Werewolf Lite CLXVIII: Band of Brothers

[jonti-h]

I am not a wolf, I would have killed the seer immidiately, sacrifising myself for the pack. I would not keep him around for two extra days. If I would have had some influence in the JL I might have kept him alive and tried destroying the village from the inside, but I wasn't. I had nothing to gain from keeping the seer alive. Instead I tried working with the JL to catch wolves.

Fair points - although again I have been the inside wolf in a JL and done the opposite of what you said - I ate Punkbob after 4 days IIRC.

So who do you suggest then?
Are you still saying snoop? or Walrus? Or me?

 

[Slinky]

Fair points - although again I have been the inside wolf in a JL and done the opposite of what you said - I ate Punkbob after 4 days IIRC.

So who do you suggest then?
Are you still saying snoop? or Walrus? Or me?

I think we have by now established that you were in a JL once, while you were a wolf. I bet that you have been in a JL more times as a villager though.

I still think it's snoopdogg. Both you and walrus are possible, but I doubt it. walrus got voted by wolves too often in my opinion and you were after Tornadoli when he wasn´t in any danger. I am not a wolf because marty99 lived. I never tried to influence the JL or steer them in any direction. I only suggested a strategy once.

 

[snoopdogg]

May as well share:

Well, I doubt you are one - I did think you were earlier, but you are so consistent.

Tornadoli - he seems like the stereotypical wolf, chucking around as many theories as poss so he can deflect attention from himself or pacmates.

Walrus - he's pretty likely IMO - the just chucking a vote on me, the fact he was not killed, the fake outing of Hax. If I were a wolf, I'd have killed him to shut up the JL.

The last one is harder. I dobut your lycanthropy, because it doesn't seem in character for wolf you.

It'd help if the forum wasn't inactive at the moment and hdk had updated the first post.

Is Yakman still playing? He's silent if he is.

I am doubting between you and jonti-h. Walrus is cleared in my opinion. I was leaning towards jonti-h, but seeing as how you formulated a pack with two wolves and jonti-h, I think you might have been trying to get that idea established already. Attacking him before it was necessary strengthens your own position. I am still in doubt

I'm not sure what to believe - after I told marty about me sending details to Slinky, the JL agreed that wasn't a bad thing to do, as Slinky seemed like a villager, we all agreed on that. I don't think jonti is the remaining wolf, just a hunch, although I can't remember the last time I saw him play a wolf so I've forgotten how he plays when he is one.

I'm still not sure about you either

Not too much to be gleaned from it really. Slinky and walrus, I'd like to hear more on why you trust each other so much. Do you both just feel sure that the other would've killed the seer the day they heard the news? Waiting a day would be a smart move, especially from Walrus' POV I think. Once slinky hears the news, he could hunt him right away, and the JLer would have no idea whether to blame him or Walrus.

 

[Slinky]

When walrus heard the news there was no JL yet. He could announce Ciryandor, hunt marty99 and claim to be the last of the JL. Or he could have contacted me and hunted marty99 the next day, blaming me. He didn´t do either of these. It´s what I would do. I would either kill the seer or control the JL, as I think any player worth his salt would. I doubt walrus was entrusted with the scan targets so he would have killed the seer.

 

[snoopdogg]

Vote slinky.

For now. I think we should all vote a different person and make a true Mexican standoff. First WW game with no winners!

 

[jonti-h]

Vote slinky.

For now. I think we should all vote a different person and make a true Mexican standoff. First WW game with no winners!

Then there would be one massive snipe at the end. Could be amusing, but not good for the 2 innocents.

 

[Slinky]

Then there would be one massive snipe at the end. Could be amusing, but not good for the 2 innocents.

I think you mean three innocents

 

[snoopdogg]

Then there would be one massive snipe at the end. Could be amusing, but not good for the 2 innocents.

We could come to a gentleman's agreement not to snipe. Who wouldn't want to play in the first ever WW game to end in tie!

Or we could just enjoy the chaos.

Walrus is not a wolf. It's possible he thought Marty99 was only a JLer and he should wait a day before nomming him, but it's just so unlikely that I'm throwing it out now. Walrus = villager. It is definitely between Jonti and slinky.

Slinky. In retrospect the reason he seemed so non suspicious to me in the way he played was largely because he was in contact with the JL. Did he even get Walrus' PM in time to hunt Marty that day. Looking at the forum he only just barely showed up in time to switch to ciryandor. At the same time as Yakwolf no less, maybe they had been in communication? In the tornadoli vs. Rysz bandwagon on day 3, he breaks the tie and saves torn. Jonti was voting torn.

Walrus, did you get a reply the same day you told Slinky about Marty, or was it the next day?

 

[jonti-h]

I think you mean three innocents

I was educated in Blair's Britain, that explains my countin skillz. o

@snoop, that would implicate Slinky would it not?

 

[snoopdogg]

Jonti, I heartily recommend you vote slinky. Slinky if you are the last wolf, I would ask you to be nice and break the tie at the deadline, if their is one. If Jonti is the last wolf, I am mad at him for getting in my face over and over claiming some meta grudge. If Walrus is the last wolf: He's some kind of crazy superwalrus and deserves a win.

 

[Slinky]

Jonti, I heartily recommend you vote slinky. Slinky if you are the last wolf, I would ask you to be nice and break the tie at the deadline, if their is one. If Jonti is the last wolf, I am mad at him for getting in my face over and over claiming some meta grudge. If Walrus is the last wolf: He's some kind of crazy superwalrus and deserves a win.

You are really flip flopping all over the place aren't you. First walrus is a wolf, now he isn't. I am not a wolf, now I am. Let's go for a complete tie, o wait, let's don't. In fact if there is a tie, it should be broken. It seems to me you are accusing everyone and everything to see what sticks. Just give up already.

 

[jonti-h]

Right.

Vote Slinky
If snoop is a wolf, he is incredbily brazen, having named his packmates.
Walrus doesn;t seem like much of a bet
I ain;t a wolf.

 

[snoopdogg]

Just give up already.

no u. Whether jonti is a wolf or not, he knows that I am not one. So if I vote you, he will have every reason to vote you too, especially if walrus jumps on me. Now go find where I ever said walrus was a wolf. Go ahead, I'll wait. My arguments have been based in reality. You've just been cherry picking rubbish. If you are a villager, you deserve to lose anyway.

 

[walrus]

@snoop - indeed, Slinky's reply to my PM naming marty was indeed post-deadline.

 

[snoopdogg]

@snoop - indeed, Slinky's reply to my PM naming marty was indeed post-deadline.

boom, headshot. I am now done thinking. Slinky dies. Jonti, if you are the last wolf congrats, but tone down the anti-snoop rhetoric next time or their could be consequences and repurcussions. If you're a villager then fair enough.

 

[Slinky]

no u. Whether jonti is a wolf or not, he knows that I am not one. So if I vote you, he will have every reason to vote you too, especially if walrus jumps on me. Now go find where I ever said walrus was a wolf. Go ahead, I'll wait. My arguments have been based in reality. You've just been cherry picking rubbish. If you are a villager, you deserve to lose anyway.

Right get insulting, that always helps.

I must have got confused by these two posts:

Auto lynch ftw!

Sadly it doesn't help us that much really, as we don't get an extra day out of it. Well, 2/3rds of my original list was correct. Was the third name correct also? Or is walrus the final wolf? Tune in next time.

Seriously, guys, PM me who you think is the most suspect. The simple fact that I've named 2 of the 3 wolves should go a long way to clearing me. I'm not that ruthless. Or am I?

Walrus, if we are to give him credit here, played it exactly as a wolf would also. That is, whether he was a wolf, or a villager, he would out ciryandor, then sit on his knowledge of who the seer was for one day, since Racz knew of him, and kill him off. Edit: of course this is far from damning him here. Just saying that his spokesman role really proves nothing either way, and the fact marty died when he did does add suspicion.

Slinky on the other hand, might have less reason to wait on this news were he a wolf, and imo has just been very very unwolfy in this game. Slink, could you share your JL PMs please?

You didn't actually accuse anyone did you. No you waited to see who everyone else would accuse and who was your best bet to survive till the end. You even send out PM's to gauge everyones targets. However I think it interesting while you kept saying that I was not a wolf and then jonti-h is not a wolf, who you would have picked as the wolf from the remaining players. Walrus or yourself. I think you can understand my confusion about that.

@snoop - indeed, Slinky's reply to my PM naming marty was indeed post-deadline.

But I read it as soon as I got online, even before I voted.

 

[jonti-h]

boom, headshot. I am now done thinking. Slinky dies. Jonti, if you are the last wolf congrats, but tone down the anti-snoop rhetoric next time or their could be consequences and repurcussions. If you're a villager then fair enough.

I'm a villager.

And I wouldn't have killed you in full either, it was a bluff.

 

[snoopdogg]

Walrus, if we are to give him credit here, played it exactly as a wolf would also. That is, whether he was a wolf, or a villager, he would out ciryandor, then sit on his knowledge of who the seer was for one day, since Racz knew of him, and kill him off. Edit: of course this is far from damning him here. Just saying that his spokesman role really proves nothing either way, and the fact marty died when he did does add suspicion.

Slinky on the other hand, might have less reason to wait on this news were he a wolf, and imo has just been very very unwolfy in this game. Slink, could you share your JL PMs please?

@ slinky: granted I was wrong about this. I got confused for a moment thinking walrus was in touch with bothRacz and Marty at the time, but later I remembered Racz didn't get scanned until later, and all my suspicion of walrus dropped off. I'm leaving my vote where it is. When the deadline's come around I'll see what happened.

 

[jonti-h]

The vote is 2:2 snoop and Slink yes?

 

[EUROO7]

Nice day, guys, felicitations to the winner(s) whoever they may be.