• We have updated our Community Code of Conduct. Please read through the new rules for the forum that are an integral part of Paradox Interactive’s User Agreement.
I sent leksu's name to aedan and Wagon because they hadn't voted Panzer, unlike Hax and snoop. I wouldn't discount any possibility, as most good WW players would rather hunt a zombie than someone good at that juncture.

(Except #3.)
 
Bravo, fellows. Say, has there ever been a sort of reverse Stalingrad before (village lynches wolves and only wolves)? You seem well on your way to that.
the second to last Big (CLVI: Council of Trent), actually. But that was due to overabundance of wolves (3 packs). village still lost.. In a standard lite, losing such a game is not possible, of course(when lynching only wolves).

i'll go with vote Punkbob for now. His non-abidance to the outing was odd. (unless he was online far too short and got ninja'd by it)
 
Hmmm. At the moment I'm leaning toward #3 as the best option, since I know I'm not a wolf, wagonlitz seems somewhat unlikely, and going for #4 puts us back to square one. Though I'm hardly certain.

Vote Arkasas
 
Vote aedan

Placeholder vote, too early to determine.
 
It is better to die for the Emperor than to live for yourself.

You're aware this is about Charlemagne's Empire, not the God-Emperor of Mankind's?
 
Vote wagonlitz

Why?

He is Torbjørn Haraldsbane the Berserker.

Yet he could have been Oger de Danemarche. I guess that's vaguely suspect.
 
Gylaug wakes up after a 2 day poison-inflicted coma. Poisonous mushrooms is an insufficiently lethal weapon to be used on a such a great warrior as Gylaug. The devilish Germanic tribesman and his minions the Yngling child and wee man Bilbo Baggins had failed miserably in their attempt to assassinate their gravest threat. Gylaug is delighted with his efforts catching hairy monsters. His offerings have made Odin grant them 3 beasts at the petty cost of 2 men carrying sticks and one man clad in armour so heavy he could not move. No wonder the beasts got to them. Very few people are cut out to be such fine and mighty warriors as Gylaug. The only man remotely likely to match Gylaug among this merry band of of ill-prepared warriors would have to be the Dane:

viking-festival-art-g3cmmtr0-1viking-festival-fs-2-jpg.jpg


Haraldsbane's head on a pole would be such a great offering Odin would likely show them the whereabouts of the lost child in return:

vote Wagon

Gylaug gets up. Best not waste any more time if he is to claim the reward for finding this missing child of the king of Franks. There are some cellars in the village he has yet to investigate.

[OT]

@Tonka: I retract everything I said about your theory. It's as good, if not better than my own.

At least 2/3 of this lazy arse wolfpack voted PanzerWulf. I'm so done making multi-quoting, coloured names posts. My Sherlock Holmes costume has been binned. *dons his Dr. Watson costume* The only piece of my puzzle that's still intact is you Sherlock Marty. Please tell me this is elementary.

I'm not entirely convinced there was no way to deduct the probable identity of the seer. Wouldn't the fact he approached an unscanned person at this junction be indicative of... something? Not as obvious as those who definitely knew his identity I admit. Although not entirely comfortable, I'll follow the lead of those who know better than me.

I believe my vote may have placed Wagon in an undesirable big lead. I chose him due to a combination of matching the narrative in my saga of Gylaug and him acting the executioner fitting what I would regard as his best shot at an alibi given the circumstances. This place Wagon an inch ahead of the competition in suspiciousness in my fuzzy mind.

@Marty: You directed that double lynching in an impeccable manner. Please do direct my vote elsewhere if needed to bag us the remaining dirty scoundrel.

[/OT]

Oy
 
Gylaug wakes up after a 2 day poison-inflicted coma. Poisonous mushrooms is an insufficiently lethal weapon to be used on a such a great warrior as Gylaug. The devilish Germanic tribesman and his minions the Yngling child and wee man Bilbo Baggins had failed miserably in their attempt to assassinate their gravest threat. Gylaug is delighted with his efforts catching hairy monsters. His offerings have made Odin grant them 3 beasts at the petty cost of 2 men carrying sticks and one man clad in armour so heavy he could not move. No wonder the beasts got to them. Very few people are cut out to be such fine and mighty warriors as Gylaug. The only man remotely likely to match Gylaug among this merry band of of ill-prepared warriors would have to be the Dane:

viking-festival-art-g3cmmtr0-1viking-festival-fs-2-jpg.jpg


Haraldsbane's head on a pole would be such a great offering Odin would likely show them the whereabouts of the lost child in return:

vote Wagon

Gylaug gets up. Best not waste any more time if he is to claim the reward for finding this missing child of the king of Franks. There are some cellars in the village he has yet to investigate.

[OT]

@Tonka: I retract everything I said about your theory. It's as good, if not better than my own.

At least 2/3 of this lazy arse wolfpack voted PanzerWulf. I'm so done making multi-quoting, coloured names posts. My Sherlock Holmes costume has been binned. *dons his Dr. Watson costume* The only piece of my puzzle that's still intact is you Sherlock Marty. Please tell me this is elementary.

I'm not entirely convinced there was no way to deduct the probable identity of the seer. Wouldn't the fact he approached an unscanned person at this junction be indicative of... something? Not as obvious as those who definitely knew his identity I admit. Although not entirely comfortable, I'll follow the lead of those who know better than me.

I believe my vote may have placed Wagon in an undesirable big lead. I chose him due to a combination of matching the narrative in my saga of Gylaug and him acting the executioner fitting what I would regard as his best shot at an alibi given the circumstances. This place Wagon an inch ahead of the competition in suspiciousness in my fuzzy mind.

@Marty: You directed that double lynching in an impeccable manner. Please do direct my vote elsewhere if needed to bag us the remaining dirty scoundrel.

[/OT]

Oy
You have to remember though that I could easily have failed at my snipe. You know yourself how easy it is to be a few seconds late for a counter snipe, so a failed counter snipe would also have given me a good alibi; I doesn't make sense for a wolf to succesfully counter snipe.
Regarding the two others I still don't know who is more suspicious. Arkasas had to make the outing when approached, so he could easily be a wolf; but so could aedan.
Regarding your theory of deducting who was seer, I don't really think that was possible. The seer had to approach an unscanned player, since all his scans had bagged wolves, so that doesn't really give any information. It could still have been a lucky hunt though.

Vote count:

Wagonlitz: 3
THE_SPLIT [273]
Cliges [292]
oyoyoy [293]

punkbob: 1
Chieron [284]

arkasas: 1
aedan777 [285]

aedan777: 1
alxeu [286]

Not voted: 5
Arkasas []
Wagonlitz []
marty99 []
tonkatoy5 []
Punkbob []
 
You have to remember though that I could easily have failed at my snipe. You know yourself how easy it is to be a few seconds late for a counter snipe, so a failed counter snipe would also have given me a good alibi; I doesn't make sense for a wolf to succesfully counter snipe.
I believe you failing the snipe would have put you on top of the lynching list as soon as people were told you knew the identity of the seer. I reckon you were damned if you do and damned if you don't. Choosing the alternative that provides you an alibi does not strike me as inconceivable. The other 2 wolves would have had to make the un-tie'ing vote(s) to create a good outcome from a wolfish pov.

I'm tempted to say that Arkasas looks the least likely suspect going by day 1 voting. He voted Panzer and was beside myself the known wolves candidate for lynching:

Sie don't have to do zis Hax. Ich svitch if sie svitch. Let'z kill non-foting heazen instead.
Jawoll! Archie or oyoyoyoy?
That may not be much to go on judging by the the kindslaying nature of this wolfpack, but from my sparse experience in the game Ark seem like too much of a teamplayer to be made prime suspect.

You and Aedan voted me/Ark on day one and both followed the lead of known wolves on your day 2 pre-outing votes. As such I have you 2 equal ahead of Ark. I picked you on a hunch, but at the same time asked for directions.

Regarding your theory of deducting who was seer, I don't really think that was possible. The seer had to approach an unscanned player, since all his scans had bagged wolves, so that doesn't really give any information. It could still have been a lucky hunt though.
It was only day 2. The odds of the seer surviving another night were pretty good. Wouldn't an experienced seer be able to predict the (possible) outcome we've had? I would have thought it presented better odds staying silent one more day as opposed to the risk of being hunted in the scenario we had. Apparently I'm wrong (no surprise considering my lousy math skills), but I imagined it possible someone could pinpoint/guess Leksu based on what they perceived an inexperienced act of a seer.

And that concludes today's brainfart from yours truly. Everyone agree we should do the obvious and I will abide by that.

Oy
 
It was only day 2. The odds of the seer surviving another night were pretty good. Wouldn't an experienced seer be able to predict the (possible) outcome we've had? I would have thought it presented better odds staying silent one more day as opposed to the risk of being hunted in the scenario we had. Apparently I'm wrong (no surprise considering my lousy math skills), but I imagined it possible someone could pinpoint/guess Leksu based on what they perceived an inexperienced act of a seer.
Oy
There was a chance of 1/11 for getting the seer by luck, so yes he would probably have survived. On the other hand there also only was a 1/11 chance for him to catch the last wolf. So considering he had two wolves and thereby almost guanranteed victory for the village, it would be stupid to wait, since the chance of catching the last wolf was low same as the chance of him dieing; he would of course have had a villager then, but he would still risk an almost certain village victory.
 
the second to last Big (CLVI: Council of Trent), actually. But that was due to overabundance of wolves (3 packs). village still lost.. In a standard lite, losing such a game is not possible, of course(when lynching only wolves).

i'll go with vote Punkbob for now. His non-abidance to the outing was odd. (unless he was online far too short and got ninja'd by it)

I wasn't paying attention sadly, was the wolf outed prior to me posting? And yes, I barely had time to skim yesterday, wasn't feeling well. All in all I am not a bad vote from the idea of killing off zombies, except that I am not a wolf.

Actually while the last wolf could be an inactive person, I somewhat suspect he isn't, and if I remember correctly the rationale I always heard behind going after inactive players favored the wolves. Let me look at it more seriously today and try and figure out what's up.

Edit: I see what I missed, this is what I get for skimming.
 
Based on a pretty shallow reading of the last two days, I am going to go with Oyoy, as he was run up and then saved by the Hax, and what might be an apparent angry outing by his fellow packmate Panzer on the first day before he was lynched.


Vote Oyoy
 
Why do people think I am much more suspicious than arkasas and aedan? Nobody forced me to volunteer to do the snipe - arkasas was chosen at first, remember - so I could just have laid low like aedan and not done anything. Regarding arkasas then nothing he did yesterday clears him: When leksu approached him he had to do the outing, since anything else would out himself. He also had to send leksu's name to two villagers, since anything else would be suspicious; hadn't he done it he would also be the lead suspect when leksu was hunted. That isn't to say he is a wolf and the smart wolf would perhaps also have refrained from hunting the seer immediately, since he likely wouldn't on top of the seer's scanning list for obvious reasons - i.e. if the seer survived he could assume that the mouth piece was less likely a wolf than everybody else.
So why do people think aedan and arkasas is cleared while I need to be bandwagoned?