• We have updated our Community Code of Conduct. Please read through the new rules for the forum that are an integral part of Paradox Interactive’s User Agreement.

Viking_Manstein

Major
5 Badges
May 18, 2010
537
0
  • Crusader Kings II
  • Hearts of Iron III
  • Semper Fi
  • 500k Club
  • Hearts of Iron IV Sign-up
Hello everyone this AAR is gonna be a Japan AAR starting in 1936 and using the Black Ice mod (which btw is a awesome and which everyone should try :) ). I will be playing on normal difficulty as it is ages since I have really played hearts of iron 3. The AAR will be written in two styles so to speak, my standard way of having conferences between the major leaders where the writing will be in dialogue form and the diary of my main character, general Yamashita. I will try to arrange my game as historically as possible, I wont play to win, more like to provide a view of the deep rivalries between the different Japanese armed forces, for instance between the army and navy. I should say that my knowledge of the Japanese chains of commands, historic general's etc are limited so I might make mistakes when it comes to this. I will also try to show my main character's personal view's and the way he tries to advocate his vision of the way forward, he will not allways get his way when it comes to how the war effort(s) will be directed.

Anyways, hope you guys will enjoy it, wish me best of luck :)
 
Last edited:
The land of the Rising sun

'
'
Japan's history had been in many ways quite unique, the nation had been isolated through most of the middle ages, except for when the Mongols tried to invade the Japanese home islands with a huge fleet. The invasion was, however, beaten off my stout Japanese resistance and a storm, or Kamikaze (divine wind) that sank the invading fleet. The sengoku period, or the period of the warring kingdoms swept across the lands in the 16th century. With the establishment of the Tokugawa shogunate isolation continued and the nation prospered under centuries of peace. For instance, the production of rice almost quadrupled between the 17th and 18th centuries. However, little technological progress was made, besides the introduction of irrigation and similar advancements in farming.

The isolation ended abruptly on the 8th of July 1853 when US warships steamed into Yokohama bay and forced the shogun to sign a trade and amnesty treaty. This caused a pro imperial part of the nation's leaders to rally round the emperor who rejected the shogun's treaty with the Americans. After a civil war power was rally round the emperor and the country entered into a lightning industrialization unlike anything else in the world's history. Japan's rapid industrialization posed a problem for Japan.

The Japanese home islands did simply not have the resources that the nation's needed, such as iron and coal, which were vital to their industry. The Japanese had also reformed their army to meet western standards and on the 1st of August 1894 the Japanese declared war on China's Qing dynasty. The war lasted about a year and resulted in a huge Japanese victory, they conquered Korea, Taiwan and Port Arthur, but after pressure from the west they were forced to hand Port Arthur over to the Russians. To the Japanese this western interference was outrageous and the Japanese high command started planning their revenge on the Russians.

eupq21.jpg

(Japanese soldiers during the Sino-Japanese war.)​

Japan started courting the British and by 1904 they managed to secure an alliance with the British so that they could keep the French and Germans from interfering in the planned Japanese war with the Russian Empire. On the 8th of February 1904 the Japanese went to action against the Russians, they attacked the Russian fleet at their base at Port Arthur. During the next year the Japanese fought several battles on land with the Russians and steadily drove them longer and longer into Manchuria. The final battles was between the Japanese fleet and the main Russians fleet that had traveled all the way from their bases in the Baltic and in the Black sea region. When the two fleets met at Tsushima the Russians were thrashed and the Japanese victory was reality. The war damaged Russian prestige and led to large revolts against the Tzar in the Russian heartland. Japanese conditions were severe, the Russians were forced to hand over half of Sakhalin, leave Manchuria and give Port Arthur and the rest of the Liaodong peninsula. Japan had now beaten the "big bear" and they were firmly established as one of the great nations of the world.

2jam1xz.jpg

(Japanese troops hold a stone wall during the Russo-Japanese war.)​

When world war 1 broke out the Japanese joined the entente and occupied German bases in the pacific and after the war they were rewarded with these after the war. During the great war and shortly after, the Japanese industry had experienced a huge boom, the eastern market's were virtually abandoned by the western nations and the Japanese could sell their good without much competition.

This was, however, not to last. When the war was well over the British, French and Americans returned and the Japanese were given the sharp end of the stick, this caused a recession in Japan and during the late 20's and early 30's the Japanese became more and more hostile towards the west. When the Japanese in the 20's demanded to be allowed to build a fleet equal to that of the US and where declined they withdrew they signature from all naval treaties and broke their alliance with the British. Fascism became increasingly popular in Japan during the Great Depression and nationalism sprung up, especially among the army.

In 1933 the Japanese troops on the borders of Manchuria invaded without the government in Tokyo's orders or blessing and over the next years the Japanese consolidated the new territory and established it as a puppet state ruled by the last Chinese emperor Pu-Yi. The league of nations condemned the Japanese actions and this caused Japan to withdraw from the league. One of the few nations which recognized the new Manchurian state was Germany, causing Japan to drift more and more towards Hitler's Germany. What lay in stall for the land of the rising sun for the future, no one knew, but some had very strong suspicions...

mmy0w3.jpg

(Japanese expansion from the boshin war until 1936 (except the islands gained during ww1.))​
 
Diary entry 1, January 1st 1936

I have just been given command of all troops on the Chinese mainland, this is great honor bestowed upon me by the emperor and I pray that I will prove worthy of the task.
I know that several members of the government and many members of the military want to expand our territories in China and that they therefore want more troops handed under my command.
While I feel honored by the responsibility I can't help but feel that we are not ready for a war right now.
The Chinese might seem weak, but I don't think they are as weak as they look to most of my countrymen.
Besides I feel that invading China would make the westerners look at us as if we were uncivilized monkeys and we need to be able to purchase their resources for our industrial needs.
I am very much afraid that a war with China would eventually lead to a war with the west.
If this were to happen I would be deeply afraid for my nation as our forces are not as modern as those of the west.
Even so I would do my utmost to see that my duties are carried out as efficiently as possible, no matter what happens.
In a few days I will travel to Tokyo for a meeting with the leaders of our nation and the emperor.



General of all Japanese troops in Korea and Manchuria:

Tomoyuki Yamashita


2ajf38.jpg
 
Last edited:
This looks interesting, there are not many Japan AARs around.
Historically, that means you won't try to divide and conquer your enemies, as in keep the USA out of the fight till the other allies are kicked out of Asia? This should be interesting...
 
I've always wanted to play a game as Japan but I've never had the experience or a single idea how to go about it, hopefully this AAR will help. Will be following
 
This looks interesting, there are not many Japan AARs around.
Historically, that means you won't try to divide and conquer your enemies, as in keep the USA out of the fight till the other allies are kicked out of Asia? This should be interesting...

That is right, of course I will try to finish off China before I go to war with Britain and the US, but Hell, if China is not beaten by the historical DoW on the US I will go to war nonetheless :)

I've always wanted to play a game as Japan but I've never had the experience or a single idea how to go about it, hopefully this AAR will help. Will be following

I surely hope so :)

Glad to have both of you on board :)
 
I´ve managed to read the introduction, you can count me in though! :D
 
looks fascinating. Love Japan AAR's. Good luck with your future endeavors and long live the emperor!
 
Sounds good looking forward to more. I also have a hard time playing as Japan. Can never master the naval aspect. Hope this teaches me some of it. Subscribed.
 
Looking forward to the next update.

It's about half finished, but the weekend kind of slowed it down a bit :)

looks fascinating. Love Japan AAR's. Good luck with your future endeavors and long live the emperor!

Thank you. Long live the emperor indeed :)

Sounds good looking forward to more. I also have a hard time playing as Japan. Can never master the naval aspect. Hope this teaches me some of it. Subscribed.

I am no master of naval aspects by any means, but will do my best, hope you will enjoy it ! :)
 
1936, a new year.

Imperial Palace, Tokyo, February 6th 18.12 PM​

*On the 6th of February the emperor Hirohito finally called his main ministers and generals to him, they would discuss the future of Japan and how they could best improve conditions within the land of the rising sun. General Yamashita had expected the conference to be held in early January, but it had been delayed by several weeks because of a coup attempt in Tokyo. *

a9snqf.jpg

(The entrance to the Imperial palace in Tokyo.)​

Hirohito: Thank you for coming gentlemen, I have several issues that I wish to discuss with you today. First on my list is an apology for the delayer on our meeting. Some of you have been told that there was a coup a few days ago, in which some of our soldiers tried to take control of Tokyo. I am sorry to say that this coup has been affiliated with our current government, the people are not too happy about it and dissent is growing.

11liv05.jpg

*Goto Fumio, Japan's minister of security rises as the emperor waits for solutions to the growing dissent.*

Goto Fumio: My emperor, we can step up consumer goods production to keep the populace happy, as long as they can buy their radios and sake they will forget this coup in a few weeks.

Hirohito: Agreed, you have my permission to do just that. We also need to make the control clique more popular, do you think that your spies can step up their activities in helping the party gain popularity and keep dissenters quiet mr Shiro?

*The room falls silent and OkamuraYasuji rises*

Okamura Yasuji: My emperor, maybe you've forgotten, but I hold the post of minister of intelligence.

Hirohito: you did hold that post, I have fired you, just like I have fired Osumi Mineo as chief of the Navy, our new chief of the navy will be Isoroku Yamamoto. The fact that you Yasuji where unable to warn me about a coup that almost overthrew the officials of this nation proves your incompetence. Yamamoto, since you are now chief of the navy, Hata Shunroku will replace you as will be our new chief of the air force, Yasuji and Mineo, you can leave the room, your services are no longer needed.

*The two men leave the room without saying anything, but before they leave they both bow in respect of the emperor. After the two men have gone the new minister of intelligence, Takasu Shiro rises up and speaks.*

5b3ceb.jpg

Takasu Shiro: I will indeed do what you ask my emperor, I will get a greater number of spies within our borders and they will certainly do their best to strengthen the party's popularity.

Hirohito: Excellent, I will be inquiring on your progress later in the year.

2mpdgmr.jpg

*At this point the head of the government, Okada Keisuke stands up*

Okada Keisuke: My emperor I strongly suggest that we pass a few new laws, to replace the old ones, we should change our industrial focus from a consumer based industry to a more mixed industry, this will allow us to produce more supplies and war materials, which we can use ourselves or sell to other nations. Before the meeting I also talked to general Yamashita, he suggested that we lengthen the training period's of our recruits, so that their performance will be better, sure they will take longer to train, but it is better with fewer trained men, than huge numbers of barely trained men. After all we don't want our armed forces to resemble those of the USSR.

33agzzm.jpg

Hirohito: I agree with you, the laws will be changed. I would like to hear from all of you what you think our research should be based on, I have made a list myself, but I would like to hear what you think.

Yamashita: We need better Radio technology, this would benefit all armed forces. The army, especially the men under my command have outdated support weapons, I suggest the production of a new mortar as well as new light artillery. We also need fabricated camouflage. I also suggest that a few of our generals should try to go deeper into the tactics of the great war and try to learn from them. I am sure that field marshal Kanin would agree.

*Kanin who is both chief of staff and chief of the army nods.*

Hirohito: I agree with you, anyone else?

*The armaments minister, Machida Chuji rises*

Machida Chuji: Yes my emperor: I believe we need to strengthen our industry and our education system need to get better. I also think that we should develop new medicine, this would help both our troops and our population.

* Hata Shunroku, the new chief of the air force stands up.*

Hata Shunroku: The air force also has needs and without a proper air force the army or navy won't be able to function. We need a new fuel tank for our interceptors and also a new airframe, the fighter pilots will also need more training.

Hirohito: Very well, Machida Chuji will be responsible for the research of these new projects, here is the full list Machida:

• Industry
• Monumental architecture
• Giant infrastructure projects
• Education
• Medicine
• Secretary of public information and education
• Broadcasting
• Supply production
• Radio detection equipment
• Radios
• Infantry support weapons
• Camouflage designs
• Light artillery
• Range finding equipment
• Artillery barrel and ammunition
• Basic small fuel tank
• Basic single engine airframe
• Great war analysis
• Fighter pilot training

Machida Chuji: I will go to work at once, however, if we are going to do all these projects I will have to take some resources away from our intelligence, diplomatic and officers sectors.

Hirohito: That will be fine for now. Gentlemen, I must tell you that there have been a new wave of Korean nationalists, they are stirring up trouble all the time.

i762xs.jpg

Yamashita: I will take care of the problem my emperor, Korea is firm within our grasp, they are not going anywhere. To this end I would support that we build up a party militia to be sent to Korea or Manchuria to keep the peace, they don't need to be well equipped or well trained, ruthless and scary will do the trick I think, don't you agree Kanin?

Kanin: Yes, that sounds like a good idea, I support it hole heatedly.

Hirohito: Very well, you shall have it.

24e584n.jpg

Yamashita: We also have to decide whether we should produce our tanks with casting or welding techniques, I support welding, but I don't know what mr Chuji has to say to that.

Machida Chuji: I have to disagree, cast tanks will be much faster to make at a very small sacrifice to their quality. Our industry is burdened enough by ship and air production, we can't spend a lot of Industrial capacity on building tanks.

Yamamoto: I agree, the navy needs all the resources it can get.

Hirohito: Very well, cast armor it is.

Yamashita: I must also bring up whether we should go for gasoline or diesel engines for our tanks. I would say that gasoline is better for our purposes, we don't need fuel that won't freeze at -30 as our operational area will be in Manchuria and our pacific holdings.

Machida Chuji: You are right Yamashita.

Kanin: As do I.

Yamamoto: I do not think that this is a good idea, what if we were put under blockade by the western powers, then the navy and air force would need most of our fuel, if the army let's their tanks go on diesel instead then it can use second grade fuel and the navy and air force can more easily get what it needs.

Hirohito: A sound argument Yamamoto, I agree, diesel it is.

*Yamashita and Kanin look disappointed.*

f1muyf.jpg

Yamashita: Are we all talking like we are expecting a war with the west, is there something in your plans my emperor that I have not heard about ?

Hirohito: Well, the reason I have appointed you in China is obviously because we are waiting for, in fact, desiring a war with China and we are not sure how the west will react to this.

Yamashita: I do not support any of this, but I will say that we can win a war with China, only if the west leaves us to do it in peace, we can't fight both at the same time and hope to win.

Yamamoto: I do not won't to sounds like a defeatist, but I have to agree with Yamashita, the navy is still not strong enough to take on the British, not to mention the Americans.

Hirohito: Relax gentlemen, if a war with China happens I will make sure that we are left to do our business in peace.

*Yamashita and Yamamoto look disillusioned, but they both nod in respect.*

Hirohito: Mr Chuji, do you have anything else for us ?

Machida Chuji: Yes I do, we have to decide whether to build up our synthetic industries further, this will drain our production in other areas, but we will be able to survive a blockade more easily.

Hirohito: I agree, you may go forward and build up a larger synthetic industry. What are we actually producing at the moment Mr Chuji?

288gsl.jpg

Machida Chuji: Right now we are building new heavy cruisers and carriers with their compliment of aircraft. We will increase our production of consumer goods to keep the public happy and Yamashita have requested that we need to upgrade the equipment of most of our men, so I have granted resources to do that as well. We are also making a lot of war supplies to sell, our budget is not as well balanced as it should be.

Yamamoto: I have looked at your report and I am satisfied that we are focusing on the naval production, the army has enough divisions I would say to deal with any incident against the Chinese.

Yamashita: One can never have enough trained men, but for now I am happy with getting better equipment for my forces.

Kanin: I strongly suggest that the army needs more divisions for the future.

Hirohito: You remarks are noted Yamashita and Kanin, but for now I am happy with the state of our industrial output. Anything else Mr Chuji?

rbcn0j.jpg

Machida Chuji: Well, this is not really up to me to decide, but our airplane factories have asked whether we want to focus on light or heavy aircraft production.

Hata Shunroku: I would say that we should focus on light airplane production, that will increase the numbers of planes to do tactical missions, the production of carrier aircraft will be increased and our factories can build far more fighter planes to keep any enemy away from our home soil.

Yamamoto: I agree.

Yamashita: As do I.

Hirohito: Good that we can all agree.

334qgxu.jpg

Hirota Koki: If I may my emperor I would like to talk about our diplomatic front.

Hirohito: Of course Mr Koki, go ahead.

Hirota Koki: We have been asked by numerous small European nations for licenses to produce our KI-59 Mitsubishi light bomber. I have agreed to this as we are not going to fight any of them and it will bring in money to us. I have also talked to the American ambassador and they will be happy to purchase supplies from us at the usual exchange rate.

1o0u4g.jpg

Hirohito: I agree. I would like you, however, to start aligning towards Germany, I have already sent my brother on a European trip where he will meet with Adolf Hitler, Germany is a going to be a giant in the west under Hitler and since our relationship with the British is ruined we are better off with the Germans.

Hirota Koki: I will contact the German ambassador immediately. I almost forgot, but I have also contacted the BIS (Bank for international settlements) in Switzerland and they are most happy to buy supplies from us.

acfj42.jpg

Hirohito: Go ahead, we need the money. Gentlemen, we have to decide what our industry is going to be focused on this year, expanding the army, navy or air force, what do you think?

Kanin: I would love to say the army, but since all these new ships are being produced we should probably focus on that this year.

Yamashita: I share the viewpoint of general Kanin.

Yamamoto: I am happy to hear that, I would of course advocate for the navy.

Hirohito: Very well, then we agree. Is there anything else before we can conclude this meeting?

wve3nt.jpg

Kanin: Yes, we should decide whether to reinforce our garrisons in the pacific with new troops.

Yamamoto: This has to be done, they are very exposed as it is.

Hirohito: Very well, Kanin, you may proceed with this. I think this concludes matters for this time gentlemen, thank you all.

wqzm7m.jpg

*All the ministers bow in respect and leave the room.*

PS: When war with China starts I am going to write reports from Yamashita to the other ministers.
 
Last edited:
Diary entry 2, February 7th 1936.

Last night I had a meeting with the emperor as well as the other ministers, generals and admirals. In the meeting we discussed matters of production, diplomacy and military. I tried during the meeting to push for the production of welded tanks and that we should use gasoline engines, in both of these matters I was beaten off by the chief of the navy, Yamamoto and the armaments minister Chuji. I did, however manage to persuade the others that we needed new equipment for the army and that we needed to develop new weapons for use by the army. I found the new chief of the navy, Yamamoto to be very reasonable man compared to the other admirals I have dealt with. No matter how reasonable he advocated strongly for the navy, that they should be prioritized in matters of production etc. I was surprised by the fact that almost all the others present were seemingly just waiting for a war with China and the fact that the west could intervene did not seem to scare any of them from the idea, except Yamamoto. Is my dear country a pressure cooker running out of control, I do not know. Tomorrow I return to Manchuria to start a long process of restructuring the chains of command and firing most of the generals in command, I do not know what kind of response this will trigger, but if I am in command then I have the right to do it.

General of all Japanese troops in Manchuria and Korea.

Tomoyuki Yamashita


atm55d.jpg

(The new carrier Soryu under construction.)
 
Last edited:
I´m surprised that Emperor just agrees with everything. I know he needs to be surrounder by people, who know something "better" than he does but I just can´t see him as a guy, who just rotates ministers. Make him more active! :p

I like it so far, at least until you won´t start writing essays :D
 
I´m surprised that Emperor just agrees with everything. I know he needs to be surrounder by people, who know something "better" than he does but I just can´t see him as a guy, who just rotates ministers. Make him more active! :p

I like it so far, at least until you won´t start writing essays :D

Yeah, was not my best work, I think it will be easier to develop his character when the war starts and plans have to be made, hope I can keep you interested until then :)
 
I like the mix of letters and cabinet meetings. One quick question: did you change the Chief of the Navy for any particular reason or was it just for historical means?

It was just for historical purposes :) Glad you like it :)