The 2010 CrusadAAR's Chalice Voting Thread

[Qorten]

2010 CrusadAAR's Chalice

The top years for CK AARland are over, but it's certainly not dead yet. Next year we'll have another 2011 edition of this thread and then it's onwAARds to CKII.

The completed AAR's are diminishing year after year since 2008 but in 2010 there were 5 completed AARs still. Not enough to give you a Nominations Thread, we'll go right to the voting for the CrusadAAR's Chalice, the SilvAAR Goblet and the PewtAAR Cup.

The available choices:

Dunkeld
Scotland
Forward in the Name of God - A Scottish Mega-Campaign
Iain Wilson
1066-1964 (Completed 12 February 2010)


Multiple Families
Genoa
The Republic of Genoa: A Community AAR
Grauuu
1090-1256 (Completed 13 March 2010)

Van der Aarlander
AARland
The Kingdom of AARland
Iain Wilson and others
1337-1358 (Completed 4 May 2010)

D'Albon
Burgundy/Jerusalem
Through Rivers of Blood and Mountains of Gold - The Story of The House of D'Albon
Tommy4ever
1066-1475 (Completed 28 July 2010)

Leofricson
Duchy of Prussia (and others later)
Homelands: Tales of the Anglo-Prussians
Mr. Capiatlist
1066-1356 (Completed 23 December 2010)


You may post here to tell everyone what AAR you voted for and why you did so. It may entice other people to vote for your favorite, who knows?
​

 

[loki100]

To me it has to be Mr Capiatlist's Homelands ...it was just such a completely realised world in which everything related, a wonderfully structured vision of an alternative reality

 

[Aliasing]

I agree with Loki, Homelands is just such a beautifully crafted world, even going as far as developing a full language for an AAR. It just proves his determination to the subject.

 

[gigau]

With all respect due to the other authAARs, it is also without hesitation that i vote for Mr Capiatlist's Homelands AAR.

 

[Rensslaer]

Except for Mr. Capiatlists's Anglo-Prussians, I don't think I've read any of these. I'd better get started.

On a side note, I find it amusing that one person -- Frogbeastegg -- who would unquestionably win one of these awards hasn't done so simply because she refuses to finish her AAR!

Rensslaer

 

[Qorten]

I predict an easy win for Homelands. It was a very, very good AAR. I'm holding my vote for later, should there be a tie for second or third place. Other people have to get some love too. Tommyever's Dauphine AAR was very good too you know. The Kingdom of AARland was funny while it lasted and a nice initiative which deserves credit for Iain.

 

[Haramir]

I already vote for Homeland because i read it last year and i found it really interesting, but ill read the other completed AAR

 

[Vesimir]

The Kingdom of AARland was awesome... But then again, I need to finally give proof to me liking Mr. Capiatlists work. So Homelands it is.

 

[unmerged(135995)]

I vote for Homelands, by Mr. Capiatlist, but all of them are pretty good reads.

 

[Qorten]

20 votes in so far! Keep 'em coming, people.

 

[Qorten]

Congrats to Mr. Capiatlist for winning the CrusadAAR's Chalice for 2010 finished AAR's! Tommy4ever and Iain Wilson and co can be very happy and proud to have snatched away a vote from Mr. Capiatlist's masterpiece and receive a shared SilvAAR Goblet!

 

[loki100]

congrats to Mr Capiatlist .... and to everyone for actually finishing an AAR as opposing to leaving it all forlorn on the way

 

[WelshDude]

Congrats to Mr. Capiatlist. Are there any links to previous chalice's? It's a bit annoying finished aars were taken out of the forum.

 

[Qorten]

Congrats to Mr. Capiatlist. Are there any links to previous chalice's? It's a bit annoying finished aars were taken out of the forum.

Overview of previous CrusadAAR's Chalice winners.

 

[Mr. Capiatlist]

Thank you, everyone. And congrats to the Silver Goblet winners as well as the runner ups, the pain of finishing what we start is a shared struggle.

 

[Rensslaer]

Wow! That's a very impressive vote total!

Congratulations to all those who were nominated, but especially to Mr. Capiatlist! Very well earned!

Rensslaer

 

[frogbeastegg]

On a side note, I find it amusing that one person -- Frogbeastegg -- who would unquestionably win one of these awards hasn't done so simply because she refuses to finish her AAR!

'Eleanor' finished long ago; it was finished in time for the previous run of awards IIRC. I don't know if anyone nominated it for anything as I don't tend to read these threads very often. More recent activity comes from a separate story ('The Third Sister') which takes place 3 years after the main tale ended; since it contains strong links to 'Eleanor' I thought I may as well keep it in the same thread. That story is 2 posts from completion.

Sorry to spoil your amusement



Congratulations to this year's winner.