Proposal: Fimir should be worshippers of the Gods of Law instead of Chaos

[Fofotron]

I have a proposal and would like to see what you guys think about it.

My proposal: Fimir should be worshippers of the Gods of Law instead of Chaos

The Fimir are a feared, ancient race that lurks in the swamps and mists, preying on nearby settlements and living in near-total isolation. Historically associated with dark powers, they are feared for their strength, cruelty, and strange mystical abilities. Though often linked to Chaos, their connection has never been fully explored, providing an opportunity to recast their allegiances.
Aligning the Fimir with the Gods of Law—Alluminas, Arianka/Astasis, Solkan, and Daora—introduces a unique twist. These gods represent order taken to an extreme: unbending, authoritarian, and absolute. While Chaos spreads corruption and decay, Law can be equally dangerous, enforcing control, purity, and discipline to the point of tyranny. If the Fimir were to embrace Law as their guiding force, they would remain a deadly, hostile faction, representing the destructive potential of unrestrained Law in the Warhammer Fantasy universe. This shift also introduces the notion that both the Fimir and the Gods of Law have waned in influence, making them a lurking but diminished threat seeking resurgence.

Rationale for the Alignment Shift

1. Law as a Force Just as Dangerous as Chaos
   • Unchecked Law, like Chaos, is inherently dangerous. By aligning with the Gods of Law, the Fimir embody an extremist vision of order—ruthless, unfeeling, and uncompromising. Their concept of Law would be as oppressive as the Chaos Gods' is corruptive, turning them into relentless enforcers of their own brutal codes. The Fimir would enforce order in the most authoritarian way possible, viewing any deviation from their strict customs as a threat. This extremism would make them just as hostile and deadly as Chaos worshipers, but in a cold, structured way that values control over all else.
2. The Ancient, Faded Power of Law
   • The Gods of Law are largely forgotten or diminished, their influence weakened by the overwhelming presence of Chaos. Likewise, the Fimir's numbers and territories have dwindled, and they remain a scattered, shadowy presence. This faded influence creates an intriguing narrative: the Fimir are ancient zealots of a long-lost order, upholding the Gods of Law with fanatical devotion. Their worship is not an appeal to a benevolent deity but rather a rigid adherence to forgotten principles, fostering a dangerous desire to reclaim their former might. This faded power makes the Fimir a dangerous relic, lurking with the potential to rise again in fierce, authoritarian opposition to Chaos.
3. An Uncompromising, Alien Code of Conduct
   • Despite their allegiance to Law, the Fimir would remain hostile and predatory toward other races, who they consider weak or undisciplined. Their sense of Law would be utterly alien, and their rituals and rules incomprehensible to most. Other factions would still view them as monstrous aggressors, but their actions would now follow a set of extreme principles. The Fimir's rigid laws might compel them to capture and punish transgressors according to harsh "justice," potentially leading them to kidnap or enslave others in the name of enforcing order. This rigid fanaticism makes them slightly more predictable than Chaos followers, but no less threatening.
4. Rare, Fragile Alliances of Convenience Against Chaos
   • While still incredibly hostile to other races, the Fimir's alignment with Law might create room for rare alliances of convenience against Chaos. Chaos represents the ultimate enemy of Law, and the Fimir might find common ground with other factions, however temporarily, to halt its spread. Yet, these alliances would be uneasy at best. The Fimir would view their allies as flawed and unreliable, tolerating them only out of necessity. These temporary truces would dissolve as soon as the Chaos threat is contained, with the Fimir often turning on their allies to restore what they see as "order" in the aftermath.
5. The Fimir as Enforcers of Law's Dark Side
   • In embracing Law, the Fimir would embody its most dangerous aspects. Solkan's desire for purity and vengeance, for example, could manifest in the Fimir as a relentless campaign against perceived corruption, leading them to exterminate or enslave any who fall short of their ideals. This extremism would give the Fimir a unique but terrifying role within the world of Warhammer Fantasy: they would be enforcers of an order that few would desire. Their worship of Law would make them feared puritans, prone to imposing their will upon any who fail to meet their standards.

How This Alignment Could Enrich the Lore and Interactions with Other Factions

1. Expanded Lore and Complex Themes: Reinterpreting the Fimir as followers of the Gods of Law introduces themes of extremism and oppression, challenging the assumption that Law is inherently "good." This shift would position them as enforcers of a harsh order, feared not only for their strength but also for the inflexible fanaticism that drives them. It would highlight Law's destructive potential, showing that order without mercy can be as dangerous as chaos without restraint.
2. Narrative Potential for Fragile Alliances Against Chaos: Campaigns could explore the tension of these rare alliances against Chaos, emphasizing the unease between the Fimir and other races. Players might work alongside the Fimir in a temporary, tense partnership, only to find that the Fimir's fanatical Law makes them just as challenging to work with as Chaos worshipers. These alliances would feel strained and fragile, creating rich storytelling opportunities as players navigate the conflicting goals and extreme worldview of the Fimir.
3. Unique Diplomatic Tensions and Ongoing Hostility: With their devotion to Law, the Fimir would still be dangerous enemies, even to non-Chaotic factions. Their hostility would be rooted not in mindless violence but in an unwavering adherence to ancient principles that other races can't understand or respect. This would introduce new diplomatic dynamics where other races might attempt to negotiate or cooperate, but always at great risk, as any perceived breach of the Fimir's code would be met with ruthless reprisal.

Conclusion
Positioning the Fimir as worshippers of the Gods of Law would offer Warhammer Fantasy a new, morally ambiguous faction—a race that serves as a remnant of an ancient order, wielding Law as a weapon just as destructive as Chaos. Their faded influence makes them a shadowy but menacing force, still fiercely dangerous and hostile, but now driven by a fanatical allegiance to an unforgiving code. This interpretation enriches the lore by highlighting the potential for Law to be as brutal and unyielding as Chaos, while still allowing for rare and tenuous alliances against the ever-encroaching threat of Chaos.