• We have updated our Community Code of Conduct. Please read through the new rules for the forum that are an integral part of Paradox Interactive’s User Agreement.
Doesn't it make Jonti-h the most likely to be a wolf, since he was the first to vote for me? The more you run your mouth Jonti the more you seem to me to be a wolf, why so stressed if you're not? :rolleyes:

Repeating what i said to you back at me does not a convincing argument make.

I voted you because you are either a total liability to have around or a wolf. Neither is worth keeping around.

@ Marty - I did read the rules, just not in-depth enough to work out Pilot = 1st in command. The way people said he was, I assumed it was a bad role and that killing him would be a wise way to use my Hunter 'power'. So yeah.

Then you should have read them to see that, or asked the GM. Assuming is bad.

@Jonti: I DID admit my mistake, several times. Stop trying to take the heat from yourself to me and actually read what I've posted. Urgh.

There isn't any heat on me, apart from your flailing around, which I am enjoying immensely. Please continue.
 
Can we have a votecount?
 
UNVOTE JONTI, VOTE EMPEROR WALTER

Finally, reason to follow the vote.
 
There isn't any heat on me, apart from your flailing around, which I am enjoying immensely. Please continue.
I found it quite funny too




At least one positive so far is that the game is now quite interesting, before there was a total sense of apathy, if we can keep up this activity perhaps we might salvage this game
 
Really? You're going to lynch me?
 
Vote count:

Emperor Walter: rexodia48, Lemeard, Marty99, White Daimon (4)
Velasco: Jonti-H, Trespoe, the_hdk, johho88 (4)
Slinky: Emperor_Walter (1)
Johho88: Tornadoli (1)
Jonti-H: Velasco (1)
The_hdk: Saintis (1)

Please check
 
Repeating what i said to you back at me does not a convincing argument make.

I voted you because you are either a total liability to have around or a wolf. Neither is worth keeping around.

Then you should have read them to see that, or asked the GM. Assuming is bad.
There isn't any heat on me, apart from your flailing around, which I am enjoying immensely. Please continue.

You say the right thing for me to do is admit I made a mistake (which I had already done multiple times) but then say I should not be allowed in the game because I am a total liability (because of a single n00b mistake in my very first round).

Assuming is bad but branding newcomers to the game "total liabilities" that need to gtfo and not worthy to be kept around is good? As has been said, the rules don't actually say that, so I would never have seen them - it is implied by the 2nd in command but never explicity said, same with the fact that who a hunter kills and the hunter's identity are made public and would get the hunter lynched.

Offense is the best form of defense - you are making this big ruckus about me likely being a wolf or a terrible gamer or whatever, so that people will be busy discussing ME and not considering for a second that YOU are in fact a wolf. So yeah, there is heat on you from the start of the game if you are - as I and others suspect - one of the werewolves.
 
OOC: How about we let the scanners do their work and let them do the obvious thing and scan Velasco instead of killing him outright? He may just be lost.

Unvote Velasco

As has been said, what scanners?

Torn is right, Velasco is probably the least likely wolf among us, if he was he would undoubtedly have consulted his packmates and they would have told him not to etc.
It's like saying Rob Green is an American spy, well, not really, but meh.

not necessarily. I find it odd that Torn was first to defend Velasco. Catching up on the thread just now, I agree w/ jonti that he COULD be playing the "newbie" card. But I do feel he is, actually, a no0b. Torn's defense of him smells of wolf, however. He defends the villager as the villager is set to be lynched. Those accused of trying to lynch the villager are themselves accused of being wolves.

I made a mistake in assuming that everything was secret until the person dies - as far as I had understood all the killing/protecting/scanning/sexing etc was all anonymously done.
Obviously if I knew people would know I was the one who had killed him or that I had the knife I wouldn't have done it.

I'm not a wolf - if I was, surely I would have killed somebody as part of the pack of werewolves in secret and not by myself openly in public.
Everyone was saying Snoopdogg was the 1st in command so killing him seemed like a fun/interesting/right thing to do.
And its pretty obvious the people who will press hardest for me to be lynched will be the actual wolves who will want one less villager.

Btw, unvote Eternaly_Lost, vote Jonti-h

just wrong in so many ways.

True, but as a baddie, he would have gotten instruction from other wolves. I doubt they would tell him to use his ability so early.
Also, I agree with OrangeYoshi - velasco will be scanned early, so let's wait until that happens.

For the time being:

Unvote OrangeYoshi
Vote johho888


Straight in the bandwagon.

Again, what scanners?

Okay, who to vote for
Obviously there's f*** all to work with, but I think the best way is to vote those who bandwagoned Velasco, particularly the more experienced ones who should know better:
(jonti), the-hdk, trespoe and johho888
jonti was the first to do so I'll give him a pass

Vote Trespoe

which fits in nicely with the earlier theory of those wanting to lynch Velasco being accused of lycanthropy.

Unvote Velasco the No0b

Vote Tornadoli


he is setting off my wolfdar. Emperor Walter was also, so he is good choice, also.
 
Ohh and the theory that perhaps he is a goodie scanner is totally crazy. I can't even begin to fathom why anyone would come to this strange and obscure conclusion

It wasn't any sort of a "conclusion", just an interesting possibility that I wanted to discuss.

Marty is right, though, that if a clueless newbie had that role that he would've already said he did instead of just saying he wasn't a baddie.