Werewolf LXXXIV: Aces of the Pacific

[sbr]

You were wrong Yoshi. snoop was no where near cleared, even if you believed him.

Lynching jonti may not have cost us the game but it was absolutely 100% the wrong thing to do; especailly if you were in PM contact with jonti. That makes it go from bad to :wacko:

 

[Yakman]

ultimately, it was probably the absent seer that killed the village. but alas.

 

[randakar]

GM AAR, part 3

Day 9
Village lynched Tornadoli the brutal werewolf
Tornadoli brutalized randakar the lover

Made sense, Tornadoli was the most obvious baddie IMO (dublish and AOK not bad guesses either) and randakar the worst goodie threat against the baddies - active, analytical and lover so hard to hunt.

Thanks johho!


@OY

I will point out now I named 4 people as baddies that day and all four of them were correct. Also, I told TAM in a PM that muttoneer was probably a hunter cultist (also correct)

I had OY, and snoopdogg down as goodies. Trespoe and Kriszo as likely goodies. (Which got confirmed the day after my brutalize when they were run up that easily and without much discussion), and TAM as either a desperate cannibal but a more likely goodie.

If only I had gone with my instincts earlier and pushed harder for dublish and torn (I was 99% sure on both even before day 6) or looked harder at the Jopi non-runup... ah well.

To be honest vLN, the reason why I didn't follow you on Jopi was simply because I didn't trust you. Just too damn arrogant, sorry.


Anyway: The winners deserved this one big time. They played the village well. Even with a severely handicapped JL. I like to think me not getting killed might have put me in a position where I could still save the village but I'll never know, will I? ;-)

 

[OrangeYoshi]

You were wrong Yoshi. snoop was no where near cleared, even if you believed him.

He was just as cleared as I was. More so after the second leader lynch.

Lynching jonti may not have cost us the game but it was absolutely 100% the wrong thing to do; especailly if you were in PM contact with jonti. That makes it go from bad to :wacko:

Again with the "It's just wrong". Care to explain either how it was wrong or another line of action? Or are your arguments AOK's?

 

[OrangeYoshi]

@OY

I will point out now I named 4 people as baddies that day and all four of them were correct. Also, I told TAM in a PM that muttoneer was probably a hunter cultist (also correct)

I had OY, and snoopdogg down as goodies. Trespoe and Kriszo as likely goodies. (Which got confirmed the day after my brutalize when they were run up that easily and without much discussion), and TAM as either a desperate cannibal but a more likely goodie.

Yep. But by the time I was trying to point out how correct you both were, the goodies were already outnumbered by the baddies.

 

[randakar]

Oh and as I said many times, there was no voting record evidence against me. I didn't know anyone except 2 people no one else cared to run up a vote on anyways.

No there wasn't, but your behaviour screamed baddie on day 6, and when I was busy trying to lynch you earlier I got very little traction. That told me you were likely a baddie.

 

[johho888]

Yep. But by the time I was trying to point out how correct you both were, the goodies were already outnumbered by the baddies.

Yes, but until the sorcerer pack made contact with the Cylons I think it might have been possible for the villagers to get support from one pack of baddies each day and manage to lynch baddies from the other packs if good enough cases were presented. You managed to lynch Tornadoli the Cylon even though the Cylons by themselves at that time was almost half the village and the baddies already outnumbered the goodies.

 

[jacob-Lundgren]

No there wasn't, but your behaviour screamed baddie on day 6, and when I was busy trying to lynch you earlier I got very little traction. That told me you were likely a baddie.

The lack of traction was by other goodies or baddies that didn't know me not voting me though not baddies that knew me and I was never usually able to be online at deadlines. Evidence against me was pretty much made up. Late game sure but early on I did nothing I don't always do as a villager. I didn't even start AS a baddie for crying out loud I WAS a villager :rofl:

 

[randakar]

The lack of traction was by other goodies or baddies that didn't know me not voting me though not baddies that knew me and I was never usually able to be online at deadlines. Evidence against me was pretty much made up. Late game sure but early on I did nothing I don't always do as a villager. I didn't even start AS a baddie for crying out loud I WAS a villager :rofl:

The earlier runup was a shot in the dark. I give you that. I wasn't screaming you were a wolf back then either, was I?

It was when you started the "vote torn - unvote torn - vote aok .." thing that I went .. riiight .. and started accusing you for real.

 

[jacob-Lundgren]

The earlier runup was a shot in the dark. I give you that. I wasn't screaming you were a wolf back then either, was I?

It was when you started the "vote torn - unvote torn - vote aok .." thing that I went .. riiight .. and started accusing you for real.

I do that stuff as a villager though also I make up my fun when I have no power very often.

 

[randakar]

I do that stuff as a villager though also I make up my fun when I have no power very often.

The thing is, you were making fun while the village was in a very desperate situation. You were too damn happy for you to be a villager. Ergo, you were a baddie. And you weren't the only player who seemed too upbeat to be a villager.

 

[Lemeard]

ITT: OrangeYoshi makes a fool of himself once again

Do go on, it's amusing.

 

[randakar]

ITT: OrangeYoshi makes a fool of himself once again

Do go on, it's amusing.

Lemeard!
Go sign up for the lite game plx

 

[johho888]

The thing is, you were making fun while the village was in a very desperate situation. You were too damn happy for you to be a villager. Ergo, you were a baddie. And you weren't the only player who seemed too upbeat to be a villager.

I was thinking this too (but as a GM I knew who everyone was but still it struck me as something that the village might pick up on)

 

[sbr]

He was just as cleared as I was. More so after the second leader lynch.



Again with the "It's just wrong". Care to explain either how it was wrong or another line of action? Or are your arguments AOK's?

You aren't going to listen so I am not going to waste my breathe. if jonti was bad he would have hunted snoop at night, not made the threat public for everyone to see. You will never admit you are wrong, even if you realize it so just forget it.

 

[jonti-h]

You aren't going to listen so I am not going to waste my breathe. if jonti was bad he would have hunted snoop at night, not made the threat public for everyone to see. You will never admit you are wrong, even if you realize it so just forget it.

You need moar

emote.

 

[randakar]

So who is starting the next game?

 

[jacob-Lundgren]

The thing is, you were making fun while the village was in a very desperate situation. You were too damn happy for you to be a villager. Ergo, you were a baddie. And you weren't the only player who seemed too upbeat to be a villager.

I am the only hunter that ever hunted himself, expecting normal behavior out of me can lead to problems.

 

[OrangeYoshi]

if jonti was bad he would have hunted snoop at night, not made the threat public for everyone to see.

jonti already covered why he would do such a thing as a baddie, however.

I am the only hunter that ever hunted himself, expecting normal behavior out of me can lead to problems.

Hey, you did it on purpose. I bet you've never tried to hunt yourself on accident!

 

[randakar]

Hey, you did it on purpose. I bet you've never tried to hunt yourself on accident!

Can you leaderlynch yourself by accident next time?
Saves jonti some effort ..