• We have updated our Community Code of Conduct. Please read through the new rules for the forum that are an integral part of Paradox Interactive’s User Agreement.

HoI4 Dev Diary - AI Plans

Hello, and welcome back to the very last feature DD before we release Man the Guns on February 28th. Today we will be showing you a few more details of the AI strategy plans you can set in the Custom Game Rules Menu.

In Waking the Tiger, we created the backend support to give the AI multiple paths it can go down, and in the free 1.6 'Ironclad' update releasing together with Man the Guns, we have expanded this feature by combining it with the Custom game Rules menu, which now allows you to pick which path a country should go down.

Every country with a unique focus tree now has at least two AI strategy plans, depending on the number of branches in the focus tree. You can either pick which plan the AI should follow specifically, let the AI pick a plan at random, or tell the AI to obey the other game settings.

Screenshot_17.jpg


The setting for an AI overrides all other game settings, so if you check historical focuses but tell the German AI to restore the Kaiser, it will pick Oppose Hitler anyway.

Since this would allow you to set up scenarios that would make some achievements fairly trivial, these settings largely disable achievements.

It should also be noted that this allows you to create combinations that lead to situations we didn’t anticipate when we made some focus trees (“Should Democratic Germany really ally with Communist Hungary to contain Fascist France? What if Britain is Communist?”) or event chains. Given the often mutually-exclusive nature of focus trees and the sheer number of possible combinations, that can lead to situations where one AI can no longer continue its path or things behave in an unexpected way.

Today, we are going to go through a little AAR based on one of the little scenarios people around the office have been using: “How many monarchies can I have at the same time?”

So Germany will bring back the Kaiser, Hungary will restore Austria-Hungary, Romania will aim to achieve Balkan Dominance, Japan will restore the Emperor, Manchukuo will attempt to gain independence, Britain will give support to the King’s Party (Charles II of Romania approves, but is quietly told that is not what that means) and finally the Netherlands will try to support the only man in the Dutch government - Queen Wilhelmina. France is kept as default (so it will react to Imperial Germany), the US and Mexico are set to be random. We will observe from the country of Uruguay.

Screenshot_18.jpg


Germany kicks off the Monarchist revival with their civil war. As a little sidenote: we have reworked the positioning of the armies at the start of the German Civil War a little to give a more coherent front line. Meanwhile, the Hungarian AI has decided to strengthen the Monarchists, Britain is still building up its industry and Japan is supporting the Kodoha Faction.

Screenshot_19.jpg


While the German Civil War rages, Britain continues to build up and Hungary is rushing down the branch to restore the monarchy. With Romania set to expand later, that is probably the right choice.

Hitler’s Summer Offensive has the Royalists in Germany on the backfoot for most of 1936 before they manage to contain it. At the same time, Otto von Habsburg has assumed the Hungarian Crown. Incensed by Edward’s insistence to marry Wallis Simpson, the British government has resigned. Manchukuo is still biding its time, building up its industry.

Screenshot_20.jpg


By October 1936, the Royalist counter-offensive is in full swing and has largely succeeded in restoring the original frontline. Meanwhile, Otto’s first act as King of Hungary is to start an ambitious program of industrial expansion - believing, no doubt, that providing jobs to the Hungarian workers will help build support for his rule.

Surprising many observers, Alf Landon has defeated Roosevelt in the presidential elections and wastes little time in returning the dollar to the gold standard in a bid to undo the damage wrought by the irresponsible policies of his predecessor.

As 1936 turns into 1937, the Royalists in Germany have pushed deep into fascist territory in the South and the far North. The British Empire has broken into pieces as the Dominions have shed the last ties to their former mother country, causing one British Civil Servant to exclaim “Not since Helen of Troy has such misfortune been brought over a great nation by a single woman!” (Churchill, reportedly, remarked “If only she had been single.”)

Screenshot_22.jpg


About a year after the insurrection started, the writing is on the wall for Hitler. A last-ditch offensive in Mecklenburg has failed with only moderate territorial gains. As the King’s Party solidifies support for the monarchy in Britain, Otto von Habsburg has begun to take the next step on his way to restore the old lands of his dynasty: Turning Hungary into Austria-Hungary by adding Austria through a referendum.

Screenshot_24.jpg


By early April 1937, the fighting has reached Berlin. Hitler orders all available resources to be thrown in a counterattack under General Steiner, but is informed by his Generals that this attack did not take place. He takes the news with his usual stoicism. The city falls a few days later, and the fascist government does not survive the end of the month.

In Britain, Edward has taken the crown and is evidently preparing a great coronation ceremony. Against all expectations, the people of Austria vote to return to the rule of a Habsburg King.

Screenshot_26.jpg


The rather hasty departure of India from the British Empire brings the question of the Muslim population in the country to the forefront: worried about a lack of representation, Muslims in Pakistan and Bangladesh have taken up arms to defend their freedom. Observers expect a long and bloody struggle.

Screenshot_29.jpg


By this point, the Civil War in Spain is considered little more than a sidenote, as Alf Landon shocks the world with a strong commitment to a policy he calls simply “America First”.

Screenshot_31.jpg


The news of a minor incident in the Zeppelin Hindenburg is missed by most major newspapers, although German Princess Victoria Louise has reportedly shown a great interest in it.

Meanwhile in Asia, Generalissimo Chiang Kai-Shek is preparing a new offensive to finally bring the warlords on the periphery under his control. Emperor Puyi has successfully re-negotiated the relationship to Japan, giving him much more control over internal matters.

As the press in Europe prepares to attend the official ceremony in which King Otto of Hungary is crowned Kaiser of Austria-Hungary and the German Military Government declares its commitment to restoring the monarchy, the central government in China has declared the “Southern Pacification Campaign” against the obstinate Guangxi Clique and the governor of Yunnan.

Screenshot_32.jpg

The Spanish Civil War ends in a Republican victory. In his first speech as Emperor of Austria, Otto announces that his government will seek to deepen ties with the former provinces of Bohemia and Slovakia, while also extending his warmest congratulations to the German government for defeating “the poisonous snake of fascism” in their country, promising to do what he can to help them in restoring the old order.

Seeing the way the wind is blowing (especially since their traditional ally, France, seems to face a resurgence of communism and may not be available to protect them for much longer), the Czechoslovakian government decides to accept Otto as King of Bohemia and be absorbed again into the resurgent Austria-Hungary. Not to be outdone by his now much larger neighbour, Charles II of Romania takes steps to institute a Royal Dictatorship.

Screenshot_34.jpg


In India, Pakistan has shocked observers by reversing initial Indian gains and taking the offensive, with fighting now in the outskirts of Delhi. In Manchukuo, Emperor Puyi has purged the General Affairs Council of everyone he suspects of divided loyalties. In neighbouring China, the war in the southern part of the country has ground to a stalemate while Chiang Kai-Shek turns towards what many suspect was his true objective all along: eliminating the small base of the Communist party.

On the 4th of August, 1938, some 20 years after he was forced to abandon his throne, Kaiser Wilhelm II returns to Germany. The world, he remarks, seems to have finally understood why it needs monarchs. Meanwhile, Austria-Hungary, although still technically under the provisions of the Treaty of Trianon, has begun a barely-concealed rearmament program.

Screenshot_35.jpg



The fortunes of war in India have turned once again, as India has launched a major offensive along the entire front and has pushed back Pakistani forces all along the line.

With the demise of the Hitler government in Germany, fascist Italy is looking increasingly alone on the world stage. This is cemented by diplomatic maneuvering at the highest level, with an exchange of personal letters between Kaiser Wilhelm II and his distant cousin Edward VIII. It appears that both see eye to eye with regards to Italy, and some diplomats even speculate that this is but the first step towards a full-scale alliance between the previous enemies. With France looking increasingly likely to fall to communism, Germany is eager to secure its back while it deals with the communist threat on the continent.

Screenshot_37.jpg


In the final days of 1938, Indian forces finally crush the last bits of Pakistani resistance and end the long and bitter struggle.

At the start of 1939, the political landscape of Europe has changed quite dramatically. Two monarchs regained the thrones they had lost in 1918, and one has brought back the crown to a level of power not seen in centuries. In the Far East, Emperor Puyi is biding his time, as he knows that Japan must eventually strike against the Soviet Union - and when it does, his moment has come. The King of Romania has cemented his power, and although any attempt to strongarm Hungary is now impossible, he may yet assert his position on the Balkans.


Screenshot_38.jpg


Meanwhile, in the US, conservative and reactionary elements have made a comeback, leading to a decisive shift to the right of US politics. With the post-war order in Europe collapsing and old thrones being restored, the US starts to prepare for an intervention in Europe, should it come to that.


That’s all for today. Next week we will have a MASSIVE RECAP episode, and then it’s time for the 1.6 Patchlog and Man the Guns release the week after.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
That's what I talk about - it is just understandable for you analogy. Just as you find idea of American monarchy completely impossible, so I see the restoration of monarchy in Russia of 1930-s.


I speak about how situation is seen from the perspective of young post-Revolutionary generation in Soviet Union of 1930-s. For them "life is getting better under the wise guidance of Stalin" is an axiom. Were bolsheviks right or not is matter of other discussion.

And really, who in Soviet Union of 1936 gives a f*ck about what would have Whites preferred? They are just sore losers, sitting in emigration and dreaming about "Russia, they have lost". They have zero popular support inside the country.
Maybe the people who are suffering which was quite a lot of the population of the U.S.S.R.
 
To be honest if there is another civil war in Russia I could even see a theocratic regime led by some holy woman be an option, because Civil wars create the weirdest situations.
 
To be honest if there is another civil war in Russia I could even see a theocratic regime led by some holy woman be an option, because Civil wars create the weirdest situations.
Don't give them even more weird ideas!
but seriously, what would this path do? make a crusade against other christians and pope? 0_o
 
Maybe the people who are suffering which was quite a lot of the population of the U.S.S.R.
"A lot" is not a number to work with.

Majority of population supported regime and communist ideology, which was proven by WW2. Otherwise, if Soviet Union was so unstable and regime - vulnerable to such minor threats as White emigration, for it everything would have ended in 1941, autumn at best.
 
Can we finally get an expansion for the home of Paradox, Sweden?
Can this be extended to the rest of Scandinavia? (Finnish, Danish, and Norwegian focuses)
Can we get a Monarchist path for France and the Soviets as well?
I think that's a good direction for the next DLC, maybe with some AI improvements as well.
Another good idea is a singular focus for Spain that branches off depending who you pick in the Civil War, as well as having options for neutrality and/or intervention.
 
i don t get why expert ai get s so much credit

for my last pre mtg playthrough i chose an operation overhaul usa, and i conquered japan faster than in vanilla
i bombed that country to zero, simply because my 2k bomber didn t see a japanese figter over mainland japan, while the ai tried to secure air superiority over the neighbouring sea zones filled with my submarines
the japanese ai's navy was decimated simply because it chose to build convoys with 30 dockyards, and my 16 carriers found the game one-sided after that
now i know that this may be operation-overhauls fault, although i don t know what that mod tinkers with the ai, and elite ai claims to not work around some of this stuff, still the modded japanese ai was a lot easier target, due to not defending against bombing attacks and not building navy, both of which i have seen in the vanilla game from it
ofc, if i am wrong enlighten me, but elite ai still feels like just in some ways (especially ground) a bit more challenging ai, not some serious upgrade over the fight they can bring
 
Good option for non-historical alt-history could be similar regime as in CK2 last DLC, where we generate a world with some certain events set as happened/not happened.

In HOI4 it could work as number of settings, set for every major and some general ones, affecting minors (like outcome of WW1, Chinese civil war and etc.). Changing options for major could alter some parts of focus tree (where it made sense).

So here is your monarchy everywhere, dead people alive and similar stuff.
 
Don't give them even more weird ideas!
but seriously, what would this path do? make a crusade against other christians and pope? 0_o
:D :D yes let's give them really crazy ideas.
 
Quick question: have there been any streams where we see the US Focus Tree in any more detail?
 
Quick question: have there been any streams where we see the US Focus Tree in any more detail?
yes, although the showed only ze althistory fascist path
however the rather obvious silence from ytbers and their hints(from last stream) point towards the fact that you will see some walkthroughs on youtube soon, very soon so you will able to see it there
 
i don t get why expert ai get s so much credit

for my last pre mtg playthrough i chose an operation overhaul usa, and i conquered japan faster than in vanilla
i bombed that country to zero, simply because my 2k bomber didn t see a japanese figter over mainland japan, while the ai tried to secure air superiority over the neighbouring sea zones filled with my submarines
the japanese ai's navy was decimated simply because it chose to build convoys with 30 dockyards, and my 16 carriers found the game one-sided after that
now i know that this may be operation-overhauls fault, although i don t know what that mod tinkers with the ai, and elite ai claims to not work around some of this stuff, still the modded japanese ai was a lot easier target, due to not defending against bombing attacks and not building navy, both of which i have seen in the vanilla game from it
ofc, if i am wrong enlighten me, but elite ai still feels like just in some ways (especially ground) a bit more challenging ai, not some serious upgrade over the fight they can bring

All of the issues you list are worse in vanilla than with expert AI. It can't fix everything. At least with Expert AI they research a naval doctrine, in vanilla they do not. In my experience the naval AI with Expert AI is significantly better than vanilla. (Instead of being 0/10, maybe 2/10)
 
Cheers for the DD Archangel :D. I really like the way that we've got selective control of what might happen in our games - I'll probably still play most of my games with no rules (although that might change once they release - it's easy to theorycraft but no battle plan survives contact with release code :)) but I can imagine I'll really enjoy playing games, say, as the UK where the US was hardwired to go all Silver Legion, or as New Zealand where Eddie won't step down :).

Also, toughest DD for a ship pic in ages - guess I'll have to get a bit more used to this again :p Here's my best shot - a pic of Kaiser Wilhelm II on the (pre-dreadnought, but you'd have to think an Imperial Germany would be naming another ship after him :)) SMS Kaiser Wilhelm II :cool:

View attachment 450631

Also seen a bunch of discussion about AI in the thread. In a game as complex as HoI4, with oodles and oodles (thousands, easily) of moving parts, there will always be room for improvement. If 1000 people were tasked with working on HoI4's AI, beyond the challenges of coordinating that (which would be a tough task in itself) they'd have plenty to keep them going. On balance, though, I find HoI4's AI, as AI (ie, the decision making of computer players, as opposed to buffs/debuffs to make things harder or easier) to be well above average in the strategy genre (and I have no idea how one would compare it to an RPG or a racer, for example :eek:). I'll always encourage the devs to do more work on the AI, as I think with all games, and strategy games in particular, the game itself is playing the computer (even in an MP game, there's always some AI going on), and so the tools of gameplay are to a degree only as good as the AI that uses them - but I've had a lot of fun playing HoI4 to date, and I'm really looking forward to playing MtG on the 28th :D.
Awesome Photo Axe, Always love seeing Willy and his navy
 
All of the issues you list are worse in vanilla than with expert AI. It can't fix everything. At least with Expert AI they research a naval doctrine, in vanilla they do not. In my experience the naval AI with Expert AI is significantly better than vanilla. (Instead of being 0/10, maybe 2/10)
yes, what i am talking about is that i expected the same thing, but got a quicker victory against it than the vanilla, partly due to prioritizing convoys and partly due to not defending against bombers, because in my previous vanilla hoi4 usa plays, these weren t such a big issue
 
Hello, and welcome back to the very last feature DD before we release Man the Guns on February 28th. Today we will be showing you a few more details of the AI strategy plans you can set in the Custom Game Rules Menu.

In Waking the Tiger, we created the backend support to give the AI multiple paths it can go down, and in the free 1.6 'Ironclad' update releasing together with Man the Guns, we have expanded this feature by combining it with the Custom game Rules menu, which now allows you to pick which path a country should go down.

Every country with a unique focus tree now has at least two AI strategy plans, depending on the number of branches in the focus tree. You can either pick which plan the AI should follow specifically, let the AI pick a plan at random, or tell the AI to obey the other game settings.

View attachment 450357

The setting for an AI overrides all other game settings, so if you check historical focuses but tell the German AI to restore the Kaiser, it will pick Oppose Hitler anyway.

Since this would allow you to set up scenarios that would make some achievements fairly trivial, these settings largely disable achievements.

It should also be noted that this allows you to create combinations that lead to situations we didn’t anticipate when we made some focus trees (“Should Democratic Germany really ally with Communist Hungary to contain Fascist France? What if Britain is Communist?”) or event chains. Given the often mutually-exclusive nature of focus trees and the sheer number of possible combinations, that can lead to situations where one AI can no longer continue its path or things behave in an unexpected way.

Today, we are going to go through a little AAR based on one of the little scenarios people around the office have been using: “How many monarchies can I have at the same time?”

So Germany will bring back the Kaiser, Hungary will restore Austria-Hungary, Romania will aim to achieve Balkan Dominance, Japan will restore the Emperor, Manchukuo will attempt to gain independence, Britain will give support to the King’s Party (Charles II of Romania approves, but is quietly told that is not what that means) and finally the Netherlands will try to support the only man in the Dutch government - Queen Wilhelmina. France is kept as default (so it will react to Imperial Germany), the US and Mexico are set to be random. We will observe from the country of Uruguay.

View attachment 450356

Germany kicks off the Monarchist revival with their civil war. As a little sidenote: we have reworked the positioning of the armies at the start of the German Civil War a little to give a more coherent front line. Meanwhile, the Hungarian AI has decided to strengthen the Monarchists, Britain is still building up its industry and Japan is supporting the Kodoha Faction.

View attachment 450355

While the German Civil War rages, Britain continues to build up and Hungary is rushing down the branch to restore the monarchy. With Romania set to expand later, that is probably the right choice.

Hitler’s Summer Offensive has the Royalists in Germany on the backfoot for most of 1936 before they manage to contain it. At the same time, Otto von Habsburg has assumed the Hungarian Crown. Incensed by Edward’s insistence to marry Wallis Simpson, the British government has resigned. Manchukuo is still biding its time, building up its industry.

View attachment 450353

By October 1936, the Royalist counter-offensive is in full swing and has largely succeeded in restoring the original frontline. Meanwhile, Otto’s first act as King of Hungary is to start an ambitious program of industrial expansion - believing, no doubt, that providing jobs to the Hungarian workers will help build support for his rule.

Surprising many observers, Alf Landon has defeated Roosevelt in the presidential elections and wastes little time in returning the dollar to the gold standard in a bid to undo the damage wrought by the irresponsible policies of his predecessor.

As 1936 turns into 1937, the Royalists in Germany have pushed deep into fascist territory in the South and the far North. The British Empire has broken into pieces as the Dominions have shed the last ties to their former mother country, causing one British Civil Servant to exclaim “Not since Helen of Troy has such misfortune been brought over a great nation by a single woman!” (Churchill, reportedly, remarked “If only she had been single.”)

View attachment 450352

About a year after the insurrection started, the writing is on the wall for Hitler. A last-ditch offensive in Mecklenburg has failed with only moderate territorial gains. As the King’s Party solidifies support for the monarchy in Britain, Otto von Habsburg has begun to take the next step on his way to restore the old lands of his dynasty: Turning Hungary into Austria-Hungary by adding Austria through a referendum.

View attachment 450351

By early April 1937, the fighting has reached Berlin. Hitler orders all available resources to be thrown in a counterattack under General Steiner, but is informed by his Generals that this attack did not take place. He takes the news with his usual stoicism. The city falls a few days later, and the fascist government does not survive the end of the month.

In Britain, Edward has taken the crown and is evidently preparing a great coronation ceremony. Against all expectations, the people of Austria vote to return to the rule of a Habsburg King.

View attachment 450349

The rather hasty departure of India from the British Empire brings the question of the Muslim population in the country to the forefront: worried about a lack of representation, Muslims in Pakistan and Bangladesh have taken up arms to defend their freedom. Observers expect a long and bloody struggle.

View attachment 450347

By this point, the Civil War in Spain is considered little more than a sidenote, as Alf Landon shocks the world with a strong commitment to a policy he calls simply “America First”.

View attachment 450346

The news of a minor incident in the Zeppelin Hindenburg is missed by most major newspapers, although German Princess Victoria Louise has reportedly shown a great interest in it.

Meanwhile in Asia, Generalissimo Chiang Kai-Shek is preparing a new offensive to finally bring the warlords on the periphery under his control. Emperor Puyi has successfully re-negotiated the relationship to Japan, giving him much more control over internal matters.

As the press in Europe prepares to attend the official ceremony in which King Otto of Hungary is crowned Kaiser of Austria-Hungary and the German Military Government declares its commitment to restoring the monarchy, the central government in China has declared the “Southern Pacification Campaign” against the obstinate Guangxi Clique and the governor of Yunnan.

View attachment 450345
The Spanish Civil War ends in a Republican victory. In his first speech as Emperor of Austria, Otto announces that his government will seek to deepen ties with the former provinces of Bohemia and Slovakia, while also extending his warmest congratulations to the German government for defeating “the poisonous snake of fascism” in their country, promising to do what he can to help them in restoring the old order.

Seeing the way the wind is blowing (especially since their traditional ally, France, seems to face a resurgence of communism and may not be available to protect them for much longer), the Czechoslovakian government decides to accept Otto as King of Bohemia and be absorbed again into the resurgent Austria-Hungary. Not to be outdone by his now much larger neighbour, Charles II of Romania takes steps to institute a Royal Dictatorship.

View attachment 450343

In India, Pakistan has shocked observers by reversing initial Indian gains and taking the offensive, with fighting now in the outskirts of Delhi. In Manchukuo, Emperor Puyi has purged the General Affairs Council of everyone he suspects of divided loyalties. In neighbouring China, the war in the southern part of the country has ground to a stalemate while Chiang Kai-Shek turns towards what many suspect was his true objective all along: eliminating the small base of the Communist party.

On the 4th of August, 1938, some 20 years after he was forced to abandon his throne, Kaiser Wilhelm II returns to Germany. The world, he remarks, seems to have finally understood why it needs monarchs. Meanwhile, Austria-Hungary, although still technically under the provisions of the Treaty of Trianon, has begun a barely-concealed rearmament program.

View attachment 450342


The fortunes of war in India have turned once again, as India has launched a major offensive along the entire front and has pushed back Pakistani forces all along the line.

With the demise of the Hitler government in Germany, fascist Italy is looking increasingly alone on the world stage. This is cemented by diplomatic maneuvering at the highest level, with an exchange of personal letters between Kaiser Wilhelm II and his distant cousin Edward VIII. It appears that both see eye to eye with regards to Italy, and some diplomats even speculate that this is but the first step towards a full-scale alliance between the previous enemies. With France looking increasingly likely to fall to communism, Germany is eager to secure its back while it deals with the communist threat on the continent.

View attachment 450341

In the final days of 1938, Indian forces finally crush the last bits of Pakistani resistance and end the long and bitter struggle.

At the start of 1939, the political landscape of Europe has changed quite dramatically. Two monarchs regained the thrones they had lost in 1918, and one has brought back the crown to a level of power not seen in centuries. In the Far East, Emperor Puyi is biding his time, as he knows that Japan must eventually strike against the Soviet Union - and when it does, his moment has come. The King of Romania has cemented his power, and although any attempt to strongarm Hungary is now impossible, he may yet assert his position on the Balkans.


View attachment 450340

Meanwhile, in the US, conservative and reactionary elements have made a comeback, leading to a decisive shift to the right of US politics. With the post-war order in Europe collapsing and old thrones being restored, the US starts to prepare for an intervention in Europe, should it come to that.


That’s all for today. Next week we will have a MASSIVE RECAP episode, and then it’s time for the 1.6 Patchlog and Man the Guns release the week after.
Very interesting, I cant wait for the release
 
I'm afraid this praise is misdirected :p I am probably the person who worked least on the division namelists. Though I am glad to hear you enjoyed them a lot, and will ensure the praise lands with the appropriate people :)

Thank you to all the team, please do pass on the praise! It just improved immersion so much.

Because that is the best environment to recognize the weaknesses of their system and deal with it from their on. Which can include AI behavior and general system

Honestly Where else are going to acquire that high level ingame behavior then from high skills players? Clearly what we have now is what paradox considers optimal play when in reality it isn’t.

You don’t train your baseball team to mirror the worst player imaginable. You train them to emulate the behaviors of the best players around. It’s not gonna apply for everything but the main elements like industry, trade, production and division design can go along way in its ability to better enhance your experience.

Those are things that I want addressed and some tweaks in the behavior parameters are what is missing here. The competitive multiplayer crowd is an option to fill in that behavior is it the right option? Who knows but I am willing to throw my hat at their ability to at least spit a few ideas to a dev in and reason as to what is a good goal marker the AI could/should reach at in 1940 as Germany.

I've yet to see anyone argue that the AI player algorithms are perfect. You have helpfully provided several examples of poor algorithms and I'd agree with all of them (and can think of more bad examples). I would also like to see PDX investing even more in improving these algorithms and/or making them moddable, and I am disappointed/puzzled by their apparent lack of enthusiasm for the subject.

But your thousands of words in this thread haven't convinced me that studying the 'competitive historical multiplayer' meta is the only, or even the best, way to fix this. Your baseball team analogy helps us to understand your reasoning. But it misses the crucial point: we're not training a human baseball team, we're training a baseball AI. If I was developing a baseball player robot, I don't think I'd need to hire the World Series winners in order to improve it. Getting a robot to reliably aim the ball at a particular point, run between bases without crashing into players, catch a ball moving quickly, etc., would all be enormous challenges in themselves. Trying to emulate the particular running style of an élite player would be a complete waste of resources in a context where bipedalism is a major achievement. In fact, I'm not even sure whether bipedalism is the optimal solution for a baseball-playing robot anyway.

We have been told many times that writing AI algorithms for a game as complex as HoI4 is hard. There's not going to be any easy fix. It needs the application of a great deal of brainpower & time. Rather than aiming to beat the 'best' players, wouldn't it be better to prioritize fixing the bugs in Bitmode's very helpful list?

Paradox could add different degrees of AI behavior for different skill levels. But knowing most game companies they dont want to do that to avoid the hassle. So they opt for the cheap work around of allowing the AI to cheat or get dumber which to me is flawed.

Making one workable set of algorithms is hard enough; multiplying the difficulty seems unwise.

"A lot" is not a number to work with.

Majority of population supported regime and communist ideology, which was proven by WW2. Otherwise, if Soviet Union was so unstable and regime - vulnerable to such minor threats as White emigration, for it everything would have ended in 1941, autumn at best.

The heroic sacrifices of Soviet citizens in WW2, which were so important to an early Allied victory, only proved that the majority of the Soviet population supported the regime's efforts to save them from slavery to genocidal foreigners. That could be motivated by Communism, nationalism, or simple survival. The terrible choice between Mr Stalin & Mr Hitler is quite different from the choice between Mr Stalin & various alt-history alternatives. So it's plausible for the forthcoming Soviet rework to include non-Communist options.

There were no reliable opinion polls or focus groups in the 1930s USSR, so it's very hard to assess the real level of support for the régime and alternatives to it. I once read an interesting paper on elections in that era that showed that in cases where more than one candidate was permitted (what Americans would call 'primaries' between CPSU and e.g. trade union candidates), the incumbent CPSU candidates didn't always win. To lose an election with the Stalinist machine behind you, you have to be staggeringly incompetent/unpopular.

And there are recent examples of stunningly swift changes in the political leadership of the region. How many Russians had heard of Mr Lenin in 1916 or Mr Putin in 1998? (EDIT: And let's not forget Simeon Saxe-Coburg-Gotha). You have put forward some very helpful points about why, for example, Mr Kerensky was not a viable candidate in the 1930s. But the devs should be wary of swallowing Soviet propaganda about the permanence of their regime when they rework the USSR focus tree.

All of you calling or citing MacArthur for King: research the following on Google. MacArthur, Duty, Honor, Country. When you have finished listening to his speech, ask yourself, does this man really want to be a King? MacArthur was a consummate Flag Officer of the Untied States who took his oath to the Constitution seriously. Maybe those who aren't from the US do not realize the oath of a career soldier in the US is to the Constitution, not a person but to an ideal. Therefore a monarchy path in the US is ludicrous and totally unrealistic.

When I finished reading his speech, I had fresh confirmation that General MacArthur was a demagogue with a political agenda, not the politically impartial military officer that he claimed to be. He was fired for undermining the elected political leadership of his country. He's the man the 'Media Personality' trait was made for.

Again, we should be wary of swallowing US propaganda about their state's resistance to monarchy. The US constitution puts all executive power in the hands of a single man (it has always been a man) and being a family member of a previous office-holder has been a major advantage in gaining that power recently. They may not use the trappings of medieval Christendom, but neither does the DPRK, which is functionally (though not rhetorically) a monarchy. Giving General MacArthur a sceptre and crown is implausible, but it's all too easy to imagine him manipulating the electoral college in order to ensure that he retained permanently the powers that he had once possessed over Japan. Plenty plausible enough for a monarchical US mod.

I'm fairly certain that a Nationalist Government with Socialist economic policies is a National Socialist Government because that was what A.H.'s government did basically.

Would you care to repeat that outside the House of Commons in the World History forum, sir? :mad:
 
Last edited: