• We have updated our Community Code of Conduct. Please read through the new rules for the forum that are an integral part of Paradox Interactive’s User Agreement.
animal joke character
Well, if he’s not there to make jokes about, what is he good for, then? Now, you in the cheap seats, enough snickering.

Nurse, nurse, have we wrecked them? Ooooh, matron!
Hirohito’s legs were mysteriously found to be broken during some mishap during that day.
That’s a wee bit brutal.
“And Japan.”
“The Americans got Vietnam.”
Hardly fair, one would have thought.
the Americans must be in even worse shape than we thought
We’ll they are now after that peace deal, anyway.
The gigantic alliances are now pretty much completely in charge. What an ungodly mess...

“Indeed. I’m…going to lie down and try to not make sense of it all with some wine.”
Make that a whole case. And some cheese too … a whole kilo of the stinkiest Roman Gorgonzola you can find!
 
That’s a wee bit brutal.
This is another one of those gameplay and story choke points. If the Amercians really had to storm Fortress Japan and waste even more lives and time searching for the Emperor as he kept escaping, they'd have just shot him when they cornered him in the north.

The nasty little man is still technically in charge of Japan however, and will no doubt soon be going to that lovely little place the other nasty little men were sent to in Germany.

Hardly fair, one would have thought.
I have absolutely no idea what the AI was thinking. I know me being involved in the trenches and doing most of the heavy lifting compellty skewed the victory points in my favour, but the Amercians and British handing over territory which they bled hundreds of thousands of men over just because is...insane.
We’ll they are now after that peace deal, anyway
This little chapter just had to be its own thing. A peace conference in Wuhan, which turned out to be batshit insane, and then the Olympics occurring a day later (and 2 years late) like nothing ever happened?

This is going straight into the more surreal chapters of our story.
Make that a whole case. And some cheese too … a whole kilo of the stinkiest Roman Gorgonzola you can find!
It's actually going to get a lot worse before it gets better. Depending on who you're rooting for, anyway.

Well, if he’s not there to make jokes about, what is he good for, then?
Well, he's retired...so nothing really, I suppose...
 
  • 1
Reactions:
It says something about the standard of a typical HOI4 game that the peace deal seems fairly normal. Sure it makes no sense, is utterly unfair and no real power would ever have signed up to it, but as stated that is about par for the course.
 
Is it possible that all the major powers got so drunk and high on various substances that they just dreamt the entire olympics happening without ever leaving the Enterprise?
This is probably one of the only likely explanations for the entire last chapter of events. Nothing in it made any sense, but it did happen and therefore is going in the AAR.

It says something about the standard of a typical HOI4 game that the peace deal seems fairly normal. Sure it makes no sense, is utterly unfair and no real power would ever have signed up to it, but as stated that is about par for the course.
I was halfway through writing a scene for it with the Big Three in person, and I just couldn't see any of them agreeing to this. Why would Rome want Japan on top of everything else? Why would the US give up Japan? Why would Churchill give up Indochina when it's the only bit he bothered to fight for and only his troops are there?

It just raises too many questions...

Of course, the game reasons are because the British didn't get enough points to really get anything, as they had a limited front in Indochina and didn't bother with much else aside from shadowing us and sinking the Japanese fleet. The Chinese war end looks about right (only we really did anything against the Chinese factions) but the Japanese war genuinely was a three part effort and its just not reflected at all in the peace treaty.

Amercia really should have Japan and the British really should have indochina, and Rome should have China itself. Its so skewed I think I might go and hack the game files to make it 'right'. However, this AAR is supposed to be a supremely warts and all look at HOI4 so...
 
Chapter 39: Two Would-Be Unions of Nations
Chapter 39: Two Would-Be Unions of Nations

The next morning saw the Roman Emperor retching his guts out into the toilet.

“He’s been in there for hours,” Alan said, by the door.

“Not surprising. Whatever drug cocktail those dratted Swedes put in conference hall were enough to dose everyone there to the moon and back.” Bean-Counter was sat nearby at a portable desk. “Herpes was telling me that the White House hit the roof when they all came to earlier today. I shudder to think what the reaction in Whitehall is going to be.”

“Indeed. What a mess. We unnecessarily antagonised the Allies, the Americans basically stole the entire Indochinese coastline from the British, and Churchill is left with nothing but war bills and what he had from before the war.”

“It’s not going to end well. This was supposed to calm Asia and push back any future problems far into the future. Instead, we’ve got three great powers next to each other, all angry and with competing claims. It’s like 1914 all over again.”

“We need to start recalling our forces, and getting them to Africa and the Middle East. I’m not sure what’s going to happen next, but better safe than sorry.”

“Agreed. Catastrophe is already on his way back to Rome. We’ll reconvene there and have a rethink about what to do. Mark my words though, things are going to be heating up before long.”
17th September 1942
“One of our agents in Rebel French Africa has been killed.”
pm9lG4ZIp

Catastrophe paused in his note-taking, and glanced up.

“What on earth was she doing there?”

“SIM got to thinking that Rebel France is so pathetic at this point that we might be able to get them to just give up and become a collaboration government.”

“Is that at all likely?”

“She got surprisingly far before being stopped. So, we might even try again.”

“Is it even worth the hassle of flipping Rebel France?”

“Not really. Now they just have their sub-Saharan territories, Madagascar, and whatever random bits of islands in the Atlantic and Pacific left. Most of the competent or useful French nationals have long since returned to France and become Roman citizens. We’re basically just trying to take out a pathetic puppet of the British government at this point, and shut de Gaulle up.”

“Any chance the British had anything to do with this?”

“Probably. We’ll know in a few days when some idiot in London starts boasting about it.”

“Well, Churchill must still want at least some token of French resistance in West Africa,” Catastrophe said, turning his gaze to a map on the wall. “He knows that the British alone will struggle to stop us in Egypt and Arabia. We don’t even have to bother with reinforcing our allies and puppets in Europe anymore, they’re strong and plentiful enough to at least hold the line against the few remaining Allies there.”

“Yes…Estonia and Poland are particularly vulnerable. I can’t see them lasting long in a war, even a proxy war. Denmark and Norway maybe, especially with the US in Finland backing them up. SIM have been receiving dozens of reports that the British are infiltrating Sweden. No doubt they’re going to extract some terrible revenge on those pricks for the mess that was the Wuhan Treaty.”

“Bastards deserve what they get. Still, if the British can flip Sweden…they’ll have a unified Scandinavian front to serve as a large fortress in Europe for their ships, planes and armies.”

“If that happens, it becomes vital to take out Estonia, Poland and Denmark immediately. Limit the front down to the barest amount, and force the British to go either through the Danish Straits or Russia to get back into Europe.”

“Quite. I may want to pull Kaboom from the Suez run to get that sorted.”

“I don’t think he’ll like that…”

“Indeed. What a shame.”
13th October 1942
“The news is out. Sweden has joined the Allies.”
polOUiOep

The rain pelted down the windows of the Alpine fortress, adding to the gloom settling in amongst the commanders and leaders of the Roman Empire, and her Allies.

“We can take them!” piped up Adolf Hitler, from the playpen in the corner. He was quickly hushed by his nanny, a large and angry black Jewish homosexual.

“Can they actually take them?” the Emperor said from his throne.

“We think so, Mighty Cheesare,” newly promoted Field Marshal Catastrophe said. “Poland and Estonia are set to fall very quickly should war break out. Denmark will be harder to crack as Germany will be focused in the east, but should be at least contained till reinforcements arrive.”

“Good. What has the Swedish response to our ambassador’s note been?”

“They say they are committed to peace through strength, and that in these uncertain times, they must stand firm with their neighbours against any and all threats.”

“Bugger. So, they actually do plan on perhaps fighting…”

The meeting continued for several more minutes before the Russian representatives could contain themselves no longer.

“In such times as these, and with the impending British Federation showing the way, should we not unite ourselves under one banner? My country and my countrymen have a great love and admiration for the Roman Empire and her people, and everything they have done for us over the past few years. You have saved us from tyranny, and the worst possible fates from a government filled with monsters.”

Everyone looked over at the Nazi playpen, which was in turmoil as Goering and Goebbels once again seemed to be trying to unify into one being. Everyone quickly looked away.

“Yes…what do you propose then?” Bean-Counter said, ever cautious of his precious account books.

“We want unification of our own. To become part of the Roman Empire itself, and for our citizens to become your citizens in full.”

“And…this would be accepted?” Alan said, in the shocked silence that followed.

“It would. It has been popularly demonstrated about for months now. The army is already all for it. The government and civil service too. Just about everyone else is either for or ambivalent at the least.”

poRBAHVBp

This created some movement and murmuring amongst many delegates and officials, before the Emperor brought them to order again. The representatives for Belarus and Ukraine also stood.

“We would, if Russia were to be accepted into the Empire, also wish to press our claim as well. Our countries would be nothing without yours, and we, all that remains that is, can never repay the debt we owe except by coming together.”

The Emperor raised his hand before every other puppet felt the need to either shout their own offer or refusal aloud. “This matter…I must admit, is of some surprise to me. It is welcome, I think, though we have no wish to take away any nation’s autonomy or independence should they not wish it. Our Imperial history shows the perils of overextension and overexertion. I therefore put it to you all that-”

He was suddenly interrupted by King Victor Emmanuel leaning over to whisper in his ear. The two and a brief and quiet discussion, before the Emperor nodded.

“I therefore put it to you all that such a move may be countenanced, should a fair and democratic vote be passed in each territory that so wishes to apply for entry into the empire, and that a full two-thirds majority of citizens indeed wish to enter our covenant. This is not a timed or obligatory offer, more an indication of our continuing support and loyalty towards our friends. Please fell no obligation to discuss the matter further, unless there is genuine desire in your countries to join our own. Thank you.”
18th November 1942

The radio was on as loud as could be, as the Imperial Cabinet, High Command and various friends and relations sat around to listen to Prime Minister Winston Churchill speak to the world.

“The mad bastard did it,” the Emperor mused quietly. “An achievement, to be sure. As dangerous as it is.”

“Listen and wait,” Alan whispered back. “He hasn’t mentioned India yet.”

Everyone craned their heads forwards as the Raj indeed was brought up. And the bombshell was dropped.

The British Commonwealth of Nations had arrived.

pn6TG47zp

And the British Raj was not coming with them.
 
  • 3Like
Reactions:
No doubt they’re going to extract some terrible revenge on those pricks for the mess that was the Wuhan Treaty.
Looks like that bad case of COVID-42 has had lasting side effects.

So, everybody is forming into real 1984-style blocs. Complete with the doublespeak!
 
Looks like that bad case of COVID-42 has had lasting side effects.

So, everybody is forming into real 1984-style blocs. Complete with the doublespeak!
The game systems really borked up the last war's results. But ot course, even in absolute defeat, the British AI has managed some amount of victory. Turns out they bagged the Japanese Empire of Micronesia as a new massive colony. So basically the actual Pacific ocean belongs almost solely to the new Commonwealth, with a few small US islands here and there.

Never give up, Mr Churchill. Never give in.

Ironically, the game being what it is, if he left the empire as it was before imperial federation, he'd basically be in an unassailable position. Decolonisation does not happen unless you choose to in HOI4, so the british empire could have just carried on and slowly incorporares dominions back into the fold through investment and shit.

As it stands, there's now a gigantic hole right in the middle of this new Federation of theirs, and the AI sure does go ballistic over this fact!
 
  • 1Like
Reactions:
That is why the "Player Led Peace Conferences" mod exists. Though where's the fun in that?
Yes, I think I would use such a thing if I was ever going to try and do any kind of 'serious' AAR. Because the system as is means that unless you killed an awful lot of the enemy, and seized most of the land yourself, you get nothing in the peace.

Though as it turns out, the British AI did manage to pull a fast one on the Americans, no doubt in response to the Americans pulling such bullshit on them in Indochina. So whilst the Americans hold Vietnam and have scored big points with Rome for caving to all our ridiculous demands, the British have basically secured the entire Pacific Ocean by seizing every island the Japanese held (that is to say, most of them).
 
Chapter 40: India Alone?
Chapter 40: India Alone?
23rd January 1943
“What are we looking at, Alan?”
pn4TDfyep

“The new state of India, sire. The British Raj declared its independence from the UK, and subsequently devolved into two pieces: Pakistan in the north, which is majority Muslim, and India on the sub-continent, which is majority Hindi.”

“Pakistan borders Persia and Afghanistan. What do our people there say?”

“The new border has been amicably agreed upon by all sides, and is relatively peaceful, at least for now. Pakistan has sent out feelers of support and friendship across the Islamic world, which we see no reason to stop as of now.”

“Indeed. Instruct our men in China to do the same for India itself. I doubt they are looking for trouble, and they may very well appreciate any aid we can offer, limited though it will be with our commitments elsewhere.”

“Yes, Mighty Cheesare.”

“What’s the strategic impact? Catastrophe?”

“Here, sire. Sri Lanka has remained a British possession in their new Federation, and is being reinforced with a naval and air wing detachment from Singapore. British Malaya and Malaysia border India to the east, and play host to a great deal of army divisions and air power. With the loss of potential expansion in Indochina, I find it likely that Churchill will seek to reinforce his grip in the Far East by linking Singapore with the larger colony to the north. Siam is now not merely a display of regional power but a lynchpin of British strategy in the whole area. We must expect an attack there soon, if the Thai government fails to cede to British demands.”

“And what does this mean for us?”

“In general, the loss of the Raj is a huge blow to the British position as Global Superpower. They still have an army reserve of millions of men, with further civilian numbers to press into service if need be. But India was their largest single source of manpower, and the Raj army their single largest force. Likewise, the loss of control in the subcontinent leaves a gaping whole in their empire’s…their federation’s defences. East Africa and the Middle East will have to stand alone against attack till reinforcements from Australasia or the Home Islands reach them, rather than within the easy reach of India.”

pnuDwnycp
In the Deep South Pacific, we have Australasia (now part of the Imperial Commonwealth), the Republic of Indonesia (basically the New Dutch Empire, a core member of the Allies), the Philippines (American puppet) and the Federated States of Micronesia (Imperial Commonwealth puppet). So the British do control the region, it's just really far away from everywhere else.

“Essentially, their realm has been split in two, west of India and east of it.”

“Exactly, Mighty Cheesare. If someone were to, for example, seize Suez as well…”

“They would struggle to respond with any meaningful strength. Very well, pray continue.”

“It goes without saying that, when the situation is resolved against Siam, the British will be looking to flex their muscles to try and recover their image and strength. Either that will be against India or…well, us.”

poYfXd0ap

Interestingly, Newfoundland appears to have re-joined the Imperial Commonwealth, alongside Canada (which was a given), along with every British holding not otherwise given up to the Americans. Not sure why Newfoundland alone got the option of returning. Probably had nothing to do with the fact that almost everyone there is white...

The Emperor reflected on that for some time, moving only to light and smoke a cigarette. After fifteen minutes of politely waiting, Catastrophe was rewarded with a small smile from the Emperor, tinged as it was with a hint of sadness.

“Very well. Continue to reassign our forces to North Africa and the Middle East. And do not worry about the British. I have a long, complex and cunning plan to-”

“Mighty Cheesare, Mighty Cheesare!”

“Random messenger N.O. 825! What on earth do you want and why are you interrupting my dramatic moment of gravitas?”

“The British, sire! They’ve declared war on Siam!”

pm3d5EeGp

Huh. Well, that was fast but no real biggie...
“Yeah, so?”

“Siam has begged for aid from India!”

poX9d5TYp

Huh. Wasn't expecting that...
“…what?”

“Pakistan and India have jointly declared their intent to defend Siam against imperialistic aggression!”

pmZfQWubp

Okay, was really not expecting that!
“What?”

“And President Roosevelt has also pledged his support, removing the United States from the Allies and entering a state of war with the Commonwealth of Nations.”

pm4K9JgMp

“WHAT?!”
poyMGAmdp

Oh, holy hell...
 
Last edited:
  • 7Like
Reactions:
It begins...
 
Holy goddamned god. Well, when the US and UK kill eachother, we all know who is sweeping the ashes into their global fireplace.
 
  • 1
Reactions:
It begins...
Just when you think this game has no surprises left and is working towards an inevitable and long awaited confrontation...
Holy goddamned god. Well, when the US and UK kill each other, we all know who is sweeping the ashes into their global fireplace.
I paused the game and immediately ran to get this chapter done, because I absolutely 100% guarantee (and am willing to put £100 on this) that one or both sides come begging for my help within one week.

I'll put fifty on it happening within one day.

I highly doubt I'll be allowed to just sit this one out. Although I am tempted to try just to see which one of them is stupid enough to attack me for no reason.
 
  • 1Like
Reactions:
So they’re on the Handbasket to Hell! How silly of them - when the only logical course would have been to gang up on the Mighty Cheesare! Mighty Cheesare! And then rain nukes on him.

I reckon you should take that bet with yourself and wait and see what happens, while getting ready to attack whoever looks like winning when they’re about half way to doing it, irrespective of who asks for help when.

Vale the Donkey. I’m sure he will be sorely missed. Especially by the Mighty Cheesare. :(
 
  • 1Like
Reactions:
So they’re on the Handbasket to Hell! How silly of them - when the only logical course would have been to gang up on the Mighty Cheesare! Mighty Cheesare! And then rain nukes on him.
On the nuke front, we're in very early 1943, so I'm just about ready to start working on a reactor, and no one else is really anywhere close theory wise yet.

It's going to be at least a year for us to get that working, and then another to get a working bomb. So everyone else is probably 3 years from nukes at least.
I reckon you should take that bet with yourself and wait and see what happens, while getting ready to attack whoever looks like winning when they’re about half way to doing it, irrespective of who asks for help when.
Pffft. Since when did we do sensible stuff like that? I'm fairly sure this is the last war of the game, and may well kill off most of the rest of humanity if I balance it out right.

Us siding with the amercians bascially means the two sides would be fairly easily matched, and the war would be sufficiently global and horrific.

Unless Churchill comes begging, I suppose, as that would be even funnier. Especially as there's fuck all I can do to help him in North Amercia. The only thing I can do is not fight for the US, and maybe take out Indochina and Finland.

Doesn't sound very exciting though, does it?

Vale the Donkey. I’m sure he will be sorely missed.
This 'Vale the Donkey' is indeed missed, given that he doesn't appear in the AAR. Yet.

The problem with iron-man at this point becomes clear, as I'm pretty sure I must be straining the game at this point, and who knows how it'll react if WW3 actually does break out and millions of men, thousands of aircraft and hundreds of ships are fighting all over the world simultaneously...

Still, I'm determined to take any flimsy excuse to finish this fic off with an almighty bang, so war it shall be, as soon as said flimsy excuse appears. I'm hoping for some real back and forth on fronts this time. Probably not in Africa, but there's enough room for maneuver in Europe, amercia and India for quite a bit of reversal and reclamation.

There may even be some oppriotnity for some redemption for the Germans and the Free French, because the former is going to be my main guy in Europe whoever I'm fighting, whilst the later has the only remaining allied port in India (and if the British are being particularly fiendish, they could feed them Indian land to boost French manpower and have another (rather technically advanced) great power in their pocket, with the manpower to match).
 
  • 2Like
Reactions:
I just caught up from being over a month behind. And what a moment to catch up.
 
I just caught up from being over a month behind. And what a moment to catch up.
So when did you stop at? Yes...quite a change from around a month ago when I don't think we'd even gotten into China yet!

Scratch that...it was during the end of the Soviet War if we're talking early September!
 
So I'm a few months looking into the war, which is very much world war three at this point. Everywhere is in chaos save for South Amercia (and it could well start there soon). Its everything I'd hoped for. Huge sea battles, huge land battles, lots of back and forth across multiple theatres, and a lot of death and destruction.

A good time, all round. This is definitely the end game, and I'm looking forward to fighting myself.
 
  • 1
  • 1Like
Reactions: