• We have updated our Community Code of Conduct. Please read through the new rules for the forum that are an integral part of Paradox Interactive’s User Agreement.

jamineu4

Private
87 Badges
Apr 27, 2016
20
2
  • Tyranny: Gold Edition
  • Europa Universalis IV: Cossacks
  • Crusader Kings II: Conclave
  • Cities: Skylines - Snowfall
  • Europa Universalis IV: Mare Nostrum
  • Stellaris
  • Stellaris: Galaxy Edition
  • Stellaris: Galaxy Edition
  • Hearts of Iron IV: Cadet
  • Crusader Kings II: Reapers Due
  • Europa Universalis IV: Rights of Man
  • Tyranny: Archon Edition
  • Tyranny: Archon Edition
  • Cities: Skylines - After Dark
  • Stellaris: Digital Anniversary Edition
  • Stellaris: Leviathans Story Pack
  • Cities: Skylines - Natural Disasters
  • Hearts of Iron IV: Together for Victory
  • Crusader Kings II: Monks and Mystics
  • Stellaris - Path to Destruction bundle
  • Steel Division: Normandy 44
  • Cities: Skylines - Mass Transit
  • Europa Universalis IV: Mandate of Heaven
  • Europa Universalis IV: Third Rome
  • Hearts of Iron IV: Death or Dishonor
  • Hearts of Iron 4: Arms Against Tyranny
  • Europa Universalis IV: Call to arms event
  • Crusader Kings II: Charlemagne
  • Crusader Kings II: Legacy of Rome
  • Crusader Kings II: The Old Gods
  • Crusader Kings II: Rajas of India
  • Crusader Kings II: The Republic
  • Crusader Kings II: Sons of Abraham
  • Crusader Kings II: Sunset Invasion
  • Crusader Kings II: Sword of Islam
  • Europa Universalis IV
  • Europa Universalis IV: Art of War
  • Europa Universalis IV: Conquest of Paradise
  • Europa Universalis IV: Wealth of Nations
  • Crusader Kings II
  • Europa Universalis IV: Res Publica
  • Victoria 2
  • Victoria 2: A House Divided
  • Victoria 2: Heart of Darkness
  • Cities: Skylines
  • Cities: Skylines Deluxe Edition
  • Europa Universalis IV: El Dorado
  • Europa Universalis IV: Pre-order
  • Crusader Kings II: Way of Life
  • Europa Universalis IV: Common Sense
After noticing the Ottomans getting balkanized every game I decided what better nation to pick for my first AAR so welcome to Redressing the Eastern Question hopefully in our favor though Europe might have other thoughts about that
vy4VWS.png


info
This is my first AAR, so I'm not entirely sure how this will progress or take shape. I promise to at least bring this to a satisfying conclusion in the early 20th century and that updates will come every few days.
I'm playing with an HFM base mod, that brings many of the features found in HPM and some over smaller mods with some personal edits that hopefully addresses some issues I find in the mods
I dont intend to cheat or exploit the game or mod, but there will probably be cases were situations that need to be addressed will be done so by console
I will be adding some flavour by adding words in Turkish as the language used then by the elites is dead the translation to them will be in brackets, Tamamdir? (okay?)
I appreciate any help along the way and hope you enjoy following this story as much as I will have making it. May we triumph over our enemies or at the very least make those European powers pay for their impudence in interfering in our affairs.
 
Last edited:
Prologue: Ottoman decline in the 18th century

It was not always like this once the march of our armies brought fear into the hearts of all. Ever since Vienna, where once our armies marched forward into new lands in the name of Osman now, they retreat. Where once our armies threatened Vienna and burnt Moscow, now Konstantiniyye is threatened, and the Northern Balkans under foreign influence.

Ever since the Pruth River campaign (1710-1711) we have been on the back foot, although victorious we failed to use the situation to our advantage with Peter the Great himself almost being captured by our forces. Our last great victory against the Russians has left us on the backside against our northern neighbors, and now the Hapsburgs and the Russians have slowly bitten into our lands during the 1700s. The treaty of Küçük Kaynarca following the war with Russia in 1768-1774 has left our Christian subjects under Russian protection no doubt to be a pretense to further Russian intervention in our lands.

7Y3MlN.jpg

Janissaries show their failure once more in the siege of Ochakov 1788 losing 9,000 to the Russian 956 while on the defensive

The accelerated decline of the new century and reform

Not all looked bleak at the turn of the 19th century Sultan Selim III, had begun a series of administrative and military reforms, the Janissary dominated armies that had failed miserable against the Russians in the 1770s and 1780s, were now to be replaced by the Niẓām-ı Cedīd, who were quick to prove the worth by defeating the French at Acre in 1799. Though this was not to last in 1807, Janissaries, corrupt officials and rebellious family members orchestrated coups leading to the overthrow and murder of Selim and put the usurper Mustafa on the throne, reversing all the old reforms. Mustafa was not to last and was righteously replaced but our current Sultan Mahmud II.

Mahmud although also a reformer has taken a slower place weary of another coup taking place, this has culminated in the 1828 disbandment of the Janissaries and their execution, but this has been at the backdrop of many tragedies to the state. Serbia, Greece are independent states, Wallachia and Moldavia still bow to the Sultan but for how long considering Russian interference there. But this is not the worst, to the south the Levant and Egypt have rebelled under the Vali Mohamed Ali, a rebellion only stopped by the hated Russians though the lands lost are still under his control. No doubt he has more aspirations of treason and his French backers might just allow him to succeed.

FIZIeE.jpg

The Treasonous Greeks fighting for their independence, no doubt they will attempt to steal more of our subjects and territory living in the empire

Two phrases have now circulated about us amongst Europe both as intolerable as the other, The Eastern question and the Sick Man of Europe, the latter a description of our state, sickly and incapable, the former the European phrase to indicate what they should do to our lands, either divide them or keep them whole, both violating our integrity and an afront to our power.

 
Last edited:
I hope writing this isn't too AARd for you :p
 
I'll be interested to see how this goes.
 
Part One, ilerideki yol (the way ahead) 1836-1840

RFbcLL.png

Ottoman empire and its dependencies border in green in 1836, enemies are highlighted in red

Under Mahmud, the empire has set itself to reform, even so, rebellions have plagued the empire. First in the west now in the east, a Kurdish Tribe called Soran and a rebellion in Tripolitania have plagued the empire for the past few years now. As such Sultan Mahmud II, first priority in 1836 before resuming reforms is to end these attempts at freedom before other Kurdish or African states decide to join them or worse still if Egypt judges this as weakness and attempts to rebel once more. As such the First Army, under the Polish ex-pat Wojciech Chrzanowski, a recent emigre after the failed Polish uprising is shipped to Africa to test the new army model.

Although not in a state of rebellion, the Suadi Sultanate of Nejd is another concern although defeated two decades ago and a shadow of its formal self, the Suadi's still continues to reject the Sultan as the Caliph of all Muslims, as such Mahmud tasks his diplomats with justifying a conflict with the Nejd to finally secure the area so close to the holy cities.

Looking towards Europe, the alliance with Russia is dropped, it is nothing but a crutch and inroad for further Russian interference, while Prussia would the most desirable ally the Prussians don’t seem that enthusiastic, nor do the British or French, and although Austria is willing they are seen as just as bad as the Russians, as such although it weakens us foreign policy-wise, the Ottomans decide not to have any great powers for the moment.


Hofe6c.png

Although considered as an expert diplomat Mehmed Emin Rauf Pasha, the appointed grand Vizer is unable to secure any foreign alliance, though he strengthens the relations with our subjects

In November 1836, The Ottoman empire holds a trade summit in Konstaniye to discuss Europe-wide trade practices but this is just a cover for more personal matters, as the empire wary of cheap European imports bankrupting their burgeoning industry begins a more protectionist stance levying massive tariffs on all European imports a stark contrast to the trade treaties signed with Britain in 1820. During this Mehmed Emin Rauf Pasha having worked tirelessly for the state is able to create a strong casus-belli against the Nejd State, the Desert cavalry are readied and the war declared, at the same time the Ottoman ambassador in Berlin is caught off guard as the Prussians offer a military alliance, one that is quick to be used……..
V89Fia.png

just two months after the alliance is finalized the Ottomans are forced to call Prussia into a war
Striking when the Empire was still fighting rebellions and has just declared war on Nejd and confident of French support Mohamed Ali declares a second war on the empire, triggering the oriental crisis. Shocked military officials scramble a general mobilization order and the main body of the army busy with reorganization and training in Bulgaria is rushed quickly to the east. The 1st Army in Africa is forced on the retreat as twice their number of Egyptians march in aid of Tripolitania.

Not all was
chaos however, wary of further French influence in the region Russia intervenes on our side, forcing the French to back down and sending their own armies into the Levant. By the time the Ottoman armies arrived, Russian troops had crushed the Egyptian army at Damascus forcing them on the retreat. Meanwhile, in Africa the 1st army having retreated into the Tunisian highlands makes its stand, defeating the Egyptian armies attempting to conquer Tunis and quickly counter attacking the Egyptian reinforcements.
94nBNE.png

Chrzanowski having defeated the rebels in Tripoli once more shows his competence in leading an attack against the Egyptians

The Egyptians having been driven back from Tunis, and the Levant sued for peace, and at the London, convention terms were given out but were instantly rejected by the Ottoman diplomates as unacceptable, the empire will have nothing but complete surrender from the Egyptians even if it means a longer war. Although Russia had left the war in protest of Ottoman actions, the Prussians had not and as such an ottoman Prussian joint force invaded Egypt properly and at the battle of Cairo defeated the last remnants of the Egyptian army, forcing them to surrender.
aHxLw6.png

Ottoman troops and their vassals crush the Egyptian armies around Cairo
Even as the peace treaty was signed, and the Egyptian lands directly annexed to the empire was not allowed to celebrate, for Mahmud II, the reformer, died of Tuberculosis on the 20th August 1938 5 days after the complete surrender of Egypt had been announced. His reign had been a troubled one at that, from his accent after a coup to his reforms and the rebellions in the empire, his reign saw the empire retreat to its smallest since the 1400s. At his coronation his son Abdulmejid I, promises to continue his father's reforms and with the defeat of the Egyptians signals a new golden age for the empire. Wherever or not the Empire would experience a golden age was uncertain especially considering the empire had just fallen from great power status, however, reforms the new Sultan could certainly do, and when the Grand Vizier questioned these reforms, Abdulmejid I has him imprisoned and places the liberal Tanzimat Firkasi (Reorganisation Opportunity) faction in charge under Grand Vizier Mustafa Reşid Pasha.

The first reform passed was to allow non-Turks into the new Ottoman army, refilling its ranks after the Egyptian war. The army that had marched in the Levant and defended Tunisia was merely 2/5 the size now and the new recruits would hopefully bolster it to at least pre-war size. Next Slavery and Serfdom were abolished, two ancient institutions that were nothing but chains holding the empire down. Furthermore, the idea of Ottomanism was propagated in the government, Ottomanism is the idea that the minorities in the empire could be integrated around the idea of the Ottoman state instead of their ethno based states that had begun popping up in the Balkans. In order to do this the reforms were issued to allow minorities in the government and give them further autonomy in their various regions. Furthermore the empire abolished the religious discrimination that had once been official policy, the new party in charge pushed for complete secularisation though this is protested by the Religous leader in the south.

As 1839 began to end, the national focus changed from increasing the beaucracy to Education, a particular challenge as in the west increased education has led to increased nationalism and in the east, religious schools and the mixed Arabic-Persian language with local Turkish has led to confusion and chaos. Never the less with the Oriental crisis behind them and a strong Prussian ally, Sultan Abdulmejid is confident that these simpler problems is all his reign will have to deal with
 
I'm almost certain that the alliance with Prussia is going to drag the Ottoman Empire into wars, both wars they want and those they don't want.

Also exactly what mod/mods are you using? That is one beautiful looking map.
 
Last edited:
Good first moves on the southern border, but I think Dereham is right: that Prussian alliance promises a lot of European entanglement to come. Encouraging to see the Porte reforming though.
 
I'm almost certain that the alliance with Prussia is going to drag the Ottoman Empire into wars, both wars they want and those they don't want.

Also exactly what mod/mods are you using? That is one beautiful looking map.

Good first moves on the southern border, but I think Dereham is right: that Prussian alliance promises a lot of European entanglement to come. Encouraging to see the Porte reforming though.

I generally see Prussia as the only reliable Great power in Europe, it borders all three countries that are enemies of the Ottomans, and who I generally expect to declare on me at some point. Any war that Prussia drags me into is a war worth fighting, if we win that is.
 
  • 2
Reactions:
I generally see Prussia as the only reliable Great power in Europe, it borders all three countries that are enemies of the Ottomans, and who I generally expect to declare on me at some point. Any war that Prussia drags me into is a war worth fighting, if we win that is.

Aye, the problem as I see is that you border two of the three countries that are your enemies. I believe you are hinting that France also is an enemy and one you do not border and thus, have no option to support Prussia other than through naval escapades. Hopefully the bad literacy still allows for some naval techs on the Ottoman side.
 
Also exactly what mod/mods are you using? That is one beautiful looking map.
didn't see that edit sorry,
the main mods in using is a combination of HPM and HFM, I've added a lot of sub mods and personal edits over the time playing it that i cant honestly tell what the others are. the thing close to it would be "the grand combination" a multiplayer VIC 2 mod, that has a similar map and premise, though obviously for multiplayer and its unfinished and as such not the most stable.
 
Partn 2, Şimdi daha iyiceyim (I am feeling better now) 1840-49

WCaUdX.png

Map of Ottoman empire and puppets 1840, the empire is thankfully at peace


Abdulmejid with the wars of his father’s reign over, and his reforms now being implemented across the empire, follows a policy of peace in Europe, war in the Empire. There would be a war waged against Illiteracy, corruption, treason, and complacency within the empire. All aspects of the state and country would be looked at and remodeled along a more western line, and the goal of Ottomanism further forwarded.


AA7Xlc.png

As part of Ottomanism, Monuments to His father Mahmud “the reformer”
are built across the empire to create an Ottoman identity.

This would be a hard and painful road to take, many within the empire would attempt to hold it back, attempt to stop centralization and to halt progress but this would not be tolerated, there is no place for these people in the new Ottoman state.

The Ottoman industry lagged behind its western neighbors, not only that but the tools and expertise to industrialize were lacking and would be for a long time as such to start Ottoman industry prioritization of state funds into state-sponsored factories would have to happen. Although complex industries were as of now unable to be built, basic factories producing Liquor, Wine, and Canned food were possible benefiting the largely agricultural resources required for them. Several religious figures are quick to protest about the state sponsoring alcohol but with several members of cabinet drinkers, their protests fall on deaf ears.

In September 1842, a scare frightens the Ottoman administration and Foreign office, and a general mobilization order is given after it is noticed that a crisis in North Macedonia has been taken interest by the European great powers, however, it seems that none of them were quite that interested and the crisis dies out, much to the relief and perhaps humiliation of the Ottoman administration, as the mobilization order is withdrawn


nREU5k.png

The unneeded mobilization angers many in the empire, but the experience drawn from it allows better practice for later wars



War never the less was a constant factor for the Ottoman empire and in 1843 several border skirmishes and outright wars with the states in the East would occur, assured of European neutrality these wars were waged on a small scale, intended to secure Ottoman influence in the East. The Aftermath of the Oriental crisis had left much of western Arabia all but independent; Ottoman troops, therefore, were sent to re-establish Yemen and Arabia as Ottoman protectorates. Furthermore, the Ottomans waged a 3-month war against the Persians, forcing them out of Bahrain, with who they had currently been at war.

Although the Tanzimat reforms had aided in reducing the separatism in, directly held Ottoman land in the west, they had angered many in the east. the Kurds rose up in 1843, under a Bedr Khan who had united the Kurdish tribes and begun killing Christian subjects of the Sultan a direct response to secularisation the Ottoman state was going under. The army sent found itself bogged down, outnumbered, and incapable of effectively controlling the area, and only more troops allowed the rebellion to be crushed though it would not be until late 45 that the Area would be under full Ottoman control


In early 1845 trusting that the internal situation was handled by his cabinet and Grand Vizier Sultan Abdulmejid personally toured Europe, officially in search of allies and to reaffirm treaties with old allies, but personally, the Sultan also desired a break from ruling as well as to tour the countries he was modeling his own empire after. As such after an invitation to a music festival in Prussia, the Sultan and his favorite consort Servetseza Kadın, therefore, took the opportunity to travel Europe the first Ottoman Sultan to ever do so, only returning after 9 months away. The prestige that such a tour gave to the Sultan was enough to convince Europe and therefore the world that the Ottoman Empire was once more a great power capable of exercising influence on the world stage.


MjLVpt.png

Although on holiday Abdulmejid did not fail in his stately duties, Prussia under its king Frederick William IV reaffirmed the alliance, and when traveling in Italy, he secured an alliance with Two Sicilies (though they had lost Sicily proper) during its war with the Roman state and France, Ottoman subsidies and the threat of intervention would consequently negotiate an end to that war with the Annexation of the Roman state, but with France receiving several guarantees and reparations. Upon returning Abdulmejid also began a policy of distancing the minor Balkan nations from the rest of Europe, Greece, Serbia, and Montenegro all had foreign backing but by distancing and alienating them from the Great powers the hope was to eventually reannex them into the empire.

The navy had long been neglected under Adbulmejid’s reign, underfunded, understaffed, and with no real purpose as the empire fought enemies at land, far from coast or ocean. This however was to change, if the empire was to fight any European power, a navy would have to be constructed to protect the coast and ferry troops. As such in 1846 and 47 two expansions of the Ottoman navy occurred, bolstering the fighting capability as well as the naval bases required to supply such a fleet. All in all the Navy would stand at 80 ships almost triple what it had been at the start of his reign.

The navy was not the only thing neglected, the Ottoman borders had grown and lay poorly defended, as such fortifications were built on the Russian and Austrian borders, as well as in all major cities. Furthermore, the experience gained in the false crisis over Macedonia also had taught the Ottomans much about mobilization, and as such military rail lines were built across the empire to allow the transport of troops quicker and in far larger numbers than ever before.

MWiPrB.png

While the Ottoman empire grew its military capability it would seem the Austrians had not,
and had once again begun to fear their southern neighbor

Not all was well in the Empire however, although minor rebellions had occurred, the Balkans and Egypt had laid mostly content with Ottoman rule, in late 1847 this began to change and the Vali of Egpyt reported an increase in militancy amongst the locals, this was echoed across the Empire, with Serbian nationalists rising up, though too few in numbers to do anything.

With these troubles in mind, there were few who opposed Abdulmejid when he announced his plans for an Ottoman Senate and as such in November 1847 Abdulmejid I announced the first local elections to such a Senate. Although the thought of allowing the lower classes to vote crossed the Sultan and his advisor’s minds, eventually it was decided that the poor were far too uneducated and easily swayed by religious or mass movements to be trusted to guide the country. Nether the less the elections went off without a hitch and the first Ottoman Senate convened in April 1848, the ruling party had won much support for its liberal reforms and gained 78% of the vote.
lLIq2J.png

The elections and the deployment of the majority of the Ottoman army in heated areas calmed most of the revolutionaries and by the year's end most said that the revolutionary atmosphere had passed. In other parts of Europe, they were not so lucky, in Prussia revolutionaries had to be fired upon to disperse, in France a revolution has placed another Bonaparte in charge, and in Austria, the Hungarians fed up with Austrian Tyranny have risen up much to the interest of the Ottoman empire.

In Apil 1849 Prussia called a conference of German states, in response to the failing situation in Austria, although not a german state the Ottomans were also invited to join, due to the alliance as well as its position in accordance to Austria. During the conference Prussian diplomats were able to convince others that Austria was no longer fit to rule its multi-cultural empire, nevermind Germany, and demanded that Austria accept Prussia as the leader of the German confederation, when Austria refused, Prussia declared war, calling the Ottomans in.
 
Would be quite the coup if you can get a hold of Austria's Balkan territories, even as protectorates. But the prospect of a rampant Prussia fifteen or so years ahead of schedule is slightly alarming. Good thing they're on your side…
 
I ended a bit early because I wanted to start the next part with the war
as this is my first AAR, I'd like to know what people are currently thinking about the AAR, and what people would like to see, less text/more text, more or fewer screenshots as well as other things
 
Would be quite the coup if you can get a hold of Austria's Balkan territories, even as protectorates. But the prospect of a rampant Prussia fifteen or so years ahead of schedule is slightly alarming. Good thing they're on your side…
With Hungary in open rebellion, the war could not happen at a better time, not only is the border smaller but ill be able to send armies to allow Hungary to win the war. a few territories were taken from them as well occupations should knock them from great power. Perhaps it is Habsburg Austria that will be the terminally sick man of Europe
 
I ended a bit early because I wanted to start the next part with the war
as this is my first AAR, I'd like to know what people are currently thinking about the AAR, and what people would like to see, less text/more text, more or fewer screenshots as well as other things

I think it’s all looking great. Most important thing is that you’re having fun writing, and you’re happy with the pace you’ve set yourself. But screenshot/text ratio is fine for me, and the write up in engaging.

With Hungary in open rebellion, the war could not happen at a better time, not only is the border smaller but ill be able to send armies to allow Hungary to win the war. a few territories were taken from them as well occupations should knock them from great power. Perhaps it is Habsburg Austria that will be the terminally sick man of Europe

I’ve seen Austria become the sick man a few times, so played right it could definitely happen. I’ve never seen Hungary hold out after 1848 except when I’ve intervened. Very interested to see the outcome here.
 
  • 1Like
Reactions: