A summary of advice from Chapter 63
Just a few comments to address this time - the question was clearly answered, which I'll deal with first, then other comments after.
Ch63 Q1: Vassal Looting Effects. OK, going off the screens above, it is clear the prestige loss is suffered by the vassal, Dyre in this case. But it is less specific re the lost gold (only small amounts here, but the principle is important). It just says ‘lost gold’: does that mean it is the realm liege that loses it, or is that still the vassal as well? I’d also ask the same of the general looting of ‘loose treasure’ in the county leading up to the fall of the holding: is that lost by Dyre as the owner (which had been my assumption) or by Eilif? In which case, he wouldn’t be laughing quite so much and may have been batter served smashing the raiders that have been plaguing his brother.





Speaking of which (ie Hel), there's been no obvious evidence of their activities or influence that I've noticed. Just the normal Slovensky murderous activities and royal family hatreds. No werewolves, suspiciously missing children, heads in bags (just making that up) etc. Like Rurik, Eilif doesn't have one of the seven deadly sins as a trait, so he couldn't join anyway. Helgi, had he lived to succeed, did, though ... that might have been an interesting 'learning experience'!
OK, thanks for those who commented this time round and all who read. The next session is played, screenies edited and words written. Just need to upload. If not tonight (my time) then hopefully in the morning!
Just a few comments to address this time - the question was clearly answered, which I'll deal with first, then other comments after.
ᚔ ᚱᚢᚱᛁᚲᛁᛞ ᚔ
Ch63 Q1: Vassal Looting Effects. OK, going off the screens above, it is clear the prestige loss is suffered by the vassal, Dyre in this case. But it is less specific re the lost gold (only small amounts here, but the principle is important). It just says ‘lost gold’: does that mean it is the realm liege that loses it, or is that still the vassal as well? I’d also ask the same of the general looting of ‘loose treasure’ in the county leading up to the fall of the holding: is that lost by Dyre as the owner (which had been my assumption) or by Eilif? In which case, he wouldn’t be laughing quite so much and may have been batter served smashing the raiders that have been plaguing his brother.
Seems the first part is right from all the answers below, but as a tribal ruler, I get no tax income at all from any of my vassals, just my own demesne counties.As far as I know the gold is lost from the province, and it results in an income penalty for some time to the province. So it doesn't leave your coffers, neither your vassal's, but in the long run it robs you of some of the tax income of your vassal that would've trickled back to you as scutage. I'm not 100% sure about this, but this is how I think it works. When I'm in this position I mostly let them screw around with my unruly vassal, but protect his vassals (in this case the temple holding for example).
Thanks for confirming and clarifying. Given Dyre is a lost cause re troops, I wasn't worried there. Indeed, if it comes to fighting him at some point, the weaker he remains the better. But a good point re a vassal I actually value - I would definitely try to help one of them against external raiders if possible to do so.Yeah, gold seized in sieges is always seized from the character owning that particular holding. On the other hand, the 'loose treasure' isn't. I agree with @diskoerekto here: it's a penalty for the province's tax modifier. As with your level of tribal organization the vassals don't pay any taxes to you, and I doubt Dyre would join any wars, if he's raided the only one weakened in the end is him. It is worth defending vassals in such a situation if you need their troops.
Again thanks, confirm's Eilif's disdain for Dyre's problems.As someone who suffers many raids in his games, I can confirm that it definitely doesn't come from the liege. And as the others have pointed out, the 'loose' gold comes from the province itself. You can see it as that bar that decreases on the province screen. Until it refills, the province suffers a penalty to it's tax rate. Note that non-raid military stuff can also lower that bar too.
ᚔ ᚱᚢᚱᛁᚲᛁᛞ ᚔ
General Comments
There are a few other awards as well, maybe I'll get a few more mentions. And you have done all right yourself. There's always next year.I didn't know the voting existed so I missed the chance to vote, but this AAR is so great it didn't even need my vote. The other 2 AARs were too, but sadly they missed an award :/
It may take a while. I recall Helgi started slowly, but then kids came along at a steady rate. I may need to look for a third concubine if nothing happens in the next session.Good pick, may she give many heirs to Eilif.
Will see how long it stays together.Nice feat by the AI to consolidate Italy. No doubt a Carolingian did it of course.
I will look eventually if I can remember!How is his heir in case stress gets him?
There may be, but I can't build them yet - may need a higher tech level.Isn't there housecarl training grounds? It's supposed to give heavy infantry some offense bonus per building level.
That's good - enough of the other family members already hate Eilif!He seems to have the "Content" trait, so he's veeery unlikely to ever rebel. A good choice to give some lands to if one day we have too much land to keep for Eilif![]()
Three concubines in addition to the wife, I understand.So, what's the concubine limit again?Maybe Eilif would take more... About the nubile thing, well the cold hard facts of the middle ages is that childbirth is a dangerous thing so most of the time the concubines are all nubile.
Yes, and I want to be able to call on his vassal levy if needed, and for that he needs to have a positive opinion.I don't ever think he'll rebel, he's a loyal Norse lad; but I agree he has a point and deserves a spot in the council![]()
No, Grimr is already occupying that - did that to keep him on-side.Wasn't it possible to take him to the advisor position?
I don't really mneed to keep him on side that much - he's just a commander, so as long as he fights ...Well at least you didn't give the guy's wife to someone elseSpeaking of which, if he's not married, marrying him to a suitable woman might change his mood. It always works!
He's had a good long time, so anything from here is a bonus. It would free up a council position though. But I want someone pretty good in it, not just a displeased vassal hack.I hope he beats it but small chance. He's well liked and a great person.
Yes, they are slowly fading away and there will be more of that in the next little period. But the local raiding scene is indeed humming - a Viking pub crawl!The old guard is being replaced. But a new raid sounds most diverting.
Þordis perhaps, though Eilif will have a look to see if anyone more promising has turned up with the passage of a bit of time. Another talent show may be needed!There were a few good choices there for concubines. Þordis might also make a good addition as concubine, strong and healthy as she is (concubine limit is three). Personally, I always tend to search for attractive concubines.
Yes, that's good. Converting his religion at least would go a long way to mending relations. Looks like making the kingdom Norse culturally will take eons!That Tyuey isn't zealous is far better for your chance of conversion, which would be much lower if he was.
Happy for the Catholics to be in trouble for as long as possible. And I think Eilif is stabilising - time aids his opinion around the realm and his actions - especially the raiding - help both with the money and prestige (which also cements his position).Looks like the Catholics go through troubled times. Edla coming from Metz, pagans in Swabia, and a prepared invasion targeting Italy. Meanwhile, Eilif's reign seems fairly stable for now.
Yes, the needs come first. Given Þorfinn's character and Eilif's clumsy interpersonal skills and 'dullness', I thought it worth hamming it up a bit! And Þorfinn had only been Marshal since Helgi had died (Rurik had suspected he might be a follower of Hel and had kept him sidelined after he emigrated to Gardariki), so it wasn't like sacking a long-term retainer.Others have already covered the raider looting query well enough, so I'll basically second what they've said.
It's a bit unfortunate seeing Þorfinn booted from the Marshal's seat like that, especially given Eiliff's somewhat... abrupt manner of dismissal -- but the needs of the realm come first, of course. It is certainly well that the king has so many competent leaders to draw upon to fill the position.
Speaking of which (ie Hel), there's been no obvious evidence of their activities or influence that I've noticed. Just the normal Slovensky murderous activities and royal family hatreds. No werewolves, suspiciously missing children, heads in bags (just making that up) etc. Like Rurik, Eilif doesn't have one of the seven deadly sins as a trait, so he couldn't join anyway. Helgi, had he lived to succeed, did, though ... that might have been an interesting 'learning experience'!
ᚔ ᚱᚢᚱᛁᚲᛁᛞ ᚔ
OK, thanks for those who commented this time round and all who read. The next session is played, screenies edited and words written. Just need to upload. If not tonight (my time) then hopefully in the morning!
- 1