Nothing personal, but if I were a spy in your position, that's exactly what I'd say.
In other news, this game is now as long as the last one was and it's only Round 2.
-
We have updated our Community Code of Conduct. Please read through the new rules for the forum that are an integral part of Paradox Interactive’s User Agreement.
Nothing personal, but if I were a spy in your position, that's exactly what I'd say.
In other news, this game is now as long as the last one was and it's only Round 2.
Pros: If the mission succeeds, we're in great shape, and if it fails, we know at least one of Falc or snoop is a spy.
Cons: This mission is only perfect with a Xarkan-Aedan-Tamius spy team. Which I suppose is still entirely possible, at this stage, but I'm not about to make a bet on it.
If a proposal has to lack me, this or some variant of it is definitely the best option, as it maximizes the information gained in the event of a failure. But I think I'd rather be on the mission than see this one go, or at least I'd like to get the plot cards.
Reject
Cons: This mission is only perfect with a Xarkan-Aedan-Tamius spy team. Which I suppose is still entirely possible, at this stage, but I'm not about to make a bet on it.
If a proposal has to lack me, this or some variant of it is definitely the best option, as it maximizes the information gained in the event of a failure. But I think I'd rather be on the mission than see this one go, or at least I'd like to get the plot cards.
Reject
Everyone should find this the best alternative to being on the team themselves. So resistance members not named madchem should all approve especially as we know tamius won't re-propose it. :mellow:
The team of Snoopdogg, Randakar, Kaisersohaib and Falc was approved 5-3:
Yay: Snoopdogg - Kaiser - Falc - Randakar - Xarkan
Nay: Tamius - MadC - Aedan
It was sabotaged once.
Next up for the first proposal of the third round is Tamius. He must propose a team of 4 after handing out the following plot cards:
Keeping a close eye on you – One time use - The player to whom the Leader passes this card may use this card to learn whether a player SUPPORTED or SABOTAGED a Mission. The player holding it may ask, by PM to the GM during the team approval or mission phase, to use it on a player on the Mission team, and when the mission has concluded will learn whether the specified player supported or sabotaged. A player's mission order may not be checked by more than one player.
Overheard Conversation – Use immediately – The player to whom the Leader passes this card must publicly choose one player adjacent to him on the player list. This player's role will be revealed to him through PM by the GM.
Yay: Snoopdogg - Kaiser - Falc - Randakar - Xarkan
Nay: Tamius - MadC - Aedan
It was sabotaged once.
Next up for the first proposal of the third round is Tamius. He must propose a team of 4 after handing out the following plot cards:
Keeping a close eye on you – One time use - The player to whom the Leader passes this card may use this card to learn whether a player SUPPORTED or SABOTAGED a Mission. The player holding it may ask, by PM to the GM during the team approval or mission phase, to use it on a player on the Mission team, and when the mission has concluded will learn whether the specified player supported or sabotaged. A player's mission order may not be checked by more than one player.
Overheard Conversation – Use immediately – The player to whom the Leader passes this card must publicly choose one player adjacent to him on the player list. This player's role will be revealed to him through PM by the GM.
Falc... :mellow:
Clearly OC should go to me or falc. Preferably me because I'm not a spy, but either way it should prove the issue.
Clearly OC should go to me or falc. Preferably me because I'm not a spy, but either way it should prove the issue.
Agreed.
I'd like to have the KACEOY card, if it's not too much trouble. Unless you know someone who is less likely to be a spy ;-)
Actually Falc is next to Kaiser on the player list. Card should go to him and he should open to Kaiserroll.
Or should go to Kaiser and he should check Falc. Details.. :mellow:
Or should go to Kaiser and he should check Falc. Details.. :mellow:
Err, the person who you give that to reveals their identity to someone next to them on the leader list ..
And I prefer snoop to reveal his identity to Tamius or Aedan. Both of them disapproved of the previous team, which failed, so a clear result on you should be rather helpful.
edit: though .. if Falc opens op to Kai, and kai says he's a spy, we gain some knowledge about Snoopdogg, too.
And if Kai says Falc is clean .. then snoop has to be a spy, because if kai is lying about that then snoop is *also* a spy.
Yeah, I like that plan. That plan is nice.
Of course with snoop proposing it the odds that snoopdogg is a spy actually go way down..
And I prefer snoop to reveal his identity to Tamius or Aedan. Both of them disapproved of the previous team, which failed, so a clear result on you should be rather helpful.
edit: though .. if Falc opens op to Kai, and kai says he's a spy, we gain some knowledge about Snoopdogg, too.
And if Kai says Falc is clean .. then snoop has to be a spy, because if kai is lying about that then snoop is *also* a spy.
Yeah, I like that plan. That plan is nice.
Of course with snoop proposing it the odds that snoopdogg is a spy actually go way down..
Overheard conversation is different than Open up. The player who is given overheard conversation by the leader will learn the role of someone he chooses next to him.
Concerning the above discussion, OC should probably be given to someone who checks either snoop or Falc. Which would mean Aedan gets the card to check snoop, or Kai/Xarkan gets the card to check Falc.
Alternatively, you could give the OC card to randy and have him check me. I would honestly prefer that, in fact, because that would almost certainly get you a guaranteed cleared player if you did. While all the other options involve some amount of ambiguity (can the checker or check-ee be trusted?), randy is almost guaranteed to be Resistance, due to his position as the third checked player in a sequence of them.
Alternatively, you could give the OC card to randy and have him check me. I would honestly prefer that, in fact, because that would almost certainly get you a guaranteed cleared player if you did. While all the other options involve some amount of ambiguity (can the checker or check-ee be trusted?), randy is almost guaranteed to be Resistance, due to his position as the third checked player in a sequence of them.
Let's not forget tamius -> snoop.
But yeah. Me checking madchemist sounds even better. It gives us less information on the recently passed sabotaged team maybe but I like the advantages of getting certainty on somebodies role.
But yeah. Me checking madchemist sounds even better. It gives us less information on the recently passed sabotaged team maybe but I like the advantages of getting certainty on somebodies role.
