• We have updated our Community Code of Conduct. Please read through the new rules for the forum that are an integral part of Paradox Interactive’s User Agreement.
More maneuvering and hardware seems to keep the Soviets on the defensive.

Well, yes. It is what the Germans were very good at, especially the maneuvering part. I'm also combing through online resources about several German weapons to find out what the various engineers and designers were planning to do when they got some breathing space. The ME-262 was slated to receive a swept-wing upgrade to increase speed and maneuverability. The HS129 had an aerial 105mm cannon developed for it and, in fact, some "Panzerknacker" planes were actually put into combat with the upgrade. And the designers of the Konigstiger had come up with a new drive train and gear box to attach to a slightly better engine to significantly increase the horsepower available to the tank, increasing its maximum speed over uneven ground from 20 to 29 kilometers per hour. I'm trying to be as rational as possible with my alternative history. ;)

How're you dealing with your low manpower btw?

Various ways. I alluded to the release and conscription of political prisoners and their guards; the first group would have constituted militia or light infantry and the second group would be a mix of light infantry and regular infantry with a generous mixing in of combat veterans from WW1. We know for a fact that Germany could have had no less than 6 million political prisoners and I've found that around 3 million German citizens were political prisoners and think that another 1.5 million worth of foreign political prisoners could be added to that. At least 10 million people were put to forced labor and as productive capacity was recovered in lieu of Allied bombing raids, many of these could be tapped as soldiers. Since we also know that at least some non-Germans put on the Wehrmacht uniform during WW2, I think it's totally reasonable to assume that the triumvirate would have access to 4-5 million men that could be tapped for the defense of the Fatherland and then moved into the offensive. Even assuming the lower number, 4 million is a good amount of reinforcements, wouldn't you agree?
 
serafine666 said:
Even assuming the lower number, 4 million is a good amount of reinforcements, wouldn't you agree?

If your figures are sound, sure. :) My knowledge in this area is non existent.
 
If your figures are sound, sure. :) My knowledge in this area is non existent.

It is possible that they are unsound but I think that counting on 4 million out of 13 million that could be put into service of Germany as reinforcements is a relatively safe bet.
 
Case Red

[size=+1]September 30, 1944[/size]

It is a little over a week since the devastating ambush of Soviet armor at Sibui and increasingly, it appears to Marshal Zhukov that the offensive in the west is effectively over although he dare not even hint such a thing lest the belief make its way to Stalin. Every day, reconnaissance reports Halder, Guderian, and Rommel advancing on their objectives apace. From the North, even an attempt by the Americans to slip forces into Hammerfest and pull Kesselring's offensive back has not seriously delayed the German general's advance through Finland towards Helsinki with the object of freeing up the mixed Finnish and Wehrmact garrison there and then sweep down passed Leningrad to join the offensive. Rommel, meanwhile, is driving his forces hard towards the iconic city, his lead elements slipping through the Red Army lines and making contact with the diversionary force holed up inside. While the diversionary forces were always relatively light and quite incapable of taking on any great amount of Soviet soldiers in a straight-up fight, they were unusually well-equipped with detailed winter gear and the very latest in Wehrmacht armaments which allows them to engage an entire Soviet army, giving ground very reluctantly and falling back to the next heavily-fortified line a couple yards away. They are holding, the Oberstleutnant assures Rommel's representative, and know that with the majority of reinforcements and supplies flowing to the all-important effort in the west, the Soviets penning them in are sparingly supplied and vulnerable. Rommel, however, had already suspected this from doing one of his familiar personal reconnaissances but did not want to take any chances considering the overwhelming numerical disparity between the Germans and the Soviets. Therefore, his representative came bearing an older Enigma machine and verbal instructions for how to take advantage of the Allies' apparent aptitude with decoding the older Enigma ciphers.

On October 1st, Ultra obtained an intercepted conversation between Rommel and the commander of the diversionary force outlining a fairly detailed counteroffensive that was trademark Rommel, a bold assault where it seemed like madness to attack--but the British generals in North Africa were on hand to recount the numerous times when such "madness" had caught them looking the wrong way and sent them into retreat. The intelligence was deemed credible and a warning of the exact plan was passed to Zhukov who forwarded it to the northernmost commander. Aware of the opposing general's gifts, the Soviet commander duly shifted to meet the expected attack, digging in and preparing to ambush the "Desert Fox" as he drove into what he thought was a weakness. Rommel, however, had cleverly instructed his correspondent to disregard every word from his headquarters using the Enigma machine except for every third one and drafted his messages accordingly. The deception had drawn the Red Army dangerously far from the shelter of the dense Leningrad apartment complexes, allowing the Wehrmact in the city to sneak into the positions and haul weapons into the towering buildings. To keep the Soviet general looking the way he wished, Rommel committed some of his more impressive-looking assets, chiefly some mechanized infantry and armored cars, to the fake assault and the Red Army was feeling quite good about itself, throwing back what the soldiers believed to be the famed German general's assault, when the heavier armored cars and light tanks came charging out of the city, having cut off and brushed aside the thin line of infantry guarding their intended approach. The Soviets were well-equipped for fighting armored vehicles but the shock had just the effect Rommel had predicted: throwing aside their fears of the ever-present commissars, the soldiers broke and ran for cover, their cohesion shattered and with armored vehicles swarming everywhere, destroying anti-tank guns and gunning down soldiers that tried to organize a defense, the shattered cohesion turned into a panicked rout. Leningrad was effectively in German hands by October 4th with the Soviet manpower numerically large enough to drive them back out but so scattered and fragmented that even the tactic of trying to overwhelming German lines with pure numbers would be an exercise in futility; there were simply not enough men armed and supplied and able to go into the offensive. Worse still, Kesselring's forward elements had begun skirmishing with the Soviet lines around Helsinki and with his numbers, plus those that could be freed up from Leningrad as the Wehrmacht grip tightened, there was no way to prevent the combined Finnish and German garrisons from being released for offensive operations. The news for Zhukov seemed to be getting worse all the time but for the famed marshal, the disintegration of his northern front was the least disastrous situation before him.

As the separate armies of Halder, Rommel, and Guderian had advanced into the USSR, the largest bulk of the Red Army had been kept locked in combat with the Wehrmact. The Luftwaffe, reinforced with the advanced HS-129s and improvements upon the deadly HE-162 and ME-262 fighter-interceptors, German airspace was effectively closed to American and British heavy bombers, the genius of German aerospace and rocketry engineers paying rich dividends in the form of a grim harvest of veteran bomber crews and fighter pilots. As pressure eased, the tireless effectiveness of Albert Speer continued to augment production and the lull gave the Third Reich precious time to gather its nerve and its war machines for still greater feats. But most importantly, the air supremacy meant that even as they remained giving as good as they got on the ground, the Red Army was suffering almost daily raids on their remaining armor, on their supply dumps, on their lines of communications, and when German pilots were feeling especially vengeful, Ju-88s were dumping incendiary and conventional bombs on any Army concentrations they could find. Worse yet, Ju-390s were making their way into the prototype phase which meant that in a time not too distant, the Allies would feel the pain they had only been inflicting up to that time. They did, however, get a respite: regarding constant V1 and V2 bombardment to be a waste of production resources that could be better spent making turbojet engines and manufacturing heavy rockets for Raketenwerfer 56 batteries, the last vengeance weapon hit England on October 1st but the rocket research facility of Peenemünde, the Allies observed with a sense of dread, seemed to be getting more busy than it had been. All this added to rumors that the German offensives to the East were proceeding to actually liberate the various ethnicities of the Soviet Union severely harmed Soviet morale and conversely, encouraged German soldiers. Even more than their successes in the east, however, the arrival of reinforcements, especially crowds of WW1 veterans, gave the Wehrmacht its first taste in a long while of the sense of invulnerability they had enjoyed during the 1939-41 period.

With things running strongly in their favor, Rundstedt draws up a strategy of attack to drive the Red Army back into the USSR called "Fall Rot" (Case Red). It calls for a simultaneous assault by both 1st Army Group and 2nd Army Group on their respective concentrations of Soviet soldiers which they have been very slowly and deliberately encircling as the more dramatic advances are happening in the east. The new waves of reinforcements, especially the Judegruppe comprising a significant amount of veterans, convert this plan from being a possible victory to a very plausible one. On October 1st, just as Rommel is preparing his attack against Leningrad, Rundstedt pulls the trigger on the massive offensive and heads east to take more personal command of the battle in the north which will be the more difficult as it is where a majority of the Red Army is concentrated. With the pipelines from Romania open, the Luftwaffe has all the fuel it needs and not an hour goes by without Stukas and Panzerknackers diving in on any Soviet attempt to push back against the oncoming waves, supported amply by the relatively slow-moving but seemingly invincible Tigers and King Tigers. Focke-Wulf and Messerschmitt fighters roam the battlefield at will, watching the battle and conveying their observations to commanders on the ground, opportunistically strafing any Soviet soldiers they see, warding off feeble bomber attacks from Russian aircraft. And when it gets dark, the two armies fight by the light of 80cm rockets screaming down on the heads of the demoralized Red Army. It is the southern portion of the Red Army that begins to crack first, the growing panic fueled by the growing feeling of the Soviet soldiers that they are completely surrounded; although the Wehrmacht never gets anywhere close to doing this, the damage to the fighting spirit of the infantry is done. On October 3rd, the arrival of the heavy armor sent to ambush the bulk of Soviet armor arrives in the rear of the southern arm and the strain finally pushes that half over the edge: a full third of the Red Army disintegrates and flees towards the east with Manstein throwing every last wheeled or tracked asset he can after them to harry and drive them, trying to provoke a full rout while he combs out the foot infantry and sends them north. When Zhukov receives the dread news of Leningrad on October 5th, he is reading the panicked cascade of cables from generals in the northern half reporting that their commands are breaking and advising that he prepare to move east to avoid capture. With the fall of Riga on October 2nd and Kiev on the 3rd and reports of Hadler's forces overwhelming the scanty garrisons struggling to block capture of the USSR's primary oil sources, there is no choice and the Red Army begins the long retreat east.
 
Last edited:
Great update, you have achieved something very few of us can ever accomplish. Reversing the 1944 situation for Germany with such speed and strategic brilliance. Bravo my good man, bravo!
 
Cool, so the Judegruppe is kicking Soviet ass. Nice, something like Inglorious Bastards, only now they serve the Nazi's. Excellent idea.

More accurately, they serve the Wehrmacht; the Nazis would have just as soon have killed the Judegruppe (along with all the other political prisoners released by the triumvirate in this alternate history) as send them to defend the Fatherland and kill the Bolsheviks.
 
Great update, you have achieved something very few of us can ever accomplish. Reversing the 1944 situation for Germany with such speed and strategic brilliance. Bravo my good man, bravo!

You are too kind. :) It's all a matter of shortening your defensive lines while concentrating forces on the weak places in the Allied advance, something that the historical Wehrmacht would have done if not for Hitler.
 
The leviathans are locked in terrible combat...

Indeed and it seems to only be a matter of time until the USSR falls under the wheels of a juggernaut. The most fun part of all of this AAR is writing the narrative; kicking Stalin around is just a bonus. :D
 
I understand the fine nuance there, there is a difference between Wehrmacht and NSDAP, although seriously blurred.

Primarily blurred because being a Nazi was required for being a general and because the officer corp was initially very fond of the Nazis; they grew markedly less fond of them when they had to deal with the partisans that the SS inspired by brutalizing any non-Aryan they laid eyes on.
 
Yes, very true and when the tide of war was turning against them.

Indeed but that was hardly the first time they were entertaining serious doubts; when Hitler was insisting on letting 100,000+ BEF and French soldiers escape to England instead of capturing them, it probably gave many of the generals an uneasy feeling. Likely, that feeling got quite a bit worse when they found out that they were off to try a frontal assault against a numerically massive nation instead of driving a knife into their soft underbelly. Historically, they soldiered on to the end with Germany bleeding out around them out of duty; in my alternate history they decide that they are loyal to Germany before they are loyal to a suicidally foolish leader and his grisly gang of SS thugs--and you are reading the results.
 
Well put, Serafine. I always found it very interesting to think what could have been if only military genuises like Manstein, Guderian, Rommel and many others would have been in charge of the Wehrmacht instead of only Hitler. But hey, thats how things were.
 
Well put, Serafine. I always found it very interesting to think what could have been if only military genuises like Manstein, Guderian, Rommel and many others would have been in charge of the Wehrmacht instead of only Hitler. But hey, thats how things were.

There is a painful irony in the fact that if not for Hitler, those geniuses wouldn't have been able to unleash their genius at all but because of Hitler, their unleashed genius did little good. Interestingly enough, Erich Raeder is another of the brilliant minds although he is rarely recognized as such. He was the first to propose the capture of Malta and a campaign by Rommel through North Africa and Persia into the Caucuses.
 
Yes, without Hitler Mansteins plan to go through the Ardennes would probably not have been executed, heck even the Panzers themselves were a thing Hitler insisted on in earlier years in debates with the generals. He gave his support to Guderian to really build up the armoured divisions, while many generals still believed in infantry, 'the Queen of the Battlefield', they said.

And about Raeder, what if the Z-plan would have been properly done? That might have really turned things around for Germany.

Anyway, cool discussion :)
 
And about Raeder, what if the Z-plan would have been properly done? That might have really turned things around for Germany.

Well, the Z-Plan was an exercise in fantasy roughly analogous to designing the Maus and Ratte ultra-superheavy tanks. Unless the UK, US, France, and USSR decided to spontaneously start scuttling their fleets wholesale, it was impossible for Germany to gain even momentary naval superiority with surface ships. Pour out submarines and magnetic mines, however, and England would have begged for mercy. The advantage of being a mighty island power is that invading you is extremely hard; the disadvantage is that if someone cuts your oceanic lifeline (i.e. mining every square inch of water that ships can traverse to your nation and torpedoing anyone that survives), you die.

Anyway, cool discussion :)

Thanks, hun. :) I'm already working on the next installment although my practice of maintaining a veneer of historical plausibility sort of slows me down.