• We have updated our Community Code of Conduct. Please read through the new rules for the forum that are an integral part of Paradox Interactive’s User Agreement.

Tinto Talks #19 - 3rd of July 2024

Hello Everyone and Welcome to another Tinto Talks, the Happy Wednesday when we talk about the most secret game with the code name “Project Caesar”

This week we’ll talk about the ages and institutions, concepts that were first introduced in a patch to EU4. They were a convenient mechanic to make different eras feel different, but soon became too gamified with development ruining the institution game.

Every age introduces several new “REDACTED”, adds several possible new government reforms you can pick from, impacts the price stability of goods, and also has some direct impacts on every country. In every age, the amount of gold you pay for your raised levies will increase, and the size of the army you are expected to have increases. Each age is global in the world, but its true impact is gradual. There is no special mana you gain through achieving goals that you can use to stack modifiers with.

ages.png

Ages of Traditions have passed, and we have just entered the Age of Renaissance here..

Each age also has three institutions that will spawn, each will unlock “REDACTED” and spread across the world.

We have designed the institution spawns to be more rigid for the first ages, and be more flexible in later ages, to guide the game in a certain direction. For those of you who dislike the dynamic spawning of institutions, you can put it in “historical” mode, and it will spawn in the same location every time.

rule.png

There are only two options for this rule at the moment.

The spread takes time, as it can only spread through adjacent locations or across a single sealane, unless you have trade routes from a market center that has embraced it. The speed it spreads is also impacted by the literacy of the population. If you have embraced an institution, then it will spread in proportion to your control in your owned locations.

When an institution has spread to more than 10% of the population in your country, you can embrace it, meaning you will get access to the “REDACTED” it will give you.

As the technology system in Project Caesar is different than the one in EU4, missing an institution for a while is NOT a complete disaster, but more on that next week.

In later ages you can also start assigning a member of your cabinet to promote institutions in a province, which will then progress any institution you are aware of in the locations of that province. Promoting is heavily based on the burghers and the literacy of a location.

There are 6 ages in the game, and in 1337 we start in the Age of Traditions, and each age from there on lasts about a century.


age_1_traditions.jpg

It was the definitely the best of times...

Age of Traditions
Different societies have been established throughout the world for hundreds and thousands of years, and their foundations can be framed in traditions such as Legalism, Meritocracy, or Feudalism.

Legalism
We gave this institution the spawn point of Rome, even though there are plenty of places that could compete for it. Most of the Old World has this institution spread and embraced at the start of the game.

The theories behind Legalism have been integrating into Chinese societal structures for hundreds of years. The concept that pure idealism and domestic stability leads to a rich, prosperous state and a powerful army is deeply rooted in the forums of thought in the Eastern Asian domains. However, as merchants and migrants brought forth the exchange of ideas, the concept of Legalism made its way across the vast expanses of the Muslim world. There, it adopted the stance of a symbiotic relationship between heathens and believers in Islamic states. Legalism in Europe signified the rite of passage, from the dying grasps of the great Roman Empire to its remnant legal roots, many of which would later serve as the basis for new jurisprudence across the old continent.

Meritocracy
This has the birthplace in Beijing and at the start of the game, it has only spread through East Asia.

Many individuals of great prestige and in positions of power often chose to appoint those closest to them in influential spots. The advent of Meritocracy as an institution and a thought movement was largely popular in the courts of Imperial China. There, Confucius himself supported the notion that those who govern should do so on the basis of merit, not of inherited status. This led to the replacement of the Chinese nobility of blood ties to one based solely on meritocratic abilities. This institution's development would ripple across and beyond the borders of Asia and would eventually reach the royal courts of even European monarchs whose Nobles had a firm grasp on the mechanisms of power and authority.

Feudalism
This has its birthplace in Aachen, the capital of the Roman Empire under Charlemagne. It has spread in most of the Old World as well.

Over time, most societies develop a need for a common structure with stronger and more permanent institutions of government. After the fall of the Roman Empire, this need came to be filled by a number of institutions and customs that taken together are often considered to be part of the European Feudal system. For similar reasons, permanent government and societal systems have formed all over the world, some of which have roots that go far further back than Feudalism itself.


age_2_renaissance.jpg

Have we show this image before?

Age of Renaissance
A new era of knowledge, arts, and progress is emerging due to growing interactions and institutions in the medieval societies affected by Pax Mongolica, the Islamic Golden Age, and the European Renaissance.

Renaissance
This institution will spawn soon after the age starts in a Northern Italian City with a University. The historical location is Florence.

Starting now in the 14th century, the wealthy and powerful in the Italian City states have been patronizing artists and scholars willing to explore the old Roman and Greek societies of their forefathers. As a cultural movement the Renaissance already encompasses most of the region and has had a profound impact on literature, art, philosophy, and music. Humanist scholars are also analyzing the society in which they live, comparing it to the ideals of the Classical philosophers. Renaissance Humanism has grown into a more mature movement, ready to permeate all aspects of society. A new ideal for rulers as well as those who are ruled is spreading as quickly as the early Printers can distribute copies of these new ideas. A true Renaissance Humanist is an expert on everything from politics and philosophy to art, textual analysis, music, and architecture. The Renaissance is now ready to reshape the world to better fit its classical ideals.

Banking
This can spawn in any town or city with more than 1000 burghers in Europe, North Africa or the Middle East, where the owner has a strong “Capital Economy” Societal Value. The historical location is Genoa.

Money lending has existed since metal-based coins appeared in Antiquity. However, it depended on some individuals and their family groupings or on the Ancient States. A shift occurred in the Middle Ages, encouraged by the renewed growth of long-range commercial activities on the Eurasian continent and its peripheries. Specialized moneylenders began to organize when Jewish communities started operating between the Christian and Islamic worlds. However, the boom of credit demand that followed the Crusades in the 12th century encouraged merchants in the Italian city-states to create larger structures for money lending, effectively founding the first Banking institutions, such as the Peruzzi and Bardi houses. More instruments were developed, like bills of exchange and debt bonds, and Banking dynasties such as the Medici, Fugger or Welser soon became as powerful as States.

Professional Armies
This can spawn in any location in Europe, which has some manpower produced, where the owner has a “Quality” Societal Value. The historical location is Paris.

Armies have existed since war was invented, many thousands of years ago. However, their form has changed over the centuries and different types of recruitment and organization have developed in different cultures and periods. In the Late Middle Ages, armies in a wide range of societies relied on levies based on the structures of feudal society, with knights and footmen forming a core that was levied seasonally. In some regions, however, states were powerful enough to finance standing armies, with professional soldiers who would be available for duty throughout the year. This system was also developed in Europe after the outbreak of the Hundred Year's War, being one of the main changes that promoted a Military Revolution in the Early Modern Age. Increasing the size and quality of Professional Armies, while finding new sources of revenue to finance them, soon became one of the main challenges for rulers around the world.

age_3_discovery.jpg

This looks like a nice place to add to the Spanish Empire!

Age of Discovery
At the dawn of the Early Modern era new continents are being mapped while feudal society is slowly giving way to centralized states. For an enterprising state this age can see the foundation of a worldwide empire.

New World
This will spawn in any port in Western Europe or North Africa, with more than 2,000 burghers, and where the owner has discovered the Azores and the West African Coastline. The historical location is Sevilla.

The discovery of the New World has heralded a new era not only for the colonizers and the colonized, but it has also led to the spread of materials and techniques as well as a realization of the vastness of the globe. As animals, crop types, silver and diseases spread across the Atlantic, the first steps have been taken towards a truly global economy. With foreign lands and people being mapped and documented, ideas as well as religious and philosophical debate are increasingly being colored by what we have found in overseas societies. Great minds feel the need to question what was once truth, and from Valladolid to Fatehpur Sikri, the nature of the world is now up for debate.

Printing Press
This can spawn in any location with more than 2,000 burghers, where the owner produces more than 5 paper and has an “Outward” Societal Value. The historical location is Mainz.

The ability to mass-produce the written word would revolutionize the spread of information and in many ways early modern society as a whole. Pioneered by Renaissance men such as Venetian Printer Aldus Manutius, the new art helped fuel the Renaissance by making the translated classics more widely available. Later the Reformation benefitted greatly from the ability to spread critical publications and translations of the Holy Scriptures. Now that Printing has matured as a technique and spread throughout Europe, hundreds of thousands of copies of everything from Religious and Political pamphlets to scientific treatises and instructions on how to behave are circulating the continent. With print shops growing evermore commonplace, rulers have found it hard to contain the new technique as the comparatively easy means of production means censorship can be sidestepped by moving business across a border or even just changing the name on a title page.

Pike & Shot
This spawns in a location, which has some manpower produced, where the owner has Professional Armies, more than 20 Army Tradition and a “Land” Societal Values, and have the gunpowder technology. The historical location is Innsbruck.

A new type of warfare began to develop at the end of the 15th Century, in the midst of the Italian Wars. The generalization of pikemen in the Late Middle Ages as an alternative to men-at-arms who could successfully face heavy cavalry charges was accompanied by the development of portable firearms, mainly matchlock arquebuses and muskets. The soldiers now adopt a new formation, in which the pikemen form a square, while the arquebusiers fan out to the sides and front, and seek cover behind or inside the square in case the formation enters close combat. This new type of formation, called Pike & Shot, was favored by German Landsknechts and Spanish Tercios, and was soon adopted by other armies, reigning supreme on European battlefields for nearly two centuries, until superseded in the early 18th Century by line infantry formations armed with new flintlock muskets mounting bayonets.

age_4_reformation.jpg

The heretic is trying to defend his heresy.

Age of Reformation
From East to West this is the age of religious conviction, debates and mass movements. In Europe, the protestant churches are entrenched while millenarianism takes hold of Iran and religious Syncretism shapes Indian society.

Confessionalism
This spawns in a town or city in Europe, which has a printing press, where the owner is Catholic, and the dominant religion is Catholic, and has a “Spiritualist” societal value. The historical location is Augsburg.

Catholicism has been regarded as a unitary entity for a long time, but the advent of the various Protestant Faiths has put an end to that. With the rise of a myriad of different interpretations of what the Faith should be, Christianity is all but united. But where before any deviance from the Church could be easily labeled as heretic, now the lines creating the differences have become blurrier at least. As such, there has been an increasing interest both for religious and secular authorities alike to clearly define the shapes of their specific confessions, enforcing their particular rules and views on all aspects of faith and life. This allows them a more firm grip on the faith of their population, but also increases the differentiation and thus animosity with all the other confessions.

Global Trade
This spawns in a market center in a city anywhere in the world that has among the most value of goods traded. The historical location is Lisbon.

Goods have been moved across continents since antiquity. But where this was previously limited to a set number of routes and goods such as the manufactured goods of India and China finding their way across the Indian Ocean and along the Silk Road, all trade is now increasingly becoming part of a greater world network. With the discovery of the Americas, sea routes around Africa and the crossing of the Pacific Ocean, local trade networks are being connected into one world-spanning interconnected web. Silver mined in the Andes is now being boxed and taken via Europe all the way to China and India. Iron mined and wrought in Scandinavia is being sold in West Africa by English merchants, and others are making a fortune just distributing cloth and spices within the Southeast Asian trade sphere. Local Indian merchants are investing in future European trade ventures. It may still be early to speak of a truly Global Economy, but surely the first seeds have been sown.

Artillery
This will spawn in any city in the world that has a gunsmith and a metal workshop, and where the owner has an “Offensive” Societal Value. The historical location is Constantinople.

The invention of gunpowder in Song China led to the development of a new device that would employ its firepower in warfare, the artillery. Although it spread throughout Eurasia in the 13th Century, its use as a common weapon system did not happen until the 15th century, as improvements in the cannon length and gunpowder recipe made artillery much more powerful, now posing a threat to stone-built castles and fortifications, the most common in Europe. Soon artillery would be used not only in sieges but also on battlefields, as smaller caliber guns now featured the mobility required to be quickly deployed and used. Its final development as a key warfare system would come in the 18th Century, especially after Napoleon perfected its use at key points during battles.

age_5_absolutism.jpg

L'État, c'est moi.

Age of Absolutism
As governments wrest the absolute power in their countries from other parties, they are now able to devote themselves to the building of Empires. This is the age of the state, of rulers, and their armies.

Manufactories
This will spawn in any location with more than 100 building levels, and at least 20,000 Burghers, and where the owner has a “Capital Economy” Societal Value. The historical location is Derby.

While a number of technical innovations during the course of the 16th and 17th centuries have increased the output of production for some products such as iron or cloth to an extent, the biggest improvement in the field of production has come in the form of new forms of organization. By creating manufactories, often outside the city limits, merchant capitalists can both bypass the ancient guild laws that inhibit mass production, and pioneer ways to increase production through the organization and specialization of labor in one place. The forerunners of the later Industrialization were able to increase output by facilitating access to raw materials and mass organization of labor rather than by expensive new machinery. This is in itself a huge change over the often heavily regulated methods of old, however, and together with later technical advances this new mode of production will come to revolutionize society.

Scientific Revolution
This spawns in a location with a university, and a high average literacy, where the owner has a “Innovative” Societal Value. The historical location is Cambridge.

It is clear that the world is smaller now than ever before. The rise of a global trade and the printing industry led to an increased flow of people and ideas, allowing for a more widespread dissemination of knowledge. This in turn resulted in a more thorough questioning and analysis of the reality of the world. What was once just accepted as fact is now questioned, what was only poorly understood is now observed, and what was only supposed, tested. The recent advancements in areas such as mathematics, physics., or biology are undeniable, but the real revolution is the change in the perception and approach towards science itself and the way of understanding it. Systematic experimentation is the true scientific revolution, and it will surely change completely our conception of the world.

Military Revolution
This can spawn in any capital with a lot of military buildings and that has a population over 50,000. The historical location is Stockholm.

The continuous state of war affecting Europe in the 16th and 17th Centuries leads to a sharp increase in the size of armies, as a necessity born of the growing authority of competing absolutist regimes. The infantry is now armed en masse with flintlock muskets, greatly increasing their firepower and performance in battle by being deployed in the innovative line formation, replacing the old Pike & Shot. Those needs also affect the capabilities of the state administration as it continues to expand to handle the manpower and finances required by this increase in the size of the military. That also is spearheading the development of the supply chains required to feed and sustain armies, through intermediate depots that support the operational armies. The result of these advances would be none other than an upsurge of wars between increasingly militarized countries in the 18th Century.


age_6_revolutions.jpg

Its one way to deal with the nobility I guess?

Age of Revolutions
The questioning of rights, authority and the world itself during the Enlightenment has led to the rejection of the Ancient Regime. As Absolutism gives way to Revolution kingdoms may have to make place for Republics.

Enlightenment
This spawns in a location with a university, and a high average literacy, where the owner has an “Innovative” Societal Value. The historical location is Paris.

The last century has seen Rationalism and Empiricism gaining an ever-increasing popularity among the great minds of the age. In letters, publications and coffee houses, kings, scientists, philosophers, and littérateurs are discussing the merits of tolerance, the scientific method, and the spreading of the ideals of the Enlightenment to all of humanity. From universities or courts of enlightened monarchs, expeditions are being sent to measure, catalog, weigh, and map the world so that we can better understand the laws that govern everything around us. Others discuss the laws that govern society and try to reach an understanding of the Rights of Man. Great projects such as the colossal undertaking of creating a complete encyclopedia of all knowledge or a complete index of all plants, animals, and fungi in the world are being pursued for the greater good of humanity. The Light of Reason has been lit and many will not rest until it has been brought to all corners of the earth.

Industrialization
This will spawn in any location with more than 250 building levels, and at least 20,000 Burghers, and where the owner has a “Capital Economy” Societal Value. The historical location is Blackburn.

The dawn of the 18th century gave rise to many new institutions as man's thirst for growth took hold. Advances in the field of production, and manufacturing as well as the introduction of complicated machinery will change the world as we know it on a global scale. The rise of the Industrial Revolution brings about international and lasting changes not just in commerce and business but in the fabric of society itself. Inventions such as the power loom and steam engines shall push the capabilities of mankind to its highest zenith yet.

Levée en Masse
This can spawn in any capital with a lot of military buildings and that has a population over 200,000, and where the owner has a “Defensive” Societal Value. The historical location is Paris.

Warfare is an ever-evolving concept, innovated and honed generation after generation. The 18th century saw the rise of powerful empires, each with its own ambitions. To satisfy the need for expansion and provide the fuel necessary to fulfill these ambitions, new nationwide conscription laws will be drafted and signed in effect, raising armies of all unmarried young men, the size of which will shape the course of history.

Next week we talk about what replaced the technology and national ideas system for Project Caesar.
 
  • 213Love
  • 160Like
  • 44
  • 16
  • 8
  • 1Haha
Reactions:
Could I propose to give feudalism a different name? It seems too western european coded for an institution that is supposed to exist all over the old world and that represents stronger states institutions. Perhaps something like "Power of the state" (but better sounding).
 
  • 3
  • 2Like
  • 2
  • 1
Reactions:
Fun fact: recently I learned that “L’etat c’est moi” is likely apocryphal. Instead, on his deathbed, Louis XIV is attested to have said

«Je m'en vais, mais l'État demeurera toujours»

Or “I die, but the State remains.”
The more you know!
Watched the Rosencreutz video on pop history or was this from someplace else?
 
  • 7Like
Reactions:
I would add Caravels and Carracks institution to the Age of discovery and move printing press to age of reformation since it makes more relatable to age of reformation rather than age of discovery. And durable ships that were able to cross oceans fits the age of discovery better than printing press I guess.
Yes I am aware we have one excess diplo institution I dont know any suggestion about what to do
 
  • 7
  • 1Like
  • 1Love
  • 1
Reactions:
I would add Caravels and Carracks institution to the Age of discovery and move printing press to age of reformation since it makes more relatable to age of reformation rather than age of discovery. And durable ships that were able to cross oceans fits the age of discovery better than printing press I guess.
Yes I am aware we have one excess diplo institution I dont know any suggestion about what to do
Priting press started being used immediately, showing its effected delayed by half a century doesn't make sense.
Europe by 1500 was producing tons of books that simply wouldn't have produced otherwise
 
  • 3Like
  • 1Love
Reactions:
Well we should also consider Prague and Hussites as a place to spawn confessionalism....
 
  • 1Like
Reactions:
I'm concerned by the the very Eurocentric nature of a lot of these innovations.

Feudalism is probably fine, but it also feels a bit like a cop-out - lots of Eurasia and Africa were governed by non-feudal polities which had better administrative reach and centralization than feudal Europe - see China in particular but most of the Islamic world had little to no systems recognizable as "feudal" as well.

Renaissance doesn't make sense anywhere outside of Europe - the Islamic world, East Asia, and South Asia all had robust philosophical traditions where they had continued access to classical texts.

The printing press feels a little off as well - although the Latin alphabet and Gutenberg's adjustments to the process made printing take off more rapidly in Europe than the rest of the world, the actual invention of movable type printing was in China at least several centuries before Gutenberg.

Global trade is also a rather exaggerated innovation - there were global trade networks in 1337 (see Before European Hegemony: The World System A.D. 1250-1350 by Janet Abu-Lughod for an overview). Instead, what happened was that previously marginalized European trade networks were able to join the already existing global trade networks.


Pike and Shot seems rather random as an innovation, I think something like Volley Fire or Drill would make more sense there.

The inclusion of Confessionalism and Enlightenment seems to fall into a very deterministic "Protestant work ethic made Europe great" kind of screed. If later institutions have more flexible spawn locations, why are they so heavily biased towards Europe?

Ultimately, I'm concerned that this set up will lead to a world where everywhere but Europe falls behind at a consistent pace, rather than the more historical outcomes, which is where the majority of Eurasia and the polities of West Africa have rough parity with Europe until around 1700, when the dividends of colonization and constant innovation in military tactics allows Europe to shoot ahead.
 
  • 27
  • 18
  • 6Like
Reactions:
On a similar vein to my earlier feudalism suggestion I would propose considering renaming "reinassance" to "humanism" to better fit a non west european setting, humanism was after all a big part of the culture of the renaissance and unlike "reinassance" it actually makes sense for humanism to be an institution that can be embraced in say China.
 
  • 6Like
  • 1
Reactions:
I wonder how this will affect New World. From my knowledge, by the time Spaniards with Cortez arrived in Mexico, Aztecs and Incas would be on the same level as High Medieval European realms. So would Feudalism be spreaded in the New World or they'll have to deal with "No Institution" game until Europeans arrive?
 
  • 4Like
  • 2
Reactions:
Limited to one atm.

We could in theory add a game-rule that allows multiple "spawns". Maybe 1 per sub-continent ?
I was just about to suggest something like that.

You said for yourself in the DD that, while you selected Rome as the starting point for legalism, other places like China invented the concept independently.

Now to be fair most if my knowledge about Chinese culture comes from watching Avatar the last Airbender, but I guess the Chinese version of legalism has some differences from the Roman one, so I'd argue that the same institution spawning in different location should have slightly modified names, like "European Legalism" for the version spawned in Rome anf "Chinese Legalism" for the version spawned in China.

Maybe the names should even drastically differ in some situations, like the version of the Renaissance spawned in Tibet could be named after some 15th century art style which, in the game timeline, represents a somewhat larger social movement.

All variants of institutions should be largely cosmetic, but maybe they are a good way to add some small additional flavor events later.
 
  • 3Like
Reactions:
Feudalism
This has its birthplace in Aachen, the capital of the Roman Empire under Charlemagne. It has spread in most of the Old World as well.

Oh dear me. Now, where did I put my pitchfork and torch?
 
  • 4Haha
  • 2Like
Reactions:
The printing press feels a little off as well - although the Latin alphabet and Gutenberg's adjustments to the process made printing take off more rapidly in Europe than the rest of the world, the actual invention of movable type printing was in China at least several centuries before Gutenberg.

Global trade is also a rather exaggerated innovation - there were global trade networks in 1337 (see Before European Hegemony: The World System A.D. 1250-1350 by Janet Abu-Lughod for an overview). Instead, what happened was that previously marginalized European trade networks were able to join the already existing global trade networks.
Moveable type is a bit of whataboutism, the printing press was an innovation on what existed everywhere else and it did factually lead to Europe outproducing China in terms of books. It was a genuine innovation and proveable one, my issue is that it's a technology more than an institution.

About Global trade, Europe connected itself and regions like the Americas to the world and made more direct trade between regions less directly connected possible and more frequent, this again is a real and massive change.
 
  • 12
  • 2Like
Reactions:
Limited to one atm.

We could in theory add a game-rule that allows multiple "spawns". Maybe 1 per sub-continent ?
Design Idea: One continent is chosen as the overall spawn, and then each sub-continent has a weighted chance to spawn the institution. The two sub-contintents with least weight do not spawn it, so there's some variation even in Europe, or Africa, or Asia, or the Americas.

So you'll still have certain continents being ahead in certain institutions, and even in that continent you'll have reasonable variation.
 
  • 1
  • 1Like
Reactions:
Yeah. Feudalism was not some brilliant advance in statecraft invented by Charlemagne. It was a forced necessity that developed out of the inability of the Frankish Empire's successors to solidify state power. It's not a universal thing, and I see no way to reframe it as some aspect of statecraft that is universal without it overlapping with Legalism.
Lots of things have already been written about Feudalism, at least since Marc Bloch wrote his Feudal Society. To simplify it, we've described it this way in the game:

Over time, most societies develop a need for a common structure with stronger and more permanent institutions of government. After the fall of the Roman Empire, this need came to be filled by a number of institutions and customs that taken together are often considered to be part of the European Feudal system.\n\nFor similar reasons, permanent government and societal systems with similar features formed over time all over the world, some of which have roots that go far further back than Feudalism itself.

Making its birthplace the Carolingian Empire is also a means of simplifying it. By the way, on this topic, I pretty much recommend the works of Charles West on the Post-Carolingian period, as he has synthesized in them much of the academic debates of the last decades.
 
  • 50Like
  • 12
  • 1
  • 1
Reactions:
My issue with the institutions as a whole stems mainly from this idea that they "arose" in a certain place and from there spread out to the rest of the world in some all-encompassing crusade of cultural and technological advancement. The feudalism spawn in Aachen for example ignores the very real processes that led to its independent development in areas other than Europe, such as India while also ignoring each "version"'s separate flair.

With this in mind I would echo the suggestion for multiple spawns (perhaps divided by region? Ideally we would do this through the spread of these institutions within cultural regions, such as the Sinosphere, the Persian world, and so on) and also a renaming of certain bad apples. "Rennaisance" is the oft-cited example from the EUIV days, but confessionalism is also another such example.
 
  • 19
  • 3Like
  • 1Love
Reactions:
Howdy! First of all, this tinto talk has probably been the best in terms of helping me understand what it is the team is trying to capture historically both between explanation and mechanics revealed. One thing I feel is conspicuously missing is the idea of "humanism" and how it developed in this game's time period. From Renaissance Italian education, to Protestant Dutch portraits of everyday people (ones that even Ottoman traders found bizarre for how common their subjects were), to the tensions between Rococo and Neoclassical artwork and their politicality in the leadup to the French Revolution, to even way later the friends of Mr Science and Mr Democracy in the New Culture Movement of Revolutionary China, this concept I think should be explicitly included as an institution. I don't quite know what the best place is for it, since it was a concept that really morphed over time, though I think either Confessionalism which feels like the weakest of the institutions you've given us, or Renaissance which is weirdly tautological with itself I think are good contenders. One other idea is instead of calling it the Age of Renaissance, call it the Age of Humanism, which would also move it out of the weirdly western europe focus the naming has.
 
Hate to say it, but this is the first Tinto Talks that has outright disappointed me. It's not bad, but it needlessly retains many problems from EU4. Ages are still global mechanics meaning a New World or Asian country that knows nothing of the greek classics still gets arbitrarily told they're in the "Age of renaissance". And institutions, while I'm happy they seem to do more than just control tech speed, have the same conceptual problem as in EU4 where most of them seem to represent technologies or government policies which makes the criteria of what advances get elevated to a spreadable institution feel arbitrary and gamey. I ask again: Why is the Printing Press or Pike&Shot something that spreads on the map, but say the similarly impactful four-field system or gunpowder a regular technology that each country has to research individually?
I generally agree with this. I would prefer if institutions represented a zeitgeist that followed from technological or societal development and could occur anywhere that development had come about. To take the examples you gave, the social change that follows from the printing press, for example, would start to spread around anywhere which has printing presses. Pike and shot doesn't really need an institution, to my mind, because there's no zeitgeist there. Professional armies are a different matter - that's going to lead to societal change.

Anyone should be able to try to fund an expensive expedition to the New World, but until there's either a trend towards thinking it's worthwhile, or solid proof that it is, that should cause some upset at court.

I think maybe it's just not entirely clear what institutions are meant to be apart from a game mechanic (this being a game, I suppose that's blindingly obvious). If the game was made entirely from scratch, with no carryover from EU4, I think they would not exist at all, because they are not quite in step with the rest of what has been presented.

Whatever way it goes, still looking forwards to it all!
 
  • 17
  • 1Like
Reactions:
I am far from thinking that adding ages and institutions to PC will ruin the game or make it unreversebly bad. While I think ages are not that bad of an abstraction (even though I still see it as limiting and eurocentric), institutions are, in my opinion an especially limiting and eurocentric mechanic (especially for the kind of game developers of PC seem to want to make.
Institutions are a hard railroad of how all games will proceed (European nations asserting dominance over some parts of the planet thanks only to their (seemingly) unavoidable innovative and technological advantages)

On top of limiting the kind of gameplay and trajectories PC could offer, this mechanic also perpetrate historical clichés (which could easily be labeled as racists) which academic historians (such as the dedicated historians who work on PC) have tried to debunk for years now (with exemples like Kenneth Pomeranz's The Great Divergence of 2000)

I don't know if this mechanic is removable at this point but I would love to read what was the thinking process of the devs (is it a mechanic you absolutely wanted in the game or did you implement it reluctantly?) and what ultimately pushed them towards this mechanic.
 
Last edited:
  • 14
  • 3Like
  • 2
Reactions: