• We have updated our Community Code of Conduct. Please read through the new rules for the forum that are an integral part of Paradox Interactive’s User Agreement.
Seems then your detailed-historical-build is giving an accurate result? Or is the MP shortage happening too early?
I think it is coming too early, a year too early
It's more an (historical) assignement issue rather than a real lack of men. See HERE for more details.

As IRL, I could have the option of lowering the number of soldiers within the Ersatzheer (by modifying the save.txt) and get my MP pool, i. e. my field units, increased (ca. 1 pts per 1000 unit-strenght point) but, in the context, it would be ahistorical.
First, the German military didn't proceed like that and, second, until December '41 and the Soviet counter-offensive, the Germans didn't really take the russian campaign seriously, which is also the reason why I still didn't change to "heavy industry emphasis".
 
Update is coming really soon and I hope the battle plans fans will be pleased.
Sorry for the delay between updates but it requires "some" time to work on the maps, preparing the SitReps etc, etc...

NotA : I'm not playing forward so basically, what you see is the exact current situation.
 
Last edited:
Ansatz 'Barbarossa'
July 1st-July 10th

The Lwow-Hotin Pocket



ReichsFührung der SS, Berlin - 1941, July the 3rd - 1430
Reichsführer-SS Heinrich Himmler meets Brigadeführer Gottlob Berger, Chef des SS-Hauptamtes.

- "Herr Reichsführer... I think you should have a look on this.
.............................

e9hbLXh.jpg

Foreign volunteers

- I see... It seems that the Wehrmacht is trying to copy us and to set-up its own foreign units. Die Schweine !!!
- Don't lose your temper, Herr Reichsführer. As far as I know, there will soon be a legal issue on this.
- ...? Explain yourself, Berger !
- It's quite simple, Herr Reichsführer. According to our laws, foreigners aren't allowed to serve into the Wehrmacht, but only people who have been granted the german citizenship, through one way or the other.
- I see... I should then be able to use this argument in order to get those new units under the authority of the SS.
- Exactly, Herr Reichsführer !
- Brilliant, mein lieber Berger !!! Do you know when these units are going to be ready ? After all, I'll rather let the Wehrmacht taking care of the training. It will save us a lot of money ... and troubles.
- Danish and sweedish units are first to be sent in Hamburg, then in Posen for basic training. As soon as the set-up will be achieved, the flamish unit will be sent in East-Prussia. All these formations won't be combat-ready before the end of the year, I assume. This will give you enough time to clear the small "legal" issue...
- Fully right. I think I can persuade the Führer on this.
Btw, any news from our 'Sonderkommando Dirlewanger' ?
- The unit has already been deployed in Poland, Distrikt Lublin. Together with the SS-Kavallerie-Brigade, they're taking care of the security in the area of General Gouvernement.
- Very good. Nice job, Berger !"


Die deutsche Wochenschau - 1941, July the 5th



[] Das Oberkommando der Wehrmacht gibt bekannt... []

Our brave troops keep their victorious advance inside enemy territory.
In the northern sector, the armies under the command of Feldmarschall von Leeb smashed the soviet defenses at Marijampole and Alytus. The Bolsheviks suffered tremendous casualties and our Panzertruppen are at the gates of Wilno, the Lithuanian Capital. During their advance, our troops have been welcome with open arms by the local population.
In the sector of Heeresgruppe 'Mitte', the armoured columns of Hoth and Guderian keep roaring eastwards. Ten-thousands of enemy troops have been by-passed and are about to be encircled. The fall of Minsk is now a matter of days !


BIXFWoz.jpg

Pockets of Lwow and Hotin
The greatest success have been already achieved in the south. Under the command of Generalfeldmarschall von Rundstedt, the hero of the Western Campaign, the Panzerverbände of Generaloberst von Kleist, after a drive of over 650km, linked up with our romanian allies south of Uman.
At least 400.000 soviets troops, including the staffs of 6 armies and one army group, are now trapped and doomed.
This brilliant move opened up wide the gates of Ukrain and southern Russia."



OKH Hauptquartier, Poznan - 1941, July the 10th - 1600
Meeting between Feldmarschall von Brauchitsch, CO OKH, General Halder, CO General Staff, and all Army Group Commanders.

- "Meine Herren, thank you for coming to this meeting. It will be the last one here in Poznan. We're about to move the HQ of the Ostheer to a small town in East-Prussia : Rastenburg.
General Halder, do you have the last update from the OKW about our operations in the Arctic ?
- Yes, Sir.

Meine Herren, as you known, our Unternehmen 'Platinfuchs' was a complete success : the city and harbour of Murmansk have been seized and thanks to the Luftwaffe, the heavy armoured counter-attacks against our 3. Geb.-D have been stopped. The Luftgau Kdo 'Norwegen' carry on with his harassing attacks against the soviet armoured division sighted in the area so as to weaken their offensive potential. Murmansk MUST stay in our hands !
On the other hand, 'Polarfuchs' is a bloody stalemate. Since the capture of Njamozero 10 days ago, our troops haven't still be able to make significant progress in the area. A great concentration of enemy forces have been sighted in Apatity, N-E of Njamozero, so General von Falkenhorst had to cancelled the drive on Kandalaska and to redirect the 211. Pz.-Abt north for a joined attack with the Pz.-Abt 40. These two armoured units finally managed to drive back the soviet forces but to a very high cost, both in lives and equipment.
In better shape, the 211. Pz.-Abt has been sent south to support the main attack of the XXXVI. Hö.K. on Tumcha. General Feige reported only very small gains but he remains optimistic towards the final result of the battle.

XsNFfvh.jpg

Finnish troops in action at Akhonaara
Akhonaara has fallen into the hands of our finish allies and von Falkenhorst will very likely send north some units of the 3. Armeijakunta in order to help. It is of ultimate importance that we cut the soviet supply lines to the Kola Peninsula ! Otherwise, sooner or later, General Dietl and his men will be doomed...
- At last, our finnish friends decided to move...
- In der Tat, Herr Feldmarschall.
They advanced on both sides of the Ladoga Lake and the bulk of their troops have reached the Neva and are at the gates of Leningrad. The Capital of Communism is too well defended unfortunatly. The Finns are waiting for reinforcement but it still unknown if they want to cross the Neva for now.
However, the FHO still confirmed that the soviet forces keep moving south instead of facing the finish threat. We have a big unknown here !
- May be they want first to establish a line of defense behind the Swir...?
Anyhow, it's not our concern for now. Thank you, General Halder.
Feldmarschall von Leeb, the situation of the Heeresgruppe 'Nord', please.

- Danke Herr Feldmarschall.
The situation of the Heeresgruppe 'Nord' is giving full satisfaction : after 10 days of intense fighting, we've been able to smash through the soviet defenses at Alytus. As it was their key position, the Reds haven't been able to recover since then.
16. Armee is now moving N-E with 3 of its Corps while the II. AK is heading east towards the Dvina.
After the fall of Wilno on July 6th, most units of the 4. Panzergruppe have a free path towards the Dvina, which bridges have been seized by our Brandenburger. The XXXX. AK (mot.) has been ordered to reinforce the bridgehead and then to attacks left towards Riga, following the right bank of the Dvina. The XXXXI. AK (mot.) will do the same but on the left bank. In these two sectors, we expect a strong resistance because we're facing fresh divisions which have just arrived from the North. Full air support from the I. Fliegerkorps has been assigned to both Armeekorps but our airplanes have now a long way to fly now. This will reduce the amount of sorties.
- There're big enough air facilities in Kaunas, aren't they ?
- True, Herr Feldmarschall. Unfortunatly, Kaunas is still in soviet hands. General von Küchler is assaulting Kaunas with 5 divisions for nearly a week now. The city itself is almost encircled with the 291. ID, west, attacking north towards Raseiniai and the XXVIII. AK (16. Armee), east, progressing north towards Jonava. He's fully confident that Kaunas will fall soon but until then our aircrafts still have to fly from Koenigsberg.
- What about von Manstein ?
- His LVI. AK (mot.) is currently attacking south to north with the Dvina to cover his right flank. His task is to clean up the left bank east of Wilno ; this being done, the II. AK will be able to establish a strong defensive position along the river.
- Aren't you afraid he will try to get a bridgehead across the Dvina ?
- With a guy like him, everything is possible, Herr Feldmarschall...
- Ich bedanke mich. Feldmarschall von Bock ?

- Meine Herren, the Heeresgruppe 'Mitte' is about to reach its main objective, i. e. the total destruction of the soviet group of forces of the Bialystock Salient.
North, after some delays, intended for the most part, the 3. Panzergruppe conducted an all-out assault in Lida and Lipinski in which 4 soviet divisions have been completly overrun. The vanguards of the LVII. AK (mot.) have reached the suburbs of Minsk while its 12. PzD is moving S-E towards Stolpce... and the Niemen. Recon elements of the 1. Kavallerie-Division, 2. Panzergruppe, have been reported only a few kilometers further south and they're about to reach Nieswiez. Once the 12. PzD will have reached Stolpce, ca. 40 soviet divisions will then be "eingekesselt" (encircled NotA).
Further north, the XXXIX. AK (mot.) is currently reorganizing. Soon it will be able to push towards Vitebsk and Smolensk and it will still have enough means to drive S-E so as to start the encirclement of Minsk.
- The Soviets have a strong position on the other side of the Dvina... in Polatsk, I think. Aren't you afraid they might launch a counter-attack to cut off your units communication lines ?
- Thanks God, I have disobedient subordinates. Despite his orders to concentrate all his means for the drive through the Niemen, General Strauss sent his V. AK in the wake of the 3. PzGr. With a little perspective, it was the right decision. These two divisions will be enough to secure the rear of General Schmidt.
The main concern remains the soviet forces in Horodyszcz ; however, they are currently attacked on their front by the FJ-Rgt 'Hermann Göring', on their left by the 8. ID, while the 19. PzD keep watching on their right, ready to intervene.
On the northern face of the Salient, the 9. Armee started to put pressure on the soviet units in order to disorganize their defense. Supported by armoured and Nebelwerfer units of the VIII. AK, the 'Lehr' Brigade keep attacking S-E so as to fix some enemy units.
102. RHG units also started some "cleaning" actions on the western face.

PSyWN0b.jpg

SitRep - July the 10th, 1941
On the southern face of the Salient, the 4. Armee took Brest-Litovsk after days of furious fighting. General von Kluge started to castle his corps from west to east. The VII. AK took Kobryn and is about to attack Chomsk in order to make the junction with the 9. Armee. Once done, the XX. AK will take care of the soviet units east of Chomsk as the XII. AK will be free to move eastwards to support units of the 2. PzGr.
General Guderian's Panzertruppen are about to close the Bialystok-Pripyat Pocket. The 1. Kav.-D will be in Nieswiez by tomorrow with the 3. PzD coming in right behind. This will give two divisions to stop any soviet breakthrough attempt and/or to support the attack of the LVII. AK (mot.) on Stolpce.
The 4. PzD will cover their left flank while the 10. ID (mot.), also on its way to Nieswiez, will be kept in reserve.
Guderian's right flank is being held by the XXXXVI. and XXXXVII. AK (mot.). Both are currently involved into very hard battles in order to cross the Pripyat. Once being done, they will initiate a pincer movement around Homyel, with the Desna to cover the right flank and the XXIV. AK (mot.) to cover the left one. This movement will pave the way for the 2. Armee, in charge of attacking and taking Homyel and Kiev. Heavy artillery pieces, from type Karlsgerät 600mm, are on the way to help with this task. We've seen them in action in Brest-Litovsk : they worked wonder !
- Well done, Fedor. Keep up with the good work !
Feldmarschall von Rundstedt, your SitRep, please.

- Vielen Dank.
Actually, there's nothing significant to report and everything is working according to the plan for the Heeresgruppe 'Süd'.
After the initial breakthrough on June 22nd, the 6. Armee keep moving eastwards without problems. 3 encircled soviet divisions have been destroyed and its vanguards are ca. 80. km S-W of Kiev. The XXIX. AK has been advised it could be diverted to support the attack of the 2. Armee on Kiev but the main body of the 6. Armee should reach the Dniepr within 8-10 days.
The 17. Armee stayed behind. It's currently busy reducing the Lwow Pocket while the Karpat Csoport is taking care of the Hotin Pocket. 8 divisions have already been destroyed and we made over 70.000 prisonners. It is estimated that nearly 40 divisions totalizing ca. 300.000 men are still being trapped in these two pockets. It might require another two weeks to reduce them.
The 1. Panzergruppe is currently reorganizing its elements. The XXXXVIII. AK (mot.) is helping our Hungarian allies to reduce the Hotin Pocket.
Meanwhile, the XIV. AK (mot.) is moving N-E to regroup with the 9. PzD south of Kiev. The III. AK (mot.), on its side, keeps moving S-E to provide flank cover to the 11. Armee.
- Very good job indeed. Big congrats.
General von Schobert. I assume you're going to speak for Marschall Antonescu ?

- Jawohl, Herr Feldmarschall.
The situation of the Grupul Armate 'Antonescu' is quite good.
My 11. Armee managed to punch a hole within the soviet lines, at first In Orhei, then in Kotovsk. Capturing Balta became a child play after that. I've launch all my cavalry and motorized elements into the breach. A soviet counter-attack temporarly stopped my romanian units at Pervomayski but the 76. ID (mot.) is about to out flank the enemy forces and to rush towards the Black Sea coast. Brandenburger units of HGr. 'Süd' are driving ahead. If everything goes fine, we should be able to close the bag within 2-3 days. Ca. 20 soviet divisions might get trapped in the Odessa Pocket and I've got all my other corps deployed to tighten the noose around them.
The 3. Armata did a very good job in covering my left flank and helped greatly to close the Hotin Pocket. Its units are now the anvil against which the Karpat Csoport is hammering... and Ivan between them. General Dumitrescu sent his Corpul de Cavalerie to help the 11. Armee. On this side, eveything's ok.
Unfortunatly, the 4. Armata remains stuck, still unable to cross the Prut at Cillia. The arrival of the Divizia Garda came just in time to compensate the collapse of the 15. Divizia Infanterie since the 72. ID alone is not strong enough to break through the soviet defenses. I don't have the figures but we assume that the casualties must be very heavy. I've sent an officer to get General Mattenklott's opinion : according to him, the Soviets are about to collapse and with them, all their defense in this sector. A painful birth, indeed...

- Well... From my perspective, everything goes fine and according to the plan. General Halder, anything to add ?
- Indeed, Herr Feldmarschall.
My first point will have to do with the Luftwaffe.
We are all well aware of how important was the role of the Luftwaffe in the past 18 days. Sadly, it won't last very long.
I've got here the last report given to me by the OKL.

4hQ1ywh.png

SitRep Luftwaffe - July the 10th, 1941
As you can see, the Luftwaffe has lost 25% of its strength in less than 3 weeks. Front reports also indicate that the soviet fighters got a lot more agressive which explains the casualties. Feldmarschall Milch told me that he will be forced to slow down air operations in the next weeks in order to keep his formations combat-ready. Please, keep that in mind when you're going to plan your operations in the future, meine Herren.
You should also take into consideration that due to our quick advance, our airbases get farther and farther from the front. This is also the reason why we should take Minsk, Homyel and Kiev as soon as possible.

My second point is about supply.
Some of you already reported some supply issues, mostly on fuel. It's not going any better !

G5MSjWb.jpg

Railroad engineers at work
You all know that the Soviets use a different track gauge. It's going to take time to convert them to our current gauge. All our railroad engineers are into the breach but until everything is fixed, we're going to rely mostly on trucks and on planes, the latest provided there're no enemy fighters within range. We already had a bad experience last week and we don't have transport airplanes to waste.
I'm done now.
- Vielen Dank, General Halder.
All right. Meine Herren, you have your orders ; keep up with the good job. You can dismiss"


 
Last edited:
It seems you're doing great in the east. With so many units, including so many armored divisions, trapped in pockets, will the Reds still pose any difficulty in what follows ?
 
for now things are goinf smoothly... do you have some troops to spare and send to Finland? I know it's ahistorical, but, success in silberfuchs already is...
 
Does ICE actually simulate the different railroad gauges?
 
Once again, excellent update Nicegil! I enjoy reading this AAR!
Glad to read this. It's the intended goal after all.

It seems you're doing great in the east. With so many units, including so many armored divisions, trapped in pockets, will the Reds still pose any difficulty in what follows ?
Right now, we're only talking about the divisions encircled in the South. Ok, 47 is quite a number but I need to get rid of 100 soviet divisions to get even. From the 40 armored divisions I've been able to identify, only 7 have been trapped so far. That's still a lot of them remaining compared to the 19 PzDs I have...

for now things are goinf smoothly... do you have some troops to spare and send to Finland? I know it's ahistorical, but, success in silberfuchs already is...
Mhmmmm... You like to hit where it hurts, don't you ? :D
Sadly, my drawers are quite empty right now. I might have one ID in Norway (163. ID) and one Geb.-D (7.) should be ready in a few months. That's it.
I'd so much share your optimism but, unfortunatly, 'Silberfuchs' is only 50% successful. I still have to severe the supply lines to the Kola Peninsula, otherwise...
And to be honest, it doesn't look that good for the moment.

I must also take into consideration that the AI, on its side, is not playing historical. I confess I have an Heeresgruppe being set-up in Northern Germany (constituted of units and HQs I should have dissolved according to History i.e. 2. ID (mot.), Stellungsdivisionen (550...), some militia of the former 1940 'Oberost', etc, etc...). A low-quality patchwork of units, not even fully combat-ready, which primary purpose is to face a landing in Denmark. Obviously, I can (or plan to...) use them in some other ahistorical place too. But, shhhhhtttt... ;)

Wow. The front is looking like a great tutorial on encirclement. <S>
That's one way to go ; each player has his own tactics or better said strategies.
For my own part, I rather choose to attack mainly "from strong to the weak", even if it sometimes means smashing a fly with a sledgehammer, but always (!!!) with some units ready to exploit the gap.
I also make an intensive use of air support but only on very specific points. A full-strength Fliegerkorps can easily inflict over 1000 casualties per day, with devastating effects on Org. ! Combined with a brutal assault by ground troops, I usually achieve the expected results quickly.

Does ICE actually simulate the different railroad gauges?
Actually not... It's just role-play. :)
I'm already improving the infrastructures on two main axis and it's just a way to introduce this fact. By the same token, the characters involved in this AAR don't speak of "IC points" (or any other game terms) but rather talk about "production priorities or budget allocation".
 
Last edited:
Ah, unfortunate - the logistical difficulties of the Russian campaign are something that are always missing from my Germany games.
 
If you can chase the Russians near Murmansk all the way to the edge of the peninsula, you can eliminate them completely, and then redirect said German division to help in cutting Kola off.
 
I would strongly recommend the Deutsche Wehrmacht Immersion mod, it allows for historical division composition, adds a ton of commanders, has German naming presets, and tons of historical events. Judging by this AAR, you would bloody love it.
Obviously, I know DWI for a long time already... ;)
I'm currently working on a 'Barbarossa' campaign with both sides having their historical OoBs. But I will require some time to have it ready.
I'm just a little bit concerned about this plethora of units and how the AI can deal with it since HOI3 was designed for 5-slots divisions and not so many different types of units.
In ICE, it has already some issues, having a hard time to identify mot.-art. units for instance.
Well, we'll see...
Ah, unfortunate - the logistical difficulties of the Russian campaign are something that are always missing from my Germany games.
You're probably the only player I know who hasn't any logistical issues while performing 'Barbarossa'. o_O
Despite some flaws, I really LOVE this logistical system and the migraines it causes, mainly in Southern Russia.
"Amateurs talk about tactics, but professionals study logistics."
If you can chase the Russians near Murmansk all the way to the edge of the peninsula, you can eliminate them completely, and then redirect said German division to help in cutting Kola off.
Mhmmmm... I thought about this but I don't know : I only have 2 Gebirgs-Divisions facing between 6 to 12 soviet divisions, including 2 armored ones and I've barely been able to stop their first counter-attack... thanks to the Luftwaffe I have to point out.
I might be wrong but, from my perspective, the best solution remains FIRST to severe the supply lines to the Kola Peninsula and THEN, to bomb all logistical concentrations up North. Once done (IF done...), the rest should be a walk in the park.
Those are some absolutely fabulous spearheads you got there...
Blitzkrieg 1.0.1 !!! :p
At last, I've got some room to maneuver my Panzers. Unlike in France the year before...
 
Last edited:
Well, I only have vanilla TFH and my army is usually small as Germany because of a disproportionate focus on naval power, or a strategy like invading in 1940. And I
always staff the theater and Army Group with a logistics wizard, which cuts the entire army's supply usage by something like 5%, and make use of convoys to captured Russian ports to ease logistical strain.
Maybe there's a reason I don't have logistical issues, come to think of it :p

Occasionally, I'll have a spearhead division running low on fuel when its a few hundred kilometers ahead of the main army and flying ahead in the face of no enemy resistance, but that's about it. Never anything bad enough to mess with my plans. Maybe the fact I never played Germany until after playing Italy, Japan, France, Romania and Communist China gave me an appreciation for small armies, heh.
 
if you are going to use the DWI mod, I strongly advice you tu wait until the new patch is out... sadly, no idea when it will be out
 
Any issues with the current version ?

Soviets are a little under strengthed... that's the most annoying thing... besides the Panthers and Tigers are only available if it is '43 and you are still at war with the Soviet Union