• We have updated our Community Code of Conduct. Please read through the new rules for the forum that are an integral part of Paradox Interactive’s User Agreement.
Congrats @stnylan and welcome back once again! Also congratulations on all the winners I've missed since I last posted here.
 
  • 2Like
Reactions:
  • 2Like
Reactions:
Folks, I've been enjoying having @stnylan back on the forum for the past little bit, as I know we all have. He was one of the first people to comment on my first AAR, and he's been a positive presence for a lot of writers before and since. He hasn't been nominated since 2020, so I nominate @stnylan for fan of the week.


Great to have another of the veterans of AARland back, so congratulations @stnylan ! Sorry I missed your recent visit to the bAAR. I hope to run into you more in these electronic columns as you continue your resurgence here.

Good choice @Cora Giantkiller .

Ahh, yes. My friend @stnylan has been an amazing commentator on these Fora for two decades, and was one of my most emphatic encouragers and supporters back when I was a beginning AAR-writer! And I think just about any writer through those decades could probably say the same.

It is WONDERFUL to see you back! We've all truly -- especially myself -- missed your presence these past few years. I hope you are able to stay! But very good to have your contributions in AARLand again!

Congratulations @stnylan!

Rensslaer

Congratulations @stnylan

Congratulations @stynlan ! Welcome back.

Same here - nicely done @Cora Giantkiller :)

Welcome back @stnylan - lovely to have you gracing the boards again, in what I hope will be a sustainable way for you

Many congratulations to my good friend @stnylan , it was such a pleasant surprise to see you back!

Congrats @stnylan, it's always nice when someone replies .

I am looking forward to @stnylan reading list. There has to be some good stuff there

Congrats, @stnylan. Nice to see you poking your head around these parts once again.

Congratulations, as ever, @stnylan!

Always wonderful to see @stnylan back and commenting!

Congratulations @stnylan

Congrats @stnylan and welcome back once again! Also congratulations on all the winners I've missed since I last posted here.

Again thank you all. I've been very gently trying to ease myself back into (as @Bullfilter describes it) a sustainable way of being here. Feast or famine, drought or flood, that's historically been my issue here. Still, it has been fun finding a few AARs to follow here and there, and catching up on one from before (and I am about to try and catch-up on another, we shall see).

So with the understanding I haven't actually be reading very much, here is what I have been reading and enjoying.

Fabulae Romae - Tales of Rome by @Kashked - an Imperator AAR, which technically begins in the mid-5th century, and then skips back and is busy telling us how we got to that point.

Taurica Part III: Age of Thought and Discovery (1300-1820) by @kakom a Grand Campaign. I don't know parts I & II, but I didn't need to. The writAAR did a commendable set of summaries of what had gone before. Each chapter tells of a reign of the Zoticid dynasty, and their continual problems with heirs. I will say no more :)

The Last of Dumnonia - A Cornish AAR by @Werson I will admit I noticed this one simply because of Cornwall, and it fortuitously started almost on St Piran's day. I may be not be Cornish born, but I grew up on the edge of Bodmin Moor and the county has a hold on my heart. In other words I am a sucker for a good Cornish AAR, and though it is very early days I like what Werson has done with his scene setting thus far.

Hearts of Iron 4 - AI War by @Eurasia - Eurasia is one of my favourite AAR writers. I do hope I might eventually catch up with his Victoria II Japan AAR and especially his CK2 AAR Road of Queens, both of which still appear to be active. In the meantime though I spotted this one, where he is basically recording what the AI does. Sometimes it is just fun to watch what the AI gets up to. :) - Incidentally he has also just started a non-paradox AAR in OT called Grand Tactician - The Civil War - Whiskey And Lemons DLC (Union) as well.

Speaking of OT AARs may I also recommend Shadows of the Long War (Terra Invicta AAR) by @Chilango2 - this AAR has only just recently started. Terra Invicta is absolutely a grand strategy game rich for storytelling potential, and I cannot tell you how excited I was when I saw the announcement of this project.

Poles Apart – an HOI4 Ahistory by @Bullfilter is just so much fun, a very much Alt-History take on things, with weird AI shenanigans, desperate defences, and all good Paradox fun.

Dreams of a Better Future - Tales of the Roccan Resistance by @Nikolai - where being peacefully inclined cannot be allowed to get in the way of more important endeavours.

Atwix Legacy with Denmark: A Multicultural European Union by @mackwolfe - a classic deep gameplay AAR, but clearly and well described so even someone like me, who hasn't played a game of EU4 in years can follow along. Actually it is making a EU4 itch flare up. We shall see. :)

There you have it.

And remember: To View is Human, to Comment is Divine :)
 
  • 7Like
  • 5Love
Reactions:
So time, I think, to pass it on. Of course not reading as much makes this a harder task, but looking through who I have seen commentating, and who has not won recently, I am going to tip my hat to @TheButterflyComposer , who if the first post is to be believed hasn't been awarded this accolade since January 2024 and who I have noticed in more than one place. So many congratulations to a most incomparable Definite Article Lepidoptera Notewright, and a very stalwart member of these fora
 
Last edited:
  • 5Like
  • 1Love
Reactions:
Congrats to @TheButterflyComposer having read some of your works already and been impressed; I can't wait to see the list of works you find interesting.
 
  • 2Like
  • 1
Reactions:
Congrats @TheButterflyComposer! Your 12th win! Thank you for commenting and encouraging all of us!

What are you reading or keeping track of these days?

Rensslaer
 
  • 2Like
  • 1
Reactions:
  • 3Like
Reactions:
  • 2
  • 1Like
Reactions:
Congratulations to @TheButterflyComposer for their continued efforts in both reading, supporting, and writing for the AAR boards!
 
  • 3Like
  • 2
Reactions:
  • 3Like
  • 1
Reactions:
Always deserved, TBC. Now, how long do we have to wait for your successor? We know you like to keep these awAARds for a minute. ;)
 
  • 3Haha
Reactions:
Catch up continues. Belated congrats to @HistoryDude (always a welcome name to see around the place, even if they are apparently not around enough to pass things on), the stalwart @Cora Giantkiller and their excellent AAr reading list and @stnylan for reasons that need no explanation.

Finally an on time recognition to @TheButterflyComposer who fortunately remains one behind me (12 vs 13) for at least 6 months or so if the rules are kept to. I dread to think what will happen to his ego when he inevitably overtakes. ( ;) ). Still it is all well deserved so my sincere congratulations.
 
  • 2Like
  • 1Love
Reactions:
Finally an on time recognition to @TheButterflyComposer who fortunately remains one behind me (12 vs 13) for at least 6 months or so if the rules are kept to. I dread to think what will happen to his ego when he inevitably overtakes. ( ;) ). Still it is all well deserved so my sincere congratulations.
In any case a while up to my 16, so all in all it doesn't matter. ( ;) )
 
  • 1Like
  • 1Haha
Reactions: