• We have updated our Community Code of Conduct. Please read through the new rules for the forum that are an integral part of Paradox Interactive’s User Agreement.
I just finished reading your first post. The thing I like most about it is that your characters boast of their achievement in battle and looting, nobody truly seems proud of themselves They all seem just a bit ashamed of what they’ve done. Yet, I am sure they will do it again. I will definitely keep reading.

Thank you, truly! That tension, between bravado and shame, between the stories they tell and the things they cannot quite admit to themselves, is the heart of any story of conflict. The campaign left me with a court haunted by what they’ve won: loot, relics, and the bell itself, but also fear, suspicion, and a kind of moral unease that none of them can shake. No one can afford to be entirely proud or entirely sorry; everyone is carrying debts, I'm glad that came through clearly.

And yes, you’ve caught it exactly: whatever remorse they feel, the world they live in will push them to repeat it. Sometimes the stories that last are the ones that wound the deepest. I’m grateful you’re following along.

---

Nice, solid work, @MichOrion. Extremely detailed character building, though I'm waiting for Yevdokia to more than slink in the shadows :).

There was a good discussion about serialization, including bits on post length and dialogue in the SolAARium, in case you are interested. I’ve always preferred the 'bite size' approach with a 'hook', or cliffhanger to whet the reader's appetite for more. Chapter 3 was a long read, but your use of paragraph breaks and 'white space' made it manageable. Personally, I would have split the chapter into two segments, with the rope snapping being a perfect cliffhanger.

That said, not everyone has the time for a long read, and that may turn off some people. Heaven knows, we're having enough trouble getting people to read other AARs so they can pass along the various awards without it going into the dreaded 'Open for Nomination' category.

Anyway, great start. I'll be checking this one out. BTW, I just noticed you've been around almost as long as I have.

Thank you, LD, for the detailed and thoughtful response, it means a lot! I’m glad the character work is coming through, even if some of them (Yevdokia especially!) are still holding their cards close for now. Her time in the spotlight is coming; she’s a spymaster in every sense, waiting for her chance to tip the balance.

I really appreciate the note about structure and serialization. My own taste runs toward long episodes too, with a hook to carry things forward. I struggled a bit with chapter length, since events were so tightly linked. I’ll experiment more with segmenting, especially as the saga gets busier and the court fills up.

Glad the white space and breaks worked for you. I’ll take the advice and aim for punchier installments where possible. Thanks again for reading, and for your sage advice.

---

Your atmosphere is fabulous. It further confirms my belief that living in Russia at any moment in history is a dismal business. If you’re poor, the rich trample you. If you’re rich, the other oligarchs will eat you if you show weakness. It’s also really freaking cold.

I do agree with other readers about the length of your post, but I would offer another solution besides splitting your chapter. You have a lot of repetition and sometimes it gets distracting. See the quotes below.

(quotes of duplicate character descriptions follow)

I think with just one of these posts per chapter, you could establish what the characters are doing and, if they’re doing the same thing as the previous chapter, maybe it doesn’t add anything to the chapter to have them keep doing the same thing. You could skip it.

I’m curious about Yevdokia. I hope she makes an insightful report to the prince sometime soon with what she has learned.

I also hope you know that I am enjoying your story a lot. I hope my observations help you make it even better.

Thank you, Sirdramaticus! Your feedback is both generous and sharp, exactly what I hope for. I’m glad the atmosphere landed for you.

You’re absolutely right about the repetition, especially with Yevdokia. I’ve been working to track character presence and “camera time” closely, but in some scenes, I caught myself circling the same gesture or mood a little too often. That’s a habit from writing AARs with big casts and wanting to make sure no one gets left behind, but you’re right that a single, decisive moment per chapter does more than three weak echoes. I’ll watch it in the next scenes, especially as Yevdokia’s role grows sharper. She’s due for more direct action and insight soon.

Your observations absolutely help—keep them coming! It’s a privilege to have such engaged readers.

Chapter 3 Part 2 coming soon!
 
  • 2Like
Reactions:
“There’s talk of a merchant’s son gone missing in the night. Too many strangers in the city. The quartermasters report two carts of rye lost.”
Hmmm… what does THIS foretell???
Each answer, true or false, added another thread to her web. The city bristled with rumor and strangers, the scent of new money tangled with old fear. Somewhere in that tangle she would find what she and Polotsk needed: proof if it could be found, or something that would serve well enough when the time came.
It’s kind of cool to see Yevdokia building her web of informants. I think it’s interesting that right now, she pays for truth and lies. The important part is buying the snitches. I will have to think about writing out a spymaster building out their network at some point in my own AAR.
Sofia let the silence settle, the weight of worry pressing at her shoulders. "If there is danger, better to name it than wait for it to find us. The prince should know."

Sviatoslav’s fingers moved restlessly over the beads. "Better to act first, but if we force a claim, we should be certain. Half-truths and old rumors do not make justice, not in the eyes of God nor man."

Yevdokia’s smile was a thin, sharp thing. "We make our own omens. Tell the prince there is proof, or what will pass for proof. Better to act than to be cornered."
Who is running the show, the prince or his council? Seems to me he’s drawing crosses in the frost while his spin doctors try to invade his neighbors. I guess we’ll see.
I’ve been working to track character presence and “camera time” closely, but in some scenes, I caught myself circling the same gesture or mood a little too often.
I can appreciate the challenge in that. I also have a big cast in my AAR. However, the character’s union hasn’t insisted on characters appearing in a certain number of episodes, so I only put them in when it matters for the story. Currently, none of my characters have logged any formal grievances about lack of story time, either. Maybe readers need a bit of a reminder about who they are when they return, but they’re relevant enough that confusion seems to evaporate quickly.

Have you considered trying to create an extended episode with a just a few characters in depth to change the pace? Your writing lends itself to panoramic mood and setting creation. What happens when it’s just two or three characters for a whole post? I would love to get to know a few of these people well.
 
Chapter 3: The Founding Part 2: The Council Divides

When the council at last gathered beneath the banner in the keep’s hall, the air was thick with breath and misgiving. Vseslav’s gaze lingered on the empty space by the hearth. “We should wait for Yevdokia. She is never late without reason.”

Rostislav shrugged, knife tapping at his belt. “There’s always reason, and half of them her own. We could freeze waiting.”

Sofia drew her mantle close, her voice gentle but steady. “We do her no favor making the city hold its breath for one shadow. Let us begin. She will join us when she chooses.”

Vseslav hesitated, then nodded. “Very well. The city cannot wait.”

Sviatoslav stepped forward, an old charter in his hand. The seal, pressed with wax and faded blue thread, trembled in his grasp. “The saints remember what men forget,” he said, lifting the parchment so all could see. “This names Polotsk as guardian of the Brasla, written in the time of our fathers’ fathers, before that land turned from the cross.”

Trifon squared his shoulders, jaw clenched as he shifted his weight. The lines of his youthful face twisted in the torchlight, irritation clear. “Fine words won’t fill the ranks. There are too few men on the walls. The men will fight if they are led and paid, but there’s not enough of either. If war comes, we’ll need more than prayers and Greek parchment.”

Theodosius set his tally stick down, lips pressed tight, a faint tremor in his hand. For a moment, the torchlight flickered on the white of his knuckles, but his voice held steady. “The treasury is thinning. Silver spent on walls is not silver spent on swords. If we are to speak of coin, let those born to the city’s burdens be heard first. It is a steward’s duty to weigh such costs.”
He glanced, just a shade too long, at Zelekman and the empty chair reserved for the city’s new doctor.

Zelekman closed his ledger, gaze steady. “A steward’s task, yes, but sometimes it is the man at the threshold who sees the storm before the master of the house. If we act boldly, others may hesitate, or they may call our bluff. Stories do not fill the granary nor mend broken bones, but they have their worth.”

Theodosius’s silence was brittle. He folded his hands over the tally stick, knuckles white.

Sofia looked around the ring of faces. “Courage alone will not hold the walls, but neither will fear. If we waver, every neighbor will sense blood in the water. We must show them we stand, even if our numbers are few.”

Vseslav listened to each, his gaze sweeping council and shadow alike. He stood, cloak stiff with frost, and gave his answer. “We do not have the luxury of caution. If Polotsk is to rise, we must shape our own fate and make our victory count before the chance is lost. Sviatoslav, gather your charters and prepare whatever proof or prayer we need. Trifon, see to the levies and tell Koz’ma to double the watches. Zelekman, count what coin we have left and what men we can raise if the gates must open. The rest, see to your posts, and let Polotsk remember this night.”

A hush settled over the council as the debate circled and sharpened, drawing old divisions into the open. Even the wind seemed to lean in, carrying away the last warmth of the day. The shadows along the timbered walls deepened as the council’s debate circled itself. Vseslav had nearly given the order to disperse when a current of cold air swept through the room, and all fell silent.

Yevdokia entered as if conjured from the dark behind the doors, her dark fur mantle dusted with a rim of frost, eyes sharp above cheeks flushed by the wind. She stepped lightly, silent boots skimming the rushes, moving not with the deference of a courtier but the certainty of one returning to her rightful place. At her approach, Rostislav shifted, jaw tight, his pride pricked by how easily she had passed him, unannounced and unchallenged.

Without pause, she laid a sealed strip of beresta—thin birchbark used for letters and notes—before the prince, her gloved fingers lingering just long enough for every councilor to register the significance. The bark, stiff with cold and curled at the edges where snowmelt had touched the wax, carried the rough marks of hurried writing. Her voice, when it came, was steady and precise, as though she addressed only the facts, not the men and women gathered around her.

“Proof,” she said, “of what I warned. A letter intercepted at the western road. In it, men of Braslav promise safe conduct to those willing to weaken Polotsk’s walls from within.” She did not blink as her gaze slid from Sofia to Sviatoslav, then to Rostislav, who met her eyes with a scowl.

Sviatoslav, catching her glance, looked quickly away, fingers worrying the beads at his wrist. Of late, he seemed uneasy in her presence, and would not meet her eyes for long. Whatever hold she had found on his conscience, it left him more troubled and silent than before.

For a long moment, only the pop of resin in the hearth broke the silence. Theodosius reached for the parchment, his movements wary, as if the letter itself might bite. He began to read it.

Rostislav’s hand rested on his knife hilt. “Anyone can write a threat and call it truth,” he growled, his pride still stung. “You slip past me in the dark, and now you bring shadows into our hall.”

Yevdokia met his challenge with a flat stare. “I bring what the city needs to survive. Shadows do not care for pride, only for opportunity left unguarded.”

Sofia’s posture was poised, but her eyes darted between the prince and his spymaster, weighing cost and necessity. “If the letter is real, we must act. If it is not, even the rumor will serve to ready our defense. What does it say, chancellor?"

Theodosius’s voice was thin but urgent. “We cannot afford delay. Every day the walls stand unfinished, the treasury empties further. Action, of any kind, must be justified, for our neighbors will know if we act on lies.”

Vseslav watched the faces around him: old loyalties, new suspicions, and the precarious trust binding his house together. He let the silence stretch until the tension became nearly unbearable. Yevdokia stood unmoving, offering no apology, she was the city’s shadow, indispensable, and never to be loved.

“We will act,” Vseslav said at last, his voice low and final. “On warning or on proof, we cannot wait for certainty while danger gathers at the gate. Let the story serve our need, and let the saints judge us after.”

A cold wind rattled the shutters as the council, bound by doubt as much as resolve, murmured assent. None met Yevdokia’s eyes for long, but none dared dismiss her, either. In that moment, Polotsk’s fate turned not on steel or coin, but on a single strip of beresta and the will to wield it.
 
  • 1Like
Reactions:
Prince Vseslav pressed his gloved palm to the parapet, then, removing the glove, bent to mark a small cross in the frost. It was an old habit, learned in childhood, a charm against loss that had long outlived its meaning (...) A young apprentice dabbed some lard onto the first timber, a small gesture for luck.
I feel Polotsk will need much more than old superstitions to survive this winter.

Word travels fast. Our riches are no secret.
Word travelled fast and Novogord's riches were no secret. The wheel of fate keeps turning, and the raider may be the next target...

Every path is dangerous. The only choice is which danger we can live with.
Sometimes you try to choose between peace or honor, only to lose both.

A hush settled over the council as the debate circled and sharpened, drawing old divisions into the open (...) He let the silence stretch until the tension became nearly unbearable.
The prince seems to enjoy the tension within Councilors, or he is just slow at making decisions; risking Polotsk on the hesitation.

“We will act,” Vseslav said at last, his voice low and final. “On warning or on proof, we cannot wait for certainty while danger gathers at the gate. Let the story serve our need, and let the saints judge us after.”
Finally he made a move. Let's see how it turns.
 
Hey! I just nominated you for an AARland Choice Awards award for this last quarter. I hope that everyone who follows will participate by voting.
It’s also a great way to learn about other high quality AARs that you haven’t read. See here the details: Q2 2025 ACAs.
 
Last edited:
  • 1Love
Reactions:
There seems to be an awful lot of ruminating over how to protect their city and what course of action to take. If low manpower and money is a problem, then what was the rationale behind conquering Novgorod? Surely it couldn't have been the bell. Spoils aside, that cost them much needed manpower. Vseslav is starting to strike me as a weak leader, relying too much on the council to guide his decisions. Too many opinions. And who sets strategy?

Continued good work. I'll be glad when summer in Polotsk rolls around. All this frost is chilling my warmth.