• We have updated our Community Code of Conduct. Please read through the new rules for the forum that are an integral part of Paradox Interactive’s User Agreement.
VOTECOUNT said:
AOK - 3
Yakman, Cyms, Xark (Xark seemed to want to vote torn, but he did not unvote and he did not bold his vote either. Thus, his vote is still on AOK until he properly changes)

Xark - 3
Marty, Naut, Torn

marty - 2
sbr, walrus

Torn - 1
Jonti

This is where we stand.
 
VOTE Tornadoli

He is as good a lynch as any. We have nothing on him, he has not been run up, he did not vote for the wolf and his bandwagoning is fairly typical wolf play. That makes it:

VOTECOUNT said:
AOK - 3
Yakman, Cyms, Xark (Xark seemed to want to vote torn, but he did not unvote and he did not bold his vote either. Thus, his vote is still on AOK until he properly changes)

Xark - 3
Marty, Naut, Torn

marty - 2
sbr, walrus

Torn - 2
Jonti, AOK
 
I thought I voted...
In any case there is only one logical thing to do right now...

Vote Marty99

Maybe we should focus on the three candidates up there for some time, but in any case I will not let the tie (if it is not broken) stand to deadline....
 
Sigh no, that's a typo.

"does not know"

Unfortunately, since I decided to be cute and use Cymsdale instead of a generic Carl you idiots will probably think it's a Crovax. Just put the rope around my neck right now and get it over with.

If you vote with me today I will delay your lynching for at least a day. :D

VOTECOUNT said:
Torn - 3
Jonti, AOK, Xark

marty - 3
sbr, walrus, SPLIT

Xark - 3
Marty, Naut, Torn

AOK - 2
Yakman, Cyms,
 
Whoops... well .. too bad! I don't want to bandwagon Torn.

Torn is a better lynch than AOK, and probably better than Xarkan.
 
Xarkan's vote for SS was not convincing to me. It was late, 10 minutes after SS had already taken the lead. Xark and torn are both good suspects. What makes torn better to you?

It did not convince me either. There is just something about Torn that strikes me as lupine. Call it wolfdar, whatever, but the forced carelessness of his "hopping on a bandwagon" line struck me as odd. Note I said "probably" Xarkan - he is certainly up there with the wolf suspects as far as I am concerned.

Why? If Torn is a villager, what do we learn from it?

About the same as we learn from Xarkan being one. All analysis is pretty much impossible until hanging a wolf gives us an "in" to the pack psychology.
 
I'm just tired, that's why I'm quiet. And yes, I am following bandwagons; as I seriously have no clue who to vote on. Lynch me if you so desire, but you will just lynch a villager. What a waste of a day.
 
About the same as we learn from Xarkan being one. All analysis is pretty much impossible until hanging a wolf gives us an "in" to the pack psychology.

I don't agree. There is a lot of chatter around Xarkan, which can be very revealing if he ends up being a villager.

For instance, if Xarkan is a villager, we can look toward the people who jumped on his throat for the late vote the other day.

Don't get me wrong, lynching a wolf is the best scenario, but I don't think there is anything about Torn that makes him 'definitely more likely to be a wolf' than Xarkan.

So don't think analysis is only possible from lynching wolves. When the probability of two candidates being a wolf is roughly equal, it's best to lynch the ones that gives the most information in general from his death. I believe that to be Xarkan.
 
I don't agree. There is a lot of chatter around Xarkan, which can be very revealing if he ends up being a villager.

Don't get me wrong, lynching a wolf is the best scenario, but I don't think there is anything about Torn that makes him 'definitely more likely to be a wolf' than Xarkan.

For instance, if Xarkan is a villager, we can look toward the people who jumped on his throat for the late vote the other day.

So don't think analysis is only possible from lynching wolves. When the probability of two candidates being a wolf is roughly equal, it's best to lynch the ones that gives the most information in general from his death. I believe that to be Xarkan.


Another convincing argument to vote XARKAN.
 
Do we have a free TIE in this game or not?
 
Do we have a free TIE in this game or not?

sp_tie.jpg