

Then came the Irish Home Rule, and he discovered himself a strange hybrid, woth a radical and an imperialist. With Lord Hartington (later Duke of Devonshire), he founded the Liberal Unionists. And, for nine years, he was lost in the limbo. He even considered resigning from politics. Then, in 1896, came the agreement between Liberal Unionists and Conservatives to create a coalition, the Liberal majority at the Parliament vanished and Chamberlain found himself heading the Colonial Office. To the surprise of Salisbury and Balfour, Chamberlain declined a post at the Treasury, unwilling to be constrained by conservative spending plans, and also refused the Home Office. Instead, Chamberlain asked to be given the Colonial Office, a department that traditionally held little attraction to politicians.

He put himself to work, and found the Colonial Office with almost no staff and hardly any funding, governing over ten million square miles of territory and 450 million people of exceptional diversity. Little by little he expanded the deparment and rose to preminence. Then the Jameson Raid threatened to end his career. He shared Milner's view over South Africa, but he prefered to leave the bussines of creating the federation to Rhodes. Soon after Chamberlain took up the seals of office, came the dilema. The Uitlander coup was expected in Johanesburg. What if the coup was sucessful and resulted in an Utilander republic under its own flag. This could be even worse for Britain.

Joseph_chamberlain.png


Thus, Chamberlain adopted a course of "not knowing toop much". If the coup failed, he could plead official ignorance; it it succeeded he could share (privately) the credit with Rhodes and Beit. However, the Uitlanders didn't want to exchange the Boer republic for a British colony and Jameson failed and almost brought Chamberlain with him. A cover-up followed, Jameson was told to kept his mouth shout and Rhodes and Beit agreeded not to produce the damning telegrams that would have damned Chamberlain. In exchange, Chamberlain agreed not to tamper with the charter of the Chartered Company. Some scapegoats were found (Sir Graham Bower, the Imperial Secretary at the Cape), who pretenteded not to have told his boss about the plans of Jameson. In exchange, he was rewarded with having his career ruined.

However, he was finally saved by the colossal blunder of the Kaiser, who send a telegram to congratulate Kruger on his escape and the following outrage in England. Then Jameson became the "Transvaal heroe" and the Liberal Party found themselves with no means to charge against Chamberlain. Add to that that the leading Liberal Imperialist, lord Rosebery, was somewhow in the "know"...

What were the effects of this ordeal for Chamberlain? He was neither no more conciliatory to Kruger nor more simpathetic for Rhodes, who had alienated the Cape Afrikaners and dared to blackmail him with he telegrams. And what about the Boers? Give Kruger enough rope, it seemed Chamberlain's atittude, as a war would be self-defeating, as it would only arouse hatred and bitterness, and would make an union impossible. So, if in the end had to be war, let Kruger be the agressor and the Cape Afrikaners on the side of the Empire.

However, Kruger had proved himself far too cunning to hang anyone, least of all himself.

But this "no-war policy" did ot tie Milner's hands. If he could find competent leadership, if Beit and the other 'gold-bugs' could be brought into line; if the Uitlanders could be manouvred into the English side and Kruger into the wrong, there could be a chance.

Milner would seek for that chance to happen.

XHR: Indeed. In my opinion, he was more dangerous that good old Kaiser Bill in one of his jingo trips! :D

Enewald: Did I mention I'm a bit absent minded?

gaiasabre11: Interesting!

Lordban: Thanks a lot. I hope that the introduction don't go for too long, but, you know, I can't help...:p

Volga: And the vaal provides endless source of adventures, you know...
 
Last edited:
Chapter four
Champagne for the Volk

"Mama, meet the gentleman who was there
when God made the earth
".

President Kruger to his wife, after being told
about the gold reserves discovered in the Transvaal in 1886.​

Meanwhile, the Boers had their own reasons to celebrate: the conquering hero was the Transvaal C-i-C, Commandant-General Piet Joubert, who had subdued, with the help of their Creusot artillery, a troublesome African chief called Mpefu. It was the triumphant end to half a dozen native wars in nearly as many years.

Oom Paul (Uncle Paul, as the burghers affectionately called Kruger) was seventy-three, a national monument in his own lifetime, a heroic survivor of the Great Trek and of the Battle of Blood River, were Dingaan and the Zulus were crushed. The Lord, praise the Lord, had given His people a great victory. His life spanned the whole life of the State. While around him people talked of celebrating Jameson Day, equivalent to the English Guy Fawkes, he just said, with his characteristically heavy humor, that it was not yet, at any rate, the moment to celebrate the destruction of the British.

If Kruger was the archetypal Boer of the backveld, 'Slim' (clever) Joubert was the Boer of the towns. No more striking contrast could be found on two men. One was as conservative and hard as the other was progressive and weak. As a general, Joubert hated to impose unpopular duties on the burghers, and as a politican, he did not dare to face Kruger in the Raad (the Volksraad, the Parliament of the Transvaal).

Kruger01a.jpg

Paul 'Oom' Kruger​

While Joubert adopted the European conventions and said nothing in grat many words, Kruger often said too much before he had spoken a sentence. Even worse, he did believe much of what he said. Kruger had made a succesful career, but the peace which followed Majuba had made him him weak to the attacks of the Progresive Party, and he almost lost the presidency to Joubert in 1893. In the Transvaal, things changed rapidly after the discovery of gold on the Witwatersrand. This discovery had far-reaching political repercussions and gave rise to the uitlander (Afrikaans word for foreigner) problem. Kruger acknowledged in his memoirs that General Joubert predicted the events that followed afterwards, declaring that instead of rejoicing at the discovery of gold, they should be weeping because it will "cause our land to be soaked in blood".

At the end of 1895, the failed Jameson raid took place and saved him.

Jameson united the volk behind the Transvaal government. At a stroke, the old president became the heroe of the Raid and the sneers of the Progressives were forgotten for the moment. Jameson had another unexpected effect. The Orange Free State was the sister republic of the Transvaal. A piece of tolerance and good sense, where the Uitlanders had all the political rights denied to their counterparts in the Transvaal. Since the Jameson Raid a subtle changed took place. The President elected in 1896, Marthinus Steyn, began to united closely his state with his sister republic. A military pact was concluded in 1897. To the 25,000 burghers of Kruger 15,000 from the Free State were added.

Thanks to Jameson the volk inside and outside the Transvaal were united. And, thanks to Jameson too, Kruger learnt how pitiful was his own burgher army. Of the 24,238 burghers he commanded, 9,996 had no rifle; the rest had old ones of new rifles of an old pattern. There was only ammunition for a fornight.

449px-Pjjoubert.jpg

Petrus Jacobus Joubert​

Kruger proceeded to re-equip the Transvaal. At a cost of 1 million pounds he ordered 37,000 Mausers from Krupp's factory en Germany. Meanwhile, Joubert was buidling an excellent artillery corps, four 155 mm Creusot heavy guns, four 120 mm howitzers and eight 75 mm field guns, plus twenty of the experimental Maxim-Nordenfeld 1-pounders ('pom-pom') that were not yet in service with the British army. Four elephantine fortresses were bulit to protect Pretoria and the Rand. Its purpose was hard to imagine, as they were against the first principle of Boer tactics: mobility above all. Perhaps Kruger wanted to overawe the Uitlanders and give them a symbol of "Krugerism". It backfired. They fortresses proved them that they were too weak to defeat Kruger. They needed England.

Just in case, he kept talking with London. He relied on Jan Smuts to do it, a young and brilliant legal adviser who was called to work fast to pre-empt the attack of the Progressives, the Uitlanders and the British empire. Kruger's choice proved his shrewdness, as Smuts was an Afrikaner from the Cape, being English his first language for writing. While Smust fought for time, Kruger played with the foreign powers and investors to set them against the other.

gws_smuts_03.jpg

Jan Smuts​

Then came the blow. Smuts met the British agent in Pretoria, Edmund Fraser, to try to settle the cause of the coloured people. Once the topic was discussed amicably enough, Fraser went to an extraordinary orbust:

"Well, you see. Gladstone made a great mistake in handing you back the Transvaal before Majuba and before [instead of] defeating your army [...] We've got to show who's the boss in South Africa [...] I know perfectly well taht England won't go to war over abstract subjects like suzerainty. Than means nothing to the man on streets. She'll go to war about things that everyone can understand".

CapturedBoer1pounder.jpg

Captured 1-pounder Pom-Pom from the Boers​


Go to war... Smut was left gasping. What was the meaning of these threat? Had Fraser gone mad or it was just the hint of a storm to come?

Then came the pebble that started the avalanche.


Enewald: In fact, this AAR is advertised in my sign, on the link "Ongoing AARs"...

Myth: Thanks a lot, Myth!
 
Last edited:
War on the horizon! All Boers, load your Mausers and man your plots of grass! It's nearly time to be fighting the British again!
 
Leaves one to wonder what that thing will be "that everyone [in Britain] can understand". It will be propaganda for sure :mad:

I like the word for the guns, 'pom-pom' but I hope the Boers will not make the mistake and try a static, fortress-based approach against the British as that will probably be their doom.