• We have updated our Community Code of Conduct. Please read through the new rules for the forum that are an integral part of Paradox Interactive’s User Agreement.
The massacres were not limited to the murdered King and his immediate entourage, with Muslims and even Arabs more generally throughout Nineveh being pulled into the streets, beaten and killed as those loyal to Todos cleared Sabrisho’s influence from the city.
In game did they all cop it at the same time? From plots, or an attack and murder uprising? Very thorough regime decapitation anyway.
With Sabrisho’ gone, he represented the last surviving flicker of the might Qatwa dynasty through the male line, tracing his descent back directly to Saint Ta’mhas, the founder of the Assyrian nation, and his heroic successors like Nahir the Bear and Niv the Hammer who had forged the mighty Kingdom.
All the deaths of recent kings, some of them quite young, has whittled the dynasty away to nothing.
provided Todos with special dispensation to divorce his wife on the grounds that she was barren and seek out a suitably youthful alternative.
The only real option.
Seeking to save his liege’s life, the court physician castrated the King – with the stroke of knife ending any chance of an heir. Entering into a profound depression, Todos came to believe that God had cursed him for his killing of his nephew and spent the last years of his life in a state of utter despondency. In 1426 he took his own life, bringing to an end three centuries of Qatwa rule in Assyria and leaving behind no obvious successor.
Well, that’s gotta hurt! The one thing he didn’t want to happen.

So was Todos’ death and dynasty ending also a game-ending event for a stand alone CK2 game, with any inheritor of another dynasty entirely? Presume for AAR purposes you will just tag on to someone else to keep it going those last few years?
 
  • 1Like
Reactions:
What is it with Tommy4ever AARs and their dynasties dying out in spectacularly absurd ways? This, coupled with the consistent collapse of empires almost immediately after their apogee, makes me think your copy of the game is cursed in some way.
 
  • 2Like
Reactions:
Hell of a way for such an illustrious dynasty to come to an end, Todos definitely got some karmic retribution for killing his own kin, as misguided (in his own eyes) as they were, Assyria is gonna be in a tough spot now, I wonder who will take up the crown now I wonder?
 
  • 1Like
Reactions:
The family was full of peak and valleys with little middle ground. I wonder how tolerant the Zikris would have been with a sizeable bloc and one or two generations of power. Brutal ending for the family. Thank you for the journey.
 
Sic transit gloria mundi. What will become of Assyria without its founding dynasty?
 
  • 1
Reactions:
End of an Auld Sang - 1426-1438
End of an Auld Sang - 1426-1438

1659034276014.png

With the death of King Todos and the demise of the male line of the Qatwa dynasty, two primary claimants to the Assyrian throne emerged – both tracing their legitimacy through the three daughters of Niv III. The eldest, and by 1426 the only surviving, of the former King’s children was Princess Marte, who had been sent away in her youth to marry the English King of Sicily, bearing him two daughters who both died in infancy before political struggles on the island realm ousted her husband from power and sent her back into exile in Assyria, where she had absconded from politics and joined a nunnery. The candidate with the greatest support within the Kingdom was Dinkha Chahar Teghi, son of the respected Malik Rahim of Sinjar – one of the pious Nestorians who had participated in the killing of King Sabrisho’ alongside Todos – and Niv’s youngest, and by now deceased, daughter Morta. The greatest threat to Dinkha’s ascension to the crown came from outwith Assyria itself – to the Armenian ve Zhamo clan. Niv III’s second daughter, Shapira, had married the mercurial King Levon the Liberator of Armenia and birthed a brood of four sons and two daughters, before passing away following an outbreak of typhus – the eldest of which was Crown Prince Aboulgharib, the eldest grandson of Niv III and the figure with the strongest legal claim to the Assyrian inheritance

1659034307958.png

The tale of King Levon and the recent history of Armenia was in itself a captivating story of heroism and transformation. Through most of the Medieval period, as late as the early fourteenth century, there had been an independent Armenian Kingdom in the region around Lake Van. Although for almost a millennium from the nation’s conversion to Christianity, the Armenians had maintained an independent Apostolic Church, outwith the confines of Chalcedonian Christendom, the Middle Ages saw Byzantine influence encroach and Armenia’s Church enter into communion with Constantinople. The nation’s independent was brought to an end by the Mongol invasions of the Caucuses and eastern Anatolia in the first decades of the fourteenth century, with their homeland later passing over to the Timurids as the Iron Khan chased the Mongols north of the mountains at the end of the century. It was in this unstable context after the expulsion of the Mongols that a little known shepherd named Levon ve Zhamo came to attention. Abandoning his flock for a life of anti-Khazar banditry in the 1390s, Levon’s fame, prestige and ranks of followers quickly grew as he gained wealth and sparked a wave of revolt throughout the Armenian lands. By the turn of the century he controlled the lands around Lake Van and was already styling himself as King. Through the first decade of the 1400s, he continued his wars against the Timurids and his neighbours – pushing on to capture Yerevan, Tbilisi and Abkhazia and claiming the Kingship of Georgia.

As impressive as this rise had been, Levon was no mere warlord, and possessed both diplomatic cunning and a vision for religious reform. The titanic Christian empires that neighboured him to the south and west – Assyria and Byzantium – were both happy to see the Armenians give the Timurids a bloody nose and both sought to exert their influence. Levon played the two powers against one another, and achieved the legitimacy and geopolitical security he craved when Nechunya II of Assyria sent his sister Shapira to be his bride. Levon then embarked on his next great task – restoring the independence of the Armenian Apostolic Church under its traditional Oriental Orthodox doctrines. This dramatic reassertion of Church sovereignty has mixed results – drawing the largest part of the Armenian community within Levon’s realm to the new national Church, but creating a divide with the Armenian populations living within the Byzantine and Assyrian empire – whose populations largely ignored the change. Most immediately, Levon’s attempts to push Georgian Church – that had no history outwith Eastern Orthodoxy – to break its links with Constantinople and adopt Miaphysite doctrines led to civil war and rebellion. By 1420, Levon had lost all of his Georgian lands, although he continued to style himself as King of Armenia and Georgia, even if the latter was in name only.

1659034334883.png

King Todos’s poor health had been known for sometime prior to his death, and although he failed to designate a clear successor, the factions competing for the grand prize of the Assyrian throne had had plenty time to lay their plans. Upon the last Qatwa King’s death, the Armenians were quickest to react. Emphasising the seniority of Aboulgharib’s claim as the eldest male grandchild of Niv III, King Levon provided his son with a sizeable army and sent him to march south the claim his birth rite. In Nineveh, having only recently ejected the apostasy of Sabrisho’, the Assyrian nobility were in no mood for a heretical foreign to take power in their homeland and instead looked towards the Chahar Taghli family. With the teenage Dinkha installed on the throne, his father Rahim took charge of a powerful alliance that dominated Mesopotamia and the Gulf, although possessing weaker ties to the western Kingdoms.

Seeing the Assyrian heartland rally against him, Aboulgharib changed course away from Nineveh and instead marched westwards to Edessa. Taking advantage of alliances with the city’s large Armenian minority, the Prince took the city without a fight. There, he took the important political decision of turning away from the Oriental Orthodoxy of his father to embrace the Church of the East. This step saved his campaign from collapse. There were many magnates in opposition of Rahim and the Nineveh-faction who had been hesitant to align with the Armenians whose concerns were now eased, in particular the Maliks of Palmyra and Amman who had both been supportive of the short-lived policies of religious toleration under King Sabrisho’ and saw in Aboulgharib a tool with which to weaken the growing influence of Nestorian fundamentalism. With this, the Armenian Prince had established himself as a major force in the western provinces.

1659034354994.png

Aboulgharib’s presence in Edessa was far from universally welcomed in Syria. Despite his conversion to Nestorianism, he remained closely associated with his father’s campaign to re-establish Oriental Orthodoxy that had seen Greek Christian clergymen – Paulicians and Old Orthodox alike – denounce the ve Zhamos from the pulpit for decades. The threat of an Armenian takeover in Assyria therefore pushed the Greek Christian majority of north western Syria into revolt. The Greek Christian revolt turned Syria into the epicentre of the ensuing civil war as a three sided struggle emerged between the Syrian rebels, Aboulgharib and his Assyrian allies and Rahim’s forces.

The fighting was bitter and chaotic. In the east, Rahim brought sieges against Edessa and Palmyra, while engaging in raiding throughout the western provinces and seeking to attract allies to his cause. Yet the heaviest fighting was between the Armenian Prince and the Syrian rebels, with Greek Christians expanding their war by massacring the large Armenian minorities in the regions they controlled and pushing south from their core holdings around Aleppo and Antioch to attack key minority-populated territories in southern Syria home to the Messalians, Marionites and Druze. This struggle culminated in the decisive battle of Samsat in 1426, in which Aboulgharib led a veteran force to a great victory over a Syrian army twice its number.

1659034378896.png

This important battlefield victory coincided with key diplomatic manoeuvres initiated by the wily old King Levon. Breaking off a proposed marriage to the Crown Prince of Alania, Levon offered the hand of his youngest daughter Sirvart to the Crusader King of Egypt, Simon, a man more than twice her age. As a behemoth among relative pygmies in Eastern Mediterranean Catholicism, Egypt held substantial cultural sway over the Cuman and Latin Catholic nobility of Philistia. The lords of the smallest of the Assyrian realms had sought to avoid committing heavily to any side in the civil war, with many considering a push for independence in the style of the Syrians. Yet the new connection forged between the Armenians and Alexandria, coupled with the tide of the war in the west appearing to turn in Aboulgharib’s favour after Samsat, convinced the Philistians to throw their lot in with his claim. Having already made alliances among the Marionites, Messalians and Druze through their mutual conflict against the Greek Christian Syrians, Aboulgharib had achieved a dominant position in the west. By the end of 1426, Syria and Philistia were firmly under his control, with Rahim withdrawing his armies towards the capital.

1659034412838.png

Aboulgharib invaded Mesopotamia in early 1427, confident of victory. Such was the Armenian’s momentum, Rahim chose to abandon the capital in order to withdraw deeper in an attempt to buy time. This gambit, although battering the confidence of his faction, proved a masterstroke. For more than a year the two armies parried back and forth, with Aboulgharib failing in every effort to push deeper into Mesopotamia. Finally, Rahim pinned his rival to a pitched battle at Samarra, vanquishing his force and sending him into a headlong retreat back to Syria – seeing Nineveh change hands once again. Receiving reinforcements from his father, the Armenian Crown Prince finally turned to stand his ground at the Battle of Darbasak, west of Edessa. In a close engagement, Aboulgharib came out with a clear battlefield advantage, forcing Rahim to abandon his push into Syria. Far more importantly, the would-be King Dinkha was captured on the field.

Dinkha was Rahim Chahar Teghi, and therefore the only alternative to the ve Zhamo clan who could trace their ancestry through the daughters of Niv III. Aboulgharib therefore offered his foes an amnesty. Should Rahim and his followers surrender and accept his ascension as King, and Dinkha renounce his royal pretensions and join the priesthood, Aboulgharib would allow his enemies to retain their titles, swear to the preservation of Church authority and provide positions of influence to his erstwhile enemies. Should they refuse, he would execute his imprisoned rival to the throne and continue to war to its bitter end. Malik Rahim took the fateful decision to accept peace, allowing Aboulgharib to return to Nineveh once more in 1429 where he was formally crowned King of Assyria, Syria and Philistia – marking the true birth of Assyria’s Armenian dynasty.

1659034432671.png

This might have been the end of the bloody succession struggle, but just as the conflict was dying down a third title claimant emerged in the deserts to the south. When King Sabrisho’ was overthrown 1422, remarkably just seven years before Aboulgharib’s final victory over Rahim Chahar Teghi, his young son Nerseh was believed to have been killed in the bloodshed the accompanied Todos’s palace coup. However, from the very first rumours had swirled, predominantly in the Muslim Belt of central Babylonia, that the young boy had been spared by supporters of his fallen father and spirited away to the friendly Muslim communities in the desert. During the late 1420s a boy in his early teenage years emerged in the heart of Arabia claiming to be the lost Prince Nerseh. Popular interest in the boy quickly grew, as a number of figures of Sabrisho’s regime began to claim that they could recognise him as the young child they had once known. He was drawn to the court of the Sulaymans in 1429, where the Sunni Caliph recognised him as the rightful successor of Sabrisho’, the last of the Qatwa, and the true King of Assyria. Seeing him as a tool with which the briefly promised Islamic resurgence in Assyria might be pursued, in 1430 the Caliph invaded the tired Assyrian realm in the name of Nerseh.

The Muslims made quick progress initially, finding largescale popular support among the Muslim communities living east of the Jordan in Philistia and, most potently, the Zikri of Babylonia. The Caliph had hoped than after half a decade of civil war, the Assyrian realm would be too weak and divided to offer a staunch resistance, yet his offensive only solidified Aboulgharib’s position by binding together the recently warring factions of Assyria’s political landscape against their shared infidel foe. The Caliph’s army was routed at Karbala in 1431, melting back into the Arabian Desert. However vicious fighting continued to roll on for years as Assyria’s Muslims fought to the end in the name of the supposed Prince Nerseh. In 1433, the Assyrian King launched a daring raid into the Nedjaz – receiving naval support in the Red Sea from Crusader Egypt – and successfully parleyed the surrender Nerseh in exchange for the safety of the holy cities of Mecca and Medina. Brought back to Assyria in chains, Nerseh was denounced as an imposter and a traitor and executed. Finally, the long battle for the Assyrian crown was over.

1659034461424.png

In 1438, the great King Levon of Armenia finally passed away after a remarkable life that had taken him from the humble beginnings among his sheep herds on the Armenian hillsides, to establish his progeny on the throne of a mighty empire. His death left Aboulgharib another inheritance, bringing the crowns of Armenia and Georgia into the sprawling collection of Assyrian dominions. He was now ruled a collection that contemporaries styled the Five Kingdoms – Assyria, Syria, Philistia, Armenia and Georgia. With the Armenian dynasty firmly secure in Assyria, and the union of their homeland with the Assyrian crown complete, a new age was dawning on the Near East.
 
Last edited:
  • 8Like
  • 4Love
Reactions:
End of Part One
 
  • 3Like
  • 1
Reactions:
So we end the CK2 portion with quite the bang and the birth of a new dynasty. Let us hope Assyria will be safe in the hands of these foreigners!

So a little explanation of in game events. As you might have guessed from the screenshots, Aboulgharib (who was probably our best stats leader since Niv the Hammer) was out legal successor as the eldest male matrilineal ancestor of the Qatwa line. After he became King Rahim almost instantly rebelled for his son's claim to the Kingdom of Assyria (which would have given him all of Mesopotamia and the Gulf as I never created Babylonia as a separate King title) and took with him the largest part of the nobility - who weren't too keen on a heretic. We also faced one of our standard massive popular revolts in Syria. Nerseh's war was a more standard invasion by the Arabs - but it made sense to wrap it into this game of thrones. We made it through, and I kept playing just long enough to inherit Levon's old Kingdom and titles so we convert to EU4 as one. Maybe it would have been more interesting converting before the inheritance so we would have ended up with an EU4 PU - but that decision was long since made, and would have maybe left too big a gap between when we stopped playing and 1444.

I will post here when Part Two begins!

I did not see this coming. I hope whoever inherits now can keep Assyria together.

Always another twist round the road! We did actually come quite close to breaking apart here. Dinkha's claim was not for all three Kingdoms in game but only for Assyria, while the Syrian liberation revolt might have split another Kingdom off. Had Aboulgharib lost those two wars then we would have ended up with Assyria in Mesopotamia, an independent pro-Byzantine Syria and a union of Armenia and Philistia.

A sad end to a glorious dynasty. :( A real surprise too. I hope their line traced through the girls will have the spunk of old Saint To'mas!

Well, they certainly have his DNA in them if that is what you mean! :p :D

Quite the way for the Qatwas to bow out, though not at all uncharacteristic. Todos is definitely more of a tragic figure than a Shakespearean Richard III type, though one wonders whether history will be kind. Depending on which direction the religious settlement ends up taking, I could well see Sabrisho’ painted as the villain by future writers – though that would imply a pretty poor reception for any idea of tolerance, so hopefully I’m proven wrong.

Either way, the drama of the eleventh-hour conversion and re-conversion was quite the end to the CK era. The sense of an unprecedented historical event, Sabrisho’s original conversion, came across very strongly. Good stuff, Tommy!


It’s all getting a bit ‘Murder on the Orient Express’… :D

I've been pleased with the healthy amount of drama the Qatwas provided us with over their three and a half century run. Although CK2 always seems to produce lots of good stories if you keep the game going. In terms of how history will look at Todos, it is hard to say. His prevention of a potential slide towards Islam is likely to win many plaudits, what this meant for tolerance in Assyria will be divisive, while his failure to carry on the dynasty (and by extension facilitation of the rise of a foreign dynasty) will not please nationalists one bit. Perhaps too soon to tell!

As for Sabrisho and the idea of tolerance, well in such a multi-religious and multi-ethnic state this is going to be one of the big questions of Assyria's Early Modern history. Let's see if Assyria turns up with a different answer than our friends in Jewish Poland did!

Wow, that was quite an extravagant and unexpected way for the dinasty to die! At peace, with no Christian heretics nor foreign Muslim jihads, but by the hand of the first homegrown muslim king and his murderer, the hopelessly childless uncle. Hope the unavoidable following internal strife doesn't tear up Assyria too badly, but then again Assyria has endured far worse!

Some irony in there that after an extended period of hardship and chaos at the end of the last century and start of the 1400s, the first moment we get a bit of peace things explode spectacularly in our face.

In game did they all cop it at the same time? From plots, or an attack and murder uprising? Very thorough regime decapitation anyway.

All the deaths of recent kings, some of them quite young, has whittled the dynasty away to nothing.

The only real option.

Well, that’s gotta hurt! The one thing he didn’t want to happen.

So was Todos’ death and dynasty ending also a game-ending event for a stand alone CK2 game, with any inheritor of another dynasty entirely? Presume for AAR purposes you will just tag on to someone else to keep it going those last few years?

It wasn't so long ago we had quite the brood of dynasty members. Three sons from Niv III looked a good base to keep the dynasty going for a long time. But wars, betrayals and bad luck put an end to all that.

Todos's death was a game ender for me. The surgery that made him a eunuch actually succeeded in curing his cancer, but he remained in frail health - so I tag switched over to his successor (Aboulgharib) and waited for him to die (which didn't take long) to continue the story.

What is it with Tommy4ever AARs and their dynasties dying out in spectacularly absurd ways? This, coupled with the consistent collapse of empires almost immediately after their apogee, makes me think your copy of the game is cursed in some way.

And this was one I was hoping to keep alive! There was a certain poetry in our founding dynasty going extinct just as we end the CK2 portion, and they went out in a very interesting way for sure. I've been looking forward to these chapters for a good while! But always fun to keep the readers not knowing when we are going to lose :p

I can't help but think that Todos's fate was some kind of karmic justice for his kinslaying. Such a sordid way for a dynasty founded in a saint's blood to extinguish itself...

You can imagine the torment Todos faced in those last years. Pushed into action by a pretty extreme situation, he probably had little choice. But the murder of his family will have haunted him, and then seeing his own health decay before losing his manhood (and his hope of keeping his family alive). A harsh end for him.

Hell of a way for such an illustrious dynasty to come to an end, Todos definitely got some karmic retribution for killing his own kin, as misguided (in his own eyes) as they were, Assyria is gonna be in a tough spot now, I wonder who will take up the crown now I wonder?

As in the above comment, there is much to feel sorry for Todos here - it is hard to see how he could have avoided acting, but the mass slaughter was certainly not necessary. We now have a new dynasty, or foreigners no less and we can at the very least put a question mark over just how commited Aboulgharib is to the Nestorian faith. Let us see what comes next.

The family was full of peak and valleys with little middle ground. I wonder how tolerant the Zikris would have been with a sizeable bloc and one or two generations of power. Brutal ending for the family. Thank you for the journey.

Yes, we ended up having very few 'steady as you go' rulers mixed in here. This was a fairly short game it should be remembered - only just under 350 years and the first third of that was taken up by Ta'mhas and his sons Niv I and Nahir. After that we got quite a lot of dross amongst one or two standout rulers.

Sic transit gloria mundi. What will become of Assyria without its founding dynasty?

We have had the power struggle, the new leaders have been chosen. What happens next is anyone's guess. The one thing we can be sure of, is that Assyria will not be the same again.
 
  • 2Like
  • 2
Reactions:
I did not expect this at all, I love that the Armenians and the Assyrians, both have been able to achieve the union to defend themselves in a place as unstable as the middle east, the first step for the union of the Eastern church!

How many Copts are there in Egypt still?
 
  • 3
Reactions:
Honestly the setup seems nicely poised for a bunch of different sect Christian kingdoms in the Near East for EU4 and the internal and external politics to make them into a singular political entity
 
  • 3
  • 1
Reactions:
Wonderful ending of the CK2 part, looking forward to seeing how the nation fares in the exploration age. While Europe looks to America, perhaps Assyria might look towards her lost possessions in India and further east to the spice islands?
 
  • 4
Reactions:
First, congratulations on finishing the CK2 part of this rollicking tale and very nearly getting the Qatwas over the line. And reflecting back on Todos’ end, how fitting it was for CK2 that the final blow was administered by one of those erratic and bloodthirsty court physician ’cures’. :D

the first moment we get a bit of peace things explode spectacularly in our face.
That kept happening in this AAR - always most entertaining!
Todos's death was a game ender for me. The surgery that made him a eunuch actually succeeded in curing his cancer, but he remained in frail health - so I tag switched over to his successor (Aboulgharib) and waited for him to die (which didn't take long) to continue the story.
Ah, thanks for explaining. So close to the end - but the Armenian dynasty worked out well for the end of the CK2 phase and promises an interesting start for the EU portion.
 
  • 1Like
Reactions:
I can't believe my prediction of an Armenian-Assyrian personal union would be true after all! Of course how it lead to that point was something I didn't expect, regardless it would seem the Assryians will have their work cut out for them in the EU4 portion if they intend to become a great power, lots of rivals, lots of opportunities, and hopefully it will not be squandered. And it's quite interesting to see the current king's father rose from a humble shepherd to becoming king and having a progeny that would rule a vast (young) empire, what an achievement. Congrats are in order for this CK2 segment my man, I am looking forward to seeing the EU4 section. As one of the users above puts it, Indian awaits!
 
  • 1Like
Reactions:
Stirling ending to the CK section, Tommy. Something quite poignant about seeing the Five Kingdoms making it thru to EU united in the end. Here’s hoping Aboulgharib has the nous as a peacetime ruler to live up to his auspicious start to life on the throne. Onwards to new challenges!

Let's see if Assyria turns up with a different answer than our friends in Jewish Poland did!
Let’s hope so! :eek:
 
  • 2
  • 1Like
Reactions:
An Armenian Ascendancy has begun. A rocky start for Assyria's new ruling dynasty, but Levon has played the political game very well, leaving his son with a powerful Near Eastern hegemony that nearly rivals the ancient empire of Sennacherib himself. Of course, beneath the surface you have two very different cultures each dominated by churches with very different views on the nature of Christ -- a time-honored recipe for internecine religious strife...

The whole time I was reading this chapter, I had Elton John's "Levon" playing in the back of my mind. Made for some oddly dissonant mental images.
 
  • 1Like
  • 1
Reactions: