• We have updated our Community Code of Conduct. Please read through the new rules for the forum that are an integral part of Paradox Interactive’s User Agreement.
He could have surrendered when it was clear that the pack was done for.

It's up to the GM whether to accept a surrender - either way, the pack didn't surrender (all the wolves need to surrender for it to even be considered as valid). I am staunchly against surrender as a game mechanic in general, so I for instance disallow surrenders in my games. I think GMs should be upfront at the beginning as to whether surrenders are accepted or not.
 
The moment Health and De Chat decided to make a fake outing it was basically over. Had they decided to push their luck with Audren, they might have snatched the victory. However they were pretty sure the JL had scanned one of them and would out them.

Assuming we were convinced that Audren was the seer :D:D:D.
 
The moment Health and De Chat decided to make a fake outing it was basically over. Had they decided to push their luck with Audren, they might have snatched the victory. However they were pretty sure the JL had scanned one of them and would out them.
I think it was over before then. Maybe they could've dragged it out one more day, but once Audren voted De Chat, the wolves didn't have a chance. If Health and De Chat had both gone after Audren it would confirmed to the rest of JL that I was right about the Health-De Chat pack, and if they didn't concentrate on Audren, De Chat was the candidate we were basically decided towards. Granted I did grow mildly worried when Npstr and Tornadoli decided to ignore the thread all day.
Assuming we were convinced that Audren was the seer :D:D:D.
I actually thought Audren was the seer too, until Tornadoli told me I'd been scanned after my spat with you yesterday started up.
 
What's up with everyone thinking Audren was the seer this game? What did he do that was so seer-like?

He was absolutely quite. Some times when you have a role like that you try to stay hidden as much as you can. When he forget to vote we thought that wasn't seer like but in the last moment he was our main candidate. I don't know why we didn't think about you as a candidate, probably for your voting record that was really bad.

Other moment when we made a bad move was the day we hunted DragonofAtlantis. I was totally busy all day (in fact that day I couldn't vote) and no wolf gave an order so Capibara used the backup list.
 
What's up with everyone thinking Audren was the seer this game? What did he do that was so seer-like?
Well, npstr obviously wasn't the seer, I knew I wasn't the seer, Jacksonian obviously wasn't the seer, Euro was obviously not the seer when Jacksonian voted him, Health and De Chat were my main suspects, and you were tunneling like an idiot against npstr. Audren was my pick for seer more by process of elimination than anything on his part specifically. But him being generally below the radar and avoiding pressure from the JL also made me suspect him as seer.
 
He was absolutely quite. Some times when you have a role like that you try to stay hidden as much as you can. When he forget to vote we thought that wasn't seer like but in the last moment he was our main candidate. I don't know why we didn't think about you as a candidate.

Other moment when we made a bad move was the day we hunted DragonofAtlantis. I was totally busy all day (in fact that day I couldn't vote) and no wolf gave an order so Capibara used the backup list.
That was by accident? I thought that was the wolves finally deciding to cull the outed JL members.
 
Thanks for GMing, Capibara.

Thanks for not lynching me others.
 
Has a fake wolf outing ever worked?
Yes; plenty of times. It all depends on timing and preparation---and it has become way harder with the new PM system. Often you need a little luck too.
Well if Health is a wolf it's one of the dumbest wolf moves I've seen, breaking a 3 villager TIE (one of them the seer lol) at the very last second. No village cred ever is worth that.
If it was for village cred I agree. Though it appears to be that they were convinced they would be outed later today and then preempting that actually isn't too bad an idea.

So Tornadoli was the seer... well, when in a Lite you can't catch the seer in all the game you're pretty ****ed as a wolf. Good game and great job with the game Capibara.
You can perfectly win with the seer living to the end; but yet it is harder. A very infamous example is God hates seers, but even in more normal circumstances it is perfectly possible.

It's up to the GM whether to accept a surrender - either way, the pack didn't surrender (all the wolves need to surrender for it to even be considered as valid). I am staunchly against surrender as a game mechanic in general, so I for instance disallow surrenders in my games. I think GMs should be upfront at the beginning as to whether surrenders are accepted or not.
There is nothing wrong with surrendering; but it needs to be done by PM and not mentioned in thread at all.
 
If it was for village cred I agree. Though it appears to be that they were convinced they would be outed later today and then preempting that actually isn't too bad an idea.

I meant the day 1 voting.
 
GG all, and thanks to Capibara for hosting. This game seemed like a battle of zombies, with the wolves going silent after I died and the village only growing more vocal once the JL was stronger.
 
GG all, and thanks to Capibara for hosting. This game seemed like a battle of zombies, with the wolves going silent after I died and the village only growing more vocal once the JL was stronger.

Did you think about Torn as the seer?