Best Completed AAR - Part One

[Lord Durham]

This is the inaugural HoI OscAAR. There are many worthy candidates, so I have decided to split the poll. There are 5 nominations. Next month there will be another five.

Voting is very important, as is taking the time to read the nominees. The success of the OscAARs will be dependent on the number of responants.

1. Chopsticks in the Mist by Peter Ebbesen

2. Our Finest Hour by BiB

3. The long wait. A Who-dunnit AAR by Norgesvenn

4. To Stand Against The Night by Prufrock451

5. Where the Iron Crosses Grow - German AAR by The Yogi

 

[String]

yay! the first one to vote and to post !!!!


Clearly it must be Yogis masterpiece.. no doubt about it.. if he only would hurry up with those pdf's .....

 

[Lord Durham]

Originally posted by String
yay! the first one to vote and to post !!!!


Clearly it must be Yogis masterpiece.. no doubt about it.. if he only would hurry up with those pdf's .....

Did you read the others?

 

[Valdemar]

heh

I seem to be the only one who voted for Norgs

What can I say, I'm a sucker for Raymond Chanlder and pulp crimes

V

 

[Mettermrck]

Well, it was a tough choice, and all of the authors wrote excellent pieces. I enjoyed Norg's mystery, Prufock's novel, BiB's history, and Peter Ebbsen's fun. But Yogi's Beast.... Had to go with it.

 

[SykoNurse]

voted

 

[Prufrock451]

May the best man win!

*hands out free balloons for the kids*

 

[unmerged(15561)]

Originally posted by Prufrock451
May the best man win!

*hands out free balloons for the kids*

Hey Mr. P, if it were about men, I wouldnt be voting! Im not that way inclined. As for the AARs, I must confess Ive only read Yogi's, Peter's and BIB's.

My favourite is definiately BiBs, but Yogi is the bests outta of the three due to its scale, style, length, pics and its portrayal of the NEW Events MOD. --havent played it yet, but I hope there will be!

As for my ignorance of the others, I hope that I will get the chance to read them and that they are renominated later on.

Lord D,
perhaps we should have categories of the following:
-Most Entertaining/Funny AAR
-Best of MOD AAR
-Best Storydriven
-Best Technical
-Best of Nation
-Best Newcomer
-Best of version

to name a few and not all my ideas, just what Ive read!

 

[Morpheus506]

Everybody vote for TSATN!!

 

[Chengar Qordath]

I wish I could vote twice, it is hard to choose between "To Stand Against the Night" and "Where Iron Crosses Grow"

 

[Morpheus506]

Vote TSATN, it isn't winning yet! Even it out!

 

[unmerged(4076)]

Vote TSATN!

*grabs balloon*

 

[h345]

i voted Where The Iron Crosses Grows

 

[unmerged(6607)]

Hey, LD... You knwo what the other 5 will be next month, or if I hurry can I get in on it?

 

[unmerged(11439)]

all these are such great AAR's but i think Pruf deserves the honor.

*grabs balloon and inhales helium*

 

[Morpheus506]

*GASP* They're tied!!! Quick, more people vote for TSATN!!

Skorzeny! Skorzeny! ....er.... I mean.... Prufrock! Prufrock! Prufrock!!!

 

[The Yogi]

Voted!

And Morpheus... I don't know if you've read "Where the Iron Crosses Grow", but since you're such a fan of Skorzeny, there should be some posts for you there to enjoy.

Have fun!

 

[Lord Durham]

Originally posted by Rocky Horror
Hey, LD... You knwo what the other 5 will be next month, or if I hurry can I get in on it?

I have a good idea... however, you have a month to finish.

 

[unmerged(10371)]

I voted for Yogi.

there should be a short aar category

 

[unmerged(16020)]

Voted for "To Stand Against The Night". The depth of its characters and solid writing make it stand out in my book.