• We have updated our Community Code of Conduct. Please read through the new rules for the forum that are an integral part of Paradox Interactive’s User Agreement.

Tinto Talks #29 - 18th of September 2024

Welcome everyone to another Tinto Talks, the Happy Wednesday where we inform you about how things will work in our super secret game with the codename Project Caesar.

In today's Tinto Talks we will delve into a few different and not entirely related topics, but they are important for what we need to talk about as they will be referenced a fair bit in future Tinto Talks.

Prosperity & Devastation
In Project Caesar this is a single value in a location ranging from -100% to +100%, where positive is prosperity and negative is devastation.

Prosperity represents how prosperous and resourceful a location is. A prosperous location increases development over time. Prosperity will slowly rise, unless different negative circumstances reduce it. If it goes negative it will cause devastation.

There is no direct way for the player to increase prosperity, but having a peaceful country will have it increase slowly over time.

prosperity.png

‘Market Fairs’ is a nice privilege to give.


Devastation represents how ravaged a location is. It includes burnt-down farms and abandoned villages, and the biggest sources of devastation are blockades and occupation.

It has a rather huge impact on a location over time, reducing how much food and raw materials it produces and the population over time.

If you have high devastation in any location in a province, the Age of Renaissance has an advance that enables a cabinet action, where you can focus on recovering devastation in a province, until it has recovered fully.

Ideally, you do not want any sort of war or conflict happening on your own lands.

devastation.png

Not ideal, let's end this war asap…

Development
One concept that has been in many of our previous GSGs is development. It has been used for various things, but in Project Caesar development represents how cultivated the land is, and how much it is used by the pops living there. The higher the development, the more people can live there, and the more it can be exploited.

As mentioned in earlier Tinto Talks, this is a value that the player mostly only has indirect control over, but you can have your cabinet working on improving development in an entire province at once.

Development helps a fair bit in improving the quality of a location, but all of these values here are still constantly being balanced.

development.png

The Woods probably has some other advantage…


Roads
We have had roads in many of our former games, and this game will also have roads. In Project Caesar this includes one of the most in-depth systems of roads we have ever made. A road is basically a connection between two land locations that reduces the proximity calculations from 40 down to 20. Most settled nations start with the capacity to build gravel roads, but there are three advances in later ages that will introduce new types of roads that can be built. Those roads will reduce proximity further, and increase movement speed for armies.

Now this may sound like it could be a lot of micromanagement if we had used the ways railroads were built in Victoria 2, or how roads were built in Imperator, but we have a few easier ways to build or upgrade road networks.

build_road.png

Here we have Kalmar selected and we are looking at building a road to Idre, which technically is in Norway at the start of the game. You can always build a road INTO the location of any country that has a positive opinion of you, so road networks can and will be connected for trade.
  • The green locations are locations you can afford to build a road from Kalmar to at the moment.
  • Striped locations are locations with a road network.
  • The white-outlined locations are the proposed path for the road between Kalmar and Idre.

Road building is one of the most important and fun parts of the control-growing gameplay loop.


Piracy & Privateers
To clarify here, a privateer is a pirate sponsored by a specific country. The ability to sponsor privateers has several different ways to unlock. First of all, every nation has access to an advance in the Age of Absolutism called Letter of Marque that reduces the cost for privateers while also making them sturdier. There are also unique advances in the Age of Discovery for some countries that allow them to hire privateers, while if you pick the Diplomatic Focus in the Age of Renaissance you have the possibility to recruit privateers that early.

Sponsoring a Privateer can be done in an area, and cost about 250 sailors per privateer, and 10 sailors each month they are active. A pirate/privateer in an area, depending on its current strength, can reduce the maritime presence of all non-friendly countries in all sea zones in that area. This hurts relations and will give them a way to get a casus belli on you though.


So how do you fight privateers? Well, you have a fleet of ships in any location in that sea area, and they will actively reduce the capacity of those pirates. Galleys are a bit better than heavy ships at hunting pirates, but light ships are by far the best at dealing with pirates, where a single light ship is about ten times as effective as a heavy ship at the start of the game.


privateers.png

You need sailors for your privateers, or they disappear..

There is a situation in the later half of the 16th century where piracy will start to grow in certain areas of the map. Pirates also have a chance to spawn from locations with pirate covens. These are buildings that peasants will build in coastal locations where control is very low.

privilege.png

This privilege when granted to the Burghers will help your privateers be more cost effective…




Stay tuned, as next week we will focus on Conquest, Integration and Casus Belli’s.
 

Attachments

  • development.png
    development.png
    387,2 KB · Views: 0
Last edited:
  • 144Love
  • 138Like
  • 7
  • 5
  • 4
Reactions:
If they both pay for it they split it equally, if one pays for it they pay the entire thing.
That would make a way to exploit it and use it to hurt economy of nearby opms- just make multiple roads towads their locations and just wait until road maintenace starts to hurt their small economy ;)

Besides: what if one realm doesnt want to maintain specific sections of road but still want to keep other roads at 100% maintenace?
You would need: either a feature to mark 'unimportant roads' or ability to intentionaly destroy road sections...
 
I think roads should have a condition status, that costs maintenance to keep it in good condition, while gradualy reducing if you dont have the money to pay for the upkeep, wich will reduce the Effekt. Also repairing should be more expensive than the sum of the missed payments of maintenance to not make this a place of mikromanaging. This would on one Hand give a tool to financially struggeling nations to relocate some money and materials to more Importent areas and also can reflect how former prosperous locations can become some backwater province, that need a lot of investment if you decide to conquer or redevelop it.
Also this would be a great way to include historic roman roads(and similar atructures) just give them 0%, so they just need to be repaired/upgraded and not fully build new. Also repairing should be cheaper than building new, as some of the old materials can be used and as there ist still some earthwork done, it should be faster too.
Another benefit is that it punishes countries who thy to grow to fast by building to much in the hope of benefiting later, so the investment will partly be lost if they cant pay for it.
Maybe you can even make the road condition or the maintenance Coast imoacted by control, or better the lack of control. Also the actuall usage(ammount of trade passing on it) can have a impact.



I also will be exited to see how the plage will spread along the existing road network. Maybe there will be a way to block of a road to reduce spread of deseases?



Another thougt: will there be the Option for Tolls on foreign nations using your road network? Or even blocking specific ones from using it all together for their trade? I'd love that.


(sry if these ideas are not new, i did not read all of the previous comments)
 
@Johan
We're doing some calculations for Hungary's cities and towns based on Kubinyi András' method for centrality points calculation:
Instead of specific places however, we're applying a corrected version that can work for entire locations too.

My question concerns development. For locations that include places with atleast some urban functions, could the sum of centrality values being divided with the area(km^2) of the location be a good approach to calculate the relative values of what the game considers "development"?

For locations that lack places with any kind of urban functions, we're planning to use population density values for basis.

To give an idea how this could look like here's a WIP version table with the current calculated values for our suggestion's locations:
IDLocation NamePopulation SizeArea (km^2)Pop. density (/km^2)CentralityRural correctionDevelopmentDev. %Urbanisation
88Buda1004763715,7650,779,55100,00%city
82Esztergom1198578015,3736,346,5458,51%city
77Visegrád37233789,8416,443,3454,49%town
43Pozsony781544917,4115,133,6542,29%town
192Szászsebes16320140111,6443,130,7538,66%city
115Várad20094124516,1438,130,5938,46%city
74Vác44375518,0616,129,2436,75%town
60Eger1382191115,1825,528,0035,20%town
240Újlak1313376017,2919,725,9332,59%town
186Pécs38949170722,8237,121,7427,32%city
23Kassa21318140915,1329,520,9426,32%town
195Zágráb14280141010,1328,220,0025,14%town
37Sajószentpéter1221572216,921419,4024,38%
36Sárospatak24286152815,892918,9823,85%town
13Eperjes18462103017,9319,418,8423,68%town
10Lőcse13362130110,2723,918,3723,09%town
56Miskolc14076116912,0420,717,7022,25%town
178Gyulafehérvár27642210413,1436,917,5422,05%city
31Korpona780310947,141917,3721,84%town
132Kolozsvár13362132510,092317,3621,82%town
48Selmecbánya11220106210,561816,9521,30%town
17Besztercebánya44376716,6111,316,8421,17%
202Verőce533051810,288,516,4020,61%
67Gyöngyös1438295914,9915,315,9520,05%town
52Nyitra16320141611,5321,114,9018,73%town
104Fehérvár1509619287,8328,714,8918,71%town
242Szalánkemén918076911,9311,214,5618,30%
78Hatvan64016889,319,814,2517,92%
16Gölnicbánya52029175,6712,513,6317,13%
86Győr1229115348,0120,613,4316,88%town
41Szikszó24168154515,6419,712,7516,02%town
93Kőszeg584043413,455,512,6615,92%
8Rózsahegy780311676,6914,512,4315,62%
33Újbánya78039278,4111,512,4015,59%
45Ság854382710,331012,0915,20%
29Körmöcbánya46168745,2810,512,0115,09%
100Pest482910844,461311,9915,08%
61Komárom40297355,488,511,5614,53%
166Szeged293413182,2315,211,5314,49%town
143Lendva33153818,694,34557708811,3914,32%
211Csázma24735208011,8923,511,3014,20%town
57Nógrád74729068,251011,0413,88%
204Bodrog357012932,7614,110,9013,71%
215Eszék11220101011,101110,8913,68%
235Diakóvár1229113079,4014,210,8613,65%
267Szávaszentdemeter357011343,1512,310,8413,63%
144Torda20375169212,0418,310,8213,60%town
62Szőgyén729355813,08610,7613,52%
89Sopron12750116310,9612,210,4913,19%
18Privigye69368148,528,410,3112,96%
198Brassó836411397,3511,710,2812,92%
39Nagyszombat1282714189,0514,510,2312,85%
27Tornavár747269510,75710,0712,66%
59Maros923165814,026,59,8712,41%
92Debrecen13898138710,0213,69,8112,33%
121Teke16499124313,27129,6512,13%
14Szucsány668110386,44109,6412,12%
185Csanád1336216558,0715,99,6112,08%town
6Kisszeben1938091021,308,79,5612,02%
113Veszprém1397417008,2216,19,4711,90%town
184Lippa192211721,64119,3911,80%
168Arad918075112,2279,3211,71%
149Aranyosbánya29588603,4489,3011,69%
54Bars15198104214,599,28,8311,10%
103Szombathely1382188315,667,68,6110,82%
124Berényhida765070510,8568,5110,70%
307Kismarton55597227,7068,3110,44%
187Kapronca15045123712,1710,18,1710,27%
20Trencsén12827123210,41108,1210,21%
50Dédes816071111,485,7400702048,0810,15%
180Sződ874767412,985,48,0110,07%
191Szekcső14280102713,918,27,9910,04%
51Tokaj1481689516,5677,839,84%
81Szatmár1677925466,5919,87,789,78%town
147Gyula23467793,0167,709,68%
196Siklós1394991815,1977,629,58%
87Csorna23468342,816,37,569,50%
21Holics29589363,1677,479,40%
228Velike85439508,9977,379,26%
125Körmend11220102011,007,57,359,24%
109Beszterce1621825306,4118,67,359,24%town
114Vasvár1282715318,3811,27,329,20%
224Pozsegavár17340155511,1511,37,279,13%
200Nagyszeben1336216158,2711,77,249,10%
230Titel754817784,2512,77,148,98%
216Monoszló72429917,3177,068,88%
141Somogyvár29156127522,8797,068,87%
136Tapolca29070170017,10127,068,87%
58Szécsény1229112969,4996,958,73%
108Pápa578916873,4311,76,948,72%
53Szölős696213035,3496,908,68%
105Dés1060814547,299,96,818,56%
71Asszonypataka357013242,7096,808,54%
162Varasd918082911,075,534581146,678,39%
145Körösszeg21420183111,7012,16,618,31%
4Lubló578912154,7686,588,28%
127Solt836411107,5376,317,93%
55Somorja1711117569,74116,267,87%
205Baranyavár13770112112,2976,257,85%
226Bács28050238611,7614,76,167,74%
220Csütörtökhely13260117611,277,16,047,59%
140Székelyvásárhely20706150713,7495,977,51%
84Heves1443316838,57105,947,47%
199Hunyadvár357013482,6585,947,46%
102Fegyvernek637511885,3775,897,41%
189Körös1657517129,68105,847,34%
26Kapos14433137710,4885,817,30%
138Kapornak27132175615,4510,15,757,23%
42Gömör23919157315,2095,727,19%
160Nádasd28254159417,729,15,717,17%
183Déva461614453,1985,546,96%
151Kanizsa13260122610,826,75,466,87%
28Csetnek754818314,12105,466,87%
236Dubica66819756,865,35,446,84%
123Bánffyhunyad872116595,2695,426,82%
25Vágújhely724211286,4265,326,69%
24Nagymihály19890151813,1085,276,62%
251Érsomlyó173413351,3075,246,59%
161Küküllővár21420173012,3895,206,54%
158Segesd17034124913,646,55,206,54%
128Nagyböszörmény12750115511,0465,196,53%
137Muraszombat38766116,343,1715223255,196,52%
237Bród13592105312,905,45,136,44%
157Kalocsa418215722,6685,096,40%
253Marót69368268,394,1971794435,086,39%
182Bátmonostor418213873,0275,056,35%
76Muhi14790121212,2064,956,22%
227Valkóvár21318121717,5264,936,20%
155Csáktornya55597627,303,649877714,796,02%
34Galgóc17952133713,436,44,796,02%
47Kisvárda13770125610,9664,786,00%
30Rimaszombat55597657,273,6352614954,755,98%
177Krapina11220108910,305,1507909084,735,94%
190Csehi18437140013,176,5859842534,715,91%
181Torja948612807,4164,695,89%
83Tata780312206,405,74,675,87%
165Simánd14790127111,645,8197247924,585,76%
171Hetes21930125717,445,74,535,70%
222Cseri14280134410,6364,475,61%
252Németi1116915797,0874,435,57%
96Böszörmény780313625,7364,405,54%
176Atád16983122713,855,44,405,53%
111Bolcshida1229113639,0164,405,53%
164Hód-Vásárhely520215943,2674,395,52%
2Bártfa1657518239,0984,395,52%
163Ozora28050160517,4774,365,48%
169Tolnavár1336216058,3274,365,48%
46Huszt173423200,75104,315,42%
266Zimony520212684,105,44,265,35%
179Medgyes1550419108,1284,195,27%
64Udvard49987806,403,2024459784,105,16%
212Gorica1116914577,665,94,055,09%
116Monyorókerék1229112349,964,9804036544,045,07%
98Székelyhíd16830148811,3164,035,07%
231Mezősomlyó578917413,3274,025,05%
150Szentes461613583,405,43,985,00%
40Beregszász1229113838,895,53,985,00%
22Ungvár222220361,0983,934,94%
79Kálló1443318008,0273,894,89%
112Bonchida1925320819,2583,844,83%
49Técső142221140,6783,794,76%
210Temesvár2193022889,588,43,674,61%
120Szolnok418216362,5663,674,61%
175Segesvár930819104,8773,664,61%
44Fülek1389817407,9963,454,33%
214Ozalj16040160210,015,43,374,24%
75Ecsed1925323828,0883,364,22%
208Szalatnok1818220528,866,83,314,17%
5Zsolna418219532,1463,073,86%
234Blagaj1443315359,404,7003468393,063,85%
73Máramarossziget173423620,7372,963,73%
85Nyék22706213,661,8286217132,953,70%
250Osztrozsác836411927,023,50984012,953,70%
126Szászrégen1282714838,654,3239206512,923,66%
152Csíksomlyó948613037,283,6411522392,803,51%
193Sepsiszentgyörgy1550416819,234,6128232052,743,45%
68Tiszalök892513256,743,3681340052,543,20%
69Óvár40299074,442,2216639912,453,08%
7Vágbeszterce1060814787,183,5875438772,433,05%
219Lugos234625650,9162,342,94%
213Rékás780312936,033,016412232,332,93%
194Révkanizsa520210674,872,4370303182,282,87%
146Belényes785430792,5572,272,86%
241Petrinya1397417827,843,9208490712,202,77%
70Nezsider34439343,691,8425368611,972,48%
135Simontornya637512774,992,4964708811,962,46%
119Adony402910623,791,8960516481,782,24%
170Kovácsháza637513864,602,2995261911,662,09%
134Békés696215064,622,311412231,531,93%
156Székelyudvarhely1871724787,553,7767369461,521,92%
91Jászberény357011703,051,5261148691,301,64%
107Nagyfalu357012902,771,3833325971,071,35%
19Breznóbánya12227591,610,80464051391,061,33%
35Malacka17349291,870,93364012821,011,26%
225Becskerek1106724204,572,2867998190,951,19%
308Szoboszló357013892,571,2853011530,931,16%
159Jenő930823144,022,0109395870,871,09%
94Káta234612131,930,96707142020,801,00%
110Cegléd234612721,840,92249365260,730,91%
269Kozara1106727733,991,9953590850,720,90%
245Barlód418217132,441,220424360,710,90%
117Túr173411311,530,76677678610,680,85%
262Orbászvásárhely724224432,961,4822305280,610,76%
129Gyergyószentmiklós11229621,170,58297588010,610,76%
9Homonna724224492,961,4785242890,600,76%
106Karcag11229961,130,56301445830,570,71%
173Maroskapronca9109051,010,50276068850,560,70%
188Zenta173413071,330,66335943510,510,64%
167Abrudbánya173413081,330,66269407960,510,64%
229Karánsebes173414691,180,59009169160,400,50%
95Lápos295819901,490,74329745090,370,47%
218Hátszeg173415331,130,56551155270,370,46%
142Szarvas192216261,180,59107315170,360,46%
207Telek418224011,740,87074721610,360,46%
90Kővár91011670,780,38988450690,330,42%
122Kecskemét293421971,340,66782675130,300,38%
203Fogaras173417650,980,49123122480,280,35%
264Illyéd234620581,140,57008695750,280,35%
248Modrus295824601,200,60132671250,240,31%
32Munkács295824641,200,60015266320,240,31%
97Zilah234622321,050,52561525840,240,30%
172Körösbánya91014360,630,31684796360,220,28%
174Kiskunhalas234628120,830,41712382150,150,19%
298Glamocs173426400,660,32838270250,120,16%
265Keve173429710,580,29178831030,100,12%
1Alsókubin51019580,260,13021574270,070,08%
272Orsova51026090,200,097732754410,040,05%
The percentage values are relative to Buda's development level.
(If I'm already at it, what centrality value would consider being the cut off point for the "city" and "town" statuses?)


Would this approach be in line with what you consider "development", or should we use another one? For example utilising this below?
1728033662308.png
 
  • 1
Reactions:
Bringing Antiquity to Life in Mods: Ideas for Project Tinto Modders

The recent dev diary got me thinking, and I wanted to share some thoughts on how certain mechanics could enhance a future mod set in antiquity. Yes, I’ve lost hope that Paradox will drop a new strategy game anytime soon, so maybe we can get something close with future mods of Tinto instead!
-
What if some of the mechanics from Project Caesar, like roads, prosperity, and piracy, were adapted into a mod? Imagine roads becoming the backbone of your empire, dynamic prosperity shaping your ancient cities, and piracy adding depth to naval gameplay of ancient Mediterranean.

Roads as a Pillar of Empire Building:
In antiquity, roads weren’t just for movement; they were the veins of empires. From the Royal Road of the Achaemenids to Roman roads, they connected vast regions economically and culturally. A mod could make roads vital for trade, military operations, and keeping your empire unified.

Dynamic Development and Prosperity:
Just like in ancient times, cities and regions rose and fell depending on trade, war, and even disasters. Prosperity in a mod could reflect these historical patterns, making it important to strategically allocate resources to cities or regions.

Piracy and Naval Power:
Piracy was a serious issue in antiquity, especially in the Mediterranean. It could destabilize regions and disrupt trade. A mod could add piracy as a real threat that requires active management, or even present opportunities to exploit it strategically.

Let’s keep the ideas flowing and see where the -future- modding community can take us!
 
Last edited:
  • 2Love
Reactions:
It's weird seeing Baltics being so developed, compared to some other parts of Europe. I guess it's because of location density.
This is after the northern crusades, and the Baltic population dropped a lot, by a half in some cases, like in Estonia. I am personally an Estonian history enthusiast, and even though I tend to get patriotic, I too don't really see why the northern Baltic has a special case in development. In the current time, there's looming peasant and pagan revolts because of the Germans stripping away more rights from the peasants and landowners, starting to turn them into early serfs.
 
  • 1
Reactions:
IMG_9748.jpeg

Yang, Zhengtai. Disquisition on national stage network in the Ming dynasty. Shanghai Ancient Books Publishing House, 2006, p. 112

This is a map of the post road network from the mid-Ming Dynasty. Although it dates to 250 years after the start of the game, the Ming Dynasty largely inherited the post road system from the Yuan Dynasty. Therefore, it is hoped that this can serve as a reference for the initial road network in the game.
 
  • 3
  • 1
Reactions:
they slowly dissapear

they don't exist on the map really.
Old post, but, could you have visual representation of the privateers sailing on the ocean as 3d objects? Kind of like airplanes in HoI4 where they aren’t present on the map per se but you still notice them dogfighting and bombing, that way you could also avoid having millions of mapmodes for only a single purpose.
@Johan
 
  • 1Like
Reactions: