• We have updated our Community Code of Conduct. Please read through the new rules for the forum that are an integral part of Paradox Interactive’s User Agreement.

unmerged(165945)

Recruit
1 Badges
Sep 14, 2009
9
0
  • Hearts of Iron III
"Lessons Learned"

An After Action Review by kaegogi

Player Nation = Brazil
Difficulty = Very Easy (hey, I'm new)
Start Date = 1/1/1936
Mod = None
Cheats = Altered saved game to lower Brazilian Neutrality to "0"

Notes:

This is only my second attempt at this game. In my first run as Yunnan I got my ass kicked when I tried to take Guanxi. My thinking was that Guanxi and Nationalist China would both be tied up fighting Japan....I was so wrong.

Now I'll be trying to create a true Brazilian Empire out of the South American continent. I don't know how the USA will react when I start taking nations they have guaranteed. Should the USA react militarily this will be a very short AAR.

Any insight, comments, criticisms are very welcome.

Lessons Learned

"Cave, cavern, cavernous"

was the thought progression that came to kaegogi's mind as he slowly spun on one heel. The warehouse he surveyed had been turned into a giant study hall for the Reich War College. On the ground floor massive wooden tables with upturned sides held tons of sand that had been sculpted and spray painted to depict the coastal plains of Uruguay. Privates from the adjacent Basic Training Battalion scurried between the tables laying out unit markers under the watchful eye of non-coms, who held maps with acetate graphics.

"Why doesn't it echo in here?"

kaegogi flattened his palms against the balcony's wooden railing and leaned out. The balcony ran around three sides of the warehouse and allowed anyone privileged enough to stand on it to review whatever portion of the world the enlisted men had faithfully recreated below. Currently the balcony held all 46 students of Class 2-52 of the Reich War College. One of those members, and the only North American by birth, was the luckless Lt. Colonel kaegogi.

skip this if you're not interested in bad writing :)
How had a man born in the small town of Mentor, in the heart of Kansas, USA, come to be standing on a balcony in a warehouse in Berlin, Germany, center of the Third Reich? It was a long and painful story. A story best left to the privacy of a torn soul and his bartender. Pretend for a minute that you're that bartender. What words of wisdom and comfort could you give a man that poured out a scotch soaked tale such as this? A member of the Flying Tigers in 1938, shot down by a Japanese fighter and swept up into a Nationalist Chinese battalion. Company Commander during a desperate counter attack onto the Korean Peninsula where your inability, despite crippling hunger, to eat dog meat earned you a nickname that managed to stick to you no matter where you went. A desperate escape from China aboard a neutral Yemeni flagged freighter. An eventual homecoming in 1941 to a less than proud German immigrant mother and father. A dutiful following of those parents back to the fatherland. A commission in an army that's not your own and a slogging mess of a war that drags you unwillingly from the Baltic to Siberia and the Pacific. Frocked a Regimental commander in a mech division during the hottest parts of the war and then reduced to Major, executive officer of an infantry battalion once the gears of war grew still. Now, with less than a year left before a graceful resignation could be submitted, promoted to Lt. Colonel and sent to the War College to learn how best to uphold Hitler's continued madness. It was 1952 for God's sake! How does a mere mortal of a bartender advise a man who has spent the past 14 years of his life fighting wars that were not his own? Best just to nod and look sympathetic, pour more scotch, on the house this time, and hope the wretch passes out sooner rather than later.​


"ATTENTION"
"ca-clack, ca-clack, ca-clack" Rapid.
"Ca-click" The sound of the dress shoes' sudden stop signaled the end to the low conversations on the balcony.

Standing on the concrete floor of the warehouse was Brigadier General Utz Herbig, lecturer for the Brazil study. kaegogi and the rest of the class stood at attention.

"Carry on."

The enlisted men silently bustled back to putting the final touches on the giant sand table while the field grade officers on the balcony stood at ease and craned their necks to dutifully attend the General below.

"Officers of the Third Reich....welcome to Uruguay and Brazil's folly.", the General described an arc with one arm, encompassing the sand tables around him.

A man who prided himself on precision, the General wasted no more than those words for a preamble.

"Gentlemen, maps.", the General pointed toward the coastal ragions of Uruguay. "Copy."

kaegogi and the rest of the officers on the balcony unfolded their maps and began transfering the graphics.

"This, gentlemen, is the plan that would lead to Brazil's Doom."

opening.jpg


"As you can see, the Brazilian High Command planned to invade Uruguay with a single Corps."

"Three divisions of infantry would be screened to the north by a division of cavalry, to the south by the Brazilian fleet and would have an airscreen of a single flight of interceptors."

The General was handed a yard long pointer by a Sergeant and moved to where he could point out the cavalry screen.

"The cavalry division will create a moving screen by separating into its three regiments, which will leap frog one another to spoil and fix any flanking attempts by Uruguayan forces positioned to the north."

His pointer moves to the center and northern infantry divisions.

"These divisions will drive through the inland plains and prepare an assault upon the capital, Objective Lime."

The pointer moves to the southern infantry division.

"The third division will follow the coast, screened and supported by the navy, and prepare a supporting attack."

The pointer moves to the fleet.

"The Battleship and her consorts will screen the movement of the coastal division and prepare to provide indirect fires on the capital, in support of the attack. Any Uruguayan attempts to put ships to sea will be met and defeated."

The pointer rests on the air component.

"The wing of interceptors will fly cover for the operation."

The General turns away from the sand tables with a derisive sneer.

"A child's parody of warfare gentlemen. But a good study of how not to lose wars. Let us see what became of Brazil's attempts at empire building."

kaegogi stared at his map as his mind drifted back to the nights he had spent sitting at the radio. As a 16 year old he had barely paid attention to the reports of war in distant South America. Now he remembered every word.

(to be continued once I've actually launched this thing)
 
Last edited:
Ooh, a Brazilian AAR, fantastic! Unfortunately your image seems to not be working.
 
Ooh, a Brazilian AAR, fantastic! Unfortunately your image seems to not be working.
hm, no idea how to fix that. I'll see if I can't host the images elsewhere after this post. Any tips on a good free site that works well with paradoxplaza posts would be appreciated!

I'll be watching this one! Brazil, thats awesome!
heh, you might not have to watch for too long. Apparently the USA doesn't like it when Uruguay gets invaded by her neighbor.

Lessons Learned (cont.)

"Herr Muuuiiiiller!"

kaegogi snapped back from his memories of better days. The intentional slurring of the umlaut into an "i" was General Herbig's way of ensuring kaegogi remembered he was born in America. As though he could, or would ever want to, forget. Looking down at the General, kaegogi kept his face impassive.

"Jah, Herr General?"

kaegogi laid his American accent on a bit thicker than normal as a deliberate, even if barely perceptible, challenge.

"Tell me Herr Mill....ah, excuse me please, Herr Mueller. In your advanced reading for this lecture series who was it the Brazilian high command assigned to lead their forces against Uruguay? Who were his immediate subordinates? And what force disposition did he execute?"

Herbig's sneer never slipped throughout the questions. kaegogi gave the man points for discipline and consistency if for nothing else.

"Herr General, General Kroner was the Corps commander. Beneath him were his division commanders:
General Kopp commanded the screening cavalry regiments,
General Farias commanded First ID,
General Silva commanded Second ID and
General Assis commanded Third ID."

"Kroner deployed his Corps in depth approximately 10 KM north of the Line of Departure (LOD), only moving forward to set the LOD approximately 1 hour prior to SP."

kaegogi gave orders to a waiting sergeant on the floor below, who sent a pair of privates to deploy unit markers on the sand table.

deployment1.jpg

Kroner's deployment an hour prior to SP


"Very good Colonel."

The General looked decidely displeasured that kaegogi had gotten it right. Impatient that his ploy to embarrass kaegogi had not worked and that he had allowed someone else to become center of attention for a short time, Herbig took over the narrative.

"Kroner ordered SP at 1000 hours on February 28th, 1936. Enemy force estimates provided through intelligence and the complete surprise achieved by Brazil in attacking so suddenly meant no resistance was met upon crossing the LOD."

SierraPapa.jpg

Sierra Papa


"In the north, Kopp deployed a moving screen to prevent enemy reconnaisance from locating the Corps' main body and to spoil any attempts at an attack on the Corps' flank."

"Kroner ordered the fleet to extend its screen southward and enemy infantry was spotted in the capital, Montivideo. Kroner sent the signal for the battleships to begin bombarding the capital. However, either through a fit of pique at being placed under Kroner's command for the operation or through a confusion in communications, the fleet admiral failed to comply."

"Similarly, Kroner's order to the interceptor wing to fly air screen over the main body was either ignored or never made it through. Kroner's assigned aircraft spent the entire operation at their base."

"Luckily Kroner's Cavalry commander was at least competent in his execution of orders. Kopp's screening force made contact with an enemy brigade in La Cruz Florida"

The entire time Herbig was speaking NCOs were sending privates scurrying to move the unit markers. Now a particularly burly private dropped a brigade sized HQ marker just to the southwest of the cavalry screens' most southern position.

firstcontact.jpg

The screening force makes contact


"Kopp had the regiment in contact develop the situation, determined the size of the enemy force and engage in order to fix them in place, preventing them from linking up with any forces in the objective area."

Koppscharge.jpg




"The Uruguayan brigade quickly broke contact and was forced northward. Away from the Brazilian main body."

LaCruzFloridaresults.jpg



"Kopp chose not to pursue, reorganizing his screen."

"The main body continued its drive to the south, making contact with Uruguayan security outposts on the outskirts of Montevideo. Kroner quickly organized his infantry along Phase Line Cerveza. He gave the honor of the main assault to General Farias and the First ID, manuevering the 2nd and 3rd ID into position to support the main effort."

"After an exhausting eight day struggle against the well dug in Uruguayan division, the Uruguayan commander attempted a tactical withdrawal. Kroner, no doubt smelling victory, ordered Assis and his division into the main attack."

assault.jpg

Full assault


"The Uruguayan division, caught moving out of it's prepared positions, crumbled under Assis' fresh troops. The Uruguayans attempted to withdraw to the west. Kopp quickly extended his screen to block the withdrawal and the Uruguayans were caught in an enfilade."

"With Brazilian troops swarming the government quarter, Uruguay's political leadership quickly capitulated. On March 30th Kroner officially accepted the surrender of the Uruguayan leadership."

surrender.jpg

Victory!

"Many still argue the Brazilian decision to install a puppet government in Uruguay. Some say it was intended to placate the United States. Certainly the Brazilian claims of "Liberating their Uruguayan brethren from tyranny" seemed flimsy at best. The giant fist of the Western hemisphere must have found it so."

nopeace.jpg

Oh sheeeite!!

(to be continued)
 
Last edited:
Your images seem to be working fine, now! Uruguay seems to have fallen pretty quickly, but the cost is high. War with the USA, oh dear! :eek:
 
Your images seem to be working fine, now! Uruguay seems to have fallen pretty quickly, but the cost is high. War with the USA, oh dear!
Oh dear is a much more polite way of saying it than what I used. :)




Lessons Learned (continued)

"The Silver Lining"​


kaegogi wandered slowly down the dimly lit Krailing Strasse. He was burnt out from a week of listening to that gas bag Herbig. A week of sifting through the bungling Brazilian commanders' orders trying to piece together the exact events of the invasion of Uruguay. A week of war gaming iteration after iteration of the battle for Montevideo. He was just looking for some relaxation.

Passing by a tenement full of windows glowing red, kaegogi heard the calls of the working girls inside. British accents, French, Russian, Arabian, African...all the accents of the Reich's vanquished enemies. This is where the war left the lucky ones. He had no desire for their particuar diversions this evening. He always left a house of red lights with more guilt than he had gone in with. He was too weary for that this evening. He took a left at the next corner, onto a street lit with lights a little clearer. In a perverse way the lights actually dimmed his mood even further. With an uneasy truce on between Germany and its last threat, the United States, the blackouts had stopped. Somehow he wished the bombers still flew over Europe. No bombers meant Hitler had room to breathe, room to plot.

Seeking to break his mood kaegogi stopped in front of the glittering facade of a movie house. A short line snaked away from the ticket booth and he resignedly joined the end. Not bothering to find out what was playing he dropped 35 pfennigs in the pretty blonde ticket attendant's hand and went inside. Whatever it was would be playing in a darkened theater and that was enough for him.

A 10 minute wait ended as the torch bulb blinked to life and the reels started their clanking spin. "Of course" kaegogi stood with the rest of the patriots as images of resplendantly uniformed soldiers saluted the reason for it all. kaegogi tried his best to blank his mind as the anthem wound through its exclamations of preeminence. Finally it ended and they all sat. kaegogi new the propoganda was next but was mildly surprised to find himself interested in it this time.

On the screen the German propoganda ministry was trying its best to show how strong the German will was in comparison with the "weak Americans". In a strange coincidence they had chosen an interview shot in 1950 with Admiral Cantanera da Silva, the same admiral who had commanded the Brazilian fleet during the invasion of Uruguay. Silva was describing the First Battle of Sao Paulo. The event that had saved Brazil from sure and swift destruction.


Silva's Portuguese flowed smoothly as kaegogi followed the subtitles in German:

"After freeing Uruguay from the clutches of the imperialist yankee puppets, we were left to wonder when and where the Americans would try to chastise us for daring to defy their tyranical meddling in Soth America. I led the battle fleet North in the hopes of challenging a yankee fleet but the best waters to do so, the Panama Canal, were over 4500 kilometers from our northern most port and we had a range of only 2000 kilometers.

For two weeks we patrolled while our troop transports brought our liberators home from Uruguay. On April 13th we received the news, Sao Paulo had fallen to a cowardly attack from the Americans. Brazil being the peaceful nation that she is, we had not bothered to station troops in the fair city of Sao Paulo. The Americans had not the courage to face the likes of our soldiers. They snuck in on airplanes to bring their imperial designs.​
invasion.jpg

The invasion of Sao Paulo




"I immediately ordered the fleet to steam at best speed and lie up offshore, where we could use our guns to support whatever action the high command decided upon. Knowing the Americans as we Brazilians do, the choice was simple - direct assault with all possible forces as soon as possible. The yankees have no stomach for true battle as we, and our brethren in the Axis, do. This is why Germany drove them off the British Isles and back to their homes.

I signaled our troop transports to reverse course and rendezvous off the coast of Sao Paulo. There would be no time for major planning sessions. Our decision was to ram our already battle weary infantry down the throats of the imperialists and choke them out of our homeland.

On April 15th we rendezvoused and began preperations for an opposed amphibious assault on Sao Paulo. It would be a bloody business for the men going ashore but we could not give the Americans time to reinforce or fortify. As it was we were already too late. On the 16th the Americans flew in a second infantry division. This meant we would be sending 3 low tech divisions, just out of battle, onto a hostile beach against 2 divisions of well equipped, well trained and rested infantry. It was a sobering thought but we could not wait as they brought in even more troops or enlisted the aid of the other puppets surrounding us. We had to strike immediately."​
reinforce.jpg

The Americans recieve reinforcements




"We launched the landing craft that same day. Our boys fought their way up off the beachheads. The battle hung in the balance for days, swinging back and forth as we managed to bring more and more men into the fight. Each day that passed brought the specter of a full American invasion fleet closer and closer. Yet each day giving us more hope as we widened the front for our men to move forward."​
landing.jpg

A Toehold vs. a Beachhead



"Finally the day I had feared dawned. Day 6 of the battle we spotted American destroyers. The smoke from our shore bombardment had prevented us from seeing them until they were close enough to engage. I feared they were the screen for an invasion escort and shifted our fires immediately. We did not kill them, although we did put a few dents in their armor, and as night descended they withdrew back to the northeast."​
firstseabattle.jpg

Undecided naval engagement



"Two days later, in a heavy fog, the American destroyers came again. Again we shifted focus from the beaches to the open seas and brought them to grips. This time things did not go so well for the Americans. They were unable to slink away into the dark and we destroyed one of their destroyer divisions."​

ships1.jpg

American defeat



"We of course recognized that with two of their divsions isolated, a destroyer division destroyed and an embarked invasion force no doubt behind that destroyer screen but unable to land with my fleet between them and their beach, the American people would be ready for the easy way out. Our diplomats sent a peace proposal through the Mexican embassador to the United States and they broke and ran."​

peace.jpg

Whew! is all I have to say.



kaegogi sat through the movie but couldn't shake an even deeper depression. Why would Hitler's propagandists be trying so hard to denigrate the Americans? As he walked out of the theater he realized that 14 years of war and 1/2 the world's surface just wasn't enough for some. He wondered if the building slips in Bremerhaven, Marseille and London were full right now. And if they were, how long he had before he'd be returning home.
 
Ok, so as I mentioned in my first post, I'm very new to this game and I'm trying to use this AAR forum as a way to learn the game. In the spirit of the title of this thread I'd like to ask some of you experienced players a few questions along the way. If you can answer, I'd truly appreciate it.

1. Once an objective is given to a HQ how do you cancel it? For example I gave a defensive posture order to my theater HQ and he started sending my units all across Brazil. Not something I want. However, I cannot figure out how to cancel that order and put him back under my command.


2. Is there a way to specifically order a shore bombardment by a fleet?


3. Is there a way to detach a brigade sized element from within a division? I'd like to reduce the size of my screening forces as a division just does not cover a wide enough area and gives me no fexibility.


4. Same thing but for ships. Is there a way to detach individual cruisers or transports from their assigned fleets?


5. How do I get rid of former enemy troops from my territory? After the truce with the USA they left two infantry divisions sitting in Sao Paulo. Considering my relations with the USA are currently at -21, I'd love to get them off my land. Seems a bit silly for them to remain in my territory.


Thanks for any help.
 
1. Once an objective is given to a HQ how do you cancel it?

Right-click on a geographical objective. It might take some effort when other stuff is near it to hit it.

To cancel the autopilot, click on the little flag that appears somewhere in the upper third of your HQ picture. It will be green when on and darkened when off.

2. Is there a way to specifically order a shore bombardment by a fleet?

Haven't tried that yet - what about selecting the fleet and right-clicking on the province in question? Hover your cursor over the ID's and watch for any shore bombardment values in the tooltip.

3. Is there a way to detach a brigade sized element from within a division? I'd like to reduce the size of my screening forces as a division just does not cover a wide enough area and gives me no fexibility.

Yes. There should be an arrow in the DIV's screen. It's in the same bar as delete unit, prioritize supply etc.

5. How do I get rid of former enemy troops from my territory?

Uh...weird. Perhaps they will have to be picked up by transports. Not sure whether the AI can load them from neutral ports though as it cannot anchor there.
 
2. Is there a way to specifically order a shore bombardment by a fleet?

I think this just happens when you have land combat in a province and a fleet off-shore, its never been very important to me so far, but when I've checked the actual land combat screen I was getting a modifier for naval support.

I'd guess that if your fleet is then attacked by other surface vessels they stop the shore bombardment but that is a guess.

Great AAR by the way, keep it up.
 
Indeed, your retrospective angle bring up questions that need answering. Like, what happened in those fourteen years? :p
 
"Lessons Learned"

Cheats = Altered saved game to lower Brazilian Neutrality to "0"

I consider this save-game altering not as a real cheat.
At the moment I am (also learning) playing Japan.
I want to wage war against Shanxi, but can't declare war. It's July 1937.
There are 10 spies working in Japan working on lowering Neutrality and 10 spies in Shanxi to increase threat.
If I go on this way it will take another couple of years before war is possible.
Takes to much time.
So I also had a look at my latest savegame.
There are however a lot of Neutrality entries.
Could you tell me which of these entries I have to alter?
AvG
 
@ Lord Solar: Thanks. The American divisions have been sitting there, out of supply and reinforcement for over a year now. Their strength bars are non-existant.

@loki100: I finally went back and read through the instruction book. It seems to be exactly as you say.

@Palmyrene & Myth: Glad you like the style. I can't imagine Brazil lasting long enough to have to justify the whole 14 year war thing. :)

@AvG: Open your saved game file in notepad and search for human=yes That starts the entry for your nation and you just have to scroll down a bit to find the neutrality entry.


Last night was an incredibly eventful bit of history for Brazil. I'm still in the middle of a battle so update later.
 
Thanks a lot Kaegogi. Changed the entry from 49 into 9 and I have now a Neutrality of 9%.
The Threat-level of Nat. China is about 8.
So in 1 or 2 monthes I can declare war.
Good Luck with Brazil.
AvG