• We have updated our Community Code of Conduct. Please read through the new rules for the forum that are an integral part of Paradox Interactive’s User Agreement.

unmerged(12439)

Private
Dec 6, 2002
13
0
Visit site
This first portion of the AAR is meant to set the stage for the rest of the AAR and so it is a little dry, but bare with me and I'll get the meat onto this bone.

Finnish AAR (Normal): Jan 1st, 1936

Current Government (Liberal Conservative):

Head of State: Pehr Svinhefvud
Head of Government: Toivo Kivimaki
Foreign Minister: Antti Hacknell
Armaments Minister: Arvi Oksala
Minister of Security: Yrjo Puhakka
Minister of Intelligence: Esko Riekki- Dismal Enigma
Chief of Staff: L.L. Oesch- School of Manouvere
Chief of Army: Hugo Osterman- Elastic Defense
Chief of Navy: Vairo Valve- Base Control
Chief of Air Force: Jarl Lundqvist- Naval Aviation

Current Military:
8 Infantry
7 Infantry reinforced with artillery brigades

Finish High Commander:
Field Marshal Mannerheim- Defensive Specialist

Rest of Finnish High Command:
Osterman-Defensive Specialist
Sihvo-Defensive Specialist
Hannel- Winter Specialist
Lundquist- Winter Specialist
Heinrichs- Winter Specialist
 
Last edited:
Conquer Sweeden and Norway for their resources and join the axis. In my opinion it is your only hope to win. And of course, build fortresses.
 
Good luck, from what I have seen of Finland the get pounded into the ground by aircraft, and weak Russian troops just walk in and collect what they desire.
 
The Little Bird-Jan 1936

"Good morning gentlemen," said Toivo from his seat at the head of the table. "We have much to discuss today and the first order of business is our neighbor, the Soviet Union. What is the status of our neighbor?"

Antti rose from his seat, "The giant is still slumbering within its borders, Minister Kivimaki..."

"But it shall stir," said Esko in his usually enigmatic tone.

"And what has our little bird heard on these wintery winds," asked Antti, only slightly annoyed at the interuption.

"Your little bird has heard that winter is coming and it shall be long and hard."

Antti turned to the frosted window and looked at the flurries falling outside. He laughed, "It has already come you fool..."

Toivo raised his hand and stopped Antti before he could continue, "Antti sit down... and Esko speak plainly I have not the patience today to listen to riddles."

Esko smiled slightly, "Very well, Minister Kivimaki, I have heard rumors that Stalin is planning a purge of his officers."

"Then should that not be a good thing for us as it may cause unrest and uncertainty in our enemy?" said Antti.

"For a short time perhaps, but any physician knows that purging the body makes it stronger in the end, if one can survive the cure... and so shall our giant be emboldened once he has finished his regiment."

"When do you expect these things to take place Esko?" asked Toivo.

"The Stalin has already prescribed the cure and he shall seek to remedy Russia by the end of the year."

"And after that?"

Esko's eyes narrowed in thought, "If I was to hazard a guess I would say that the Soviets would turn their eyes towards Finland... or perhaps Poland, Estonia, or Latvia, though Finland would be the more logical choice as our defeat would secure the Soviet flanks before they move on Europe proper."

"Unbelievable!" cried Antti. "The Soviets would be foolhardy to attack us, they would not only bloody themselves against our lines, but they would bring the ire of our allies!"

"And who might those be?" asked Arvi, minister of armaments. "Did I miss a memo? Have we gained the backing of Germany, the UK, or... the Americans?"

"Nothing official mind you," replied Antti. "But I have received words from some countries that if we were to find ourselves at odds with the Soviet Union that they would help us with men and materials."

"Enough to bury our dead most likely," said Arvi with a sniff.

Antti leapt up from his seat and exclaimed, "If you doubt me..."

Toivo immediately stood from his chair, "Be calm Antti and Arvi I too have spoken to the Swedes and it does seem that they are concerned about the prospect of Soviets upon their border. I feel confidant that they shall aid us. In any case, Esko's theory is one that we shall need to address. What can we do to prepare for the day when our giant wakes and crosses our border with mal intent? Antti?"

"I shall continue to work towards gaining alliance with other countries to ensure our survival. The UK and Germany are obvious choices, though I shall also continue our talks with Sweden and Norway as well."

"Good," said Toivo. "And you Arvi?"

"I shall speak with Oesch, Osterman, Valve, Lundquist, and the rest of High Command about preparing for the probability of war with the Soviets and come up with a plan of action that will ensure our victory or at least give the Soviets a great wound."

"Yrjo, you have been silent today. What shall you do?"

"I have a cold," said Yrjo plainly. "And for my part I shall make sure the people love you enough to elect you in a year and a half. That is if we survive that long."

"Just don't twist too many arms, Yrjo."

"If I do you shall hear nothing about it," Yrjo's lips curled in an eerie grin. "Though perhaps Esko may."

Toivo raised an eyebrow, but said nothing, instead he turned to Esko, "And speaking of Esko, what shall our little bird be doing to insure our safety."

"A bird can do little against twenty divisions minister Toivo, but he can watch and wait for his opportunity to make a difference."

Toivo looked around the room and said, "For my part I will speak with Pehr and we shall look into increasing our industrial capabilities and begin work on the fortifications we had planned near the city of Vipuri."

"We should also look into building up our infrastructure and other fortifications in case we are unable to hold Vipuri best to have a defense in depth," said Arvi.

"I shall have our enginners look into the infrastructure and fortifications of our heartland, but I believe it best if we leave the countryside as barren as possible that way if the Soviets do come they shall find themselves in an inhospitable land facing a mobile and entrenched enemy."

"A wise plan and one that Field Marshal Mannerheim shall appreciate," stated Arvi and others around the table nodded their approval.

"Now onto other business..."
 
Originally posted by Estonianzulu
Good luck, from what I have seen of Finland the get pounded into the ground by aircraft, and weak Russian troops just walk in and collect what they desire.

When I played Finland in 1.01b (Bolted)I indeed learned those lessons and had to give into their demands during the winter war, but a year later I joined the Axis and was able to take back Vipuri and from there crushed the defenders of Lennigrad and their 3 air divisions stationed there ;-)

It's good to be Finnish ;-)

Joseph

PS: I'm not certain this will happen in 1.02, but it should be interesting to see the contrast in how the game plays out ;-)
 
In my first 1.02 version it happened (Russia took ALL of mainland Finland, and settled for a lousy peace) good luck
 
The Bear Trap-Jan 1936

Mannerheim listened quitely to Arvi as he detailed Toivo's plan for the defense of Finland against the Soviet War machine. It was an interesting and novel approach to a gigantic problem. The others present at the High Command meeting seemed to be mulling over the plan, some faces seemed to approve of the approach, while others appeared to be doubtful. Valve and Lundqvist were looking particularly unhappy, the plan being laid out did not include a navy or airforce and both had grand designs of a "modern" army for Finland. A noble goal, but foolish in the face of an enemy so heavily based upon overwhelming land forces. The enemy would come through the forests of Finland and it would be those on the ground that would win or lose the war, not those in ships or planes.

"...and that my fellow ministers and generals is the plan of action. Are there any questions, comments, concerns?"

Arvi sat down at the head of the table opposite Mannerheim. There was a moment of silence and than as Mannerheim expected Lunqvist stood and said, "How are we to become a modern fighting force without a airforce..."

"Or a navy?" added Valve.

"Exactly!" said Lundqvist. "None of these plans include a plan for the future..."

That was enough, and Mannerheim interupted with his heavy voice, "The future is a luxury we do not have Chief Lundqvist. By the time we developed the proper technology for a airforce and navy you desire we would all be speaking Russian and calling each other "comrade". No my good friends if we are to have a future we must defeat the russians on the ground first only then shall we have the luxury you seek. The only question is how do we hold the giant at bay?"

"Why should we simply hold them at bay, Field Marshal Mannerheim," said Chief Oesch. "We should mechanize our armies and take the fight to the Russians if they cross our border. If we were to have a fast moving army we could quickly blitz Leningrad and strike a blow at our enemy that shall shock him and perhaps cause pause and confusion in his ranks. With the proper planning and amount of troops we could even take Moscow... what a glorious moment it would be for the Finnish army to march through the streets there..."

Mannerheim smiled, "Oesch, if I had a million of you to bring to bare against the Soviets and enough halftracks to bare you the plan you speak off would indeed be tempting, but what you speak of is a dream that we cannot hope to obtain. We have neither the resources nor the proper manpower to pull off such a stroke against the giant on our border."

"What if we were to focus upon mechanizing our troops, but for defensive purposes." said Osterman. "In this way we could supplement our static defenses and conventional infantry forces with quick moving reserves meant to be a reaction force against Soviet agression."

"An interesting idea, Chief Osterman." said Mannerheim. "And one that we should work towards, but again we speak of the future and one that we may not reach before the giant awakens and comes knocking at our door. I need a more practical plan one that can be implimented as quickly as possible and will provide us with the best possible prospects for success."

"And what would you propose, Field Marshal Mannerheim?" asked Arvi.

"With the limited time I have had to ponder the problem I would suggest that we take a defensive stance based upon fortifying our positions with bunkers and AA implacements which should minimalize their airforce's potency... We should also seek to improve our command and control, medical capabilities, and infantry weaponry and if possible then begin to mechanize our army as Oesch and Osterman suggest. I believe that by improving these things we may be able to hold off the Soviets to minimal gains and perhaps even push them back across the border once they have worn themselves out against our lines."

"So we shall let the Soviets take the initiative and dictate the battle?" asked Oesch sounding uncertain of the plan.

"Yes Chief Oesch, but remember that those who take the lead in battle are frequently the first to die. It is my hope that the Soviets will be the first to die when they attack our lines, but only time will tell."

Arvi stood up from his chair, "That is enough... Field Marshal Mannerheim, Finland's course has been set for better or worse... let us hope it is the Soviets who sink in the end and not us. I expect a detailed outline of your needs for the upcoming year upon my desk within the week... now for the last order of business... what shall we name this plan of ours?"

There was a moment of silence and then Field Marshal Mannerheim spoke, "Let us call it Operation Bear Trap."

Some of the generals smiled at the name and Arvi grinned, "Very well... I shall inform Toivo and the other ministers of the details."

Arvi left the warroom and Mannerheim looked upon the map that dominated the center of the table... Russia would need a very large bear trap indeed...
 
Long live House Stark!

"Winter is Comming" is an allusion to the "A Song of Fire and Ice" series by George R.R. Martin right?
 
Originally posted by Timothy Ortiz
Long live House Stark!

"Winter is Comming" is an allusion to the "A Song of Fire and Ice" series by George R.R. Martin right?

That would be correct... I figured playing Finland would be on parwith (or perhaps a little bit easier than) what the Starks went through in that series ;-)

Jaldaen
 
Nice one!
I havn´t played Finland in 1.02 yet, so I will keep an eye on this one
 
Originally posted by Lord Martin
Nice one!
I havn´t played Finland in 1.02 yet, so I will keep an eye on this one

Unfortunately I have been side swiped by work and will be heading out of town for the next two weeks... so my Finnish game will have to wait until January to finish up...

On the bright side I have Finland's economy going at a nice clip in preparation for war ;-)

Happy Holidays!
Joseph
 
Kuva.jpg


From left to right:

General-Lieutenant Hugo Österman, Major-General Rudolf Walden, Marshal Mannerheim, defence minister Juho Niukkanen, Major-General Lauri Malmberg and in the right General-Lieutenant Lennart Oesch.
 
Last edited:
I will try to hold an eye on this one.
 
Report of the Military Engineers

Summary Report from the Military Engineering Department:

Our survey of the feasibility of constructing border fortifications indicates that we lack the industrial means to construct defenses in any border province except Viipuri, bordering Leningrad. A similar problem exists with many of the interior provinces.

We recommend that the primary fortified defensive line include Vaasa, Seinajoki, Tampere, Helsinki, and Viipuri.

Our primary fortified line includes most of our economically key provinces, leaving only 15 Coal and 25 Steel output and 2 ICs of industrial capacity outside the line and 42 ICs, 65 Coal and 30 Steel inside this perimeter. Our resources are essentially fully utilized by our current ICs and by necessary trade for rubber (or, more likely, for oil to convert to rubber) to support our industry. Accordingly, the economic impact of building defenses will be minimal on the whole.

Rear-area provinces to the southeast including Pori, Turku and Mariehamn should also be fortified as fallback positions.

Mariehamn is an island and should be heavily fortified as a last bastion to preserve Finnish independence. Helsinki, Vaasa, Pori, and Turku are the key economic centers. Vaasa should receive Level 3 fortifications and Helsinki, where our forces will always be strongest if it is in the front line, at least Level 2 fortifications. Pori and Turku should also receive Level 2 fortifications. Viipuri, Seinajoki and Tampere should be fortified to the maximum possible extent.

We should also place Level 1 fortifications in Kuopio and Oulu when war appears more imminent, but in view of their lesser economic value and the extension of the line that this involves these must be regarded as dispensable outworks to delay the Soviet invader.

All fortified provinces should also be equipped with fixed anti-aircraft artillery. This will be helpful in supporting the defense of our ground forces, whose organic AA equipment will be necessarily limited due to other technological priorities.