DEVELOPERS PLEASE READ: The Best Ideas and Features from the Community

[HMAS-Nameless]

Here I will compile a list of the best features and ideas from the community for CK2. I will only include ideas that have been brought up that have been extremely well received from the community so that Paradox Developers don't have to look through all the far fetched ideas that have tons of arguments from everyone. Hopefully Doomdark may implement some or most these in the CK2 making the best game ever!

4th Tier: Empires
http://forum.paradoxplaza.com/forum/showthread.php?t=494118


Two cultures for characters
http://forum.paradoxplaza.com/forum/showthread.php?p=11535913&posted=1#post11535913

Holy Roman Empire Discussion
http://forum.paradoxplaza.com/forum/showthread.php?p=11535924


Crusades Discussion
http://forum.paradoxplaza.com/forum/showthread.php?t=494386


Playing as Courtiers
http://forum.paradoxplaza.com/forum/showthread.php?t=494167


SO DEVELOPERS! THE COMMUNITY HAS GOOD IDEAS TOO!

 

[Alexspeed]

Thanks for summing that up, if i recall right the CK1 forum had an ideas thread too, i bet there are a lot of gems and good ideas to find there too =)

EDIT:
Here is the link to the Crusader Kings 2 Wishlist in the CK1 Forum
and here the link to the Wishlist Thread in this Forum

 

[Duke of Bavaria]

Looks more like your most preferred ideas so far, as there are a lot more discussed and wished topics not inlcuded.

 

[Hellvink]

Looks more like your most preferred ideas so far, as there are a lot more discussed and wished topics not inlcuded.

Indeed.

 

[Romtos]

This thread just adds to the clutter and is horribly subjective. If anything, I find the playable courtiers the best idea till now, but it's not in your list. Ergo, it's subjective.

I'm sure the devs read threads without the title demanding them to do so.

 

[HMAS-Nameless]

Indeed.

No there just ideas that the majority of people recieved well and therefore easier for Paradox Developers to find in this thread.

 

[Woody Man]

This thread just adds to the clutter and is horribly subjective. If anything, I find the playable courtiers the best idea till now, but it's not in your list. Ergo, it's subjective.

I'm sure the devs read threads without the title demanding them to do so.

And there is the HRE thread in the list, which doesn't have anything particularly interesting, and is far less well received that the playable courtiers thread.

 

[HMAS-Nameless]

And there is the HRE thread in the list, which doesn't have anything particularly interesting, and is far less well received that the playable courtiers thread.

alright alright i forgot that one

 

[Romtos]

alright alright i forgot that one

Oh, it was just an example. There are loads of threads with new ideas.

 

[HMAS-Nameless]

Oh, it was just an example. There are loads of threads with new ideas.

..and Im trying to put the realistic ones here. As in sorting through all the "lets create custom characters with custom attributes and traits" type ideas that just wont be put in.

 

[Duke of Bavaria]

I still think its not up to you to decide which ideas are relistic or not. As said before it only makes things more cluttered, even if you might have had good intentions.

 

[Romtos]

I concur with Duke of Bavaria. Where is the thread about the "letters" idea? That one is very feasible and interesting, and seems to gather almost as much support as the courtiers thread. This thread is simply not the alpha and the omega of good CK2 suggestions.

 

[Veldmaarschalk]

I concur with Duke of Bavaria. Where is the thread about the "letters" idea? That one is very feasible and interesting, and seems to gather almost as much support as the courtiers thread. This thread is simply not the alpha and the omega of good CK2 suggestions.

I am pretty sure that the developers will read most threads, not just the ones named 'DEVELOPERS PLEASE READ'

 

[Romtos]

I am pretty sure that the developers will read most threads, not just the ones named 'DEVELOPERS PLEASE READ'

Look at here.

 

[HMAS-Nameless]

alright alright god i didnt think that compiling a constant growing list of forumite ideas was such a bad and self-centered thing

close it off if its really that bad

 

[Veldmaarschalk]

alright alright god i didnt think that compiling a constant growing list of forumite ideas was such a bad and self-centered thing

close it off if its really that bad

Relax, it is not a bad idea at all. And you put in a good effort.

Though adding your personal comments to the links might not have been such a good idea, since as you have seen this causes people to think that you are biased towards a suggestion. This of course is most likely not the impression that you wanted to give with the comments, but this is how people understood it.

 

[Alexspeed]

I had the impression he goes out collecting ideas to make and maintain an evergrowing list of the suggestions he finds, and those would be just the first ones (every list has to start somewhere), i think that wouldnt be a bad thing to have.

 

[vertinox]

Also characters need localization and by that I mean they actually need to actually have a physical presence in the province they are in.

Say if you are leader of a regiment, then as that regiment moves the game treats that character whatever the province they are in. So events tied to provinces on characters should be applied depending on which province they are in together.

I think Rome:VV sort of had this and CK did too but with courts, but it was more or less treated as court wide rather than any particular place.

I mean if you had a regiment with your King in the holy lands, he would still have hunting events and relationship events with people back at home.

It would make more sense if this could only happen if the characters are in the same province.

Of course you should have to option to take your wives and some people from court with you on a long journey, but was silly to keep having kids with your wife while she was 1,000 miles away from you.

 

[HMAS-Nameless]

Relax, it is not a bad idea at all. And you put in a good effort.

Though adding your personal comments to the links might not have been such a good idea, since as you have seen this causes people to think that you are biased towards a suggestion. This of course is most likely not the impression that you wanted to give with the comments, but this is how people understood it.

Okay deleted comments. It was more just to describe what the thread talks about so you didnt have to go into it.
yeh sorry about before I was just a bit annoyed that I tried to start a list of good ideas and started getting told I was biased immediately.

 

[unmerged(34400)]

Portraits

Out of the Park baseball 11 has a great portrait generator for its baseball players. Paradox should check it out and buy the engine for CK2.
The portraits age they can be edited and randomly generated.

Please paradox check this out.
Out of the Park Baseball
http://www.ootpdevelopments.com/joomla/home-ootp.html