August 1079-November 1080. The controversy of the three rites, part II (or, a Gordian solution to every trouble)
In early August I led a Navarran Army against Burgos and faced my cousing, albeit briefly. He was swept aside by a cavalry charge, which was not a bad thing since he's always had a better sword arm than I.
At almost the same time, my army in Soria was fighting Rodrigo "El Cid" Díaz. We had twice as many casualties as them, but we won the day. They tell me half of our dead were personally slain by Rodrigo.
In short, they fought (in November Rodrigo tried to break the siege of Burgos) but they lost.
As soon as I could leave the battlefield, I rode for Rioja and Nájera. On November the 7th, as the Council was in session and no answer was in sight, I decided to cut the matter to the quick. I had my royal ermine brought, with the Crown of Sancho the Great and one particularly large and wicked sword (placed on an equally outsize red velvet cushion), and had a long conversation with the Borg. Then I summoned the captain of my guards and the abbot of the monastery.
"Gentlemen", I said while I climbed into the royal vestments, "this Controversy has lasted enough, and has cost us enough. We need to put an end to it, and we will do it today".
The abbot looked flustered. The guard captain merely nodded and looked tough.
"This is what I want you to do. My lord abbot, I want all your monks dressed in Christmas robes and arrayed in the cloisters in twenty minutes. In two columns. Captain, I want your men to spruce up and shine their armor until they look almost civilised, and to form in the same lines, before and after the monks. Abbot, I want you to get your processional cross. Captain, get yourself the largest flag we've got. And two trumpeters".
They did. And so, just after the bells tolled Sext (and thus noon, at this time of the year) and the Council prepared to adjourn, we rocked them a bit. First, the trumpeters started blasting as if they wanted to bring down the walls. Then, we ritually knocked on the Council doors, and opened them without waiting for permission. And then we walked in.
The abbot with his cross, the captain with his large, red flag, and then myself in full regalia. Then the columns of monks (singing something suitably solemn, of course, although I don't remember what) and guards. The second half of the guards, upon coming in, blocked the doors and surrounded the room. The first formed a cordon between the seats of the attendants and the middle ground, which I held. And the monks went towards the other end of the room, where they kept playing the choir until I raised a hand.
We had got their attention. After that, it was quite easy.
I explained that the Controversy was over. The lands of Navarra would henceforth use the Roman rite, except those Mozarabite parishes that explicitly petitioned us and the Pope to keep their customs. The Visigoth rite was no longer recognised by the Pope, and thus would no longer be allowed to be performed in the lands of Navarra. And anybody carrying on the controversy after the close of the Council would be considered a felon and heretic, and dealt with as such.
The prior of Santo Domingo de la Calzada rose from his seat among the general silence, harrumped, and said:
"Sire, may I ask with what authority you speak thus at the Council?"
"You may", I say, as the Borg and I had also expected this question. "My authority is simple: I am the Lord's appointed King in all the lands subject to this decision. And I have the means to enforce it".
The prior straightened as if stung, and murmurs rose everywhere.
"So you would put your wish above the knowledge of the Council? Your crown weights more than all our wisdom?".
"It does", I said. "As did the crown of Constantine in his day. Your wisdom has made you consume years debating endlessly on a useless matter. The Visigoth rite is dead. Its successor, the Mozarabite rite, is approved by the Pope, but he prefers the new, Roman one. There it is, and there is no further room for negotiation. Indeed", I said, raising my voice to quell a hundred objections, "you have led your flocks astray with these meaningless questions, and given reason for rebellions and wars. You are personally responsible for the uprisings in Barcelona, in Burgos, in Jaca, in Toledo. You have caused the death of good Christians with this infantile quarrel about rites."
I looked around the room for effect.
"And now... you will help me correct it. You will all sign a Conclusion that will be sent to the Pope, with the unanimous recommendation that things should be as I have told you. You will return to your parishes, monasteries, cathedrals and universities... yes, and palaces. And you will uphold those Conclusions as if you had written them. You will knit together again what you have been trying to unravel with your Controversy. Does anybody object to this?"
I looked around again. Many councillors looked actually happy, many more were morosely inspecting their feet. Nobody dared answer.
The Borg produced the document, and the Council dissolved within the week. It was hailed as a resounding success, and it was. Relations with the Church did get a bit frosty after the event, and the Borg had a hard time polishing the story. But the result was an effective end to the Controversy and an increase in stability throughout the realm.
The (other) good side of it is that when the Pope called to Crusades, he thought it useless to call on me.
On December the 6th, we conquered Soria, the last stronghold of Sancho of Burgos. I offered him his life and Soria in exchange for renouncing his rights on the throne of Castilla. To defang him, I kept the province of Burgos, which was closer to home and made a nice capital. I would miss winters in Córdoba, though.
I was afraid all these annexations were going to raise hackles, but my vassals seem to have appreciated the reasons.
On February 18th, the fortress of Plasencia fell and the Emirate of Toledo with it.
I followed the same procedure than in Catalonia: I stripped the Emir of his title, left him the province, and forced him to renounce every claim on me.
And then, as my army was raising the siege, we saw another army marching toward Plasencia. I sent my scouts and they arrived with greetings from Alfonso of León, and a short letter.
In the letter, Alfonso said that he was sorry to have arrived late at the siege of the province, but that he intended to punish and vassalize it in very short order.
I sent another letter telling him that we had already done that and the matter was settled.
He answered that it was all right, he didn't mind. But since he was already there, he intended to finish the work.
I told him to leave the province at once.
He refused, saying that not only it was his right to pursue a legitimate war, but that the enemy was an infidel. And he requested, as Emperor of Hispania, that I should either leave or join his army.
I declared war on him.
Well, what would
you have done? I couldn't have a repeat of my old Mallorcan ally's antics.
By April we were fighting in all his main provinces (yes, I did allow him to waste his time in Plasencia).
It was not an easy war. My cousin's generals were often as good as mine. It was at this time, also, that I reorganised my government and put the Borg in charge of the newly-created Ministry of Truth.
And they tried to take the war to us in Burgos, but there, again, the Lord saw fit to lend me a hand.
By the end of November, we had managed to conquer both domain provinces of Alfonso.
Which (after a little finger work at the Borg's new Ministry) resulted in Alfonso losing his crown and becoming a vassal.
Yes. You have noticed it too. When he signed and sealed the treaty, I felt a great weight lifting from my shoulders. As Granny used to say, "there could only be one". And I was the one.
Hispania was
unified.
I had restored the kingdom to solvency. I had solved the Controversy. I had eliminated the rivalry of Hispanic emperors (and got myself a nice new province). And I had got rid of the Curse of Doña Muña for good.
Or maybe not. Cousin Sancho of Soria inherited the duchy of Galicia, and thus had muscle enough for further rebellions. If he found a motive.
A further result of this was that Navarra was getting some recognition abroad as more than just a flash in the pan. They began to believe that we were here to stay.
Now, if only I could convince myself of that too. But somehow I still don't feel safe.
You may wonder, what was Granny doing all this time?
Well... so do I. But I can't help thinking that this last bout of trouble from all the players of the Jimenez Stakes must have had something to do with her books.