• We have updated our Community Code of Conduct. Please read through the new rules for the forum that are an integral part of Paradox Interactive’s User Agreement.
Polish marines conqering Japan? Brilliant! Not sure about HOI but in Darkest Hour the ai in my expirience doesn't attack level 10 forts.

Aha, someone replied at last! Glad to see that you're still following this AAR!

I've actually played far ahead of this point already, but I was holding off on posting further updates to see if anyone would respond. Now that you've responded, I think I can post the next update. :) Unfortunately, it took a couple of months for me to see your reply, my gosh.

I too have never seen the AI attack level 10 forts, though I think that's not something set in stone but simply because forts give damn near a 100% penalty to attackers. I think the AI would attack a level 10 fort if they had 50 divisions and the fort was defended by 1 division. But since I've read that "Fortress Luxembourg" can survive the German onslaught for pretty much forever, I may be wrong about that.
 
Aye, I was worried I would be necroing the AAR but turns out it just needed a nudge in the right direction. Its alright about not replying for a while, I actually posted just a few days ago. I'll have to try a fortress Luxembourg one day, just to see if it works. I would be worried most about bombers. And then after Germany, due to AI fail at amphibious assaults, I would have to face the USSR. Fortress Netherlands works and fortress Belguim stops the entire Axis advance due to it covering the un-defended part of France.
 
Aye, I was worried I would be necroing the AAR but turns out it just needed a nudge in the right direction. Its alright about not replying for a while, I actually posted just a few days ago. I'll have to try a fortress Luxembourg one day, just to see if it works. I would be worried most about bombers. And then after Germany, due to AI fail at amphibious assaults, I would have to face the USSR. Fortress Netherlands works and fortress Belguim stops the entire Axis advance due to it covering the un-defended part of France.

Yep, a nudge is what it needed. LOL, my bad, I got the month/date format mixed up and thought you'd posted two months ago, which wouldn't make any sense since my most recent updates were after that time. :wacko:

Have you personally tried both Fortress Belgium and Fortress Netherlands? I haven't actually tried any of the "Fortress Benelux" strategies yet, but I've read about them on the HoI wiki. According to the wiki, Fortress Belgium stops the German advance cold, as you said, and even better, when the French eventually counterattack they will do so through your provinces and give them to you. Fortress Netherlands works as well, but France will still fall, and then you have to worry about the Japanese eventually attacking your holdings in Asia and both Germany and Japan sinking your convoys, which seems rather problematic.

As for Fortress Luxembourg, the wiki says that it works. The idea of a tiny single-province country surviving while being completely surrounded by the Third Reich for years is hilarious. :laugh:

I'll try to post the next update today or tomorrow. I think you'll quite like it. Things are going even better than I expected, actually.
 
Yep, a nudge is what it needed. LOL, my bad, I got the month/date format mixed up and thought you'd posted two months ago, which wouldn't make any sense since my most recent updates were after that time. :wacko:

Have you personally tried both Fortress Belgium and Fortress Netherlands? I haven't actually tried any of the "Fortress Benelux" strategies yet, but I've read about them on the HoI wiki. According to the wiki, Fortress Belgium stops the German advance cold, as you said, and even better, when the French eventually counterattack they will do so through your provinces and give them to you. Fortress Netherlands works as well, but France will still fall, and then you have to worry about the Japanese eventually attacking your holdings in Asia and both Germany and Japan sinking your convoys, which seems rather problematic.

As for Fortress Luxembourg, the wiki says that it works. The idea of a tiny single-province country surviving while being completely surrounded by the Third Reich for years is hilarious. :laugh:

I'll try to post the next update today or tomorrow. I think you'll quite like it. Things are going even better than I expected, actually.

I've tried Fortress Belguim, it works just as you said, German advance fails and Franco-British forces advance. I got bored as it turned into a stalemate and quit. I'm going to try Fortress Luxembourg today with DH full. Speaking of against the odds fights I'm trying a fight against aliens in The Abyss scenario as Empire of Russia, I have experienced the feel of being totally out-teched and out-numbered at the same time. Still holding though.
 
Okay, I really gotta apologize. I said I would update tomorrow, and it took me three months to do so. I got preoccupied with real life again, and also with Civ5 and other things. But like I said before, I'll finish this AAR for sure. I'll work on the update after posting this.

Regarding Fortress Belgium, I imagine that if you hold out long enough, even if the Western Allies aren't able to defeat Germany, the USSR will declare war on Germany eventually. I should try it.

As for the aliens...heck, I wouldn't ever want to try that. Hordes of 1945 infantry and tanks and level 5 interceptors spawning out of nowhere all the time...
 
Last edited:
Japan Surrenders

July 11, 1945

With Tokyo captured by the Poles for the second time, it was time to attack Niigata for the second time and attempt to encircle the large Japanese army in Fukushima again. Capturing Niigata would divide the remaining Japanese troops in Honshu into two pockets, one in Fukushima and another in Kanazawa. Three divisions from Nagoya would carry out the assault, with the marines in Tokyo providing support.

BattleofNiigata_zps83540ca3.jpg

Once Niigata was in Polish hands, Kanazawa and the Japanese troops in it fell soon after. Polish troops in Osaka and Polish ships patrolling the Inland Sea were also keeping five more divisions of Japanese troops holed up on the island of Shikoku. Fukushima was surrounded on all sides. It was finally time to confront and destroy the largest Japanese army.

The moment Polish troops reached Niigata and completed the encirclement, the Japanese in Fukushima attacked Akita, the weak link in the encirclement as it was defended by only three Polish divisions. There was no time for the Polish troops who had reached Niigata to reorganize. Every Polish division was ordered to attack the Japanese in Fukushima while they were busy attacking the Poles in Akita.

BattleofFukushima_zps7a12707a.jpg


BattleofFukushima2_zpsb4b15bf8.jpg
The climactic battle for control of Japan​

The Battle of Fukushima was the biggest battle of invasion of Japan. 30 Polish divisions, including the three being attacked in Akita, fought 23 Japanese divisions. Since most of Japan's garrisons had already been destroyed, many of these divisions were elite infantry and marine divisions. The Poles were in for a bitter struggle.

FukushimaVictory_zpsa9490f40.jpg

At 1800 hrs on July 21, almost two days after the battle started, a Polish corps reached Fukushima. 23 Japanese divisions, the bulk of what was left of their army, had been utterly annihilated. The divisions attacking from Niigata were exhausted, but the other participants had weathered it well. Even the small force defending Akita had managed to hold out.

The Poles had heard from their intelligence services that Japan was on the verge of surrendering - to the USA, and not to Poland, despite the fact that Poland was the one occupying 95 percent of Japan's territory. This was unfair in the extreme, and so the Poles had been hurrying to capture as much territory as possible before the Japanese surrender. With the capture of Fukushima, all that was left to capture was Shikoku, defended by five divisions. Unfortunately, five divisions was probably more than Poland's six marine divisions could defeat, and they were too well-entrenched for aerial bombardment to have much effect.

The Poles considered a plan of luring out part of all of the Japanese defenders from Shikoku, by leaving Osaka undefended and temporarily ceasing the naval blockade of the Inland Sea. Once the Japanese reached Osaka, the Polish ships would move back into the Inland Sea, cutting them off. Then the Japanese would be destroyed in Osaka, and Shikoku could be captured later.

However, before the Poles could implement this strategy, Japan surrendered to the United States on 1800 hrs, July 22, 1945, just as predicted, exactly one day after losing Fukushima.

JapanSurrenders_zps39a84bde.jpg


Poland had been unable to secure Shikoku before the Japanese surrender. Fortunately, this was a small loss, as most of Japan was already under Polish control. The new Japanese puppet state would only get Shikoku to rule over. Amusingly, the US also chose to grant independence to Korea, despite the fact that Korea was occupied by Poland. Poland would not be granting independence to Korea just yet, as they needed the peninsula for the upcoming war.

One final war to bring about world peace. Poland had defeated two powerful enemies in the past - first Germany, and then Japan. This third enemy would be more powerful than either. The Soviet Union. And while Poland had many powerful allies, it was the only member of the Allies to have a physical border with the USSR - two borders, in fact, in Poland and Korea. Poland would bear the brunt of the war with the Soviets and do most of the fighting on its own. It would be a two-front war, fighting the Soviets in both the east and the west.

The Poles knew that the Soviets would declare war soon after the defeat of Japan. They just didn't know when exactly. When the declaration did not come immediately, they breathed a sigh of relief and used the time to continue building up their forts. Nothing much happened in the world during this period, except that Nationalist China, now freed from having to fight the Japanese, declared war on Tibet.

NatChivsTibet_zps99f4696e.jpg


NationalistsTakeQamdo_zps1fa2259e.jpg
The Chinese defeated the Tibetans in Qamdo, but the long march there left them tired out and once they arrived, they would be pushed out again. This pattern would repeat again and again over the next several months.​

Finally, after months of suspense, it happened. And to everyone's surprise, especially Poland's, the declaration of war didn't come from the Soviets.

TheThirdWorldWar_zps98d8f517.jpg

At 1800 hrs on December 22, 1945, Greenwich Standard Time, the Third World War began as the United States declared war on the Soviet Union.
 
Last edited:
Oh snap. I will be looking forward towards the war with the Soviet Union :D.

It's time for the big showdown. Stay tuned! I've played ahead enough for one or two updates. Will work on it shortly. :D
 
The Third World War - Softening up the Soviets

December 22, 1945

The Third World War had begun! And just a few months after the end of the last one, although it could be said that the last one had never become a world war in the first place thanks to Poland, defeating Germany even before Japan attacked. Surprisingly, the Americans had declared war first, not the Soviets. Nevertheless, Poland was the only Allied nation that bordered the Soviet Union, and on two fronts at that.

In the European theater, the Kościuszko line was mostly complete, except at a few provinces where construction was still ongoing. These provinces were deemed less important and could only be attacked from one or two provinces at most. They could also be used to funnel the enemy into attacking there and then surrounding them.

However, in the Asian theater, the line of forts on the Korean peninsula was still very rudimentary. It had been decided before to abandon the defense along the Pyongyan-Wonsan-Hyesan-Chongyin axis, and then falling back to a narrower defense line along Pyongyang-Wonsan. This meant giving up the defensive advantage provided by the Yalu River, but since the Soviets already had a beachhead across the Yalu in Sinuiju in any case, this was not considered important. The forts in Korea were still at only Level 1 or Level 2, though, and considering the visible Soviet forces in this theater amounted to almost 100 divisions, losing the entire Korean peninsula was considered quite likely. If that happened, hopefully all the Polish forces in Korea could be evacuated to Japan.

KoreanFront_zps2b4614c2.jpg

The limited Polish forces in Asia were heavily outnumbered by the Soviets in the region. These were the same troops used for the invasion of Japan, moved to Korea after Japan surrendered.

However, at this moment, something fortunate happened. The moment the war started, the massive Soviet forces opposite the Poles were greatly reduced. It appeared that the Soviets had not been expecting the war declaration either, and the moment the US declared war, they immediately redeployed forces. The same thing was happening in Europe, suggesting that the Soviets were deploying troops from west to east and from east to west. That made no sense, but Poland took full advantage of it.

Polish war strategy aimed to reduce the vast Soviet numbers through completely unrestricted use of air power. Poland's tactical bomber wings were already experienced from the war against Japan and would become more so. Close air support wings were also being built and trained for the war with the USSR. The winter of 1945-46 would be used to lower the Soviet numbers, and perhaps a ground offensive could begin in spring of '46.

a>

Note the outdated nature of the Soviet divisions being bombed, especially the 1918 cavalry.

The Soviet forces facing the Poles in Korea were greatly reduced, entrained for strategic redeployment, and many of those that were left were also on the move for whatever reason (but not to attack the Polish forces). This made bombing them a lot more effective.

Another priority was to destroy the Soviet Navy. The Red Navy was certainly nowhere near as much of a threat as the Red Army, but by annihilating it, the Allies could focus solely on the ground war. The Red Navy was believed to be made up mainly of submarines. The Polish Navy, which included several modern destroyers, was set to patrol outside Vladivostok to find and sink the Soviet Pacific Fleet. Part of this fleet was found on December 26.

SovietSubmarinesEngaged_zps3ba82640.jpg

The submarines in this fleet were pretty outdated as well.

On the other hand, Polish naval bombers also set to patrol around Japan found a much larger Soviet sub fleet that had entered the Inland Sea.

HugeSubFleet_zpsd161a6b7.jpg

This fleet was more modern than the previous one.

Poland's subs and destroyers were set to work searching for that large Soviet submarine fleet, while the naval bombers were ordered to perform port strikes on Vladivostok. Vladivostok's thick AA net could be expected to take its toll on the brave Polish bombardiers.

PortStrikingVladivostok_zpsc10f217c.jpg

While Soviet subs were abroad, a lot of Soviet surface ships were holed up in Vladivostok. Polish naval bombers would send this fleet to the bottom of the sea.

The Polish subs and destroyers found the Soviet sub fleet in the ocean to the east of Japan.

HugeSubFleetCaught_zpsee3a738a.jpg

No less than 7 Soviet submarine flotillas were destroyed in this battle.

HugeSubFleetCaught2_zps2d1497e1.jpg

Two days later, Poland's fleet of carriers and heavy cruisers found the smaller and more obsolete Soviet sub fleet, although nighttime and winter weather limited the amount of damage they could do.

CarriervsSubs_zpsbf53d243.jpg

Poland's fighter wings were initially kept in Asia to defend the bombers there, but since Soviet fighters seemed to be more active in the European theater than the Asian theater, they were rebased in a daring flight across the Soviet Union, which took more than a day to complete.

RebasingthroughRussia_zps755e22b8.jpg

Intelligence provided by this flight showed scattered Soviet divisions moving both east and west throughout the interior of the USSR.

Some Soviet equipment was quite outdated. Just one example among many was this lone Soviet 1918-era infantry division, soon eradicated by Polish bombers.

1918Infin1946_zps057ef2e2.jpg

What exactly were Poland's allies up to during this time? Well, France had captured the southern half of Sakhalin from the Soviets and was resolutely building up a huge army there.

FrenchSuperStack_zps49c6f4c5.jpg

80 French divisions just camped in the southern half of Sakhalin. They showed no intention of moving from there.

On March 1, 1946, both India and Pakistan achieved independence from the United Kingdom. Although this was a step forward for the decolonization process, since India and Pakistan were not part of the Allies, this move would only weaken the UK at a time when it was still at war with the Soviets.

IndianIndependence_zpsdb6b7f99.jpg

Meanwhile, something interesting was happening in China. Because Japan had conquered a large part of China when the Soviets declared war on them, the Soviets took that territory from Japan and ended up with a large amount of Chinese territory. Since China was not at war with the Soviets, they could not take it back, or so everyone thought. In fact, somehow theywere taking it back just by moving into it, possibly cutting off Soviet troops there, where they would starve to death.

NatChiStealingfromSU_zps15a42cdd.jpg

(A/N: This is a weird glitch that also happened to me in a previous game. I was Nat Chi and joined the Allies. I waited for the German invasion of the Soviet Union to reach the China-USSR border and then attacked the Germans. While I was pushing the Germans back, the Soviet remnants, who were not at war with me, somehow started taking back their territory that I was holding by marching into it, cutting off my troops fighting the Germans. Pretty annoying. Does anyone know how this happens?)

In addition, Nationalist China finally annexed Tibet in April of 1946.

TibetAnnexed_zps9916cb7d.jpg

Polish spies were able to steal blueprints from the Soviets.

TechStolen_zps5aa1caf1.jpg

And the number of French troops (plus some American troops) camping out in southern Sakhalin continued to increase to absurd levels. With that many troops there, you'd think they would start doing something with them.

FrenchSuperStack2_zps8e9d89a7.jpg

And that's now 316 Allied infantry divisions crammed into the southern half of that island.

Lastly, intelligence reports to gauge the effectiveness of Polish bombing. This one from March 22, 1946, showing that the Soviets had 437 land divisions, including 259 infantry, 52 motorized infantry, 29 armored, and 13 HQs.

Note also that the French army was almost as large, and had more armored and HQ divisions.

Statistics1_zps16141c7f.jpg

And then, this one from May 9, 1946. The Soviets were down to just 401 divisions, including 229 infantry, indicating a loss of 30 infantry divisions over the past one-and-a-half months.

Statistics2_zpsc7238094.jpg

Interestingly, the French army has swollen to 507 divisions and the British and American armies have shrunk. The British and Americans seem to be lending their forces to the French for that superstack in Sakhalin, so much of the troops there might not be French at all.

A/N: I forgot to take a screenshot of Soviet forces right at the start of the war, but I'm pretty sure that they had upwards of 450 and maybe closer to 500 divisions. So almost 100 Soviet divisions have been destroyed since the war started.
 
Last edited:
Sorry for late late reply, caught up with Rome 2 and haven't been on Paradox for a while, impressive French army if the ledger is to be belived, even if they are using it on a useless island. Lets hope you can evacuate Korea in time.
 
oh wow, that doomstack reminds me of good old times in hoi vanilla when soviets would have 80 divs per border province.

Indeed, this is HoI vanilla. I wonder if this AI doomstack tendency has been reduced in the expansions. I mean, not the tendency to form doomstacks per se, but the tendency to form doomstacks on that particular island. I notice that the AI loves to put doomstacks on Sakhalin for some reason.

Sorry for late late reply, caught up with Rome 2 and haven't been on Paradox for a while, impressive French army if the ledger is to be belived, even if they are using it on a useless island. Lets hope you can evacuate Korea in time.

It's impressive indeed; many if not most of those units are British and American though. I think most of the actual French army is stacked up in two doomstacks along the French-Polish (formerly French-German) border for some reason.

Oh, and I don't think I'll have to evacuate Korea, so don't worry about that. ;)
 
Last edited:
wow i forgot this aar is in vanilla :D damn so many moved on, so it's still surprising you are playing vanilla. It might be that allied ai is made so that it plans amphibious assoults and thus puts most units onto nearest islands... if there was an soviet cored island near moscow, i could easily see >500 babylon doomstack
 
Well, I do have Armageddon, and I was (trying and failing) to get Kaiserreich and MDS to work on my laptop. I would appreciate it if somebody could help me install those mods since I must be missing some files or must have installed incorrectly.

But since this AAR was started in vanilla, I have to finish it in vanilla, of course.

The US and other Allies really seem to love landing doomstacks on Sakhalin if they are at war with the owner of the USSR's landmass (not necessarily the USSR itself; the US did the same thing in a game I played as Romania on Very Easy difficulty, where I conquered the entire Soviet Union. :laugh:)

I'm working on the next update, but it requires editing some screenshots.