• We have updated our Community Code of Conduct. Please read through the new rules for the forum that are an integral part of Paradox Interactive’s User Agreement.

unmerged(7708)

Second Lieutenant
Feb 9, 2002
197
0
Visit site
I have been preparing to start up an AAR with a slightly different method of play. I'm making this post first to ensure that no one has done it quite this way before.

I have seen AAR's started before where a player has switched to an AI nation as in the fall of the 3rd Reich because the situation looked like a way to get a challenge from the AI and the game as it was, was pretty much finished.

What I have done is taken two nations (Germany and the Soviet Union) and instead of switching sides when one side was almost crushed, I switch sides monthly.

I used the 1941 scenario since it placed me immediately into a battle situation and would give me reasonable levels of tech in case this system is to disruptive on research.

I must admit I was surprised and concerned a few times by what I found. Overall, however, it worked well. I had never gone into AI nations save files before. I hadn't done this so I could prolong as many surprises as possible about how the AI played. Now switch with the AI every month and you really see how he plays.

The next thing is you have to take over again after the AI has had your forces for a month. Even if you understand how the AI plays, trying to guess how he will play with your moves is something else.

You find yourself in a tug of war with Adolf/Stalin and military leaders/ministers of different philosophies. THe battlefield you can control at least half the time but you find yourself only able to influence production and research. You can get what you want but sometimes only at considerable disruption to the overall effort.

There are other relevations but need to save surprises for the AAR.

My big question is HAS ANYBODY DONE THIS BEFORE?

One of the big reasons I'm doing this is to interest someone with more play and writing time (and talent) to take this idea and run further and quicker with it than I can. It is an interesting way to play and deserves exposure.

All said first posts by end of week.
 
Last edited:
I doubt it.
 
Wow, quite impressive, man! I´m looking forward to this one. I can imagine you´ll have a large problem with production, though; I can see the AI cancelling you airplane orders and changing your research priorities...
 
Nuc Winter

Only 4 months in but research has not really been a problem. Production however...
I haven't seen the AI cancel much but he will sure shift priorities. Thats okay I can do that to. but that's what I was talking about.

Probably have to do this more as a narrative than a story to better list the gaming effects.
 
This looks like a very interesting exercise. Can't wait until your start writing.
 
Very innovative idea for an AAR. I even like the title "Outflanking Myself".

I can imagine the poor generals.

One month it will be "Comrade General, race to defend Stalingrad." The next month, "Comrade General, support the assault on Riga."


The time frame should be good to. You can get alot done in one month, or alot can happen in one month.

V.
 
This should be interesting. I'm eager to see if you can pull this off. Whatever that means, since you win anyway. The greatest challenge will be to co-ordinate with the AI. You won't win the war by changing your (long-term) plans every month. Good luck!
 
I don't know how you can handle this, but I can't wait to see. I tried something like this one time, but I ran into the same things as you did & gave up because it was so upsetting to see the AI change all my brilliant plans :D . Good Luck & I'll be looking for the update.

Jono
 
Widow Maker what append to you???

Hes posts b4 were always quite frequent.
 
So sorry guys!!! The cat walked across the map (just a thought for the old boardgamers)

Actually, I attempted to post my first update on schedule and weather cut the server. Then I have had hardware problems on my primary computer.
Can you hear the violins playing.

No really I have lost my computer temporarily (I hope all file will return intact from the shop) but for the time being most of my notes, and text are unavailable. Fortunately I have some older computers and at least I'm online again. Can't play HOI on them (yep they are that old) but I do still have some paper notes and some screenies on disk.
 
Once again sorry guys. Having trouble attaching or copying files to web pages. I use computer for work and games but if I don't do it regularly I either forget it or never learned it. Would study up but we are working a 7 day schedule. Tried to tease someone else into carrying this ball but...