• We have updated our Community Code of Conduct. Please read through the new rules for the forum that are an integral part of Paradox Interactive’s User Agreement.

CR0N0S LXIII

Second Lieutenant
42 Badges
Mar 26, 2017
134
0
  • Crusader Kings II
  • Europa Universalis IV: Third Rome
  • Europa Universalis IV: Res Publica
  • Europa Universalis IV: Golden Century
  • Hearts of Iron IV: Death or Dishonor
  • Cities: Skylines - Green Cities
  • Europa Universalis IV: Cradle of Civilization
  • Hearts of Iron IV: Expansion Pass
  • Europa Universalis IV: Rule Britannia
  • Cities: Skylines - Parklife
  • Europa Universalis IV: Dharma
  • Cities: Skylines Industries
  • Cities: Skylines - Mass Transit
  • Hearts of Iron IV: Expansion Pass
  • Cities: Skylines - Campus
  • Crusader Kings III
  • Crusader Kings III: Royal Edition
  • Battle for Bosporus
  • Europa Universalis 4: Emperor
  • Hearts of Iron IV: By Blood Alone
  • Hearts of Iron IV: No Step Back
  • Hearts of Iron 4: Arms Against Tyranny
  • Europa Universalis IV: El Dorado
  • Europa Universalis IV
  • Europa Universalis IV: Call to arms event
  • Victoria 2
  • Cities: Skylines
  • Europa Universalis IV: Mandate of Heaven
  • Europa Universalis IV: Pre-order
  • Europa Universalis IV: Common Sense
  • Cities: Skylines - After Dark
  • Europa Universalis IV: Cossacks
  • Cities: Skylines - Snowfall
  • Europa Universalis IV: Mare Nostrum
  • Stellaris
  • Hearts of Iron IV: Cadet
  • Europa Universalis IV: Rights of Man
  • Europa Universalis IV: Wealth of Nations
  • Europa Universalis IV: Conquest of Paradise
  • Europa Universalis IV: Art of War
  • Victoria 2: Heart of Darkness
  • Victoria 2: A House Divided
Hi everyone. So I would like to share my personal list of the 5 most powerful empires or civs thorugh history, just as a way to start kind of discussion on this matter. English is not my native language, so I ask that you forgive any mistake you see.

Be free to leave any opinions on this list or share yours. I am only a fan of History but non a hard student of it, so I understand if you think I have some common mistakes.

1. Roma (509 BC - 476 AC)
Senatus PopulusQue Romanus (S.P.Q.R)
Roma, Invicta!
Maximum Extension: 6.5 million square kilometers (117 AC)
Population: 88 million people (117 AC)

I think the first one is pretty obvious. The roman civilization conquered half of Europe, north Africa and middle east, being the most larger empire if we don't count colonies or other overseas territories. The influence they got from greek civilization gave them a way of understanding politics and laws that they spread over Europe, and that is partly the base of our political and legal systems nowadays. Their technology, their capacity to organize a huge territory from a metropoli, their armies... I think is perfectly sayable that Rome was the only empire that achieved to be the unique organised state that existed in all the old world (meaning the world they knew, not the ancient world), something not other empire could tell.

It is commonly said that this empire was so powerful thanks to its armies, but I think their nationalism, the rulers that understood life as a constant fight between powers defending interests, their use of diplomacy and law to subjugate the conquered peoples, was what makes Roma so special as civilization.

The fall of this empire came during centuries IV and V AC, due to the germans pressions in northern europe, the economical crisis and, upon all, the inability of the last emperors. I think it was the lost of the old roman ideas, from the times of Cato, what made this great civilization sick. The eastern roman empire, known today as Bizantyum, survived for another 1000 years, but already in 1453 when Constantinople falls in hands of the ottomans, there was pretty nothing of the old roman civilization left.

2. The British Empire (1707 - Nowadays)
God save the King!
Maximum Extension: 29.5 million square kilometers (1922)
Population: 458 million people

The United Kingdom was born in 1707 with the Union Act, that united the Kingdom of Great Britain with the Kingdom of Scotland. Great Britain also was dominating kingdoms of Wales and Ireland, so this union act united them in a single political entity.

The sucess of this empire was due to the extension of the British colonies through the 5 continents, thanks to one of the most powerful navies of all the times. This colonial expansion made the British appear in any part of the world you can imagine. They got colonies in North America, Egypt, South Africa, Arabian Peninsula, India, Singapur, Australia, Indonesia, the Mediterranean, New Zealand, The Caribbean... And this huge colonial empires, alongside with new economic and commercial ideas that promoted free trade instead of old mercantilism, made the British the richest power in the world for 200 years. I consider XIX century can perfectly be called the british century.

I said nowadays because, they still control some overseas territories (like Gibraltar or Malvinas), but more important because Queen Elizabeth from UK is also Queen of Australia and Canada, and I think that's enough to say that this empire kind of survived until our days.

3. The Spanish Empire (1492 - 1898)
Plus ultra
¡Santiago y cierra, España!
Maximum Extension: 31.5 million square kilometers (with Portugal 1580-1640), 19.2 million square kilometers (1790)
Population: 31 million people (with Portugal 1580-1640), 27.4 million people (1790)

Be aware that I'm spanish and I may be not objective

The discover of the Americas by Columbus in 1492 opened to Spain and Europe the door to world domination. In 50 years, Spain conquered the territories of Central and South America and the Caribbean, getting a gold income that made it the richest nation in Europe. The diplomatic labour of the Catholican Kings, marrying his daughter Juana I with Phillip von Habsburg, granting an alliance with the Austrian kings, and the union between Spain in Portugal gave Spain in 1580 the hugest empire never seen before, controlling Iberia, half of Italy, the Netherlands and Belgium, the Americas, most part of southern Africa coast, Phillipines and some cities in India. During this period Spain was capital of the world, in what was named as a golden century for art.

The military power of this empire was, in one word, fascinating. Based on new military tactics introduced by the Great Captain, Gonzalo Fernández de Córdoba, in italian wars, the spanish army was organised in tercios, a formation of pikes and arquebusiers that for 100 years knew no defeat. Always in numeric inferiority, the Spanish Tercios fought and win all the European powers of the time (France, England, Germany duchies, Sweeden, the Ottoman Empire, Portugal, the Dutchs...). Known for their discipline, bravery and sense of honour, the Spanish Tercios were the first professional army in Europe since Roman times. Their most brave victory was in my opinion the battle of Pavía, were 6000 spanish men could resist the siege of 30000 french until 20000 spanish reinforcement arrived, defeating the french army, capturing the France king and some of the most important nobles, humiliating their rival and ending the war. Seriously, I think only Roma can compare to us in military terms.

The fall of this Empire came because of the exhaustion after continous wars, that can no more be paid with gold from the Americas. Westfalia's peace was the beginning of the fall, that ended in 1898 with the Hispano-American war, where we lost the last territories of the first empire were sun never set.

It's a bit late, so I will update this with positions 4 and 5 tomorrow. Let me know what you think
 
I think any ranking that does not include the Franks misses out an entire chunk of europe. The franks ended up directly and indirectly as by far the most important factor in post-roman europe. France, Germany and Italy are frankish constructs, the medieval catholic church and the papacy toa large extent a result of frankish influence.

The Franks arguably created the medieval european world. (which of course created the "modern" world) even England ended up conquered by frankified vikings :p

Arabs and Persians are also hugely important, for the steppe peoples I think it's tossup between mongols and Turks as most influential (though "Turk" is a squishy concept, but then most "civilizational" definitions are)
 
No one mentioned Han China yet? The cultural hegemon of all of East Asia.

And of course the Rashidun Caliphate. Hard to find another empire that left as big a footprint on history in as short a time as this one.
 
Any such ranking is doomed to fail. Aside from the radically different forms and definitions of states and empires across history and the inherent subjectivity of the one doing the ranking, all you're doing is prioritising certain times and places because of their political institutions, rather than economic, cultural, societal pressures that transcend state lines. You're placing the entire history of the world into neat little arbitrary boxes to be ranked and judged, which is ridiculous.

This endless need by Paradoxians to suborn everything of interest to the political is a mind-numbingly dull way of looking at the past. I am fed up of the history forum being full of silly threads ranking rulers or generals or states or discussing who the true successor to Rome is or obsessing over Sassanid lineages or what have you.
 
I am fed up of the history forum being full of silly threads ranking rulers or generals or states or discussing who the true successor to Rome is or obsessing over Sassanid lineages or what have you.
Are you? There is plenty of other stuff here too. :)

Oh and you forgot to mention the ever fresh question of whether the T34 or the Panther tank were better.
 
The question probably depends on whether you're looking for the strongest "recent" influences, or the most profound effects over time.

If recent, then the British Empire probably ranks way up there. If looking back further, Rome has almost certainly had more total effect over time, and probably the Egyptian and Persian Empires as well as the earlier Babylonians and Assyrians affected Greece profoundly (indirectly, in the earlier cases), which in turn heavily influenced Rome. China has impacted the world even in the West, as ideas spread along the trade routes, and the Mongols impacted both East and West by bridging the vast gap between them, despite not having developed much in the way of art, literature, or technology of their own. Ultimately, if we go back to long-forgotten tribes of migrating early humans, their choices of direction and ways of interacting with the environment have formed the foundations all of human civilization (domestication of plants and animals, etc.).

The ultimate influence would have to be the first "human" tribe, who literally made us who and what we are.
 
Achaemenid Persia is way underrated and belongs at the top of this kind of list! Monotheism in the levant and Abrahamic faiths is traced straight back to them. Their empire was debatably the largest ever by percent of global population. Their roads were far more expansive than Rome's famed ones (even if their overall engineering was not) and their united rule from Northern India to the Mediterranean left a trade network that would be dominant until the last few centuries. Many of the non-cultural credit dumped on Greece really belongs to them; Alexander conquered into it. (Being fair though some of theirs can then trace back to Media, Babylon, or Syria, etc, but still...)
 
The most influential civilisation in history is Poland 1919-1939 because it managed to maintain control of Vilnius despite the objections of Lithuania over the matter. The shocking, stunning Fall of Vilnius truly shook the world and put humanity into a slumber from which it never truly recovered.

Other less-influential-but-still-crucial world civilisations include the Soviet Union, the Russian Empire, Modern Lithuania, Poland-Lithuania and the Grand Duchy of Lithuania. If I were to narrow this list down to the top five as suggested by the OP I would put it something like this:
- Poland 1919-1939
- Modern Lithuania
- Poland-Lithuania
- Grand Duchy of Lithuania
- The Russian Empire

Soviets unfortunately for them are sixth (only just lower than the Russian Empire though) because they weren't as good at maintaining control of Vilnius as the others. Poland 1919-1939 obviously is at the top because they won the Vilnius Crisis, Modern Lithuania still maintains control of Vilnius today, Poland-Lithuania maintained control of Vilnius for centuries, the Grand Duchy of Lithuania actually made Vilnius, and the Russian Empire was also successful at maintaining control of Vilnius for quite a long time.
 
The most influential civilisation in history is Poland 1919-1939 because it managed to maintain control of Vilnius despite the objections of Lithuania over the matter. The shocking, stunning Fall of Vilnius truly shook the world and put humanity into a slumber from which it never truly recovered.

Other less-influential-but-still-crucial world civilisations include the Soviet Union, the Russian Empire, Modern Lithuania, Poland-Lithuania and the Grand Duchy of Lithuania. If I were to narrow this list down to the top five as suggested by the OP I would put it something like this:
- Poland 1919-1939
- Modern Lithuania
- Poland-Lithuania
- Grand Duchy of Lithuania
- The Russian Empire

Soviets unfortunately for them are sixth (only just lower than the Russian Empire though) because they weren't as good at maintaining control of Vilnius as the others. Poland 1919-1939 obviously is at the top because they won the Vilnius Crisis, Modern Lithuania still maintains control of Vilnius today, Poland-Lithuania maintained control of Vilnius for centuries, the Grand Duchy of Lithuania actually made Vilnius, and the Russian Empire was also successful at maintaining control of Vilnius for quite a long time.
Now there is a post that deserves the "helpful" button! Thank you for bringing reason and objectivity back into this thread.
 
The most influential civilisation in history is Poland 1919-1939 because it managed to maintain control of Vilnius despite the objections of Lithuania over the matter. The shocking, stunning Fall of Vilnius truly shook the world and put humanity into a slumber from which it never truly recovered.

Other less-influential-but-still-crucial world civilisations include the Soviet Union, the Russian Empire, Modern Lithuania, Poland-Lithuania and the Grand Duchy of Lithuania. If I were to narrow this list down to the top five as suggested by the OP I would put it something like this:
- Poland 1919-1939
- Modern Lithuania
- Poland-Lithuania
- Grand Duchy of Lithuania
- The Russian Empire

Soviets unfortunately for them are sixth (only just lower than the Russian Empire though) because they weren't as good at maintaining control of Vilnius as the others. Poland 1919-1939 obviously is at the top because they won the Vilnius Crisis, Modern Lithuania still maintains control of Vilnius today, Poland-Lithuania maintained control of Vilnius for centuries, the Grand Duchy of Lithuania actually made Vilnius, and the Russian Empire was also successful at maintaining control of Vilnius for quite a long time.

Why is holding Vilnius for a mere 20 years such a big feat? Past 1991 Lithuania did much better than that. They also managed to reduce the population of Vilnius, thus turning the wheels of time. Nazi Germany also deserved to be mentioned, because for almost 25% of their existence they controlled Vilnius, which translates for close to 250 years, since it was a 1000 years empire.
 
The USA, because it could easily just nuke all the other empires. Duh.
Yeah sorry but the US cant just nuke the Roman or British Empire. Thats out of the laws of physics.
 
I am pretty sure that with some modifications the Nimitz can go back to whatever time and not just Dec 1941.
Possible but then they will get fined by the Time Police.
 
Yeah sorry but the US cant just nuke the Roman or British Empire. Thats out of the laws of physics.

And here I was expecting you to nominate the Swabians for greatest civilization.