• We have updated our Community Code of Conduct. Please read through the new rules for the forum that are an integral part of Paradox Interactive’s User Agreement.
But the Arch King took a fancy to young princess Siofra Tudor
A Wittlesbach and a Tudor. A very powerful bloodline.
The tiny free state of Ulm had gone Protestant
Tiny free state? Don't underestimate the power of mighty Ulm!
under her 70 year old young Emperor Christian.
If you have enough states, there's an achievement for having a ruler over 70. "Live Long and Prosper." Might not be possible with your goals this campaign.
 
  • 1Like
Reactions:
It's a lucky thing that Christian is able to live so long by (I assume) feeding on the life-force of his wives.
 
  • 1Like
Reactions:
1) RNG. I have been very lucky that my 6/5/6 ruler has reigned from 15 to (at least) 70. Great stats during one of the most crucial periods of the game ( when you fill 2 idea groups simultaneously and tech is so important and you have to Dev for Colonialism). He outlived 2 wives and 2 heirs. I will never, ever complain about RNG the rest of this campaign. My heirs can die hunting, fall on stairs or fall ill and I will not raise a peep.
The monkey's paw curls.....
Be careful when invoking the RNGods for they are fickle and their wrath comes swiftly.

But yes, a ruler like that at the start of your game can do wonders.
 
  • 2Like
Reactions:
If this was CK (or Project Caesar definitely not EU5) it would be interesting to see the family tree.

He's certainly doing very well for himself, King Christian.

I am more and more convinced that we have a vampire bloodline

It's a lucky thing that Christian is able to live so long by (I assume) feeding on the life-force of his wives.


Margrete of Lund must be the original vampire - married a much younger man, outlived her granddaughter. Somehow the power passed to him.

If you have enough states, there's an achievement for having a ruler over 70. "Live Long and Prosper."

I am at 23 states. Not all with prosperity. Maybe one of Christian's successors.

but could still preemptibly use a merchant in Lubeck node to stablish communities,

Keep forgetting to use this tip. thanks for the reminder. I am working on getting an extra merchant from Colonial Nation.

The monkey's paw curls.....
Be careful when invoking the RNGods for they are fickle and their wrath comes swiftly.

Unless you have my luck and have the imposed heir being disinherited and waste the favors.

Providing an heir for Bohemia can be a gamble, as they have a elective monarchy and can pick a different king

So this is how the run will go. Get very lucky with ruler, but then every time a Bohemian, Hungarian or Castilian ruler dies, they have an immediate heir, or disinherit the heir I give them.
 
  • 4Like
Reactions:
Chapter 9: The Monkey's Paw (1520-1530)
Chapter 9: The Monkey's Paw (1520-1530)

The 1520s started with Christian I the Great still leading Denmark, now indisputably the strongest power on the planet. And yet also the "innocent" defender in wars against the Hanseatic cities . Two of those four wars were already concluded in the last chapter. The next one to finish was with Catholic Hamburg , who got fully annexed.

1 Hamburga annexed.png


That event did sour relations with the Catholics of Europe, but luckily the Emperor had a chance to mend fences a bit by banning the translation of the Bible from Latin.

2 NO bible translation.png


Soon after it was Bremen's turn to conclude the last war with the Hansa.
3 bremen annexed.png


That peace put all the important ports in Northern Germany in Danish hands. Trade dominance in the Lubeck node was now assured. But Denmark had taken some aggressive expansion reputation hit with those wars, and Christian thought it was best to limit wars in Europe for a while. So to satisfy his appetite for conquest, he turned to the Americas, where Denmark's colonies were getting close to becoming a new colonial nation . And that would be significantly sped up by conquering land from the natives, a process much faster than building colonies from the ground up.

4 DOW POwhatan.png


WE will not describe that war on Powhatan, but instead update the map and diplomatic situation in Europe, where Bohemia continued her expansion .


5 bohemia dow polotsk ryazan march.png

And annoyingly the very weak HRE ( Ansbach) demanded the return of Stettin, or else. This was shrugged off, but it did affect relations with the other Germans . And Ryzana was made into a March to help with their manpower and military forces ( in fact, Denmark generally favored turning all her vassals and Client States into Marches since she did not need their monetary contribution anymore).

In the meantime, the war in the Americas ended with Denmark annexing 3 native provinces.

6 Powhatan war ends.png


The Emperor now eagerly waited for those provinces to become cores of Denmark. Meanwhile, he assessed the Ottoman threat which had continued to grow despite the defeat that Denmark dealt them in the last war.


7 break mamluk.png


The Ottomans had been able to bypass the Danish-Mamluk alliance by declaring war on Cyprus, guaranteed by Mamluks. And were now in the process of defeating their middle eastern rival. Seeing that the alliance with the Mamluks was now just a diplomatic drain , the Emperor cancelled it . And instead, he decided to hamstring the Ottoman economy by sending the fleet to privateer in Constantinople ( made possible by owning the province of Abkhazia). And those privateers were to receive extra training in the old pirate dens of Visby City in Gotland, which were being renovated for that purpose.

After that, the Emperor, now 72 , celebrated his third wedding , this time with Dorothea of Pontus

8 dorothea.png


And then he pretended to be supportive of his ally Bohemia who continued their expansion in Germany.

9 bohemia to bavaria.png


With dreams of the triple BPL crown still alive , Emperor Christian did not want to lose that very important alliance. Although seeing his Wittlesbach cousin's lands get whittled away distressed him . As for Denmark, the only expansion she was doing at the time was far away in America, where wars on weak natives continued

10 DOW mohwak.png


IN a quick 6 months war , Denmark annexed two costal provinces from the Mohawk nation. The war was kept brief as Denmark was not interested in Mohawk money and could not annex inland provinces. A similarly short war on Fox was done soon after


11 war on fox.png


That war netted Denmark two provinces: one in Colonial Canada region, and one in Colonial Eastern America. The next year brought another war on the natives, this time further south where Denmark used her colonist to help fabricate a claim on the Cofitachequi

12 Cofitachequi war.png


But before that war finished, important events happened. First, the cognoscenti of Europe declared the Age of Discovery over and that Europe was now in the Age of Reformation .


14 new objectives.png


The Emperor, now old and set in his ways, did not really like the new objectives. Denmark was still mostly catholic and was not going to embrace the new heresy of Protestantism, at least not on his watch. And he did not care much to convert provinces or nations in Germany, what with the Centers of Reformation there being very active. About the only province conversion that Denmark undertook so far were of native provinces' in the New World. And people expected Denmark to trade in Spice and Tea, when the Cape Province was not in the maps available to his realm!!. But what worried him the most was the loss Denmark's special age ability regarding subject loyalty.


15 subjects still loyal.png


But fortunately, thanks to his half century of effort growing Denmark, the subjects remained extremely loyal .

The second big event was the birth of the Colonial Nation of Atwixia, named after the legendary strategist admired by the Emperor and many others.

16 atwixia born.png

That nation was based out of the city of Massachusett , recently taken from the Mohawk tribe. And it already boasted over 10 provinces, which allowed it to contribute a merchant enterprise to Denmark's economy.

17 new merchant.png


That merchant was promptly sent to the Saxony trade node to divert her trade towards Lubeck instead of Rhineland. And while at it, he was instructed to establish communities with the locals, imrpoving Denmark's relations in the area ( h/t @alonsom13 ) ( a similar request was given to the merchant in the Champagne node as well ) . The new merchant helped boost Denmark's trade income significantly , jumping from 50 to 57 ducats monthly.

18 ottos and hungary austria.png

Meanwhile in interesting international news, the Ottoman Empire, the only valid rival of Denmark, was still growing stronger absorbing its neighbors to the East. Although they would soon face a powerful Timurid Empire. And Denmark's strong ally Hungary was poised to become stronger after declaring restoration of Union war on Austria ( who was HRE at the time ) .

Meanwhile in North America, Denmark conquered two more provinces that were immediately added to Atwixia.
19 south caronla counts feud.png


At that point, Emperor Christian saw no point in helping Atwixia further as they had reached the 10-province point that he cared about, and he wanted to focus on expansion in Colonial Canada and also in Africa. And he was also keeping a wary eye on a conspiracy being cooked by Count Christoffer of Oldenburg.

In Africa, the French and Spanish ( formerly Castilians) had claimed most of the coastal land. And the only unclaimed provinces were out of Colonial reach for Denmark. So to help with that, a colony was started in Alcantara in South America.

20 africa range.png


But that was going to take a long time. And old Emperor Christian was getting impatient. And so he decided the best way to get a foothold in Africa was to take a European colony. Since he was allied to the Spanish , that left the French as the only target. And thus preparations for war with France were begun. But before we get to that, we note the creation of Denmark's second colonial nation in North America, in what is today called Canada. But back then it was called Vinland

21 vinland born.png


Vinland was smaller than Atwixia and still needed help to reach the key number of 10 provinces. But that will be dealt with later. Another thing the Emperor needed to take care of before declaring war on France was accomplishing some Danish missions related to trade.

21b trade missions needed.png


These missions promised hefty rewards but one of the requirements was having trade be more than 50% of Denmark's income- and it was very close at 46% already. So Emperor Christian recalled the fleet from privateering Constantinople ( despite being very effective at that ) , and sent it back to the Channel to protect trade.


22 privateer stop.png


He then hired a Trader as diplomatic advisor, and that was enough to push trade income to 71 ducats per months, and cross the threshold. And then he proclaimed the missions "Cities of the Hansa " , "Expand The Sound Toll" and "Control the Channel" accomplished.


23 trade missions.png


As a result , the royal treasury got a windfall of 4 years of trade income and trade income itself increased even more .

24 new money.png


With the treasury flush with ducats, he felt ready to declare war on France in January 1526.

25 DOW France.png


For the war, he was unable to call on Hungary as they were still in the process of turning Austria into their junior partner. But both Spain and Bohemia were willing to join, as they owed Denmark 99 and 90 favors respectively. Emperor Christian decided to call the Spanish , but not the Bohemians, just in case he had the chance of using the favors to install a von Wittlesbach on either throne.

And of course, not even one month into the war, the ruler of Spain died and his young successor, 19 year old Enrique VII took the throne. That left an heir vacancy in Spain as Enrique was still unmarried. But Denmark did not have enough favors to have him select a von Wittlesbach.

26 spanish king dies.png

Observers thought that fate was playing with our old Emperor, and that his streak of great luck had run out. But Christian called on whatever talisman or dark magic he has used all these years, and lo and behold, Enrique remained single until one of Christian's many grandchildren was appointed heir.

27 vittlesbach heir of spain.png

At the same time the great fortress of Chartres fell to his troops, and his ally Hungary managed to create a Personal Union over weak Austria.

Things were therefore looking very good for our Emperor. And he soon got to celebrate the completion of Diplomatic Ideas and with it the completion of all of Denmark's national ideas giving her improved naval engagement width. And he activated the Mercenary-Diplomatic policy of Diplomatic Arms Act , giving Denmark two more relations slots [net of +1 since policy uses 1 DIP].

28 all ideas full.png

When his heir, the future Christian II , was born , courtiers were pleased with his diplomatic skills thinking they would be useful for completing the Diplomatic Ideas group. But no one anticipated that Christian the first would actually be the one to carry that out, making his successor's diplomacy skills less relevant.


Meanwhile the war in France was pursued methodically, and French counterattacks were handily repulsed at Paris and Chartres.
29 war in france.png


ANd the Emperor took time to settle a score with the governor of Copenhagen Castle who apparently poisoned his mistress Dyveke ( Dorothea of Pontus must not have been meeting his needs ).

30 pluralistic gov.png


And as if he was some superhuman being feeding on a unnatural energy source, he then had his diplomats declare war on Cree in the North American continent.

31 DOW Cree.png

The purpose of that war was to gain more land for VInland, and get her as large as her sister colony Atwixia. And speaking of Atwixia, Denmark was forced to defend her against an attack by the Creek confederation.

32 defend atwixia.png



And thus Denmark was involved in three simultaneous wars when good old Emperor Christian finally died ( of a heart attack while having sex if I had to guess), at the ripe age of 78.

33 christian dies.png


Christian was so beloved , skilled and lucky that even in death he managed to grow the realm of Denmark. But here he was *too lucky*, if there is such a thing . Because as unlikely as it was to happen, the people and nobles of not just the Palatinate, but also Norway, decided to become an integral part of Denmark . Both nations were bequeathed as full inheritances to his grandson Christian II. In normal times, most would consider such an event a fortuitous occurrence. But the special structure of the Kalmar union meant that Denmark was actually weaker as she lost the manpower bonuses of her Personal Unions, who themselves had the bonuses of Marches. And Denmark also lost the bonuses gained from the "Degradation of the Norwegian Crown" mission . Not to mention taking a huge step back towards the goal of having 10 personal unions ( so from having 4 unions out of 10 at one time , we are now down to 1) . Add to that the problem of having Norwegian land with unaccepted culture to deal with.

34 degradation is lost.png


Christian II could not believe his (mis)fortune at this turn of events. But all he could think of were the words of his late father's friend:

The monkey's paw curls.....
Be careful when invoking the RNGods for they are fickle and their wrath comes swiftly.


But kind-hearted Christian II collected himself and began the long journey of leading his nation to more glory . He first signed peace with the Maliseet tribe in Canada, adding one province to Vinland.

35 maliseet annexed.png


And then he was about to direct the war in France when news reached him of the French sack of Heidelberg, now a Danish province and not the capital of the Palatinate anymore. And right on the heels of that misfortune, he faced the revolt of the Count of Oldenburg, known to history as the Count's Feud.

36 cound feud.png


Christian's life and throne hung in the balance for a while ,as the nobility and the army weighed their choices between supporting him or supporting the pretender. The Pretender had similar skills but much better legitimacy. But he was a von Oldenburg and not a Wittlesbach, and that meant the family ties Denmark had with Pontus, Gallia and most importantly the heir-apparent of Spain would be broken. And so the court and army threw its support behind Christian and against the Pretender

37 support the monarch.png


But that still meant Christian had to divert troops from the French war to suppress the Pretender rebels in Dithmarschen and Chelmno. And that meant France enjoyed temporary success on the battlefield.


38 temporry french victory.png


But after defeating the first rebel troops , and then another rebellion in Osel, Christian was able to draw on the administrative resources saved by his Grandfather , as well as a lot of unused Papal Influence to increase the stability of the Kingdom and end the feud.

39 end the feud.png


After that point there were no more challenges to Christian's authority or legitimacy, and he renewed the royal marriages with Spain , Hungary and Bohemia. He also managed to conclude the war with Cree in America, adding more land to Vinland.

40 added Shaggami.png

ANd similarly he grew Atwixia at the expense of the Creek federation, who regretted their rash attack against the Colonizers.

41 added Creek provinces.png


ANd with those wars over, he was able to focus his attention on the French war . And after getting France's allies ( Switzerland, Lorraine and Florence) out of the war, he was in a position to impose a maximalist peace on France in October 1529. But he held out till January 1, 1530 to take advantage of advice and inspiration that historically happened a lot in our histories on New Year days. And so as we close the chapter, he has various options of peace with France.

42 possible peace gallia.png


He could go for growing Gallia, like his grandfather planned. But that was going to generate a lot of enmity . HE also has options to release nations like Toulouse .

43 toulouse option.png


Or annex less and release Provence:

44 provence option.png

The choice Christian makes is very important. Because that will set the overall strategy for his nation for a century or more. You see, after the inheritance of Norway, it has become apparent that fickle fate was going to be Denmark's most implacable foe in her quest of having 10 personal unions. And there are two strategies Denmark can go about to do that. First, create and grow client states with the Wittlesbach dynasty all over Europe then turn them into Personal Unions by force later. That is the military route to forge the European Union with steel . The second strategy is the diplomatic route , where DEnmark cultivates relations with as many nations as possible, spreading her dynasty through favors and marriage, and feeding land to Wittlesbach allies over time. THat strategy requires luck and as many viable nations as possible to turn into Wittlesbach allies. The French peace option annexing land to Gallia is implementing the fist strategy. The option of releasing Provence as a free nation with whom Denmakr can earn favors and turn into a good ally is implementing the second strategy. Our kind-hearted Christian ( yes, that is his trait) favors the second option, but he is open to advice.

The other big decision Christian has to make is the status of Norway.

46 culture acceptance.png


Norway is not accepted culture and that problem needs to be addressed. Christian is considering three options

1. Keep the land as part of Denmark and eventually accept Norwegian when possible ( through technology, Humanist Ideas or government reform changes) .

2. Release Norwegian land back as either Norway itself ( gets Iceland and the Shetlands and Faroes) , or a new client state

3. Give the Norwegian lands to Sweden ( same culture group) who will then be certainly not inheritable in the future. As Sweden's home trade node is in Baltic, and Norwegian lands are downstream of that , this will have little detriment to Denmark's trade. Also Denmark can concentrate the development from Norway into Zeeland ( and even a new capital if needed) to avoid making Sweden too powerful.

Our young Emperor has made his leaning towards the third option known , but again , he is awaiting advice and inspiration over New Year's eve


Finally, the domains of Christian II
45 Status.png
 
Last edited:
  • 1Like
Reactions:
I'm not an EU4 expert by any means but the Swedish option makes a lot of sense to me.
 
Not to mention taking a huge step back towards the goal of having 10 personal unions ( so from having 4 unions out of 10 at one time , we are now down to 1) .
I have a feeling the goal will require a balancing act between keeping Denmark strong enough individually so the PUs don't break free and keeping the PUs too big to be inherited. Either that or trying to cheese it at the end by having the last ruler continuously claiming thrones and surviving long enough to claim and conquer enough.
 
The old warlock (for surely he was) of dead. And his death unleashes the strange and mysterious inheritance curse upon the realm. Who knew ? :)

As to the options, give how out of date my gameplay knowledge is but it seems like option 1 would probably be the "safe" course, but option 2 sounds rather more engaging.
 
After that, the Emperor, now 72 , celebrated his third wedding , this time with Dorothea of Pontus
The more kids Christian I has, the more chances to marry them off and spread his dynasty (if EU4 kept track of such things).
And he did not care much to convert provinces or nations in Germany, what with the Centers of Reformation there being very active.
If a Center happens to be on a capital of a nation, will you go for force conversion to delete the Center?
And Denmark's strong ally Hungary was poised to become stronger after declaring restoration of Union war on Austria ( who was HRE at the time ) .
Another chance at a double union!
Does the 25% trade efficiency you got here from the English Channel mission apply to your whole nation? It seems like quite a lot!
Our kind-hearted Christian ( yes, that is his trait) favors the second option, but he is open to advice.
Second option sounds like it is more in the spirit of the achievement and challenge.
3. Give the Norwegian lands to Sweden ( same culture group) who will then be certainly not inheritable in the future. As Sweden's home trade node is in Baltic, and Norwegian lands are downstream of that , this will have little detriment to Denmark's trade. Also Denmark can concentrate the development from Norway into Zeeland ( and even a new capital if needed) to avoid making Sweden too powerful.
I say give it to Sweden so you have a "guaranteed" union that won't get inherited. And Sweden is already loyal, so I don't think the Norwegian land will tip them over the edge.
 
ANd the Emperor took time to settle a score with the governor of Copenhagen Castle who apparently poisoned his mistress Dyveke ( Dorothea of Pontus must not have been meeting his needs ).
life-force stealing to the max...
Observers thought that fate was playing with our old Emperor, and that his streak of great luck had run out. But Christian called on whatever talisman or dark magic he has used all these years, and lo and behold, Enrique remained single until one of Christian's many grandchildren was appointed heir.
... to appease the RNGods
And thus Denmark was involved in three simultaneous wars when good old Emperor Christian finally died ( of a heart attack while having sex if I had to guess), at the ripe age of 78.
Speaking of going with a bang
But he was a von Oldenburg and not a Wittlesbach, and that meant the family ties Denmark had with Pontus, Gallia and most importantly the heir-apparent of Spain would be broken. And so the court and army threw its support behind Christian and against the Pretender
Blood is ticker than water. And murkier, or something.
But after defeating the first rebel troops , and then another rebellion in Osel, Christian was able to draw on the administrative resources saved by his Grandfather , as well as a lot of unused Papal Influence to increase the stability of the Kingdom and end the feud.
Keep your friends close, and your enemies (and unused points) closer.


I´m guessing if Norway comes back, the bonuses from PU can't be recovered, even if release as vassal, put dinasty, break vassal, force PU.
If that's the case, IMHO you could go for client states, there and everywhere else. It's not common to have the option this early, and prepare the seeds (dinastic and otherwise) for future release and catch with claim throne cb. Easier to go for achievement. And also gives the chance of molding them to proper borders/cultures like east holdings for the goal of the campaign of EU. Something Bismark something Iron and blood. Without dealing with the install dinasty on friends and grow them to avoid accidental inheritances. Granted, AE should be managed properly, but since you are not convertig religious centers of reformation, should be doable. My vote is for more Gallias. **cough and has nothing to do with diplomatic approach being too similar to current run/aar-in-the-making of yours truly cough**
 
I'm not an EU4 expert by any means but the Swedish option makes a lot of sense to me.

I say give it to Sweden so you have a "guaranteed" union that won't get inherited. And Sweden is already loyal, so I don't think the Norwegian land will tip them over the edge.

I´m guessing if Norway comes back, the bonuses from PU can't be recovered, even if release as vassal, put dinasty, break vassal, force PU.
Correct. Bonuses came from mission which cannot be resuscitated. They are gone forever. So no point in wasting a diplo slot on a new Norway.

I agree with Cora and jak. Better have a guaranteed PU that does not get inherited, and I doubt Sweden will every be disloyal.
 
Second option sounds like it is more in the spirit of the achievement and challenge.

Agree with this. BUt I worry it is too luck based.
IMHO you could go for client states, there and everywhere else. It's not common to have the option this early, and prepare the seeds (dinastic and otherwise) for future release and catch with claim throne cb. Easier to go for achievement. And also gives the chance of molding them to proper borders/cultures like east holdings for the goal of the campaign of EU. Something Bismark something Iron and blood. Without dealing with the install dinasty on friends and grow them to avoid accidental inheritances.

Also agree with this . This approach is more effective. But the AE and relations hits can be a huge problem. Also still needs luck because even if Wittlesbach they can still have heirs.

I have a feeling the goal will require a balancing act between keeping Denmark strong enough individually so the PUs don't break free and keeping the PUs too big to be inherited. Either that or trying to cheese it at the end

It will be a balancing act. And I think I will pursue both strategies simultaneously. Keep feeding the 2 clients I already have ( Gallia into French land, since it is hopeless to get France to become a PU diplomatically , and Pontus can expand in Ottoman land which has to be conquered ( Muslim). ) But at same time I will cultivate marriage and relations will all others. Denmark is so powerful that everyone will ally / marry it. And with the Diplomatic ideas finisher I can always enter and break marriages at will .
 
The old warlock (for surely he was) of dead. And his death unleashes the strange and mysterious inheritance curse upon the realm. Who knew ? :)

The more kids Christian I has, the more chances to marry them off and spread his dynasty (if EU4 kept track of such things).

life-force stealing to the max...

He had the Fertile trait after all . I like how eu4 gives just enough character info to imagine an interesting person. Wonder how Christian II will be remembered.

Does the 25% trade efficiency you got here from the English Channel mission apply to your whole nation? It seems like quite a lot!

Yes. Trade efficiency applies globally. Yes, bonuses of Denmark missions are OP ( they want you to buy the DLC ;) )


If a Center happens to be on a capital of a nation, will you go for force conversion to delete the Center?

No. I want a religiously fragmented Germany. Monolithic catholic does not help me with AE. So I am keeping the Centers.
**cough and has nothing to do with diplomatic approach being too similar to current run/aar-in-the-making of yours truly cough**
Happy to hear you are going ahead with it. I will certainly follow and hope to pick up some helpful tips there.
 
I also agree with feeding Sweden the Norwegian lands.

As for the French peace treaty, I may have an alternative at this time:
Do you need to grow Gallia already? Do you even need that land connection at this moment?
Perhaps you could give some Breton lands to Leinster. I'm assuming you want to feed them Scottish and Welsh land eventually, but that means they will have room to accept a bit more.
Besides that, maybe release nations closer to your borders like Normandy so Spain doesn't beat you to those lands. And so you have a chance to increase your control over the English Channel trade.
Also, do you have to give Spain provinces at this moment? It may be good to keep some of their cores in French hands so they don't form an annoying alliance.


There's 1 thing i've been wondering though: a nation becoming an empire can form a cultural union.
And while PU's can change government rank, vassals can't.
Are you planning on growing nations like Gallia to 1000 dev for empire rank or are you planning to work on smaller PU's without the cultural union?
Because you very often concentrate development first, so will that have a noticeable effect on when your subjects can form a cultural union?


I like the title of this last chapter, i managed to score 2 titles in this AAR already :D
(and soon i will be Gimli with '2 already!' and some Legolas can say 'i'm on 17' )
 
  • 1Like
Reactions:
Do you need to grow Gallia already?
At some point I want to grow them so they can be a useful vassal/march and eventually turn into a PU. No hurry though.

Do you even need that land connection at this moment?

It is nice to have. Disconnected lands are a nuisance ( e.g I could end up with an exiled army stuck in Gallia if Lorraine would not give me access). But it is not essential.


Perhaps you could give some Breton lands to Leinster.

Feeding Breton to Leinster or Francien to Gallia is pretty equivalent in terms of AE . YOu are right that eventually Leinster will be given Wales
Besides that, maybe release nations closer to your borders like Normandy so Spain doesn't beat you to those lands. And so you have a chance to increase your control over the English Channel trade.

NOrman culture exists, but there are no Normandy cores . I don;t know when Paradox removed them. In my Oda run I looked for them, and thought they were expired. BUt they are not in this run either. Eventually I will annex Normandy outright for CHannel control and likely accept Norman culture (role play appropriate too - NOrman is norse men , which is Danish /Viking origin)

I can release tags like Gascony, Toulouse , Auvergne etc. I think Gascony is too big ( I will not have much left in peace treaty ) and certainly cannot diplo-vassalize. Toulouse may or may not be vassalizable . If I cannot diplo-vassalize , I can turn Toulouse into ally to grow and install a Wittlesbach eventually via favors.

Also, do you have to give Spain provinces at this moment? It may be good to keep some of their cores in French hands so they don't form an annoying alliance.

Good point. I was thinking about earning back some favors in the peace treaty. But keeping them enemies with France is better. I will not give them Barcelona.

Are you planning on growing nations like Gallia to 1000 dev for empire rank or are you planning to work on smaller PU's without the cultural union?

Not to 1000 Dev. THere is not enough space in Europe to do that with more than a couple of nations . PLus liberty desire will be very high ( they get 0.15 LD per Dev, so realistically cannot keep loyal if bigger than 300 and still divert trade ) .

I do want to grow them to 30 provinces or so each , to avoid inheriting them like Norway. At about 10 Dev per province, we are looking at about 300 Dev or so. I have not counted how many provinces exist in EUrope, but if we do a quick math of 10 PUs x 30 provinces each, we are looking at a minimum of 300 provinces . I may need to have PUs outside of Europe to get to the 10 ( I really want to have 10 PUs passed from father to son at least once, not just get the achievement and then quit the run ) .


I like the title of this last chapter, i managed to score 2 titles in this AAR already :D
It was very appropriate. I actually had to look up the MOnkey's Paw reference and the story is quite instructive.
 
  • 1Like
Reactions:
I think giving Sweden the Norway provinces makes the most sense - two birds with one stone.

I also like the option of going for more “natural” PUs that you grow enough to keep without inheriting, rather than client state -> force union. It does seem more in the spirit. And also lets you use the rather awesome “PU’s get march bonuses” thing. If you end up not getting enough you can always round it out with the direct approach later.
 
  • 1
Reactions:
NOrman culture exists, but there are no Normandy cores . I don;t know when Paradox removed them. In my Oda run I looked for them, and thought they were expired. BUt they are not in this run either. Eventually I will annex Normandy outright for CHannel control and likely accept Norman culture (role play appropriate too - NOrman is norse men , which is Danish /Viking origin)
When France takes all of Normandy they have a mission to destroy all Norman cores
 
  • 1
  • 1Like
Reactions:
Chapter 10: A Fervent Prayer for Tolerance and Good Relations (1530-1540)
Note: some screenshots have failed to upload. I will try to upload them again tomorrow .

Chapter 10: A Fervent Prayer for Tolerance and Good Relations (1530-1540)

Emperor Christian II spent New Year's Eve of 1530 in the Royal Chapel in Zeeland. This was in stark contrast to his grandfather, who typically celebrated the occasion in a drunken party among friends and mistresses . Instead, Christian II went into the chapel alone, taking with him a (translated) bible, some religious tracts written by the reformers in Warsaw and Ulm , and a note written by his diplomatic advisor.

1. install heir relation.png

The note explained why the Catholics of Europe looked askance at his grandfather installing a Wittelsbach as heir to the Spanish throne, and warned that if he were to repeat that feat, Denmark would generate a lot of animosity. But the note also gave him a way to avoid that and maintain good relations with his neighbors [but see footnote].

Christian then looked at the writings of the Protestants of Ulm and their arguments in favor of their faith

2 protestant.png

Finally he looked at the recent writings of Reformers from Warsaw, who took a tolerant view of Religion and government, more in line with his personal leanings.

3 reformed.png


When he emerged in the morning from the Chapel, his advisors asked him how he spent the night. Our kind-hearted ruler's only reply was "I fervently prayed for tolerance and good relations among mankind".

He then went to the palace to address the peace treaty with France.

4 peace france.png


Although he was initially leaning towards giving Spain some provinces in Iberia. he changed his mind based on external advice ( h/t @Steckie ) and after realizing that the Spanish had occupied the Ivory Coast province he wanted. So Spain got nothing, and instead the big winner was Toulouse who was released as a free nation. Also released was the Duchy of Bar based out of Verdun, which connected Gallia to the Low Countries , and was expected to agree to becoming a vassal. Denmark also took Calais, an important center of trade with Walloon culture that would be a permanent part of Denmark. And Paris was pillaged to grow Zeeland.

And the first important question after the peace treaty was whether Toulouse, fairly large but less than 100 development, would accept vassal status. And it was close .

5 toulouse vassal.png


But after hiring a Diplomat and with some nudging from a Papal Legate, the Toulousians agreed, barely, to become a subject of Denmark. Bar was much easier to convince, and joined Denmark's subject family soon after. Christian planned for both vassals to be annexed into Denmark in 10 years , and then have their lands transferred to Gallia. Although that plan was going to waste diplomatic resources, he felt it was better than direct annexation from France which would have generated a lot of aggressive expansion.
6 toulouse and bar accept.png

During those diplomatic maneuvers, Christian's prayer for good relations was answered when the English decided to split away from Catholicism and establish their own church.

7 Anglican england.png


Since Christian was about to attack England in any case, having them turn heretic meant his relations with the catholic powers would not worsen, and that he would not need to worry about a Catholic Defender of the Faith protecting England. But before he attacked England, he had to settle the Norwegian question, and based on unanimous advice from his corresponding advisors ( all my readers were in favor) , he transferred all the provinces in Norway to Sweden ( Iceland and the North Atlantic Islands were not adjacent to Sweden to allow a transfer). Since Sweden was very loyal, he did not concentrate development from Norway to Zeeland, feeling that a stronger subject was a better option ( too much development would have been lost in the transfer) .

8 map after transfers.png


And then he surprised his advisors by announcing that his night of special prayer [ my unpausing for AAR ] had led him to decide that the tolerant Reformed faith was the best choice for Denmark, going against all his grandfather's previous proclamations that Catholicism was best . But he reassured his subjects that he would not impose the new faith by force, and made sure to issue edicts that preserved and even increased tolerance for Catholics and Protestants, even at the price of decreasing missionary strength. As a result of that tolerance, the religious unity of the Empire suffered only slightly, and there was never any danger of the disaster of religious turmoil taking place.

9 conversion to reform.png


Of course, Christian wanted his realm to convert to the new faith, and he proclaimed himself Defender of the Reformed faith, and he hired an inquisitor to spread the faith faster. And in that endeavor, he was helped by the new Center of Reformation in Breda and an older one in Warsaw , conveniently close to the Prussian provinces. He assigned his missionaries to the former capitals first ( Bornholm, Sjaelland, Jorvik, Scarborough) and then methodically converted all the English provinces, followed by Danish, Estonian and Scanians provinces, leaving the Low Countries to the center of Reformation.

While the conversion did not cause problems from Religious Unity ( despite what his grandfather predicted) , it did cause a major problem with Prestige as the rulers of Europe looked down on his decision . And that was a problem because Prestige was important in getting rid of aggressive expansion, and also incase he he had the chance to claim a throne, he needed high prestige. So to recover this prestige,he made sure that Denmark did NOT call on her allies when he next declared war on England:

10 DOW england.png


England was allied to Two Sicilies ( formerly Naples), Portugal and East Frisia. In England itself the war was fairly easy as Denmark quickly wiped out the English at Bedfordshire ( they were on their way to deal with religious rebels and got ambushed by the Danes). The war with Portugal spread to South America, where Denmark hired the Grand Company to attack Bahia, capital of Portuguese Brazil.

11 war in brazil.png

Unfortunately, as the Grand Company besieged Bahia, the Brazilians snuck up to Alcantara and illegally seized the colony by force.

Meanwhile in Europe, Danish armies besieged Lisboa and defeated a combined Sicilian and Portuguese force in Southern France/

12 war in france.png


But even without her allies, Denmark was still much stronger than the enemy alliance and eventually England's allies were peaced out one by one, starting with tiny Frisia early in the war

13 frisia out early.png


Frisia was forced to cancel treaties left and right, restoring some prestige to Emperor Christian II . Portugal came later, giving up Bahia, to atone for the stealth of Alcantara .

14 peace portugal.png


Although Denmark suffered some aggressive expansion penalty in the peace deal, Bahia was a good upgrade from Alcantara, being closer to Africa, but also containing the Salvador de Bahia monument, which inspired traders and settlers all over the world, and which Emperor Christian began to renovate as soon as the province was cored in 1534.

Two Sicilies exited the war in late 1532 for prestige and money ( the Emperor resited the urge to pillage Napoli, trying to manage Denmark's aggressive reputation). England followed soon after, but the peace was delayed till January 1 to minimize the potential coalition ( a process helped by the Emperor calling for a fervent focus on diplomacy every fall around October or November, to last till January or February) .


15 peace england.png


In the peace , Christian sought to maximize control of the Channel node while minimizing aggressive expansion . So he annexed the last two centers of trade in English Hands ( Gloucester and Hull) and just enough provinces to connect the Danish holdings on the island together. He then forced England to release Wales nd Gaeldom. He intended to vassalize and annex both nations by diplomatic means later on ( ideally after Bar and Toulouse have been annexed , but before the 15 year truce with England ended ) .

Our kind hearted ruler's efforts to manage aggressive expansion were rewarded by an alliance with his recent enemy Portugal.

16 marriage with portugal.png

THat made Denmark an ally of all the large nations of Catholic Europe, with the notable exception of France. Christian then sent a colonist to Beafada in Western Africa to being the process of advancing towards the Cape province, one of Denmark's national missions.

17 beafada colony started.png


Now one of the effects of waiting till January first to make peace with England was that coincided with the exact end of the truce with Ottomans from the previous war ( when the first Christian also waited till New Year). And Christian II did not want to risk them starting a coalition, so war was immediately declared on the Sultan , citing the conquest of Mansur in the Pontic Steppe.


18 Ottoman third war.png


Denmakr called onher allies Spain and Bohemia for the war. Hungary was willing to join, but Christian feared they had designs on Constantinople and so he made sure he called them AFTER he secured the city .
The first engagement of the war was in Slavonia, in the Hungarian plain, where Bohemia and Danish troops combined to defeat the Turks with relative ease.

19 slavonia battle.png


That victory and the sheer numerical superiority of the alliance over the Turks ( Denmark alone outnumbered them ) led to the fall of the enemy capital after a brief 41 day "siege" .

20 constantinople falls.png


At that point Christian called on Hungary to enter the fray, while Danish troops moved into Anatolia and captured fort after fort .
While that war raged, Danish colonists were busy establishing a presence around the Atlantic coast of Africa. Once Arguin became a core of Denmark, colonial range reached modern day Angola, and a colonist was promptly sent to Luanda.

21 arguin cored beging luanada.png


You see the Emperor was keen on advancing that project forward quickly, because Denmarks' Colonial Ambitions were fading away and her ability to explore terra incognita was not permanent. He estimated he had just about 20 years to round the Cape and explore as much of the Indian Ocean as possible.

Meanwhile back in the Middle East, the Ottoman empire's subject/ally Eyalet-i-Pers was forced out of the war in exchange for some prestige and pillaging, and also releasing the nation of Mushasha ( as a friendly Muslim nation, they will later be useful in sharing maps) .


22 peace eyalet pers.png


And switching his attention between Africa and the Middle East, the Emperor was happy to see that the important Cape province was held not by a European nation, but by the African nation of Kilwa, who had no knowledge of Denmark ( it was much better to antagonize them than a European!!)

23 cape is kilwan.png


And being a good multi-tasker like his predecessor, he also found time to direct a quick war of prestige on tiny Muscovy

24 muscovite prestige war.png


To maximize his prestige gains Christian forced Muscovy to abandon a large number of cores under Karelia, and he also forced them to become Reformed faith - one of the rare instances where he went against his tolerant nature. That satisfied one of the objectives of the Age of Reformation, so it was a good use of a small war.

Back in Africa, a new colony was started in Calabar, bringing the provinces in the Guinea region to three ( Arguin, Beafada, Calabar) and allowing the completion of the "Colonize the Gold Coast" mission which gave Denmark a permanent claim on the Cape Province and others in South Africa. This meant that as soon as Denmark had coring range to the Cape, war on Kilwa could be started. But that needed completion of the colony in Luanda first, so this will be covered in the next chapter ( or so I hope).
25 gold coast mission.png


Meanwhile the war with Ottomans was reaching its end, as the enemy was almost completely occupied. And in fact the only delay in signing a peace was from waiting for a spy network to be constructed in Egypt ( formerly Mamluks) which was going to be Christian's next target. And as soon as he had enough spy power to claim Egyptian land, peace with Ottomans was made.

26 peace ottomans.png


IN the peace , Constantinople itself was annexed. It was later given to Pontus after its development was concentrated to Zeeland. Also given to Pontus were the islands of Crete and Cyprus ( Greek culture) and provinces near Constantinople that would be helpful to have in a future war against the Turks. Although these were mostly Turkish culture, the Emperor expected Pontus to accept Turkish as they had free culture slots. As for Denmark herself, she took three provinces on the Asian mainland in the Aleppo node that bordered Egypt. These were promptly turned into the Prussian Levant Trade Company. And since they were outside Europe and not promoted to States, the Emperor did not feel obligated to address the unaccepted culture of their denizens[I mention that in first post - culture rule only applies to Europe].

When the Emperor's entourage expressed their bewilderment at the choice of annexed provinces ( many expected him to annex land in Europe , or release Bulgaria for example) , he showed them this document.


27 african trade mission.png


It was the "Expand African Trade" mission document. And it required control of *six* trade nodes in and around Africa. Several of these were deep inland, or where controlled by his Iberian allies. But Aleppo and Alexandria, controlled by the Muslim powers of Ottomans and Egypt respectively, also counted. Another benefit of having a base in the Levant was the ability to "punch through" the Suez Isthmus to the Red Sea, and from there to the Indian Ocean to reach the famed Spice Islands (whether that path would end up being faster than rounding the Cape, only the future would tell).

And so with this explanation in hand, he then directed his diplomats to declare war on the surprised and outraged Egyptians, before they had a chance to organize a coalition

28 DOW Egypt.png


With a large number of troops positioned in Syria already, the invasion of Egypt was very quick. Al-Kerak, Tabuk, Cairo and Alexandria fell without any serious opposition.



29 fall of cairo and others.png


Despite his aggressive wars on the Mohammedans, Christian personally was a tolerant person and he promised his future subjects that he would govern with a light hand, and would not seek to force convert them to Christianity .
30 tolerant christian.png


It seems his prayers on New Year's Eve 1530 were very sincere. But as ruler of Denmark, he had to be firm with his enemies. And when it came to peace with the Egyptian ally Medina, he maximized his prestige gains and used that to parlay for maps from Mushasha ( who he previously freed from Eyalet-i-Pers).

31 using prestige to buy maps.png


And he also did not hesitate to cash in favors accumulated over time in Pest to install a Wittelsbach cousin as heir to the Hungarian ( and by extension Austrian) throne. However, this was still looked at as an aggressive action by the Europeans, which bewildered our Christian who then realized he misunderstood the note passed to him by the diplomat on New Year's eve 1530 [ see footnote].

32 HUngary heir.png


But the reaction the European convinced him that he needed to continue working on improving relations and in that sense his choice to convert to the Reform faith was justified.
As to the war with Egypt, that wrapped up in mid 1538, with Denmark taking the strategic provinces of Sharqiya and Suez - where the isthmus is narrowest and where one day a canal can be built- as well as the important centers of trade and estuaries at the mouth of the Nile Delta.

33 peace Egypt.png


That ensured that Denmark would have enough control of Alexandria trade node for purposes of the Africa mission . The aggressive land grab raised concerns about a Muslism coalition. But luckily for Denamrk most of the involved nations did not have knowledge of Denmark, so she had time to improve things. And the one nation that could have been a problem- the Timurids - soon declared their own war on Egypt.

34 poor egypt.png

THe Ottomans piled on soon after. Poor Egypt. But our Emperor used the Egyptians for one last act, and that was to steal maps of the Horn of Africa. And he promptly ordered exiled armies to move there in preparation for war against Kilwa in the next decade

35 steal egypt maps.png



Our Emperor wanted to spend the last year of the decade in relative rest, but his attention was grabbed by another unusual declaration of war, this time of Spain claiming restoration of Union on England

36 Spain union war on England.png


This war presented opportunities and challenges to Denmark. Spain still had a Wittlesbach heir, although he was 3 years older than her current ruler so may still die without ever sitting on the throne. BUt should Spain prevail on England, and then Denmark manage to claim the Spanish throne, she would have a potential double union on her hands ( although keeping England loyal will be difficult given the bad blood between them and Denmark). But also if England becomes Junior to Spain, all the English cores under Denmark will certainly sour relations between Spain and Denmark.

IN any case, that event brings us to the end of the chapter, and we will close with the dynastic map before the obligatory status map.

37 dynastic map.png

First we sadly note that the Wittelsbachs were no longer rulers in Pontus. When the last Wittlesbach there died without an heir, he was replaced by a local noble. And the blame for that unfortunate event lay squarely on Christian the Great , who was smitten by Dorothea of Pontus and accepted her family's marriage proposal instead of sending his own proposal. When her father died, the marriage relation ended and the Wittlesbachs could not get one of their own on the throne. Christian II would not make that mistake again, and any time a vassal proposed marriage, he sent his own proposal instead. Second, we note that Denmark has excellent diplomatic reputation and improved relations . And that Sweden is in no danger of being inhertied by Denmark in case of Christian's death. We also note that there are two other Christian von Wittlesbach in line for succession in Spain and Hungary. In both cases, however, the heirs are older than than the rulers, so it will take a lot of luck for Denmark to claim those thrones ( ruler has to die, and the Wittlesbach heir needs to ascend without a ready-made heir of their own ) .

Finally we close with some views of the internal workings of Denmark.

Income is great thanks to trade ( although our Emperor forgot to abolish war taxes and the fleet basing rights with Spain!!) .

38 economy.png

Her trade is growing rapidly thanks to have new merchants from the two colonies and the Levan trade company. This income should mushroom in the coming decades as more ships are built and investments made into manufactories in the Textile provinces of the Channel and more merchants gained from Africa-based trade companies.
39 trade.png


Trade is boosted by healthy mercantilism, mostly obtained via the Estates

40 estates.png



41 status.png





footnote : I either misunderstood the Wiki or it is out-dated. I did get AE with Hungary and other Catholics when I installed an heir on Hungary. So that is a bummer and it negates one of the reasons I went Reformed. But still I think Reformed was the better option because of the 35% relations for AE reduction .
 
Last edited:
  • 3Like
Reactions:
And since they were outside Europe and not promoted to States, the Emperor did not feel obligated to address the unaccepted culture of their denizens[I mention that in first post - culture rule only applies to Europe].
Finally, Christian found a place where the native inhabitants can be treated as second class citizens!
It wouldn't be a paradox game otherwise :D

Curious to see how the Spanish claim on the English throne will play out. And i think they have a mission for the Portugese throne as well.
If the Hungarian plot doesn't work out, the Spanish could perhaps out-Atwix you for a while.
 
  • 1Like
Reactions: