reis91 said:
Coherence maybe? If I had done anything, you would point out what I previously said and accuse me of incoherence. I must recognize that I missed the deadline, though, got caught up watching TV. Feel free to check if I was posting, although it won't help you.
Now, Bagricula, well, he was in the running so he had the self-preservation excuse. I must give this some thought, before committing my heavier-than-usual vote.
@ Boris: Read what I said on day 1. If you still want to lynch me then, go ahead and try.
Coherence? So you didn't do something that would have been useful for the village, because you had actively opposed doing that thing that was useful for the village? Is that the only real reason you did it? Wolves' primary concern is to appear consistent. Everyone else's primary concern is catching wolves. How about you try and catch some wolves?
reis91 said:
How was I supposed to know it would be disastrous? AFAIK there could be wolves in there. Why would I save them?
Not that having one more villager die fits my definition of disastrous, by the way...
Would you like us to play one hundred games in a row TIEing people on the first day before it sinks in that a TIE on the first day is the most likely to see two villagers caught, the most likely to see them die without it netting us any information, and the most likely to see the seer get killed (he doesn't have a JL working to protect him)?
Plenty of people have been telling you it would be disastrous. You could have realized it would be disastrous by listening to their arguments. For hundreds of games we have stuck to the format "lynch one person a day". Unless you have some seriously brilliant theory, which you can definitively prove, and then show us examples of, you should stick to that format.
reis91 said:
We can use ties. We just need to ensure they are made of wolves, and that task is made more difficult when each and every villager takes into his own hands to save someone, while having no data on said someone that makes him less likely a wolf than another guy.
These are the kinds of posts that make it impossible for me to take you seriously. "We just need to ensure they are made of wolves" is the kind of statement that has no relevance to actually analyzing the game. Have you ever considered that no villagers here are taking it into their hands to save someone, and that we're just trying to avoid TIEs and bring up the people we find the most suspicious? YOU take it into your own hands, and try to save people you don't know. EVERYBODY ELSE analyzes and votes and tries to lynch the person they think is a wolf.
Listen to Vainglory, he argues my points better than I can.
---
At the end of the day, reis91 is like tamius23 was. tamius23 seems like he might actually be learning his lesson and playing better. I somehow doubt reis91 will ever stop being a liability for the village.
VOTE REIS91
And I'm really sorry I don't have anything more useful or original to say.