Finally something to work with.
The runup on Randakar was joined by Aedan, Yvanoff, Dedonus, Alxeu(and Alynkio, but he's a little bit on the dead side
).
We need to bear in mind that the case on Alynkio wasn't exactly the strongest of cases yesterday, so some opposition to the Alynkio lynch from villagers isn't entirely weird. That said I'm kinda suspicious because of the target chosen.
What I'm seeing in Randakar is just someone that's inactive. Which would also kinda make sense with Caillean asking for a sub. From what I've seen in the past baddie Randakar is just as active as goodie Randakar, and we've already mislynched him in the past when he went inactive and didn't really pay attention to the game for whatever reason. Sure, it doesn't clear him, but it isn't damning either.
In other words: not in any way a good case against him(and certainly not better than what little we had on Alynkio), but a perfect scapegoat that nobody really opposes lynching either. Almost as if a wolf brought up the easiest scapegoat that could be found to try and save his packmate.
Aedan was the one that originally brought up Randy as someone that could be lynched instead of Alynkio near the end, and he was also by far the most vocal in opposing the Alynkio lynch. That he was mostly lying low before this and suddenly became active when a wolf was targetted doesn't exactly help him either.
Yvanoff's PM stuff also seems a bit suspect. From what Wagon is saying he seems to have PMed Wagon asking if he had a scan on Alynkio, and then promtly went and opposed lynching Alynkio. I'm not sure on one thing about him though: if he was a wolf, then why would he even send the first PM to begin with? Potentially trying to phish, but would he really get anything of note out of it? What would a wolf expect to get from something like that?
That said, I don't see what a villager would gain from it either.
@Yvanoff Can you explain what happened in those PMs?
Alxeu initially voted Alynkio in a post that seemed to suggest he had no real choice anymore, then flipped to Randy, and then flipped back after the outting. Could be a wolf that thought Alynkio was done for until the Randy runup and then switched thinking he could be saved after all. But he subbed in fairly late and may not have have time to figure out what exaclty was going on. Still, deserves some attention.
(We should also note that Alynkio redirected/opposed an attempted runup on day 2 against him, for what it's worth)
Dedonus seems to have intially mistrusted Wagon enough to vote for Wagon, then switched to Randy when that runup started. Consistent, but could be a wolf opposing the lynching of his packmate. I don't see nything beyond joining this runup on him I think, and I'm not sure if he's the msot suspiciosu of the bunch right now.
Of course we should also be a bit careful about wolves seeign Wagon going this diehard on Alynkio, suspecting there's a scan at play and just going in alibi voting thinking Alynkio's doomed already. But I'm not sure where we should start for exploring that hypothesis, and there's probably better cases to go after for today than assuming someone alibi voted.
I feel like Aedan is the most suspicious out of the bunch for now. He is the one that picked the seemingly all to easy target for the runup, and was also by far the most vocal about wanting someone else/not Alynkio killed.
This is what Wagonlitz is probably referring to. And while it looks bad now in hindsight, I think it's silly to assume that because Wagonlitz was acting uncharacteristically (by his own admission) I should've assumed he was JL trying to force a lynch on a scanned wolf. That isn't the first thing that comes to mind when a player is ramming through a weak case, the first thing I think is a wolf trying to get someone who isn't a packmate lynched.
A wolf would just be suicidal if he's pushing a weak case with this level of fervour, and from what I've seen from baddie Wagon he'd be
far more subtle about it. I agree it would be silly to just assume he was JL, but it's equally silly to just assume he's wolf.
My day 2 post had a fiar amount of content to it, and this attempt to say people who make few votes are suspicious is baseless. I made an active contribution to get a candidate lynched, and while it was only one post, it still counts. Making more posts and spamming the thread is not a mark of goodieness.
Ehm, so you think
THIS post is "a fair amount of content":
Hmm, discussion of parity rules aside, I'm most suspicious of Xarkan from day 1. He was the main beneficiary of the heavy push on Jeray late in the day, making a wolf save quite possible. Determining if he's a wolf could lead us to many other suspects, so I think he's the best lynch for today.
Vote Xarkan
?
All you're really did there was target Xarkan for the crime of not dying on day 1. The only person Xarkan's death even really gave info on was Yvanoff I think? Or is there some other post you're referring to that I've missed?
VOTE AEDAN
