Confirmed CK III - Realm Feudalism Decision Does Not Account For Non-Independent Muslims with Tribal Lieges Adopting Clan Ways (They End up Feudal)

[Elaugaufein]

Short summary of your issue
Realm Feudalism Decision Does Not Account For Non-Independent Muslims with Tribal Lieges Adopting Clan Ways (They End up Feudal)

Game Version
1.4.4

What OS are you playing on?
Windows

What platform are you using?
Steam

Do you have mods enabled?
No

Have you tried verifying your game files (Steam only)?
Yes

How much "pain" is this causing you?
2

Please explain the issue you experienced in the most condensed way possible
If you're a Tribal Muslin with a Tribal non-Muslim Liege then using the Adopt Clan Ways decision results in your being Feudal

Please explain how to reproduce the issue
Be a Tribal Muslim with a Non-Tribal Muslim Liege who can use Adopt Clan Ways and take the Decision. You end up Feudal.

I have attached a save game Pre taking the decision, so you can see that the Decision says Adopt Clan Ways and take it, and a save game Post the decision showing an Islamic vassal of a Tribal liege with Feudal government

Is there anything else you think could help us identify/replicate the issue?
This is due to an oversight in convert_whole_realm_to_feudalism_effect ,

The code doesn't account for Vassals with Tribal Lieges using the non-Adopt Through Liege decision path, this works okay for Tribal non-Muslims because the default effect is Feudalism (the final else effectively mistakes them for Independent non-Muslim) but fails for Muslims (the tool tip doesn't account for either situation but seems to default to Feudalism regardless for some reason)

(The setup is ridiculous since I specifically setout to engineer this outcome, as easily as possible , once I noticed the problem in the code, just to check I was correct)

I have attached a save game
Yes

Upload Attachment
File(s) attached

 

[Elaugaufein]

After a little thought this is actually pretty trivial to fix at the moment.

Remove the independent ruler check from the Muslim decision and then mirror the effect structure into the tooltip (because the two possible playable Liege government type checks come first and the selection is closed, that covers all existing circumstances.)

The attached file implements that fix and seems to work in my testing.

 

[jakeowaty]

Hi there!

Thank you very much for the report! I have logged a ticket in our database for further investigation.

Good luck on your future endeavors in CK3!