• We have updated our Community Code of Conduct. Please read through the new rules for the forum that are an integral part of Paradox Interactive’s User Agreement.
You always do. :confused:
What is this supposed to mean? :confused:

Wow I had that update up 2 minutes after the deadline. That's how you GM a game. :cool:
Thank you very much for a good GM'ship so far.

Back on topic: As others have said, a TIE is the best course of action. I'll make my vote for Jester for now, and will try to keep the TIE later.

Vote Jester180
 
I am not the Warlock, it was a ploy to see if I could capture any wolves. It failed, and I got nothing. Lynch me if you must, but that is what happened. The only way to clear myself is to have the Seer scan me, but that has not happened as far as I know.

Nautilu must of freaked out when he saw my message.
 
Vote Jester180

I do not agree with lynching punkbob. I think he is telling the truth. I wished Nautilu had waited a bit longer before outing him, since I am sure more warlock claimants would have presented themselves.
 
What appears to have happened is some evil character contacts Jens claiming to be the seer. There have been two nights and the 'seer' has made two scans, one identifying Nautilu as a wolf and then another identifying Jens as a villager. The 'seer' then instructs Jens to out Nautilu, and Nautilu is promptly lynched. Because the 'seer' is actually a wolf he then has Jens hunted to cover his tracks.

Holy hell, Polar made sense.

It makes sense to try that.
But in my experience it often fails :(

So IMHO we can better go for one target.
Shall I change my vote to Jester (if you really believe he's a wolf) ?

We just hang anyone who breaks the TIE. Simples.

You will forget to vote... YOU WILL FORGET TO VOTE!

No, I won't. Vote Punkbob He might be innocent, but it could be that he really is Dave. If he is Dave, then we need shot of him. He is the only thing between us and a 4th term in office.

The people who don't help keep the tie are the ones most probable to be wolves, as well.

Yup
 
Jonti: Who is this Dave you speak of?

I am honestly surprised that Naty lite took me seriously after I "outed" myself yesterday. But he was understandably freaked out.

Sorta reminds me of what Slinky did a few games ago, where I freaked out...
 
OK I'm not sure why people think I'm a wolf because Nautilu said I was. It's now apparent that Jensthemens was lying but for what reason I don't know. His post seems to indicate that someone lied to him.

Nautilu simply stated that he was contacted by a JL member but gave no further details even when asked to clarify that point. Could this simply not a ploy by the wolves. One gives Jensthemens false information another contacts Nautilu giving further false information knowing by that point Nautilu can't prevent his own death. Lynching me therefore simply gives the wolves what they want the villagers killing each other while they sit back and laugh.

As for Punkbob I have no idea if he's telling the truth or not but Nautilu did state he was contacted directly by him however at that stage he may simply have been trying to save his own life, Punkbob may simply have been a handy scap goat.

At this stage I'm going to think about things and vote when I get back from work tomorrow night.
 
OK I'm not sure why people think I'm a wolf because Nautilu said I was. It's now apparent that Jensthemens was lying but for what reason I don't know. His post seems to indicate that someone lied to him.

Jens was obviously lied to. But on the same day, nautilu had a similar PM. I don't think any group of wolves would be stupid enough to send out two of those PM's. They could only cover their butt on one of them, while the other would out a wolf. The only other option is that nautilu was contacted by the real seer.

Nautilu simply stated that he was contacted by a JL member but gave no further details even when asked to clarify that point. Could this simply not a ploy by the wolves. One gives Jensthemens false information another contacts Nautilu giving further false information knowing by that point Nautilu can't prevent his own death. Lynching me therefore simply gives the wolves what they want the villagers killing each other while they sit back and laugh.
That would take some real guts. This early in the game, that might be too big of a risk to take. However, this might be the only time of the game it would work at all. :confused:

As for Punkbob I have no idea if he's telling the truth or not but Nautilu did state he was contacted directly by him however at that stage he may simply have been trying to save his own life, Punkbob may simply have been a handy scap goat.
While I'm not 100% convinced Punkbob is the warlock, there is some evidence that he is, and this evidence is coming from a dead villager.
 
As for Punkbob I have no idea if he's telling the truth or not but Nautilu did state he was contacted directly by him however at that stage he may simply have been trying to save his own life, Punkbob may simply have been a handy scap goat.
Punkbob has already admitted he sent the PM to Nautilu. The only question is was it a fake PM to try and get the names of some wolves or was it the real thing. Nautilu didn't make it up to save his skin though.
 
Last edited:
:rofl:

Awesomely done :D
 
Punkbob has already admitted he sent the PM to Nautilu. The only question is was it a fake PM to try and get the names of some wolves or was it the real thing. Nautilu didn't make it up to save his skin though.

This is the point. The PM did exist, all to debate is whether it was sent to mine information, or to link up to the baddies.
 
Well if Nautilu is to be trusted and people seem to, I will Vote Jester.
 
This is the point. The PM did exist, all to debate is whether it was sent to mine information, or to link up to the baddies.

Indeed, but Jester was suggesting Nautilu made it up using Punkbob as a scape goat. Either Jester isn't paying attention or he is clutching at straws to defend an ally.