IF you secure Norway would you be able to use it as a launching point for landing in Western Europe? Now excuse me while I go cry in the corner over flashbacks of Norway.
- 1
Yes, that's definitely a possibility. I think opening up secondary fronts is the way to go to spread out the Axis forces and open up more opportunities for breakthroughs. For now the two operations I'm looking at is landing in the Balkans and pushing into Denmark from Zealand. The former might be achieved as soon as late December 1942, the latter will take a little longer to prepare, as more forces would have to be gathered, but a first stage could be launched as soon as the new Naval Infantry Corps is ready for action in early 1943. Of course, those timelines are contingent on nothing else going wrong and requiring our reserves to be committed.IF you secure Norway would you be able to use it as a launching point for landing in Western Europe? Now excuse me while I go cry in the corner over flashbacks of Norway.
Looking at the bright side, at least this game has weather, and penalties for fighting in bad weather. Of course, some very bad weather should entirely preclude any engagement, but at least weather has an impact.Constantly reminded about how silly the game system is permitting an engagement during heavy weather.
Thus is a good front to have alm wrapped up. More forces for striking into the north of Germany.Southern Norway has been cleared, and all of Norway's major harbours are firmly in Comintern hands.
Huzzah!the harbour and the battered Kriegsmarine forces were reduced to rubble and scrap metal. Tirpitz, six Destroyers and a troop transport ship were all sent to the bottom
The Americans are the ones who decided on the route. Losses have been quite small, and now that the last of the German surface fleet has been bombed to smithereens and the Red Banner Baltic Fleet is escorting the convoys in, there have been no losses at all. I guess Destroyers with modern ASW equipment and Radar combined with two escort carriers' worth of aircraft is too much trouble for the U-boats. Of course, with Comintern Air Bases in Bornholm, Copenhagen, Oslo, and Riga, the convoy also benefits from land-based air cover against Naval bombers all the way through the Baltic.That Lend lease convoy route from Boston is taking a very optimistic route, clearly they can bully through the Baltic with some losses. But surely the OTL Arctic convoy route is the better option, particularly when the Red Army is working so hard to clear out the German threat in Norway? Such are the inscrutable ways of theAIUSN. It's almost as odd as the large number of Bulgarians in Norway.
It must be said that the Royal Navy did most of the heavy lifting against both the Kriegsmarine and the Regia Marina, at this point the Red Navy is mopping up the remnants rather than fighting large fully formed fleets. The Japanese, on the other hand, have been wiping the floor with the Royal Navy, and the USN is being very shy. If this continues I expect that once the Germans are dealt with, and the Red Navy has to go toe to toe with a still very much intact IJN, they might well end up with a bloody nose for our Navy.The continued success of the Red Navy continues to disconcert me for some reason, however it is indeed getting results. I would warn the Admirals that the Italian navy is not a first tier navy with respect to AA warfare, nor are the Germans. This is not to take away from their achievements, but a warning against over-confidence.
We don't have many forces in Norway, and there are no mountains in Northern Germany, so realistically, when the units finally reach the ports, we will have two rifle corps available for an operation into Denmark or Northern Germany. Add in the Marines and we might be able to take and hold most of Denmark, but we really need a motorised corps to take full advantage of a surprise offensive, and the next motorised units to be commissioned are slated for the Balkan operation.Thus is a good front to have alm wrapped up. More forces for striking into the north of Germany.
Huzzah indeed, though let us not count our chickens before they hatch. Things can still go wrong and delay what now seems more and more inevitable.Huzzah!
This was a pretty successful month on the ‘other fronts’. Surely the Fascist swine are doomed.
Finally! Vur ha...I mean, ummm, Da, Comrade?With most of the Red Army’s Tank units allocated to this area for months now and not much to show for it, things finally take a turn for the better as our tanks break through to Palanga, trapping tens of thousands of Axis troops to their North.
Seems that the Red Army still lacks sufficient mass to press everywhere at once. Thus there is still work to be done on the back end.As units have been shifted to the north to complete that crucial encirclement, the line has become dangerously thin. Our forces are on the back foot, our attacks go nowhere while the Wehrmacht gains ground. Only the timely arrival of a fresh Motor Rifle Corps stems the tide before we loose the crucial Air Base in Zelva.
Congratulations!OOC: I have graduated with a Masters in Architecture in September.
The system is quite excellent now and really showing the fruits of revisions. It is always challenging to report well on a Soviet AAR so I am delighted you've found something that works so well.I finally found the time and energy to get back into 'Odin' and finish what I started with the new, and now that it is set up, less time-intensive, reporting system for the GPW.
They really have evolved from simple character quotes to evocative storytelling moments.I do love these little vignettes, especially the dry as dust last sentence. Wonderful stuff.
I am appreciating the broken-down format of the reports, as it makes each piece more digestible.The second part of this report
Seems like the ideal case would be to build up a solid reserve of units which can be leapfrogged forward to secure a gain and dig in at full strength. Although even then, advancing one province at a time minus losses to enemy attacks elsewhere means going will still be slow.This area turned into a bloody stalemate as any beachhead or breakthrough is mercilessly crushed an neither side seems to be able to hold on to any gains. As the Red Army forces in this area are slow and mostly geared towards the defence this isn’t surprising.
Anyone who would call it such shall be promptly overkilled.In an impressive display of what some would call overkill,
It is due largely to the AI, which is unable to build up a reserve and concentrate for an offensive, leading to perpetual high-intensity war along an entire front until somebody runs out of men or materiel.A familiar phase of such huge wars, before one side or the other becomes too hollowed out to sustain it any longer.
<spit>Kubela, sharpened pencil in one hand and emptied hip flask in the other, prepared a drunken report to send back to Tiso and Tuka in the Command Hovel back in Bratislava. He will probably blame Czech <spit> fifth columnists for undermining Hungarian resolve.
What's particularly ironic is that much of the Russian experience in WWI was of maneuver warfare (minus most any sort of large-scale mechanization, of course) as the front was simply too wide for a trench stalemate like that in the West. That really speaks to the expansion of scale in the present war.For all the talk of manoeuvre warfare much of the front sees Infantry fighting infantry with artillery support and trench systems.
Heh.After moving North into Hell (3)
Since the carrier air groups are the products of Soviet engineering, even money says "no".There were still some serious questions: Will our Carriers be able to stay outside shooting range of enemy Battleships when there aren't any other capital ships to take the heat? Will our carrier-based bombers and torpedo-bombers be able to hit and damage fast-moving enemy ships?
This is highly unrealistic. A truly Soviet carrier air wing would not be able to manage effectively the radio communications to carry out such an efficient maneuver, thus we are forced to conclude that the "Soviet" carrier force is actually American mercenaries in disguise.The rest of the planes of I & II KPA were led in towards the target, and the air attack commenced fifteen minutes later.
This also raises the question of what, at least in the Mediterranean, carriers offer that full-size aircraft operating from littoral air bases cannot do better. Hardly anywhere worth caring about in the Mediterranean is not within range of an air base, and those places which are could easily have air bases constructed in range.'Chteyre' has emitted concerns that the Air Base in Rodi might be used to target our troops in case we put our operation to open a new front in the Balkans into action. Of course, the Naval Bombers based in that Air Base are also a significant threat to any landing fleet.
There is a reason why nearly every serious HoI3 mod ramps up the weather penalties.Constantly reminded about how silly the game system is permitting an engagement during heavy weather.
Because it is a ghastly abomination and an assault against sense and sensibility which expects barely-seaworthy ships and death-trap submarines? Because the Red Navy being even vaguely competent is nearly as anti-historical as anything TBC says? Because you hate Communism?The continued success of the Red Navy continues to disconcert me for some reason,
This is another argument in favor of building up a strong naval aviation arm with lots of MA regiments to clear the waters around the Japanese home islands.If this continues I expect that once the Germans are dealt with, and the Red Navy has to go toe to toe with a still very much intact IJN, they might well end up with a bloody nose for our Navy.
As usually follows after graduation, I have now started working as an Architect. I'm also going to be playing as a soloist with my orchestra at our next concert, and I'm going back to school on Saturdays to become a trainer in a sport I've been practising for over ten years. Unsurprisingly this has left me precious little time to write the next update, let alone keep up with all of the other AARs I was reading consistently little more than a month ago.Congratulations!
Seems that the Red Army still lacks sufficient mass to press everywhere at once. Thus there is still work to be done on the back end.
It is due largely to the AI, which is unable to build up a reserve and concentrate for an offensive, leading to perpetual high-intensity war along an entire front until somebody runs out of men or materiel.
There are more than enough forces on the board for the Red Army to operate massive manoeuvre forces while still holding the line. The Ai just decides to use them to probe river defences or throws them into a contested province one at a time. We have more tanks than the Germans at this point, and they're all modern T-34 and IS-2 variants.What's particularly ironic is that much of the Russian experience in WWI was of maneuver warfare (minus most any sort of large-scale mechanization, of course) as the front was simply too wide for a trench stalemate like that in the West. That really speaks to the expansion of scale in the present war.
The system is quite excellent now and really showing the fruits of revisions. It is always challenging to report well on a Soviet AAR so I am delighted you've found something that works so well.
Great to see the positive response from you too. The reports will probably stay this way for the foreseeable future, so I'm glad it works.I am appreciating the broken-down format of the reports, as it makes each piece more digestible.
I'm trying to keep them short, but telling. Lest I fall into the trap of writing the same thing over and over, I've been getting more creative with the quotes, and as it has been a success, I will continue down this road.They really have evolved from simple character quotes to evocative storytelling moments.
Since the carrier air groups are the products of Soviet engineering, even money says "no".
Sure but the CAG's aren't actually the product of Soviet Engineering but borrowed tech from the British. Basically they're modern Lavochkins and Ilyushins which are modified for carrier use by copying the undercarriages of British carrier aircraft.This is highly unrealistic. A truly Soviet carrier air wing would not be able to manage effectively the radio communications to carry out such an efficient maneuver, thus we are forced to conclude that the "Soviet" carrier force is actually American mercenaries in disguise.
That's all well and good, but if you don't control any of those air bases. Sure, we have Mythiléné now, but they've only just finished building a rudimentary dirt strip there, so it'll be a while until we can deploy some serious land-based air power from there. Having a few carriers around doesn't hurt in protecting your ships from enemy air attacks. Of course, you do run the risk of losing the carriers to air attack or submarines, or even land-based artillery, then again, our carriers are cheaply build variations on British & French inter-war designs. Pieces of crap with shiny new planes on them, really. The question is how much the Red Navy can build upon the 'borrowed' tech and doctrines and adapt them based on experience at sea. There are going to be a lot more Soviet Carriers than OTL, so there is a lot of learning to be done, especially it we go to war with the Japanese at some point.This also raises the question of what, at least in the Mediterranean, carriers offer that full-size aircraft operating from littoral air bases cannot do better. Hardly anywhere worth caring about in the Mediterranean is not within range of an air base, and those places which are could easily have air bases constructed in range.
There is some method to the madness.This is another argument in favor of building up a strong naval aviation arm with lots of MA regiments to clear the waters around the Japanese home islands.
I can only concur here. Conditions on Soviet ships are definitely terrible. Note that nothing has been invested in improving crew training or naval doctrine for years. The little improvements there have been were 'borrowed' by our spies from abroad. The naval aviators, on the other hand are well trained and well equipped as our air doctrines are not far off our enemies (and frenemies), and our planes are quite modern. They just need to pray the carrier doesn't sink, break down, or spontaneously combust at any point during their deployment.Because it is a ghastly abomination and an assault against sense and sensibility which expects barely-seaworthy ships and death-trap submarines? Because the Red Navy being even vaguely competent is nearly as anti-historical as anything TBC says? Because you hate Communism?
I honestly have no clue. I started writing the next update, a narrative one, a month ago, but I just can't find the time or energy to sit down and focus on it. 2-4 months seems doable. We'll see. And to say I had the ambition, at some point, to put up an update very two weeks... that's not happening for the next two years at least, if ever.I look forward to this continuing in another 2-4 months, as is the traditional timeline.![]()
Having the time and energy to consistently read AARs is, I have learned, a rare blessing to be treasured while it lasts.Unsurprisingly this has left me precious little time to write the next update, let alone keep up with all of the other AARs I was reading consistently little more than a month ago.
I suppose it works up until December of '41 OTL, you could even argue for Spring '42 depending on how you feel about Operation Mars, and then again through Summer '42. The trouble is that once you get to Uranus and beyond, the Eastern Front in broad strokes turns into an exchange of grand operational strikes back and forth, which the AI on either side is woefully incapable of masterminding.The lack of coordination and the obstination with attacking across the entire front rather than focusing on a narrow area aren't that far removed from reality, at least in those first years of ww2 when Stalin didn't trust(some of) his generals yet.
This is whyThat's all well and good, but if you don't control any of those air bases.
Truly an uphill battle for whatever g/God they might choose to pray to, certainly it has never yet been accomplished.They just need to pray the carrier doesn't sink, break down, or spontaneously combust at any point during their deployment.
I can certainly relate to this. Building one's new life keeps one entirely to busy, but necessarily so or so we like to think.I honestly have no clue. I started writing the next update, a narrative one, a month ago, but I just can't find the time or energy to sit down and focus on it. 2-4 months seems doable. We'll see. And to say I had the ambition, at some point, to put up an update very two weeks... that's not happening for the next two years at least, if ever.
And then there is the dilemma, when you find some time and energy: Do you read AARs or do you move your own AAR forward.Having the time and energy to consistently read AARs is, I have learned, a rare blessing to be treasured while it lasts.
Of course, in TTL Barbarossa happened in 1941, so we're fine until mid-1943... After that, I guess we'll need to use a bit more imagination and/or a bit more player control, though that would be unfair on the enemy AI, of course. Who knows, maybe we win this thing before Christmas...I suppose it works up until December of '41 OTL, you could even argue for Spring '42 depending on how you feel about Operation Mars, and then again through Summer '42. The trouble is that once you get to Uranus and beyond, the Eastern Front in broad strokes turns into an exchange of grand operational strikes back and forth, which the AI on either side is woefully incapable of masterminding.
The Red Army is excellent, of course, the best and biggest in the world. However, when the enemy is on an island or another continent entirely, some boats are required to get them there. Realistically, they can't bring the revolution to the entire world without a navy.This is whyGodStalin created the Red Army.
Good thing the Soviet Union is atheist, though everything that happens is part of Stalin's plan, obviously. Comrade Secretary general works in mysterious ways after all.Truly an uphill battle for whatever g/God they might choose to pray to, certainly it has never yet been accomplished.
It's all about choosing what to invest time in, what to sacrifice, what to put on hold. Now that I've settled into my job, I might be able to claw back a bit more time and energy, though striking the right balance, for me, between social life, music projects, and this massive project is definitely tricky.I can certainly relate to this. Building one's new life keeps one entirely to busy, but necessarily so or so we like to think.
Every division counts, and so does the liberation of the Baltic states, shortening the front, and moving us a little closer to Berlin. Our operations in the Baltic continue to be occasionally harassed by Ju-290 naval bombers, but realistically with carrier-based and land-based fighters nearby, they mostly get intercepted before they can do significant damage to our fleets. Of course, we don't know what the Kriegsmarine is building, so maybe we're in for a nasty surprise at some point in the future. Unless, of course, we manage to end the war, or take the German Baltic coast, before the Germans finish building their new ships.Indeed a triumphant return! Good progress on, well, some fronts. Gratifying to see the encirclement finally complete, even though the prize is perhaps less than could have been hoped for. Still, every division eliminated reduces the amount of Axis forces our troops will have to contend with. Success in Norway will also result in the capture of several divisions, and the freedom to operate in the Baltic Sea is certainly valuable. Now if only the pesky commanders of Luftwaffe would realize that the Red Star rules the skies, and they should just go home, or fight with the Brits instead...
Thanks. As much as it was my goal for years, It was truly just the beginning.Congratulations on your graduation!
Indeed, just not its citizens.Long live the Soviet Union.
This is much more like it. Blindly hurling men into a meatgrinder with the only concern being the level of reserves and not the human cost, that's proper communist thinking.Manpower:Available: 2.041.000 (-18.000) Heavy fighting and the creation of new units continue to sap our manpower reserves, though we continue to benefit from a large pool of fighting age men. (and women) At this rate, we still have over three years before we have to really start worrying.
Thanks for the warm welcome. Hopefully, I can keep moving things forwards now, without having to make too many 'comebacks', though life does have a way of interfering.Glad to have you back, and in spectacular fashion!
Very grimly enjoyable restart. Someone had to pay and there was only one currency Uncle Joe would be willing to accept.
A dramatic meeting with Murderous Joe indeed. Slightly disappointed in Stalin taking the soft option, had he been on form he would have waited until after Odinstat had shot Shest and then shot Odinstat as well, because frankly who can ever trust her again? The idea of him caring about the loss of her ability is very out of character for him, entire generations of scientists, engineers and experts of all kinds were purged just on the off chance that a few of them might not be 100% loyal, Odinstat should never have left that room alive.
Someone definitely had to pay here, I'm glad the work I put in to get the pacing and tone right paid off. I'm definitely doing more rewrites on the narrative updates than a few years ago and am less apprehensive now about scrapping paragraphs, or even entire scenes.However such quibbles aside it was a strong chapter, while you always had a sense of what was going to happen (Odin is sometimes slightly naive about the nature of the man he works for) it rattled along at a good pace and the exposition from Stalin was done well.
This is much more like it. Blindly hurling men into a meatgrinder with the only concern being the level of reserves and not the human cost, that's proper communist thinking.![]()
It doesn't seem to be just Communist thinking, but (also) very much a Russian tradition... That said, the Communists did take it to a whole different level, on the battlefield, and even more so with the forced labour system. (I've recently read Solzhenitsyn's best-selling book on that particular subject - a fascinating and gruelling read. I won't be writing about it explicitly in order to comply with forum rules)Indeed, just not its citizens.![]()
The slowed down upload schedule for Road of Queens means I might actually have a chance to keep up now, I'm glad to see that's still going strong.Welcome back! Looking forward to seeing more of this AAR! Also noticed you trying to catch up on Road of Queens. I'm so slow posting now-a-days you can easily catch up.