Both are not #1 at the moment, that much i can say
I'd expect Communitarian and naggy to be in the top three, I'd say that the other 600 score is either mine or Plancks.
Also, can you tell us which AAR got the 99 and 1 score?
-
We have updated our Community Code of Conduct. Please read through the new rules for the forum that are an integral part of Paradox Interactive’s User Agreement.
- Status
I'd expect Communitarian and naggy to be in the top three, I'd say that the other 600 score is either mine or Plancks.
Also, can you tell us which AAR got the 99 and 1 score?
Yes, No, No, Yes
Pallen was it who got 99 and 1 from different Judges
-------------------------------
Scores Update:
We also have new standings today with:
- 9 legit scores that can count for the contest
- 4 scores that still need a revision to be legit
- 4 missing scores
Here are the current scores (including 3 of those scores that still need a revision):
Look how close most are together!
There are even two who have exactly the same score =)
Also alittle more statistic:
The #1 AAR got only 1 time 99 but the highest overall scores through the bank till now
The #2 AAR got 4 times the 99 but also some low scores mixed in
One AAR got 4 times the 1 but is still not the last
One AAR got 2 times the 1 but is still in the top 10
Two AAR´s got at least 1 times the 99 but are not jet in the top 10
The last one got only one time the 1 but the lowest overall points
Last edited:
Okay, from that we can determine:
* Communitarian is currently in the top three
* Naggy is fifth or lower (as he is not in the top three, nor is he fourth)
* I am not fourth
* Planck is fourth.
Am I right? also, are Moonstruck & Fire and Ash in the bottom 5? I quite liked their work but they suffered from some point deductions.
Dont forget, that answer was aimed at the former standings, it changed with the current standings again.
Moonstruck & Fire and Ash are not in the top 10 with the current standings.
I agree, i liked their AAR´s too, a shame that they didnt carried on with it.
Point deductions are done at the end by me and are not reflected in those standings jet.
you are making it unbearable to wait for the results ^^
I would say Communitarian is second, I bet his AAR could get the 4x99 while still scaring some away by the amount of text
I would say Communitarian is second, I bet his AAR could get the 4x99 while still scaring some away by the amount of text
Last edited:
That's true.I would say Communitarian is second, I bet his AAR could get the 4x99 while still scaring some away by the amount of text
Alex, could you rank the AARs by number of 1's they recieved? The more random statistics you can provide in lieu of actual results the better!
I'm not going to even guess the standings, but I am sure I will be surprised when the final results are announced.
Just as a small spoiler, get ready for more action soon!
Just as a small spoiler, get ready for more action soon!
I'm just hoping I'm not in dead last, that's my only expectation for my AAR. In any case, I think Ottomans, Letters, and Metternich will be up there in the top 5.
New Scores Update:
Hot and fresh! We have new standings today with:
- 12 legit scores that can count for the contest
- 2 scores that still need a revision to be legit
- 3 missing scores
I also included the penalty points this time.
Here are the current scores (including 1 of those scores that still need a revision):
Look at around place 10... this is a tough fight on whos gonna get into the Top 10!
The #2 got another 99 and could cover some ground to the #1,
but its still more than 100 points behind.
Will it be able to overtake the #1 in the last scores that will come in?
Other changes:
The former #10 covered ground and is now the #9
#7 and #8 changed position
#11 lost a position and is now #12
There are also some changed positions on the end of the score table
because of the inclusion of the penalty points.
Hot and fresh! We have new standings today with:
- 12 legit scores that can count for the contest
- 2 scores that still need a revision to be legit
- 3 missing scores
I also included the penalty points this time.
Here are the current scores (including 1 of those scores that still need a revision):
Look at around place 10... this is a tough fight on whos gonna get into the Top 10!
The #2 got another 99 and could cover some ground to the #1,
but its still more than 100 points behind.
Will it be able to overtake the #1 in the last scores that will come in?
Other changes:
The former #10 covered ground and is now the #9
#7 and #8 changed position
#11 lost a position and is now #12
There are also some changed positions on the end of the score table
because of the inclusion of the penalty points.
Hmm... well lets see (with the current standings):
Land der Dichter und Denker (Moonstruck) - 4
Wishing for the Sun (MJJ55409) - 3
Dar var et yndigt land (Pallen) - 3
WhAAR? A NowhAAR of Iceland (Surume) - 2
Unification of Italy (Ricox) - 1
No 1 point scores recieved:
Letters from an Unquiet August (Communitarian)
Legend of the Marble Emperor (Alerias)
Onze Plaats in de Zon (Tanzhang)
Sick Man of Europe (Naggy)
Central Asian Might (Brandenburg III)
Portugal's Second Coming (Scholar)
Legacy of Metternich (Forgiven)
Making of Empire of Brazil (Planck)
Pope's Tale (Poh)
Beer, Chocolate & Waffles (TekcoR)
Queen of the Adriatic (Twichy Boy)
Viva ArgentinAAR (Polar Mongoose)
History as it Should Have Been Written (Jarloresl)
Better to Send 5 Lions (Fire and Ash)
Now what could that mean? I am so curious!
You are not last, and yes, yes and no. (at the current standings)
You are in the lower half of the points (below rank 10) with the current standings,
but your position can change with every vote that comes in
EDIT:
The top 6 are the same AARs, but not necessarily in the same order.
The fact that he vanished from this forum and didnt report back till now surly didnt help him in getting points,
if he had carried on with his AAR, i am sure he could have made it in the top 10.
Tastes differ, but with so many judges it all evens out at some point
The fact that he vanished from this forum and didnt report back till now surly didnt help him in getting points,
if he had carried on with his AAR, i am sure he could have made it in the top 10.
Judges were not supposed to take the number of posts into account. Still, the decision is theirs to make, there's no point in complaining. (Although when the contest is over, motives may be clarified.)
I am not complaining, of course its all the decisions and personal choices of the judges
I was just speculating on what he could have done better (besides on finishing the AAR)
And i hope that at least some judges will take the additional time to explain their points score.
Its not required but i encourage it and hope to read some =)
Hey its your first AAR, and you had some readers, alot of views and i am sure you had some fun with it and learned 1 or 2 things,
so even if you dont make it into the top 10, i hope you had a good time and i thank you (and everyone) for taking part!
- Status