Epilogue (Part I)
-= 239 =-
June 1786
Charleston, South Carolina
The carriage creaked and swayed as it rolled along the pitted road leading to Charleston. Years of abuse and neglect led to tiny plants shoving cobblestone aside along with missing brick. The gutters on either side, built partially for drainage and so the larger wagons would have something for their wheels to grab onto, were choked with dirt and weeds.
John Preston stared at the desolation following eighteen months of war. Outlying farms lay empty where they weren't scorched, the final stands of multiple rebellions. Trees and animals were slow to come back, but already a few brave saplings lined the torn road promising greater things in years to come.
“Johnny?” Cassie touched his arm. She'd dressed in bright yellow for what would hopefully be a festive occasion with white lace gloves. Their daughter, now a precocious two and likely to cause an international incident just by existing, stayed in Columbia with friends and their new cat, a small black one found starving after Charleston burned.
“It never should have come to this, Cass,” he said, still looking at the devastation. “Damn me if I know how I could have stopped it though.”
Following Black/Moultrie's death, Richard Caswell of North Carolina took over the Federation. If he'd been fully in command he might have stalled the crisis. The remaining Carolina Guard along the Georgia border wouldn't listen however. They knew the northerners invaded, used some infernal device to kill their fellows defending the city, then in the confusion Charleston itself went up in flames. They wanted revenge and invaded...through Virginia.
Governor Henry escaped first to Richmond, then Fredericksburg ahead of the Major Ellis's Carolina Guard while calling on the Americans for help. Ellis broke off pursuit and headed west, hoping to use the roads along the Appalachian frontier to sneak into Maryland and so capture Baltimore and Philadelphia.
Congress, goaded by independent privateers operating out of Charleston and under new leadership, had already massed two armies on the border. The first struck down the Post Road to liberate Richmond and Williamsburg. They would also free Benedict Arnold if he was still there, then march all the way to Charleston. The second army under Benjamin Lincoln would destroy the Guard. Later a third, led by Harry Lee and Colonel Kirkland, seized the Carolina coast.
The Carolinan Rebellion (1785-86)
Lincoln defeated the Guard, chased them into North Carolina and won a decisive victory. Arnold met minimal resistancd on his march and after that it was simply mopping up.
Cassie shook her head. “There was nothing you could do, except remove yourself.”
They
did stay out of it, despite repeated calls to take command of the flailing Guard. John spoke repeatedly about reconciliation. As the futility of their cause became more apparent and the naval blockade caused merchants to fail left and right, he won supporters.
John nodded grimly. Six horsemen from the Connecticut First ringed the wagon, both for escort and protection from fanatics. He hated their occupation, hated what it had done to
his people. And yet, was it better than anarchy?
The twin forts that once guarded Charleston, now stone husks, came into view. General Arnold hadn't even waited to see if they were occupied. He'd deployed his cannon and spent a day and a half knocking them down before marching into the city proper. By that point the city wasn't capable of organized resistance at all. They were spared the usual horrors only because there was so little left to take.
The wide, empty field where refugees once camped was now filled with army tents. They'd built their own city there relying heavily on naval supplies. This they shared with the civilians grudgingly out of common decency, enslaving them as sure as they'd once done to blacks and Indians. Northern sentiment on the subject won here through brute force. No one formally emancipated
them, but if they wanted to try their luck up north then the army would get them there and damn their owners.
“Driver!” He rapped the carriage with his cane. “We'll stop here!”
“Johnny?” Cassie's brow furrowed in confusion. “What's amiss?”
“There's...” Preston shook his head. He didn't want her to see the rest of the city. Pride. Shame. It wasn't to protect her sensibilities: In the end she'd proven tougher than he was. “I...I need to go on alone.”
She studied him for several moments until the door opened, and a Connecticut soldier nodded. “We brought a horse for you, gov'ner!”
“Governor?” John turned, startled. “No, sir. Just me.” He slowly dropped from the wagon and took his cane. “Cassie? I'll see you tonight and explain everything. Hopefully we'll be celebrating.”
She nodded. She didn't understand, but sensed this was important to him. “Hurry.”
He smiled, then grimaced as the soldier brought a horse. His leg never healed right, and mounting... Preston managed on the third try, hissing. The horsemen smiled.
“What's so funny?” he demanded, thrusting his cane into the holster usually reserved for rifles.
“Nothing, sir!”
Mounting hurt, but not as much as a long walk would, and now that he was actually on board... “Then catch me if you can!” He yanked the reins away, kicked the horse with his good leg and bolted down Meeting Street. After several startled seconds, the Nutmegers raced in pursuit.
Little traffic on the streets: The omnipresent soldiers saw to that. This gave John all the room he needed to maneuver. He took his escort on a grand tour through the city, ducking down Queen Street to the docks. He avoided the center of town with its crater where the church once stood. Arnold's army knocked down the neighboring State House as a danger. It survived the firestorm by virtue of being upwind. Much of the rest of Charleston couldn't claim the same, and soon they raced past tiny wooden buildings and shacks.
Too soon, far too soon, the race ended. He pulled up as they reached the one military dock and waited as the soldiers rounded the last turn at a gallop.
“What are you about, sir!?” demanded their leader, somewhere between amazed and furious. He ripped the reins out of John's hands.
“Not bad for a civilian with a bad leg,” Preston smirked.
The horseman's face twisted, then he smiled. “Aye. Now, off with you.”
John dismounted, an even more disagreeable process than mounting in the first place, and huffed silently as another man brought him his cane. He thanked his escort then hobbled towards the waiting cutter.
“Hey, gov'ner!” the lead called.
He turned.
“Good luck!”
*******
The heavy frigate
Constitution, flagship of the American navy, floated about half a mile out to sea surrounded by fisherboats, a civilian packet, and several escorts. They helped him up with a boatswain's chair, not unlike a swing, and brought him aboard.
Despite himself, John had to admire their quiet perfection. The cannon brass glowed in the mid-day sun. The wood planking of the deck could have been installed yesterday - not a trace of wear or soil. The officers' uniforms, blue and white of course, were freshly laundered.
“My name is Jones, sir,” said the captain with a bow. “We have...had a mutual acquaintance. General Heyward.”
John nodded, returning the bow. “He once spoke about your rescue. I'm sure he would thank you if he could.”
Jones returned the nod. The last he heard, this was the man who'd killed his fiance. Perhaps, perhaps not. This war and the years before did strange things to otherwise reliable people. “Mister Stark? Would you show the colonel to my cabin? The sooner this business is done, the happier we will all be. Do you agree, sir?”
Preston bowed. Stark, a ten year old midshipman, bounced ahead of him. Excitement did away with discipline and he talked animatedly about the one sea battle of the war. Six ships tried to break the blockade. Four, as well as two Americans, now sat on the ocean floor. The lone Carolinan survivor now took refuge in Savannah.
“Was you at the battle, sir?”
“No,” John said. “This is my first time on a ship.” Not quite true. He'd taken a transport from the siege at St. Augustine to meet up with Cassie in Charleston. True enough though - this was his first warship.
Stark knocked at the cabin door. A familiar face answered the door and Preston instinctively saluted. “Sir!”
Benjamin Lincoln smiled, as if party to a private joke. “Colonel.”
“I didn't expect to see you.”
Lincoln turned to the boy. “Compliments to your captain, and thank him again for the use of his cabin. We will send word if we are at need.” To John: “I arranged this meeting. Did you think I'd miss it?” He opened the door wider.
The main part of the cabin consisted of a wide, low table currently empty except for a pot of coffee and three cups. A single American marine took it upon himself to stand guard against one wall. A dignified man with an aristocratic air sat at the table.
“Mister President? May I present John Preston?”
Alexander Hamilton, President of the United States (1785-)
Hamilton didn't rise, but he nodded civilly and indicated a chair. “Please sit, Colonel. That looks uncomfortable.”
It was. The rocking of the boat, even at anchor, meant he had to constantly shift his weight. His right leg didn't like that. “Thank you.” He limped to the offered seat. Lincoln sat between them.
Pleasant civilities. Congratulations on your election, thank you very much. I understand you have a daughter, she's very well. Then, over their second cup of coffee, Hamilton got down to business.
“I understand you have authority to speak for the Federation?”
John leaned back and stretched his leg. Better. “I have agreement from most of the leading citizens of both South and North Carolina,” he said. “I've also been in contact with mayors and aldermen from the major towns in both states. There is no Assembly to speak of, of course, but it's safe to say I have their full support.”
“What I don't understand is why I'm here,” Hamilton said. “Similarly I have authority from Congress to address this conflict...but so does General Arnold, and he's been here all along.”
“General Arnold,” John began. He started, then mastered himself and emptied his cup. After filling it again he continued. “General Arnold's suggested terms are unreasonably harsh. They cannot be agreed to. No man with any pride in him can stomach them.”
Arnold took his job as occupying governor seriously. Resistance was met with deadly force, which in itself wasn't unreasonable. Farm buildings, hangings, searching and confiscating property on weak prospects: Those took some explaining. His terms included a long term military occupation “until order is restored,” the merging of South and North Carolina (“birds of a feather”) which would limit their voice in a future Congress, and the arrest of anyone associated with the 'rebellion.' Officers would be hung, while enlisted men would be barred from public service, voting or owning property.
“I've discussed his terms with him,” Hamilton said. “I can see why your principals would feel this way. It must be said, however, that even after taking control and restoring order we've met with armed, albeit isolated, resistance.”
“They want to be free,” John replied. “The Articles...”
“Are null and void.”
“Yes, but they granted each state sovereignty over their own affairs. This is all we want. Governors Moultrie and Caswell made unfortunate decisions. I cannot answer for Major Ellis: He did not strike me as a vengeful man and I suspect he was pushed into invading. None of them spoke for the entire populace. Almost everyone I've spoke with want to return to the union ... as equal states however, not occupied territories.”
“
Almost everyone,” Hamilton returned.
“Old feelings die hard. The sooner we can build a lasting peace, the sooner it will fade.”
Hamilton glanced at Lincoln, who nodded. “Very well. What do you consider a lasting peace?”
“North and South Carolina be allowed to reconvene assemblies. The assemblies will vote to return to the union, and Congress will accept. I understand the need to maintain security, and a minimal garrison is probably a good idea while we rebuild. However, most of the army, including General Arnold, needs to go home.”
“We have it in mind to maintain a large force in South Carolina regardless, in case of British mischief,” Hamilton replied.
“That can be discussed,” John replied. His third cup done, he reached for the pot. Empty. “We're no more anxious for British troops marching through Charleston than General Arnold's.”
“Very well. So far there's nothing I can't answer for,” Hamilton noted. “Now our terms. We will forgive the enlisted men, of course. The officers as well, provided they sign statements professing loyalty to the United States and swear not to take up arms against her again.”
“That is...”
“Not negotiable.”
John stared at him. “What else?”
“There will be no effort to recover property lost during this campaign,” Hamilton said.
“You mean the slaves.”
“Yes.”
John grimaced. That would be harder to push through, but realistically what chance did anyone have of recovery anyway? “Anything else?”
Lincoln spoke: “I think we understand you can't answer for those still taking up arms in the hills, Colonel. However, as the Carolinas regain political strength and the ability to take care of itself, we expect unqualified help dealing with them.”
“I'm sure they will fade away.” Most of them would, anyway. As for those last few holdouts, the Carolina governments would have as much to lose as the northerners. “Alright.”
“Then we're agreed.” Hamilton nodded to the general. “Ben, I will appoint you governor of the Carolina district.” He held up his hand against John's protests. “Your term will last only long enough to ensure fair assembly elections, and that basic security has been restored. After that, and once they've elected their own men to take over as governors, you can come home.”
Lincoln nodded.
To John: “Your duty will be more difficult, I fear. Since you seem to be in contact with the important men of this area, then you will need to help them organize and prepare for elections.”
Preston nodded as well, slowly. “I can do that.”
Hamilton turned to the marine. “Send for my servant. Tell him I asked for the wine.” He smiled at the others. “We must drink to our new friendship!”
Carolina Federation (1784-86) (Defeated)