• We have updated our Community Code of Conduct. Please read through the new rules for the forum that are an integral part of Paradox Interactive’s User Agreement.

SirCliveWolfe

Misthios
86 Badges
Apr 11, 2005
1.614
10
  • Europa Universalis IV: Cossacks
  • Victoria 2
  • Victoria 2: A House Divided
  • Rome: Vae Victis
  • 500k Club
  • Cities: Skylines
  • Cities: Skylines Deluxe Edition
  • Europa Universalis IV: El Dorado
  • Europa Universalis IV: Pre-order
  • Crusader Kings II: Way of Life
  • Europa Universalis IV: Common Sense
  • Crusader Kings II: Horse Lords
  • Cities: Skylines - After Dark
  • Semper Fi
  • Crusader Kings II: Conclave
  • Cities: Skylines - Snowfall
  • Europa Universalis IV: Mare Nostrum
  • Stellaris
  • Stellaris: Galaxy Edition
  • Stellaris: Galaxy Edition
  • Hearts of Iron IV: Cadet
  • Crusader Kings II: Reapers Due
  • Europa Universalis IV: Rights of Man
  • Stellaris: Digital Anniversary Edition
  • Stellaris: Leviathans Story Pack
  • Stellaris: Nemesis
  • Europa Universalis IV: Art of War
  • Crusader Kings II
  • Crusader Kings II: Charlemagne
  • Crusader Kings II: Legacy of Rome
  • Crusader Kings II: The Old Gods
  • Crusader Kings II: Rajas of India
  • Crusader Kings II: The Republic
  • Crusader Kings II: Sons of Abraham
  • Crusader Kings II: Sword of Islam
  • Deus Vult
  • Europa Universalis III
  • Divine Wind
  • Europa Universalis IV
  • Hearts of Iron II: Armageddon
  • Europa Universalis IV: Conquest of Paradise
  • Europa Universalis IV: Wealth of Nations
  • For the Motherland
  • Hearts of Iron III
  • Hearts of Iron III: Their Finest Hour
  • Heir to the Throne
  • Europa Universalis III Complete
  • Europa Universalis III Complete
  • Europa Universalis IV: Res Publica
  • Victoria: Revolutions
kaiserlich und königlich​





Introduction

Good evening gentlemen,

Welcome to my new(ish) AAR, my aim is to steer the Hapsburg Empire through WWI, using the excellent 1914 mod. It will be written in the format of a history-book and will primarily focus upon the events upon the eastern/Serbian fronts and in particular the progress of Arch Duke Charles, an imagined General. I shall show the events of the western/Middle Eastern fronts, especially once Charles is, hopefully, re-assigned their after beating Russia and Serbia.

One other thing to remember is that the ‘author’ is British and very much a Charles ‘fan boy’, so there will be bias towards Britain/Charles in the writing. Also I have found it very hard to find detailed information on the Eastern front, so it may not seem 100% historical. If anyone has any goldmines of information it would be great if you could share this.

Some of you will also remember the title and even the previous AAR of this name that I began back in 2006 and this is no coincidence. This AAR is part of my ‘Project Phoenix’, that I have begun with the hope of finishing the many AARs that I have started, but have been for various reasons unable to finish. I have started this AAR afresh as a new thread as the style will be different from the original. I should also point out that my current British Vicky2 AAR will be being updated at the same time as this one.

Thank you for your time and I hope you enjoy the story as much as I enjoyed the game.

Your Humble Servant,

Sir Clive Wolfe

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

Dedicated to all those who died in the Great War, lest we forget...

 
Last edited:
Table of contents...

reserved
 
Correct me if I'm wrong, but by saying "Lest we not forget" isn't that just saying "Lest we remember" ? :(
 
Correct me if I'm wrong, but by saying "Lest we not forget" isn't that just saying "Lest we remember" ? :(
Sorry, not sure where the errant 'not' came from, thanks for the catch...
 
Prologue





“It is my hope that one day these modest writings may give an account of the history of my Empire. My name is Charles Konrad Salvator, Archduke of Austria-Tuscany son of the late Franz Salvator and Marie Valerie, the history of this country has always fascinated me, I feel that we now approach a time of great strife and struggle. War looms on the horizon and I have graduated from the Theresian Military Academy in Wiener-Neustadt, I have been put under the tutelage of Franz Graf Conrad von Hötzendorf. I hope that I can help lead my country to greater things, and seek to write some of my experiences here also.” - Archduke Charles



Archduke Franz Salvator, Charle's farther

I have long been interested in the Hapsburg Empire and with the lack of material that has been written on the subject of the eastern front of The Great War, it was obvious to me when I started writing history, that I should focus upon this area. I started the laborious job of research in the majestic city of Vienna and its leviathan archives. What I saw there helped me to amass a large database of information with witch I was to return to my native Chester and begin writing. It was at this time that my publisher, Penguin, suggested that I retire to the British Library and scour the archives for more information to make the work a general Great War book focusing upon the Austrian fronts. With some hesitancy I agreed, but when I arrived I soon struck gold in the form of the published, but almost unnoticed, diary’s if Archduke Charles. That such a man’s writings can be largely ignored is strange, but I immediately decided that I would work heavily with his accounts.

The young Archduke was given a strange education, for it seemed that as the second son, he would not inherit and so a carer in the army beckoned. As such his formative years in education were under took by a family friend, Sir Archibald Massingbird. The Englishman was a strange and eccentric figure, but one with imense experiance having served with the British during the Boer War, the Japanese at Port Arthur. Charles took an instant liking to his tutor and when his farther died in 1902 in a automobile accident alongside Intelligence supremo, Alfred Redl[1], he looked upon the man as a farther figure. The young man went on to study at Cambridge university in Great Britain, where he showed he sharp intelligence by gaining a first, returning to his homeland to study at the famed military academy.



Archduke Charles, Duke of Teschen. The great Napoleonic commander

The year 1914 started uneventfully for the Rittmeister[2] of the, 1. Kavallerie Division[3], but as the year moved from winter to spring his older brother, was involved in a riding accident. Within a few months, Archduke Hubert Salvator, lay dying from his injuries and so Charles was to take the mantle the senior male of his family. He was not ready at the tender age of only 21 for what was to come, but his blood was that of his famous namesake, Archduke Charles of Austria, Duke of Teschen, the famous Napoleonic commander. Breading would eventually show, and it would be needed quickly, as in June the world exploded...

---------------------------------------------------------------------------​

[1] Alfred Redl was a spy for the Russian’s in OTL (Our Time Line) he was recruited in 1903 and passed over detailed plans of the Austrian attacks on Russia and Serbia which lead to massive losses in the first few months, in this timeline he dies in 1902... the loses shall not be so great... I hope :)

[2] Austrian rank for a captain in the Cavalry

[3] German for Cavalry

 
“...it was with great sadness that I heard the news of Franz’s death, from that point on we were all thrown towards the gates of Hell that was the war...” - Archduke Charles




Chapter I: the July Crisis


At the turn of the century Europe had been in a state of uneasy peace since the end of the Napoleonic wars, so much so that idealists and economists were beginning to predict that a major war was no longer possible due to inter-dependant trade. This was merely a facade and one that was to be brought crashing down, and the journey to war began in 1903, when Serbian military officers led by Dragutin Dimitrijević, known more commonly as Apis, stormed the Serbian Royal Palace and brutally murdered the King and his wife. The Coup brought with it a nationalistic and militaristic executive, bent on re-creating the 14th century Empire, causing rising tensions with the Austro-Hungarian empire, and the Balkan wars. After the Second Balkan War, tensions between the two powers were markedly increased, with Austria supporting the Albanians in the west cutting Serbia off from the sea. Apis, by now head of Serbia’s Military Intelligence, believed that Archduke Franz Ferdinand represented a double threat with his support of triadism, under which Austria-Hungary would be reorganized by combining the Slavic lands within the Austro-Hungarian empire into a third crown, and his supposed hawkish views on war with Serbia. In fact the heir to the Dual-Monarchy was, along with the Hungarian prime minister Count Tisza, were the staunchest advocates of peace. Nikola Pašić, prime minster of Serbia did not see any advantage in war with its northern neighbour and twice tried to undo the work of Apis, once trying to detain Princip and then giving warning to Vienna.



The assassination of Franz Ferdinand

In the event the Black Hand, a group of mainly disaffected Bosnian Serbs, were armed and trained by the insidious head of Serbian intelligence and sent forth with the mission to assassinate Franz Ferdinand. So on the 28th of June 1914, the Archduke’s motorcade passed by six assassins, the first two failed to act, and when the third threw his bomb it bounced off Ferdinand’s car, severely damaging another behind it. The assassin, Nedeljko Čabrinović, swallowed a cyanide capsule and dove into the river. Unfortunately for him, the capsule only induced vomiting and with his suicide attempt thwarted he was set upon by an angry mob. The other three assassins also failed to act as the motorcade past by them at great speed. The party had made its way to the town hall where Ferdinand thanked the people of Sarajevo for their ovations "as I see in them an expression of their joy at the failure of the attempt at assassination." It was decided that they should visit the victims that had been injured by the bomb-thrower, it was while on route to the hospital that the driver made a fatal mistake. Having not been informed properly of the route, he took a wrong turning and ended up in front of a fortunate Princip. The man used his FN Model 1910 to shot twice, the first hit the Archduke and the second his beloved Sophie. Anti-Serb rioting broke out in Sarajevo and various other places within Austria-Hungary in the hours following the assassination until order was restored by the military.[4]

The destruction of the peace in 1914 was precipitated by the events of Sarajevo, but above all the feeling of fear in the major capitals. The first fear was that of Vienna, since the middle of the last century, it’s natural sphere of influence had been taken by first the creation of Germany and then of Italy. This caused the Austrians to look south to the Balkans and also pushed it into a downward spiral in regrade to the other Great Powers. In 1914, after the assassination, the situation looked grim Vienna had to act against Serbia, otherwise it would loose all of its influence in the Balkans and may even see a general uprising of the ‘south Slavs’. Vienna was also concerned by Russia and so sought assurances from its northern ally Germany. Berlin had seen that Bismark’s legacy was becoming endangered, after he had defeated France he sought to isolate her so as to protect against revanchism and possible future conflict. Since his fall from power, however, first Russia and then Great Britain had moved into friendly waters with France. Kaiser Wilhelm II knew that he had only one reliable ally left, as Italy was seen quite rightly as ‘flaky’ and so the Germans knew that they must support their Germanic brothers.



Europe in 1914

On the Entente side many parallels ran between its fears and those of its adversaries. In St. Petersberg, the Tsar’s position was still unstable from the aftermath of the 1904-05 war with Japan that had seen much discontent directed at Nicholas and forced him into accepting reforms. Pan-Slavism, was a major concern that could complicate the issue as was the fact that Russia saw the Balkans as within its sphere of influence, one that had taken a knock with the annexation of Bosnia by the Dual-Monarchy in 1909. Paris’s view, meanwhile, held a strong similarity with that of Berlin, as they had only just come out of diplomatic isolation and could not let one of its new allies fall to the Central Powers, this along with its vitriolic views upon German control of Alsace-Loraine, meant that they too could not stand back from war. Over the Chanel in London things did not seem so drastic, after all they were not at threat of loosing any continental positions. The case for war, however, was still overwhelming for Britain feared that if it left its allies to tackle the Central Powers alone, a victory for either side would mean control of the Chanel ports would be in the hands of a now opposing power and the balance of power in Europe would be lost. So Britain too could not afford, it seemed, to stand aside from its allies and would have to be involved in the coming war.[5]

For the remaining European powers, Italy and the Ottoman Empire, the case was no so straight forward. They had little to gain and no strategically important allies to loose, if they chose to enter the conflict at its start. It was to their benefit to stand on the sidelines until they could either see who the victor was likely to be, or which side could ‘bribe’ them with the best offer. The two extra European powers, Japan and the United States of America, had little interest in the matter in 1914 and were far from interested.



Alfred von Schlieffen, co-author of the France first plan

The Great War was, therefore, almost a forgone conclusion from the time that the megalomaniac Serbian intelligence unit drew up its plans for assassination.[6] Once Franz Ferdinand was dead a general European conflagration was hard to avoid. The added factor was each countries expectations that the war would be short and decided upon the timetables of mobilisation as much as the field of battle. Once the Austro-Hungarian empire had declare war upon Serbia and the Tsar gave the order for mobilisation, little else matters. Some ‘academics’ claim that a general mobilisation need not have caused a war and cite that it was only Germany’s war plans that needed a immediate entry of troops into Belgium that made turning back impossible. This as we have seen is not the case, and even though the Schlieffen-Moltke[7] plan did mean that German mobilisation did mean war, then general European conflict was by then inevitable anyway. So on the 1st of August, 1914, the Great War had begun.

---------------------------------------------------------------------------​

[4] All this is as in our time line (OTL)

[5] This, I believe pretty much sums up the fact that that by mid July war was inevitable

[6] The author has a pro-Austrian bias and so seeks to place all the blame upon the Serbs - these are not my views per se

[7] The fabled Schlieffen Plan was really only a forray into the idea of a France first scenario, and much of the credit/blame should rest with Helmuth von Moltke the Younger.

 
If only Franz Ferdinand had got a cold and decided to remain in bed that fateful day...


... it would have started somewhere else by some other odd reason.
 
Yeah, while WW1 wasn't inevitable, something had to give sooner or later.
 
If only Franz Ferdinand had got a cold and decided to remain in bed that fateful day...
Or if he had just holed up in the town hall and maybe gone to to hospital the next day

... it would have started somewhere else by some other odd reason.
Most probably... although not neccesarily

Yeah, while WW1 wasn't inevitable, something had to give sooner or later.
WWI who says theres going to be a WWII ;) but yeah your right, up until the Russians supporting the Serbs The Great War was not inevitable

btw... hopefully an update tomorrow
 
“No plan of battle ever survives contact with the enemy.” - Helmuth von Moltke, the Elder




Chapter II: Battle of the frontiers


As early as the 4th of august, German troops entered Belgium as the initial stage of Moltke’s plan required the fall of Liege before German mobilisation finished, so the the dense network of Belgian railways could be used to move and supply the envelopment of the French army. General Leman possessed a reinforced infantry division of some 24,000 to defend the position against the Germans. The forts, twelve major and numerous minor redoubts, ringed the city, but Germany’s Krupp works had not delivered the guns for them, neither did they have retractable turrets. Thus Leman was obliged to keep most of his force in field fortifications around the city to keep the German artillery out of range. German forces led by Erich Ludendorff, stormed the ring and deployed 305mm Skoda heavy howitzers, borrowed from the Austrians, and the massive 420mm Krupp howitzers to smash the turrets leaving the fortifications useless. Even before the 18th August German troops were streaming past the city and concentrating, completing the process of mobilisation. The force that would smash through north-eastern France consisted of von Kluck’s First Army with 320,000 men, von Bülow’s Second of, 260,000 and von Hausen’s Third of some 180,000. The invading forces were to meet little resistance as king Albert retired to the ‘nation redoubt’ around Antwerp, these were easily masked by two reserve divisions from von Kluck’s forces, as well as two divisions that would try and hold at the Namur complex, but was easily brushed aside on the 23rd. Brussels quickly fell on the 20th of the month, and only the British Expeditionary Force at Mons stemmed the German tide. The action was heroic as the four divisions of professional and highly trained troops of Great Britain deployed behind the canal line on the 23rd of August and for a day held off eight divisions from von Kluck’s army. Their fire from the excellent Lee Enfield rifel was so great that some of the German commanders thought that each man must have a machine gun, and the British soldiers sensed that the angles of Agincourt archers had come to their aid. Sir John French, commander of the BEF, was overnight compelled to retreat back into French territory and linked up with their allies on the left flank of Lanerzac’s Fifth army. At the end of the month the front had stabilised as both the Anglo-French and German position pivoted upon the great fortress of Verdun, with the BEF and French Fourth, under General Langle, and Fifth facing off against the German armies.


The Battle of the Frontiers

For their part the French had used in excess of 11,000 trains to complete their mobilisation, moving up to seven times more troops than they had managed with only slightly more rolling stock. The French Plan XVII was now put into action with Joffre as its master and commander and while it called for an immediate attack upon the German forces, the place of attack was left to to the mans discretion. Two factors contributed to the Frenchman’s underestimation of the threat to his northern flank, the first was his uncertainty as to Moltke’s intentions and his own preference for an attack into Alsace-Loraine. As early as the 8th of August, Franch troops moved into Mulhouse to much acclaim from its citizens, but they were soon compelled to retire. Once French concentration was complete on the 14th of August Joffre sent his First Army, under Dubail and Second, under Castelnau into Lorraine, hoping that they could reach the Rhine and distract Moltke from his northern attack. The two main armies were linked by only sporadic telegraph messages, whereas the opposing German Sixth, under Rupprecht and Seventh, under Heeringen benefited from strong comunications. The Germans, as called for under their war plans, fought a fighting withdrawal and then held at the battle of Morhange-Sarrbourg on the 20th. The French weighed down by heavy packs toiled uphill into a hail of machine gun fire and artillery directed by aircraft. Their followed a counter attack that thrust the French invaders across the border costing them 150 guns and 20,000 mean taken prisoner with countless more dead and wounded. Jeffre now delayed his next actions as he awaited intelligence reports as to the situation, however, he still committed himself prematurely. With the surprising strength of the German right and left, Joffre incorrectly inferred that the centre must be weak. Thus he tasked his Third Army, under Ruffey and the Fourth, under Langle to make an offensive through the Ardennes to threaten Moltke’s flanking movement from its pivot. The Germans has a local superiority in recognisance cavalry and on the 22nd of August mist grounded French aircraft, moving forward in echelon along the sparse roads of the area the twenty or so French divisions, therefore, blundered into not a weaker force but a German one that contained 21 divisions of Albrecht’s, Sixth Army.. The exclent 75mm French artillery was ineffective in the hilly terrain and poorly liked via communications to the infantry and so there was no answer to the massed German machine gun and artillery fire. With the massive losses in the Battle of Neufchateau on the 26th of August once again compelled French troops to break off the offensive and retreat.

So by the end of the month the Germans seemed to be closing on Paris, and more importantly the encirclement of French forces that their plan envisioned as a knockout blow. Events were far from certain and in the east the bear was stirring.

 
Update should be up tonight folks :)

Smashing stuff.
Thank you, hope you enjoy the show :D

Suscribed!
Ah the one little word that means so much to an AARer :)

Well, this is going to be fun....
Indeed!... just a little bit worried that it may be a short war... :D or maybe not ;)

Provided you're not on the receiving end of a bombardment :D
Yes, always keep your head down on the battlefield... :D
 
“...it was a devastating blow to me, so soon after such a victory to be returning covered in my men's blood and weary, I learnt a great lesson that day, one which would stand me in great stead for the future...” - Archduke Charles, on the Battle for Galicia


Chapter III: The Battle of Galicia

Of all of the contending European powers the Russian Bear was by far the largest and it committed its power to bear upon both the Central powers at the same time. Russia’s most immediate aim was to crush the forces of Austro-Hungary, relieving the Serbs and dealing a knockout blow to one of the opponents, as such they committed 21 divisions against Germany’s 13 and some 53 against Austria’s 37, smaller divisions. Yet the mobilised power of Tsarist Russia was only comparable to that of France and Germany, while having a much larger population. The eastern state traditionally upheld a large standing army, which was used mainly to protect its far flung positions and for internal repression. Much of the budget went on supplying and supporting this standing force until 1909, when a spectacular boom allowed them to spend more, but they still only called up around one quarter of the available men, with the effect that they had a trained reserve of only 2.8 million men to be added to the 1.4 million of the standing army. Nor were the conscripts particularly well equipped as in 1914 Russia was spending more upon the navy than Germany was, but with little to show for it and, furthermore, they spent heavily upon fortifications to the consternation of many in Russia. Russia’s war minister, Sukhomlinov, was a controversial figure and although he was on balance a reformer the officer corps split between his protégés and enemies, he knew that the forts were vulnerable and would have preferred to abandon them, but had to compromise by modernising some. In 1914 these border defences had some 2,813 modern guns to only 240 mobile heavy pieces for the field army and while they had a good quick firing compliment, they were rationed to only 1000 shells each. The 4.5 million Mosin M.91 riffles were scarcely enough to complete mobilisation. The country had few officers and NCOs and so having the same problems of the French, they did not have the mitigation of an excellent and dense railway network. None the less the Stavka, or Russia’s military headquarters, decided to land simultaneous blows against both of their enemies. The adoption of the aggressive plan was a recent on and showed that the army was increasingly confident that the recent military programmes had shifted the balance of power back to Russia from the Austro-Germans. Russia’s aggressive Plan 20 was scheduled for adoption in 1914 and was largely used by the Russian General Staff at the outbreak of war, in the event Russia launched two needlessly weak attacks, when it would have served her better to sit tight on one front and attack on the other.



Conrad, C-i-C of Austrain forces and Aleksei Brusilov, one of Russia's finest Generals

The Austro-Hungary overall commander, Count Francis Conrad von Hötzendorf, at the outbreak of war quickly followed the prewar Plan R, which called for the the deployment of the First Army, under Dankl, Fourth, under Auffenberg, Third, under Brudermann and Second, under Bohm Ermolli from north west to south east along the Galacian border. He did not, however, decide to attack Russia but stopped his forces concentration upon the northern foothills of the Carpathian mountains, where they awaited the Russian advance by the Fourth Army, under Salza, Fifth, under Plehve, Third, under Ruzski and Eight, under Brusilov. The plan was controversial in that Moltke expected his allies to attack, but Conrad rightly assumed, after consultations with his staff including Archduke Charles, that the Germans were themselves took weak to attack and that the imperial army would be wasting its strength alone against the Russia's. The move was astute, Russia’s military budget was more than double that of the Dual Monarchy and a lower proportion of the Monarchy’s young men were called up than any other Great Power and served only very short periods when they did. Added to these constraints, while they did have elite forces, such as the Tyrolean mountain fighters, the reliability of the Czech and South Slav soldiers was uncertain. The smaller Austrian divisions only had 42 field guns each and although the Skoda pieces were of supreme quality, they had no quick firring guns such as the Russians had and generally had small stocks of shells as well. The Galician plain was defended by three hard points in the forts of Lemberg, Przemysl and Cracow which were all impressive and surrounded by well established rings of trenches. So while Conrad had decided to pit most of his army against Russia, he decided upon only one weak attack into Serbia as was required of him politically.As such when the Southwest commander, Ivanov, pushed his soldiers forward upon the onto the Galician plan and toward the mountains they found little resistance, save the strong forts of Lemberg and Przemysl which he ordered the detachment of significant forces to mask. By the 28th of August Russian forces met up with their adversaries and ploughed head-long into a frontal assault across the entire length of the front, the result was a predicitable disaster for the Russian forces.

Worse was to come for them as Austrian forces in the north-west started to push back those of the Fifth Army, which had been weakened by the detachment of forces to mask Przemysl. As with the battles on the western front lines of communication between attacking armies were weak, while those of the defenders were superior. When Ivanov saw that the retreat of Plehve’s Fifth Army was opening a gap between that force and that of Ruzski’s Third he immediately ordered both the Third and Eighth to close the gap, unfortunately while the Third army received the order, Brusilov’s Eighth did not, worse still they had made the most successful advance of the Russian army and were in intensive combat. As such a wide gap opened up on the left of the Russian army, Conrad was quick to try and take advantage, but Archduke Charles was quicker. His 8th Kavallerie Division had been held in reserve in his superiors Second Army and was itching for action. The young man was headstrong and gung-ho and determined to get into the action which had hitherto been dreary defensive involving the unglamorous world of infantry and artillery. He moved before any orders had been received and lead both his 8th and that of the 1st straight into the gap facing little or no opposition and wheeled south-east forcing Brusilov’s entire Eighth Army against the strong Austrian positions on the Carpathians and the river Dniester. Charles, however, was not content and massed his horse for a charge against the Russian rear guard. It was the last glorious cavalry charge in a major war as the grey and red uniformed man, sabers flashing in the sunlight, rode towards their prey. Unfortunately for the men of the 8th, it was the last charge for a reason, they ran not into weak prey but to the hail of machine gun and artillery fire and barley limped back to their lines with six in ten men fallen. The Archduke was shocked, bloodied and battered, he grew that day and, as always being astute, he survayed the great power of concentrated artillery and machine guns.


The brave men of the 8th kavallerie Division

Ivanov was shocked by Brusilov’s, understandable, surrender and by September had ordered a general retreat towards the Dnieper river and Kiev, he had lost some 400,000 men, 200,000 surrendered with Brusilov, a full third of his forces. While the allies were stumbling under the western and Galacian offensives, in the north the Russian’s were making great gains against the German Eighth Army in eastern Prussia and inept leadership on the Serbian front threatened to ignite anarchy and undermine the entire Austro-Hungarian war effort.


 
That's a bad beginning for the Russians... Brussilov won't be attacking in 1916.