• We have updated our Community Code of Conduct. Please read through the new rules for the forum that are an integral part of Paradox Interactive’s User Agreement.

Lordling

Captain
103 Badges
Dec 26, 2006
386
2
  • Rome: Vae Victis
  • Europa Universalis III Complete
  • Naval War: Arctic Circle
  • Europa Universalis IV: Res Publica
  • Victoria: Revolutions
  • Europa Universalis: Rome
  • Rome Gold
  • Semper Fi
  • Sword of the Stars II
  • Supreme Ruler 2020
  • Victoria 2
  • Victoria 2: A House Divided
  • Victoria 2: Heart of Darkness
  • Majesty 2
  • Warlock: Master of the Arcane
  • 500k Club
  • Europa Universalis IV: El Dorado
  • Europa Universalis IV: Pre-order
  • Mount & Blade: Warband
  • Mount & Blade: With Fire and Sword
  • Crusader Kings II: Way of Life
  • Europa Universalis IV: Common Sense
  • Crusader Kings II: Horse Lords
  • Knights of Pen and Paper 2
  • Europa Universalis IV: Cossacks
  • Stellaris: Nemesis
  • Europa Universalis IV
  • Crusader Kings II: Charlemagne
  • Crusader Kings II: Legacy of Rome
  • Crusader Kings II: The Old Gods
  • Crusader Kings II: Rajas of India
  • Crusader Kings II: The Republic
  • Crusader Kings II: Sons of Abraham
  • Crusader Kings II: Sunset Invasion
  • Crusader Kings II: Sword of Islam
  • Commander: Conquest of the Americas
  • Europa Universalis III
  • Europa Universalis III Complete
  • Divine Wind
  • Crusader Kings II
  • Europa Universalis IV: Art of War
  • Europa Universalis IV: Conquest of Paradise
  • Europa Universalis IV: Wealth of Nations
  • For the Motherland
  • Gettysburg
  • Hearts of Iron III
  • Heir to the Throne
  • Europa Universalis III Complete
  • Lead and Gold
  • The Kings Crusade
(Firstly, I did nick the title from my old Eu2 Byzantine AAR. I like it)

Chapter One

It was in the December of 1337 that we officially mark the Roman Empire having reached its weakest point. The anti-zenith, we shall say. For years of incompetent, greedy Emperors, military defeats, and a strengthening nobility had left the Byzantine Empire, or Eastern Roman Empire, with a level of strength that simply could not see it survive any longer. Perhaps, at this point, it was capable matching the Ottoman Turks man-for-man, or even the Croatians, or Bulgars. But while any one of the enemies of Rome might have been fended off indefinitely, the tide of destruction that poured in from all sides certainly could not have been.

The present Emperor, Andronikos Palaiologos, was not a man of great intellect. Nor, it must be noted, were his advisors of the genius we see in later centuries. It is curious, then, that the grand revival second only to the conquests of the old Roman Empire was begun with him. He was, by all accounts, hardly kingly in stature or face, and he could scarce read.

He was loathed by many of his subjects, and his skill at diplomacy was little more than a farce. Why, then, was he able to orchestrate such a revival?

This question is best answered by the study of the men of the time themselves. Andronikos had a friend in the Prince of Thessalonika, and their friendship, one day, found itself tested. For, in this Empire, there were but two Principalities sworn to the Emperor. The first, Thessalonike, made up more than two-thirds of the Empire's land, and over half of its men. Should it have ever chosen to rebel, there is no doubting the fact that the Basileus's already-unsteady reign would've collapsed there and then.

But the Prince was a friend, and so he remained. Nevertheless, Andronikos, in his customary manner, insulted his courage one day, and the Prince took it upon himself to remind his Emperor just why he served - it was not out of fear for the Emperor's formidable army, that was for certain.

In a rage, Andronikos told his friend that he should fear his army, for he was a general fine enough to slaughter the men of Thessalonike with but a tenth of his force.

There, then, were the fatal words that were to rebuild an Empire.

"Prove it."
 
Constantinople had remained the City of Men's Desire, even unto this age. Although it had been devastated by the Fourth Crusade, it was not yet to suffer the horrors of the Black Plague, and the City remained grand, although it did not aspire to the glories of old. From Constantinople, then, a force could be mustered. The themata were mustered, and almost ten thousand men rallied to the Emperor's call. Little more than a rag-tag army, though almost eight hundred kataphraktoi were numbered among it, it still vastly outnumbered his intended target.

b9c0lz.png

The Byzantine Empire in 1337

Despite the expense, Andronikos intended to march on the Count of Epirus, who, some years previously, had abandoned the Empire, seeing it as a sinking ship. In the meantime, Venice had guaranteed Epirus's independence, in a bid to gain the Count's loyalty. Epirus consisted of a significant - not to mention useful portion of Greece, and, as Venice already controlled a quarter of the Peleponnesus, through a forcibly installed Italian Count, any gains in Greece it could make would only further its power.

It was not that Andronikos was clever enough to call the bluff of the Venetians, who were otherwise engaged at the time, but rather that he simply did not know. A man who lived for little else but military matters, the diplomatic situation meant little to him. Epirus was a traitorous polity of the Empire, and he intended to reclaim it.

In a famous example of his kick-in-the-door style of diplomacy, he sent the demands for submission to the Count mere days before he entered his territory. The terms were harsh. The Count of Epirus would give up his lands to his son, who would swear loyalty to the Roman Empire, and the Count would be a prisoner of the Emperor, who would administer his lands as regent in his absence until his son came of age.

Naturally, the Count refused. Thus begun the first campaign of what was to be one of many, and, whilst the Epirus Campaign was hardly famous, it was to establish Andronikos as a general without peer. As he said, men would come to fear his army.
 
Last edited:
I've always wanted to play out this scenario into EU3... A Byzantine recovery as sorts!

Andronikos sounds like he could be a military genius but a diplomatic lout - who will step up to provide the diplomatic acumen his regime needs?

Hope this one goes well for you, I'm gonna keep an eye on it! :)
 
General_BT: He's got a nice 12 Martial, and an equally not-nice 3 Diplomacy. It helps that he made friends with the Prince of Thessalonika 3 seconds into the game, but I can't stretch my BB too far. If I conquer all the way to Rome, my empire will crumble underneath me.

Also, playing this scenario is certainly interesting. In 1066, if you play as a decent Prince, the challenge is preventing the Empire from crumbling. In 1337, you no longer have an empire to crumble, so it's more a matter of desperate survival. Once before a reload, I lost my entire empire to the Mongols, who had just recovered from the Black Plague, while I had almost every single province plagued. (On that note, I've practically played this entire scenario out, primarily because of what happened in my Nubia game).
 
Last edited:
A daunting task... Doubtless it will be an interesting journey as a result!
 
Force Change: I hope this one's going to be great. As it stands, I've got a format in mind, which is a darn sight better than I tend to do.

Capibara: Thankee. Here's hoping it doesn't disappoint.

DerKaiser: The struggle doesn't really manifest until the bastard, heretic, excommunicated, kinslayer, diplo 2 Emperor shows up. :D

Kidding.

Or am I?
 
Chapter Two - The Conquest of Epirus

Sword bashed against shield, spear stabbed against armour, horses smashed into ranks of unlucky infantrymen, blood and bone spraying across the battlefield. Count Christophoros had chosen to make his stand here - two thousand against ten thousand. Perhaps a thousand kataphraktoi were numbered in Emperor Andronikos's army, against thirty under the men of Epirus. They had besieged and taken Arta not two weeks ago, driving off the force sent to the castle's relief.

Now, Epirus remained. Christophoros truly had no choice. If he ordered the retreat, his last stronghold would fall, and Andronikos could simply occupy his lands, garrison his castles with his own men, and establish Epirus as an outpost of his own demesne.

It was grim for the Epirans, now. A thousand men, mostly spearmen and heavy infantry, arranged in a circle a top a hill. A few hundred archers were within the circle, and, together, with his knights, the Count of Epirus, Christophoros, sat.

Andronikos roared with joy. "Ha! You are a fool, Christophoros! A weak, cowardly fool!"

A voice answered him. "I am a fool, Emperor of the Romans? I had no chance to respond to your missive. You assumed I would deny you the fealty you believe owed to you."

"You did, though."

"Yes. But that is not the point. It was dishonorable to attack me thus."

Christophoros shook his head. "It was dishonorable to deny your basileus the fealty owed him. You are a traitor, Count of Epirus, and I will have your head."

The voice was cool, now, despite the overwhelming odds arrayed against him. "To be honest, my Emperor, the last three lords have merely been the pawns of the Dukes of Thessalonike. Your family has shown no desire to be anything more than weak, useless figureheads. I cannot serve such a man. Cowards, all."

"Cowards?! Come and face me, you dog, and say that!"

"Very well, then. You and I, Emperor?"

"You and I, traitor!"

The two men rode towards each other, the armies clearing a space around them. Andronikos slowed his horse, and, as Christophoros rode towards him, he raised a hand in signal. A volley of arrows slammed into the hapless Count of Epirus, felling him from his horse.

Andronikos quietly dismounted his horse, and, well out of arrow range from the hill, saw that the Count was still breathing. He drew his sword.

"You.. traitorous.. bastard..", he rasped.

Andronikos laughed. "You are a fool. Let us hope your son has better sense than you. Otherwise we might have to find you a new heir."

His sword stabbed through Christophoros's visor, smashing his skull irreparably.

He cantered back to his camp, and, upon reaching it, spoke to a general. "Ah, Marshal William. How pleasant to see you. Would you be so kind as to slaughter these traitors? I intend to make an object lesson of Epirus."

The Norman marshal saluted. It made him uneasy, this.. dishonour. Nevertheless, he had been a landless knight, before, until the last battle, where had cut through an ambush by rebels, just in time to see the previous marshal die. Had it not been for him, Andronikos might well be dead. Out of gratitude, the Emperor had granted him the title of Megas Domestikos, and promised him lands of his own, should he decide to convert to the Orthodox faith.

Still. He knew what would happen next. Epirus would become a charnel-house, its wealth ground into dust, so that the Emperor could show his enemies what happened when they opposed him..
 
I enjoyed your short-lived Nubia AAR, and I'm liking this so far.

I think I speak for everyone when I say...

Update!
 
Great update! It seems the empire is recovering it's strength
 
TwistedChimp: Honourable and good people rarely restore empires.

Jooce: I'm here. I had to abandon a place in a succession game because of early schoolwork, but I've got a bit of time, having dealt with the first few assignments thrown my way.

Capibara: Perhaps. It does have troubles up ahead, however. The least of which being civil war.

- - - - - - - -

William looked down. The baby continued to scream, as it was held away from its mother. He shook his head.

"My lady, if you would follow me?"

Alexandretta, the wife of the former Count, nodded dumbly. It seemed so unreal - an Emperor coming to take what was his. It had not happened in an age. Still, his Domestikos was here, demanding that she come with him. A hostage, for now. He insisted it was to keep her safe, and beneath his calm demeanour, she occasionally caught him shaking his head, or flicking his eyes from side to side. Guilty, perhaps. Of what? She stifled a mad laugh. The Emperor of Rome had come and shown Epirus that he was not to be trifled with. Smoke filled the outside air, the death-rattles of so many sounding in the streets below.

William looked down, agonized. He had, of course, obeyed the Emperor. But at what cost? His soul? No, no. Of course not. The Emperor, while differing from Rome in some theology, was still an agent of God on earth. Sometimes, brutality.. happened. It was his command, but, then again, he had been expressly commanded to ravage the city.

After a moment that seemed like hours, the smoke billowed up more strongly, obscuring all sight of the streets below. Whilst the houses were made of stone, the markets were made of cloth and wood, and they burnt most handily.

He nodded to the Countess. "My lady, if you would be so good as to follow me? The Emperor has given me leave to escort you to his presence. As, it seems, there are no others capable of signing the treaty that will be signed, you may take on the temporary status of regent for your son."

She frowned. "And I refuse?"

William laughed, more a release for his nerves than out of humour. "My lady, Basileus Christophoros has taken your people and put them to the sword because your lord might have denied him the fealty owed him."

"It was never owed him!", she snapped, her eyes flashing with momentary fire.

William looked at her, and shook his head. "If the Basileus demands your fealty, you obey. It is your duty. Your lord flouted the taxes and men he owed to Constantinople, and your people have paid the price. Now, I am merely a man who knows of tactics, and speaks poor Greek, but I can tell you this of the Emperor. He is not a man to be trifled with. If you are properly servile, and give all that he wants without insult or defiance, he may let your son live to rule Epirus. If he sees too much defiance in you.. do you think you would escape, because of your noble birth? I, perhaps, would have your lands. Now-"

"You? You are a baseborn Norman! You are-"

William, angered now, stretched over, and hit her in the mouth. She spat blood, but not teeth, as she looked up at him in sudden terror.

"Listen, you silly bitch. I am giving you a chance to save your child. Do as the Emperor says, and you will live. Happily, even. Show any signs of disobeying, and I'll escort you to the gallows myself."

She nodded, suddenly servile. William didn't believe a moment of it, but.. he looked down at the child. Internally, he laughed at himself.

So, you save one child, and put a whole town to the sword? Oh, very noble. Just like a true glorious knight.

Without another word, he turned and walked out, gesturing to the Countess to follow him. She did so, mutely.
 
Chapter Three: The Recovery of Asia Minor

Epirus had been recovered with a minimum of cost. Alexandretta had sworn, in her son's name, fealty to the Emperor. Of course, there had been demands. One Zeno Bagratuni, cousin to the King of Bulgaria, had been installed as regent - a cruel and hateful man, William knew. A just one, in that he was equally brutal to all, but, nevertheless, not a man he would've chosen. The Emperor, however, had orderered that Epirus be made an example of. Despite the complaints of the Prince of Thessalonike, who, for the first time, saw his privileged position slipping away from him, Christophoros was exuberant.

The first war he had fought in a decade had been won, and, with the Greek world now in fear of him, he felt that it was time to turn his attention to the Turk. He ordered William to bring the Constantinople themata up to full strength, every man who could fight would, in this new conquest. The minor Sheikdoms in the west of Turkey at the time believed that the Ottoman Sheik, the most powerful among the Muslim lords of Turkey, would rush to their aid.

However, as Andronikos ordered his strike, six thousand Crusaders passed through Constantinople, upon a "holy mission to recover lands lost from the Turk.". Though Andronikos, at first, wished to fight them, William managed to convince him to use these Danes as fodder for the armies of the Ottoman.

He gestured at the map, pointing first at the spy-reports, and secondly at the reports on castles.

"My lord, look. There are, perhaps, fifteen thousand Ottoman Turks. Another eight thousand in the assorted Sheikdoms we intend to conquer. We, altogether, may muster perhaps thirty thousand men. However, if we muster in full, there is no doubt that the Bulgars, who have long been muttering about our weakness, will take the time to strike. At most, we may take half our men."

Andronikos leaned forward, nodding intently. "But a lightning campaign would be more effective. We move from here - to here - to here", he said, pointing at cities along the Aegean coast, "and we secure those cities within half a month. The Turk will have no time to respond."

William sighed. "Perhaps, my liege. But I also think that we need hold forces in reserve. The minor sheikdoms are scattered and do not trust each other, they may muster two thousand men apiece. With twelve thousand men, I could take them, and the Ottomen also, if you desired it of me. However, five thousand would be sufficient to take the coast."

"I see. But I will give you ten. The Constantinople theme should have more than enough men for your campaign. Do not attack the Ottoman Turk, however, unless he comes after you first. Campaigning so deeply into Turkey at this time would leave our armies too far from the City, and, if what you say of the Bulgar is true, then we dare not stray too far."

William nodded. "It will be done, my lord. We will move quickly through those minor kingdoms, and retake them, for the glory of God."

"The glory of God? You have recanted your heresy, then?", Andronikos said, raising an eyebrow.

"No, merely hoped that you have recanted yours."

The Basileus laughed, and slapped William on the back. "No peasant in the Empire would dare speak to me in such a manner - indeed, it is doubtful they would speak to me at all! And yet a Norman peasant debases my faith so. If the Patriarch knew, he would demand you hang."

"I believe he would, my lord. But it is much the same to me. A bishop in Rome, a bishop in Constantinople - neither of them are willing to pick up a sword and serve in my army, so what do I care?"

Andronikos roared with laughter. "I believe that's true, my friend. All I have to do is hint at a blade, and those old men scurry back into the corners, waiting for my next command! Oh, I should tell-"

"Let's not get me hung for heresy today, my Emperor, if you'd be so good?"

Andronikos nodded. "Very well. You have a campaign to conduct, do you not?"

"Now?"

"The Danes should be landing in the Turkish land within a week or two. You should have a victory by then."

Expectations. He had some. To fulfill them would not be difficult. He had the men, and the skill. The generalship. The jovial moment gone, they were Basileus and Megas Domestikos once again. He bowed deeply, and withdrew, silently. It would take a few days to muster the army, and a few more to organize a crossing into Asia.

Dreams of glory filled his head. Perhaps he would convert. A princedom was worth a Mass, and, with the conquests they were to make, there would certainly be lands for the taking, enough to make him a grand prince. Rather than being reliant on the goodwill of the Emperor for their livelihood, his children would rule lands of their own, involved in politics, wealthy enough to live a life of grandeur.

Until they cross a Emperor who they think is weak. Then they go the way of Epirus.

He shut the thought out of his head, but the vision of wealth and power for his descendants was gone. Besides. If those dreams were ever to come to fruition, there would need to be immense planning to make it come about.
 
Last edited:
Another Byzantine AAR! Lovely, especially since it's a 1337 one! I like the narration and am curious to see how the reconquest of Asia Minor goes. I personally always found it too easy to wipe out the Turks in the 1337 scenario since Constantinople alone supplies you with a truly abundant supply of troops. The game just can't simulate the great devastations of the Fourth Crusade and the resulting loss of political and economic importance of "The City".

But by the way could it be that you got mixed up with the Emperors name? At the beginning he is called Andronikos like he should be but now you refer to him as Christophoros. Has the emperor decided not only to take over the lands but also the name of the vanquished count? :D

~Lord Valentine~
 
I have pursued you to another forum, Lordling. I enjoyed the start and look forward to reading more.

Vann
 
Lord Valentine: Firstly, the Muslim kingdoms aren't a problem. The Mongols are. Come 1400, they'll control everything south of the Black Sea that's also east of the Roman Empire. They're immense, and, at their height, were mustering 300,000 men to my 175,000. Admittedly, they were then cursed with 1-martial leaders after that one great guy, but I was quite convinced I was going to lose it all at one point in the game.

Also, about 10 years in, Constantinople gets the Black Plague, and doesn't lose it until the turn of the century. This more-or-less cripples me, and simulates the Fourth Crusade quite nicely. And yes, I got the names mixed up. Thanks for reminding me.

Vann the Red: 1337 AARs (Paradox must've known what that meant in leetspeech) are a lot harder as minor powers, as, in the Hastings scenario, there's plenty of time to rise up, become a kingdom without peer, and crush the world under your heel. In 1337, restoring the empire of Justinian is impossible. Restoring the empire at Hastings, in fact, is scarcely feasible.
 
*Subscribes*
 
Lord Valentine: Yes, I did. Thankee. It's edited now.

Vann the Red: I hope I'll be able to keep this up. I'm busy now, so it's more of a "whenever I can get to the forums" thing, as opposed to on schedule. Nice to see you're here, in any case.

igorvragovic: If there was a Serbian crown in CK, it'd be there, I assure you. I may add it on to the list of titles of the Emperor, if only for the sake of accuracy (even if it doesn't crop up in gameplay).

Fulcrumvale: Mighty nice to have you aboard.

- - - - - - -

A Brief Discourse on the Smyrna Campaigns

It is well-known that the Roman Empire's hold on Asia Minor is what has given it the vast manpower advantage it enjoys to this very day. The Hellenization of what was once Ottomite territory gave the Romans both the resources, and control of coastal areas, permitting them to develop in areas of both trade and production.

The Megas Domestikos, William de Voifellon, ordered ten thousand men onto the edge of Asia Minor, in order to sweep up the minor states that existed at that time. While the Roman army at this time was vastly inferior to that of surrounding states in quality, equipment, and pay, the Basileus, Andronikos Palailogos, made the pay of the army his very first concern. Discipline skyrocketed, and while the finances of the Empire grew increasingly grim, the army, at least, was under the thumb of the Emperor. In previous ages, the position of Megas Domestikos was a political one, appointed to the man who supported the Emperor the most. William de Voifellon, however, was a man of outstanding military talent, named by Sultan Jawfarim of the Fars Mongols as the "finest general of his day". As Jawfarim led the Mongols from being a provincial power, under attack by aggressive Christian crusaders, to an empire that extended from North Africa to the depths of Persia, this is a valuable insight insdeed.

At this selfsame time, the Principality of Armenia Minor, once a loyal province of the Roman Empire, had since declared independence, but had struck up an alliance with Basileus Andronikos. While Andronikos was a man who saw no problem in disobeying traditional codes of conduct in battle (See Martin Lockyear's The Recovery of Epirus, p. 23-45), he kept his word unfailingly, even when it was to his disadvantage.

The Prince of Armenia, Manuel Kantekoukes, however, had the poor judgement to send his missive requesting aid to William's army in Asia Minor, assuming they would march to his aid. William immediately disregarded the message, burnt it, and had the messenger slain. He knew that if Andronikos demanded his men march to the aid of Armenia Minor, they would expose the flanks of his army to constant Turkish attacks of attrition en route, and would give the sultunates time to mass their forces.

It was an immensely simple plan of attack. Outlined below are the basic territories - William intended to secure the coasts, before continuing into Ottoman territory, in order to staunch the coming counterblow. What he had not counted on was that the Ottomans were, effectively, losing their war against their aggressors. Instead of throwing his men into a conflict in which two sides might take up arms against him, he merely secured the coast, and passed on the territory to the Emperor.

919k0i.png

The simplistic campaign plan

However, all was not well at home. Despite the popular victories in Asia Minor, Constantinople was suffering from a breakdown of law and order. Most men considered their territories to be farms, of sorts. Plant it with good order and law, and you will harvest wealth. Andronikos did not understand this, and is remembered as one of the poorest stewards on record. Thankfully, the minor sultans of the Turkish coast had plentiful wealth, which was distributed among his soldiers - who then took this wealth home.

The economy was sustained by plunder, and, with huge new influxes of it to be had, thieves rings rose up in Constantinople. In a vain attempt to stamp them out, Andronikos banned much trade. This, however, merely accentuated the problem - smuggler's rings were now as common as the thieves. The City began to falter, and, despite his military revival of the Empire, Andronikos had begun to drive its economy into the ground.