• We have updated our Community Code of Conduct. Please read through the new rules for the forum that are an integral part of Paradox Interactive’s User Agreement.
As you say a real spy and the most decorated solider in the Italian Army in WW2. As I suspected that was an incredibly low bar to clear, best I can tell he managed to blow up one (1) arms dump in Eritrea in late 1941. And then get captured, escape, get captured again and spend 4 years in a POW camp.

He is in essence the real life Colonel Kaboom. And as noted, has specialisms regarding explosives, sneaking, etx. So probably will manage to do some spelunking at some point.

Releasing lions on the Grand Council is the very least they deserve, indeed my main concern is the poor lions have to digest fascist bureaucrat. Though the Grand Council were so spineless at least there are no large bones to choke on.

The Grand Council of Fascism. Well...I really do think that the Mel Brooks School of Thought regarding fascism is the correct one - entirely vibes based and succseful...provided you can make sure no one laughs. As soon as someone does, the ridiculous absurdity of it all destroys the illusion and you're looking at a bunch of weird men in leather doing hand signs and poses.

The council vs Mussolino mechanic simulation seems relatively in depth so no doubt they will be back at some point, though I don't hold out much hope for them.

Though their inclusion into the game (presumably) means there is now yet another way to murder Mussolini...I think he might actually be the most murderable person in the game considering how many paths and options lead to that, in multiple different countries too. I wonder if the devs just finish the latest expansion and then wonder if there's any way they can add another way to kill the man.
 
When the Grand Council appeared, I thought you had decided to retire Mussolini this time and send in the Pope instead, since the world was crazy already. (And he can reform Rome too)
 
When the Grand Council appeared, I thought you had decided to retire Mussolini this time and send in the Pope instead, since the world was crazy already. (And he can reform Rome too)

I didn't know they were in the game, having not played Italy since the last AAR and playing as I write. So they literally just popped up. I think it comes in after Ethiopia ends or after a few tree focuses or something...

I am certainly tempted to do the full rome series discussed above. Pope, restore rome, HRE, byzantine, third rome etc etc. Pius XI reversing his horrible mistakes and managing to utterly destroy Mussolini and conquer Italy as the papal states before he dies in 1939 would be a challenge.

The HRE path actually requires (for those that remember this) an honest to God Hinderberg Olympics fireball type situation taking out everyone else in the government.

The ottoman campaign would also probably be a 'try to make everything early modern again'. Bring back Austrian empire so we can kill it. Destroy unfied Italy and Germany. Make everyone monarchies etx.
 
When the Grand Council appeared, I thought you had decided to retire Mussolini this time and send in the Pope instead, since the world was crazy already. (And he can reform Rome too)
I like to imagine there was a Paradox meeting where this was discussed, given their insanely lax definition of 'Historical Focuses' a Papal Take-Over of Rome and then Italy probably falls under what they see as a historical outcome.

Though their inclusion into the game (presumably) means there is now yet another way to murder Mussolini...I think he might actually be the most murderable person in the game considering how many paths and options lead to that, in multiple different countries too. I wonder if the devs just finish the latest expansion and then wonder if there's any way they can add another way to kill the man.
HOI4 as a Mussolini Murder Simulation game is a perspective I've not come across, but I cannot deny you make a strong case. Certainly it has long since stopped being a "WW2 Grand Strategy Game", so perhaps that has been Paradox's plan all along.
 
I like to imagine there was a Paradox meeting where this was discussed, given their insanely lax definition of 'Historical Focuses' a Papal Take-Over of Rome and then Italy probably falls under what they see as a historical outcome.

Alas, from what I can see, it's the final option of a focus tree so the game won't do much after the Pope takes over unless there's special events etx. The alternative names should be funny if the papal stares exist but somehow the communists etc take over.

HOI4 as a Mussolini Murder Simulation game is a perspective I've not come across, but I cannot deny you make a strong case. Certainly it has long since stopped being a "WW2 Grand Strategy Game", so perhaps that has been Paradox's plan all along.

Didn't think of it before I typed the comment but yeah...it's weird how many ways there are, right? Considering trotsky and hitler do not come close to having that many options and really should have...
 
  • 1Like
Reactions:
HOI4 as a Mussolini Murder Simulation game is a perspective I've not come across, but I cannot deny you make a strong case. Certainly it has long since stopped being a "WW2 Grand Strategy Game", so perhaps that has been Paradox's plan all along.
Hoi4 was never a "WW2 Grand Strategy Game" - it's always been a "WW2 Grand Sandbox Game" (as in - when you put a bunch of kids with plastic toy soldiers in a sandbox, what do you get)
 
Hoi4 was never a "WW2 Grand Strategy Game" - it's always been a "WW2 Grand Sandbox Game" (as in - when you put a bunch of kids with plastic toy soldiers in a sandbox, what do you get)
Paradox's Own Words
"Hearts of Iron IV, a grand strategy wargame"
"Authentic real-time war simulation"
"Hearts of Iron IV is more than a historical simulation"

That said you are of course correct about what the game actually is, but I think the fact that Paradox are still pretending otherwise is significant.
 
Hoi4 was never a "WW2 Grand Strategy Game" - it's always been a "WW2 Grand Sandbox Game" (as in - when you put a bunch of kids with plastic toy soldiers in a sandbox, what do you get)
Paradox's Own Words
"Hearts of Iron IV, a grand strategy wargame"
"Authentic real-time war simulation"
"Hearts of Iron IV is more than a historical simulation"

That said you are of course correct about what the game actually is, but I think the fact that Paradox are still pretending otherwise is significant.
The former is certainly how this AAR series treats HOI4.

The latter is the marketing line I trot out every so often whenever things get too silly. It must be legit, because it's a serious historical simulation.
 
  • 1Like
  • 1Haha
Reactions:
Paradox's Own Words
"Hearts of Iron IV, a grand strategy wargame"
"Authentic real-time war simulation"
"Hearts of Iron IV is more than a historical simulation"

That said you are of course correct about what the game actually is, but I think the fact that Paradox are still pretending otherwise is significant.
Only the first sentence goes against me, the second two agree with me. (Ok, the middle one might be neutral)

(And the first one was probably written back when HoI1-3 was a thing and has just followed the franchise)
 
  • 1Like
Reactions:
Here? Who knows? Did the US get any updates since last time?
Nothing major I don't think. Paradox has been doing minor tweaks to focus trees here and there, so there are probably some changes to the US.
 
Chapter 9: The World goes Bananas
Chapter 9: The World goes Bananas
4th November 1936

“Why can we only send three divisions?”

pms1itHKj

“Because that’s the system, Mighty Cheesare. If our army was bigger, we’d be able to send more.”

“Or we could just invade Spain, again.”

“…I don’t think the Council would like that, sir.”

Alan and Cheesolini looked over the balcony to the courtyard below, where the surviving members of the Grand Council of Fascism were returning from hospital/the sewer system.

“Somehow I don’t think they will be a problem from now on.”

“The League of Nations, then?”

“This would be the League of Nations that did nothing to stop us committing attoricties in Ethiopia, is doing nothing now our armies are poised to strike the Balkans, and did nothing even as Denmark did their weird little coup and Germany their incredibly bloody civil war?”

“Point. But still, rules are rules. And this one just seems to be a law of the universe.”

“Damn those laws of the universe.”

Beancounter came out to two very glum figures, and decided they could do with a boost. “The 14th Baron of Sillavengo has decided to join SIM.”

“And who is he?”

poLfsNCAj

Once again, a very interesting chap. Makes me wonder who the UK have for their spies, and if Christopher Lee, Jon Pertwee and Ian Fleming are options...

“Mountaineering expert, special forces chap with experience in alpine and desert warfare, engineering and secret murder. Meticulous details man, curiously good at writing, and also a pretty good platoon leader.”

“Why on earth are we wasting him in SIM?”

“Not entirely sure. SIM seems to just be a catch all for everyone to do with intelligence, security, special forces etc. Good catch for us, I think.”

“Sure. Figure out something useful for him to do.”

“At once, Mighty Cheesare.”

Before he could leave, General Catastrophe marched onto the increasingly overcrowded balcony. “Interesting news, everyone. Saudi Arabia has declared war on Oman and Yemen.”

poJ8GBxbj

“Goodness me…the British won’t like that.”

“The British have bigger problems. Actually, we all do. Iraq and Iran are also at war.”

poXZpfclj

“Right…does this matter?”

“Well, it’s awful news for global trade and the British Empire in particular. All their oil partners are now at war, the Middle East is in chaos, they have a mandate to aid a lot of these places and it means both the Persian Gulf and the Suez Canal are no longer safe shipping lanes.”

“Beancounter, I seem to recall you complaining that our supplies from South Asia go via land. Presumably this is through this region?”

“Presumably, Mighty Cheesare, unless for some reason they’ve managed to go through Russia.”

“Will this impact us in any way?”

“Probably not, sir. So long as it remains uncertain as to which route is taken.”

“That makes no sense,” Catastrophe blustered.

“Welcome to bureaucracy, General.” Beancounter made a note. “Is it obvious if anyone will win?”

pnGgkyhDj

“Iraq and Iran have similar sized armies and are fighting across a narrow front. So it could be a real long slog for anyone to get anywhere, but personally I doubt Iraq can invade Iran. Loads of mountains and valleys. If the Iranians are smart, they’ll even drop back a bit from the border to lure Iraq into the killing fields.”

“And in Arabia?”

pneRbS1tj

“The Saudis have a slight manpower advantage, plus a huge desert between them and both countries. Oman barely has an army so can serve as little more than a distraction, which might be enough for the more equal Yemen forces to take a defendable forward line. Again, the smart thing would be crushing Oman before anyone can do anything, and then slowly pushing Yemen back…and praying the British don’t get involved.”

“Will they?”

“They might. It would get them a better deal with either side than they already do, especially if they back Yemen and then win.”

“Either way, in either war, there’s not much we can do even if we wanted to,” Cheesolini surmised. “What about Spain?”

“Has the law of the universe been explained?”

“Well, I know about it now. I don’t know about it being explained…”

poQqb0sKj

“The RNG for this timeline has heavily favoured the Republican government in Madrid. The Nationalists have a larger army but its split into two very vulnerable regions, the southernmost one almost certain to fall perhaps even as we arrive to help in the north.”

“Bugger. So can we help the Nationalists at all?”

“Not unless someone else joins in. Or the Republicans split into factions. Sort of outright invasion, it seems likely that the republicans will win.”

“So…mostly neutral or bad news, is it?”

“It seems that way.”

“Hmm…” Cheesolini leaned over the railing and shouted down. “I’ll be taking over the Ministry of Justice. That fine by you?”

There was a long pause, and then a quiet “No.”

pndxaBDkj

“Splendid! Alan, make it so!”


Meanwhile, in Denmark


Sveinn Björnsson, Grandmaster of the Icelandic Order of Freemasons, and Minister to Denmark, was on the phone again to the King of Denmark.

pm3hf48Aj

“No, your Majesty, I have no idea why the Icelandic people seem to view you as a destabilising influence,” he drawled. “I share your concern that the communists now have more than 50% of the popular vote in Norway, however. That can’t be good.”

pmoHs7Cuj

He paused and nodded to whatever the king said, idly doodling what his official head of state emblem would be.

pmKTitWaj

“Indeed, perhaps you can worry too much about such things. Still, best to ready the troops in case intervention seems warranted. I happen to know there are several Royal detachments here doing nothing particularly useful. Perhaps you could send them closer to home? Wonderful…excellent thinking, your Majesty. TTFM.”

poujGD3Zj

He rang off and rubbed his hands together. “Right, next steps…invite the Americans in.”


Back to Italy

6th November 1936
pni60vpfj
pnIs19P7j

The Italian government was trying and failing to figure out what to do with its too small and too weak air force and navy, when General Catastrophe thankfully interrupted with something more interesting.

“The tanks have arrived in Galicia, sir.”

“I thought we were aiming for Granada?”

pnLKZhgmj

“Granada is doomed to fall, sir.” Catastrophe brought out the maps. “Quite frankly, if the combined Spanish/Italian assault on the northern Republican pocket fails or gets bogged down, the southern armies will arrive and crush us.”

pnvQ0Ly8j

“So…the Nationalists have not miraculously found a way not to lose then?”

“I’m sorry, Mighty Cheesare.”

“Never mind…never mind. How goes our own army building?”

pmPsOgbEj

“The initial wave is a third completed. We are soon sure to have the strongest army of the secondary powers in Europe. Provided we aren’t fighting France or Germany within the next few years, we’ll be fine.”

“Very good. Beancounter?”

pnJBHCy6j

“Initial industrial builds are nearing completion, Mighty Cheesare. The peninsula resource sites are nearly up to maximum infrastructure, at which point we’ll switch to building some more civilian factories so we can at least fully commit to two building projects at once.”

“I miss having an entire industirlised contient to build things for me. Italy in 1936 is just pathetic.”

“As you say, Mighty Cheesare.”

Catastrophe was suddenly hit by a bolt of inspirational lightning (it happens), and excitedly began scribbling out something.

“What’s that, General?” Cheesolini said, as everyone else peered out from behind the settee.

“I’ve just realised that we can disband all those useless irregulars, Mighty Cheesare.”

“We already tried that, General. Er…didn’t we?”

poqenn6Zj

“We did. It did not work. But this time it will. We have more soldiers.”

“Um…I’m going to agree and not pursue this line of questioning. Alan?”

“Well, with the irregulars gone and no longer eating up resources, the Red Shirts are now more understrength than ever before, but everyone else will get a bit more supply. Which is nice, I suppose.”

“Do we get the guns and stuff back?”

“No. I specifically asked that question, and the answer is no, Mighty Cheesare,” the General said, emphatically.

“Several thousand armed irregulars just got released into the alps then…okay. Sure hope that doesn’t impact anything later on.”

“That’s foreshadowing, F-O-R-E-S-H-A-D-O-W-I-N-G,” Colonel Kaboom said, idly solving Alan’s crossword puzzle on his way into the meeting room.

“Kaboom? I didn’t know you could read.”

“I don’t make a habit out of it.”

“Hmm. Anyway, everyone…now the irregulars are gone forever and Ethiopia remains ours, and we’re about to make the King of Italy the Emperor…what comes next?”

Beancounter and Alan nodded at each other. “We’ve had a little plot, you might say.”

“This isn’t the death by a thousand micro post-colonial nations again, is it?”

pmSt7Foyj

“No, Mighty Cheesare. One massive East African colony/company, which we can add all our current holdings to, plus the British and French bits if chance comes up.”

“Eh, that sounds novel enough to give it a try. I assume we can’t do this until after the Emperor becomes a thing, right?”

“Just so.”

poZpBKDJj

“I do like arbitrary timescales. Excellent work, gentlemen. With just a small number of black shirts left in the high alps, the Ethipopian question resolved, the Grand Council diminished and the rest of the world increasingly turning chaotic, the future seems bright for Italy! Again!”


Meanwhile in Denmark


11th November 1936

“What is it Hans? I’m in the middle of figuring out how to dress as a military dictator cum absolute monarch whilst also marking Armistice day. It’s very awkward already, even without you bursting in without my trousers on.”

“Beg pardon, Your Majesty” Hans the butler said plummily, “But I am afraid to advise His Majesty that the King of Italy, Victor Emmanuel III, is now also His Imperial Majesty, the Emperor of Ethiopia.”

poUxcWt5j

“Oh,” said the King. “I don’t care.”

“Very good sir. Very good. Oh, and it may also interest Your Majesty to know that Oslo has fallen.”

There was a much longer pause this time.

“Is my brother alright?”

“As well as can be expected sir, given the communists and the bullet holes.”

poOaO6JEj
 
  • 2Like
  • 2Haha
Reactions:
Setting the irregulars loose in the Alps, what possibly could go wrong? (What if they've acquired a thirst for blood?)
 
Setting the irregulars loose in the Alps, what possibly could go wrong? (What if they've acquired a thirst for blood?)

I thought nothing of it and was pleased the game actually gave me an out.

There aren't actually any in game negative effects from this...as least so far as I am aware as of now.

But it will help to explain something very bizarre that happens in a few months.
 
“Iraq and Iran have similar sized armies and are fighting across a narrow front. So it could be a real long slog for anyone to get anywhere, but personally I doubt Iraq can invade Iran. Loads of mountains and valleys. If the Iranians are smart, they’ll even drop back a bit from the border to lure Iraq into the killing fields.”
My money's on Iran just because they have slightly more divisions. As you said, pull back and let Iraq wear themselves out.
Provided we aren’t fighting France or Germany within the next few years, we’ll be fine.”
It's very bold to tempt fate like this.

It's good to see the irregulars can be disbanded. That must've been added in since I last played in Italy. You not getting the manpower I can understand, but where'd the equipment go? Strange Paradox logic.
 
My money's on Iran just because they have slightly more divisions. As you said, pull back and let Iraq wear themselves out.

Depends on what exactly happened when they declared war and who has proper war plans. If both are trying to get to each other's capital, it'll be a bloodbath. If Iraq initially manage to push through, they'll lose a lot more in the mountains.

We'll see.

It's very bold to tempt fate like this.

I have no idea what Germany is going to do now. Scandinavia is about to blow up presumably, due to Norway. And I'm not sure what the Germans will do about the rest of their borders now they are hitler-free.

France meanwhile is in rather deep trouble regarding communists and some other factions. Fact is that as of now, there's just so many different ways for France to tear itself apart. Several communist, monarchist, fascist and separatist factions, and they can all run parallel to each other.

So im expecting them to implode at some point, but we'll see. Im hoping they distract Germany thougy, because it looks like as soon as im done with the balkans, im going to have to actually invade a victorious republican spain, given how badly the fascists are fighting.

It's good to see the irregulars can be disbanded. That must've been added in since I last played in Italy. You not getting the manpower I can understand, but where'd the equipment go? Strange Paradox logic.

Oh yeah, it would have been a pain if they'd be permanent supply and manpower drains. I would have just forced them to increasingly awful deployments as punishment, or sat them in Rome so they don't consume anything.

As it is, they just vanish with all their gear and men. Makes some sense for colonial troops I suppose, but a bit worrying in universe given they essentially ran off into the mountains of Italy rather than safely disbanded back into Ethiopia or somewhere.
 
It's good to see the irregulars can be disbanded. That must've been added in since I last played in Italy. You not getting the manpower I can understand, but where'd the equipment go? Strange Paradox logic.
They're irregulars, so they brought the guns with themselves home, duh.
(Given you get the guns for free when they are set up, you could easily argue it was their own guns to begin with.)
 
  • 1Like
Reactions:
Someone stood up and said "Yes, a Norwegian Civil War with one side being the Communists is an entirely historical outcome, that should definitely be possible with Historical Focuses on." and then wasn't sacked. It's a good thing I already have no respect for Paradox or I would have lost quite a lot after reading that update.

Still, Mussolini is enjoying himself and isn't that the main thing in an Italian AAR?
 
They're irregulars, so they brought the guns with themselves home, duh.
(Given you get the guns for free when they are set up, you could easily argue it was their own guns to begin with.)

I suppose that makes sense. I barely used them so I'm not sure if they take up the normal resources and manpower etc but if they do, eventually all the guns and the men are going to be mine, rather than random signups.

I suppose that's why you should get rid of them quickly.

Someone stood up and said "Yes, a Norwegian Civil War with one side being the Communists is an entirely historical outcome, that should definitely be possible with Historical Focuses on." and then wasn't sacked. It's a good thing I already have no respect for Paradox or I would have lost quite a lot after reading that update.

Still, Mussolini is enjoying himself and isn't that the main thing in an Italian AAR?

Believe it or not, it get's a little weirder in the next chapter where I find out who is now running the communist side and the democratic Norwegian resistance. Hint for the latter - it's not the then-PM and historical government in exile leader during WW2...
 
Believe it or not, it get's a little weirder in the next chapter where I find out who is now running the communist side and the democratic Norwegian resistance.
It's Paradox, so of course I believe they have not taken the rational and sensible decision here.
Hint for the latter - it's not the then-PM and historical government in exile leader during WW2...
Obviously I am hoping for Comrade King Haakon VII of the Communists vs Prince Regent Olav V of the democratic resistance.

Did they shoe horn Quisling in somehow? Kind of thing Paradox would do. Failing that Haakon's OTL best mate and entirely-unpolitical-in-every way Peder Anker Wedel-Jarlsberg?
 
Obviously I am hoping for Comrade King Haakon VII of the Communists vs Prince Regent Olav V of the democratic resistance.

Don't think it's even possible for Haakon to become leader of anyone. Which makes sense, tbh, given it's him.

Did they shoe horn Quisling in somehow? Kind of thing Paradox would do. Failing that Haakon's OTL best mate and entirely-unpolitical-in-every way Peder Anker Wedel-Jarlsberg?

He's not shown up yet, but he may well do at some point. The latter might do too, given paradox seems fond of bringing in entirely unpolitical and disinterested people into running various countries. I'm not sure what happened to Johan Nygaardsvold but he appears to have vanished and been replaced.