Golden CaesAAR: Best Beta AAR

[comagoosie]

Welcome to the first Golden CaesAAR, where it is now your turn to vote for the Best Beta AAR. All of the Betas for Rome were great and when they came out we read them, re-read them, and saved it under favorites. And here are our nominees

[thread=349015] The Devil's Horsemen: A Parthia Beta-AAR [/thread]
Parthia
By Secret Master
611 - 653

[thread=346989]Catrulda Gelimarid of Eubornes - A Tale of Conquest, Betrayal and Irony [/thread]
Eburones
By Jinnai
474 - 496

[thread=346283] Macedonia - An Interactive AAR [/thread]
Macedonia
By King
474 - 604

The rules are simple. Vote for you favorite AAR and you can give a reason why. And at the end of the month we will see who the winner is. Good luck to the nominees.

Hmm...I don't know how to do a poll, but I am sure we will figure it out.

 

[Enewald]

It is fifty-fifty now...

Lol. :rofl:

 

[comagoosie]

It is fifty-fifty now...

Lol. :rofl:

it is what people nominated. I don't change the rules.

 

[Capibara]

Parthia all the way!! I really liked because of the way he narrated the AAR, and of course, I've always had a soft spot for Parthia

 

[spl]

33, 33, 33 now! Go Macedonia!

 

[Capibara]

It is fifty-fifty now...

Lol. :rofl:

33/33/33

 

[Jaspume]

Macedonia all the way.

 

[Enewald]

no, the eburones are losing!
maybe they are only a one province minor, but still they could win this battle.

 

[Woody Man]

Vote Cast!

 

[unmerged(7509)]

Macedonia for the same reasons I nominated it.

 

[Rensslaer]

Besides the fact that I do also have a soft spot for Parthia, I really do think Secret Master's Devil's Horsemen deserves this award.

But I will grant it is a very hard choice! Even the un-nominated beta deserves recognition -- a great crop, all around!

Rensslaer

 

[comagoosie]

Besides the fact that I do also have a soft spot for Parthia, I really do think Secret Master's Devil's Horsemen deserves this award.

But I will grant it is a very hard choice! Even the un-nominated beta deserves recognition -- a great crop, all around!

Rensslaer

too true. All Beta AARs were of top notch quality. They were a pleasure to read. I hate it when we have to give awards to the "best" when they were all astounding.

 

[Berrrie]

Out of those nominated, I liked the Parthia AAR best.

Thanks to all beta's who took the time to write the AAR's.

 

[Enewald]

Why is no one else going to vote Eburones?

 

[unmerged(7509)]

too true. All Beta AARs were of top notch quality. They were a pleasure to read. I hate it when we have to give awards to the "best" when they were all astounding.

If you hate it then why did you start the thread I liked them all but there is nothing wrong with choosing the best in a field full of strong candidates.

 

[comagoosie]

If you hate it then why did you start the thread I liked them all but there is nothing wrong with choosing the best in a field full of strong candidates.

Sorry that is my fault I didn't explain it well enough. It is tough for me to choose, kinda like choosing between children. I don't hate it, rather like the thrill of having the ability to vote.

 

[Enewald]

Btw, shouldn't we have a winner declared now when the voting closed a week ago?

And what does the winner get?

 

[comagoosie]

Btw, shouldn't we have a winner declared now when the voting closed a week ago?

And what does the winner get?

the voting isn't closed. It closes July 12th

the winner gets the pride of having the best Beta AAR.

 

[comagoosie]

10 days left. And we have had 44 people vote, which is astouding

and the winner gets something else besides having the best beta AAR.

 

[comagoosie]

We got less then one day folks, so if you haven't read the betas or haven't voted, you should do so before tomorrow.